The Question Of Justice : Plato And Aristotle Essay

2015 Words Sep 29th, 2016 9 Pages
The Question of Justice
Thinkers for centuries have attempted to find a way to establish a republic or state with a system that ensures perfect justice. Many of these thinkers shared a common idea on what justice should look like but many also disagree on how they should go about establishing that republic. Plato and Aristotle exemplify this idea as although Plato taught Aristotle, they have vastly different answers to the question. Both wrote books explicating their different opinions, Plato wrote The Republic while Aristotle wrote The Politics. The two books work towards a common goal but they go about doing this in different ways. Plato argues for an oligarchy dominated by one percent of the population who are born with virtue and among this group, Plato wants strong unity to ensure that human nature cannot destroy the purity of the rulers. Aristotle argues for a constitutional democracy in which the masses are able to participate as active citizens and influence the government all the while being taught by the government on the importance of moderation to prevent corruption. Since Plato and Aristotle are some of the most important thinkers when it comes to finding a perfect republic, they need to be considered in the modern day. However, Aristotle is much more useful to consider as his ideas on the rule of the many and moderation are similar to the ideas in Modern America and would simply be a modification for the better. While Plato’s radical ideas are very different to…

Related Documents