The Right To Privacy Analysis

Improved Essays
There has been an increased interest and knowledge in relation to privacy rights and issues. The reason for this is that they are a fundamental right which ensures the personhood of individuals by allowing them to control who has access to personal information about them. Privacy issues are also of importance because it helps individuals avoid unwanted intrusions in their personal dealings. Consequently, for the reason that privacy is such a complex concept, there have been ongoing concerns and discussions in relation to the legal concept of privacy rights. Various theorists have provided their interpretation of privacy which includes an understanding of how privacy rights should be defined as well as what they should protect. Some of the theorists …show more content…
This paper will delve into and critically analyze Thomson’s perspective of privacy rights as being unpersuasive because it is diluted, incoherent, and subjective. To achieve this goal, the paper is organized into two main sections. The first section consists of a summary on the arguments Judith Thomson makes to aid her in proving her conception of privacy and the second section this conceptual paper will examine and evaluate Thomson’s paper. Judith Thomson states in her work that there is little consensus as to what privacy rights entail. She claims in her paper that this may be due to the fact that privacy issues do not have distinctive characteristics which separate them from other right and this makes it difficult to form boundaries as to where other rights end and where privacy rights begin. This explains Thomson’s perspective on privacy which maintains that most of the elements in privacy rights are based on other rights and why she regards privacy issues as an extension of those rights. Seeing as Thomson believes privacy rights to be contingent on various other rights, she reasons that privacy rights can be better understood as an infringement …show more content…
Through this assessment it will be apparent that the arguments Thomson utilizes are not convincing. To accomplish this, the paper will delve into various aspects that show how her paper dilutes and simplifies complex concepts in order to justify her perspective of privacy rights. The critical analysis will also depict how there are various factors involved in her work which make the overall paper incoherent and hard to understand. To finish, this section will conclude by inspecting the ways in which Judith Thomson is biased and this is due to the ways in which she intentionally uses specific examples that will justify her notion of privacy and pays no consideration to the other aspects that may play a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The sources of data to be employed poses a set of challenges considering that a significant portion of information is likely to remain under-published or non-published, and in most cases, there would be no way of confirming the veracity of the presented data. Thus, it will be crucial for the study to offer credit whenever due by acknowledging the source of information. Whether information is provided by published or non-published communication, it is critical to provide the citation of the appropriate literature. An ethical issue that emerges in such a study involves the tendency of the researcher to be vulnerable to selective citation in expressing personal prejudice. It is acknowledged that selective citation would be bad scholarship and can mistakenly be interpreted as demonstrating the ignorance of the researcher.…

    • 1482 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    But using too much or too little of any technique can throw off the writing piece. Cepeda starts off her writing with giving her reader logos but as she gets deeper into the article she overshadows her own voice and her point of view using summary and pathos and no ethos. The techniques used in the article are not evenly distributed causing the reader to be partially effected by her writing. Esther Cepeda the Author of “ Jose Antonio Vargas's Lies Deserve No Sympathy” is partially effective on her reader because she uses logic in her writing, but notwithstanding she complicates her writing by adding summary and using her readers feelings and not using ethos throughout her article. Despite her effort of convincing her reader to have no sympathy for Vargas, she loses her reader by having unevenly used techniques throughout her work.…

    • 1676 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hare And Maxion Analysis

    • 1921 Words
    • 8 Pages

    She also finds herself may be prejudiced and snobbish. M’s morality of self-introspection cannot be considered as the U-type. On the 22nd page of “The Idea of Perfection”, Murdoch claims, “M’s activity is peculiarly her own. Its details are the details of this personality; and partly, for this reason, it may well be an activity, which can only be performed privately. M could not do this thing in conversation with another person.” Murdoch means M’s morality of self-introspection is the activity that comes from her own personality and experience rather than any universalized reason.…

    • 1921 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In “Towards a Theory of Privacy in the information Age,” James H. Moor explains greased information, the foundation and nature of privacy, and the adjustment of policies to ensure privacy under certain situations before proposing a control/restricted access theory of privacy. Moor argues that one of the problems of privacy is that once information is exposed, others can have access to it and use it, sometimes without consent. He then claims that privacy is not a core value, or an essential value shared by all cultures, but that privacy is indeed essential in what he calls our system of values. Overall, Moor argues that it is important for us to think of privacy as a control/restricted access account because it encourages informed consent and…

    • 1065 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Virtue Rewarded

    • 1856 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Pamela; or, Virtue Rewarded, is a novel that provokes substantial ambiguity, uncertainty, and criticism regarding the narratives controversy when attempting to categorize the genuine intentions, and authenticity of virtue of the novel’s protagonist; Pamela. Importantly, the readers doubt stems from a variety of stylistic techniques that Richardson applies throughout the novel, consistently forcing his audience to shift their approach in drawing conclusions regarding the hidden character behind Pamela’s words, and actions. Much like Pamela, who finds herself in an atmosphere of secrecy which forces her to interpret the motives of others to preserve her purity, the reader must also interpret the paradoxical information they are given through;…

    • 1856 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She begins by saying “How can I tell you about the people of Omelas” (LeGuin 6)? How reliable a narrator is, is incredibly important as it determines whether or not the intended reader is willing to believe the narrative and the storyworld. The narrator in “The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas” is very self conscious of how she tells the story and constantly worries about the reader. As her main goal is for the intended reader to believe her story, she allows the narratee to pick and chose certain details of the narrative. This causes subtle contradictions within the story.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sexuality In Workplace

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages

    These sections are composed by the introduction, which is too long and tedious as Fleming uses complex language. Then, some research concerns sexuality as control and resistance in literature. Following this an empirical study is introduced, and although properly conducted, as it illustrates a balanced view which includes both sides of Fleming 's argument. It also contains too much dialogue and the language can be categorized as offensive, ergo, disrupting the flow of the text. Moreover, as Fleming himself says the study was not designed to investigate sexuality but organizational culture and, therefore, does not contain an actual insight to his argument.…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In my critical opinion, their objective was to try and concern how a social right (the right to privacy) can be as crucial as legal right (such as the right to property). Although, their main focus was to explain a better way of understanding an individual’s right to their privacy, the better way of implementing this law is to relate it to “the right to be let alone” which they have addressed in their article (205). Warren and Brandeis’ theory and concept of an individual’s right to be left alone is more severe, since it essentially has to do with the individual’s fundamental right to be able to live life freely. The “right to be let alone” is part of the American legal act. However, this still does not relate to an individual’s right to privacy under the law, this has to do with one’s right to liberty.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Bell's To Blame Summary

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Suppose that one were to claim that weak-willed hypocrites have standing to blame, while clear-eyed hypocrites do not. Bell thinks that we should reject such a claim on the grounds of respecting privacy. Her idea is that we can’t know whether someone is engaged in clear-eyed hypocritical criticism without performing an extensive investigation of the critic. However, our moral obligation to respect other’s privacy forbids such investigation. Bell puts this quite nicely in saying, “we should not have to publicly sort through all of our dirty—and clean—laundry in order for the content of our criticism to be taken seriously.” Furthermore, Bell thinks that those who claim clear-eyed hypocrites lack standing to blame seem to be conflating “failing to blame” with “lacking standing to blame”.…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Their goal was to give solidified bounds of cognition. They struggled with Clark and Chalmers and other likeminded philosophers’ belief that there was more than a limitation on cognition. Adams and Aizawa’s claim that cognitive processes are causally individuated was something I thought of when reading Clark and Chalmers. Cognition will look different in a computer and a human, but that does not necessarily mean that one is thinking and one is not. The bounds are significantly dependent on the individual.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays