The Pros And Cons Of The Stanford Prison Experiment

Improved Essays
There are many experiments and studies that researchers do to find out how most individuals, groups, cultures, etc. think and act. Like what is considered to be moral or immoral and how society can be better as a whole. Some experiments are more well-known than others and will forever be discussed even if they took place decades ago. Along with the Tuskegee Syphilis experiment and the Milgram experiment the Stanford Prison Experiment displayed unethical conduct that would not take place in today’s society and displayed the conforming of roles.
First taking place in the 1970’s, the film “The Stanford Prison Experiment” involved a psychologist by the name of Philip Zimbardo who conducted the study. He went on to gather twenty four “healthy” college
…show more content…
The Stanford Prison experiment would have been a lot longer if Zimbardo’s girlfriend at the time who is now his wife, Christina Maslach, had not pointed out that the study was no longer a study. She exclaimed “I think it’s terrible what you’re doing to those boys,” after he continued to watch the abuse that took place in front of his very eyes he finally stepped in and announced that the experiment was over. The prisoners endured a large amount of stress and showed signs of depression. At the very end of the movie after the experiment was over the “head guard” and one of the “prisoners” spoke to each other about why the guards were so evil and brutal. The selected head guard basically exclaimed that nobody stopped him despite how sadistic he got and wanted to continue to push the envelope further and further. To add on to what he said he also said that he was conducting his own experiment inside the experiment. Surprisingly the Actual Dr. Zimbardo is still a working psychologist and was “honored by the American Psychological Association” in 2012. What was interesting about him was that he also became a part of the experiment and became like a warden and it showed him conforming as well. As time went on in the film some of his colleagues explained to the prisoners that they were disgusted by them and that they did not deserve to function in the outside world. The study also showed how real prisoners were viewed in the prison system and they deserved to be punished and that they should not have any type of rights. In the outside world many prisoners who get out of jail can have a hard time functioning in society because a lot of people have the notion of once a criminal always a criminal so they could have a difficult time finding jobs and home and often they end up right back in jail or

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This was a very misleading statement because it could mean anything and may lead to drastic emotional scars. Evidence supporting this is that guards were allowed to assign meaningless, menial labour to prisoners and if they did not comply, punishment was encouraged. Also, when being transitioned from the city police to the mock prison, they were blindfolded so they would be unaware. Then, they were placed in a degradation ritual where they would have all of their personal belongings and clothes stripped away from them. This would make the elected prisoners feel extremely vulnerable and uncomfortable and was not ethical, especially if they requested the actions to be ceased.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Violations were indicated frequently throughout the video about the Zimbardo Prison Study. During time point min 13:52 the violation of Standard 3.06 is present. It is explained as Philip Zimbardo and the staff of the study treated Prisoner 8612 unfairly and coldly for wanting out of the study due to the treatment he was receiving. This was due to Zimbardo’s neglect as his role of psychologist and being aware of what was happening in the study, Prisoner 8612 could have been drastically harmed if his role of prisoner was continued. At the beginning, he was pretending to be crazy but eventually became crazy.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They began to be aggressive and abusive towards their prisoners. The prisoners did not take to that very well, some cried and obtained anxiety. The study was set to last fourteen days, they did not make it the full two weeks. They ended the experiment in six days because of how brutal the guards became. In Kendra Cherry’s article “The Stanford Prison Experiment: A Closer Look at Zimbardo’s Infamous Prison Study” it states that “Even the researchers themselves began to lose sight of the reality of the situation.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But the guards won’t let the prisoners tell their parents that they are being tortured and beaten. The guards had the prisoners write letters to their parents but they never shipped the letters out so none of the letters got to their parents. The guards got so mean and rude to the prisoners that they started to have mental breakdowns because they started to I believe that they were in prison. This caused The Stanford Prison Experiment to end after 6 days instead of lasting 2 weeks. This experiment affected the prisoners so much that those prisoners had to get a therapist to help them with their problem.…

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    During all of this, one guard lined the prisoners up outside of the room and had them chant, “Prisoner #819 is a bad prisoner. Because of what Prisoner #819 did, my cell is a mess, Mr. Correctional Officer.” The prisoner broke down once more and when offered the opportunity to leave, he refused, saying he had to go back out there to prove he was not in fact a bad prisoner. Until he was kindly reminded that it was all just an experiment, he agreed to…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Scientifically, Zimbardo was asked what is the independent variable of the experiment? Zimbardo furious claims that scientifically they do not understand, there was a riot about to erupt soon. He then tells the guards to reassemble the prison; out of frustration they took it out on the prisoners, escalating dominance, humiliation control, etc. Prisoner began to shut down, they started to refute against the prison. Especially prisoner 819, because of his refusal his cellmates were put to mindless work, having little support.…

    • 1089 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So with all these statistics, it seems that the prisons aren’t doing what they were made to do, and part of that is true, prison just aren’t working and most inmates repeatedly neglected to the point of mental illness. This mental illness causes the free inmates to feel a sense of security in prison, and this is caused by the consistency of prison life and the lack of decisions, “Jerry confides during his interview that he’s had trouble sleeping at the shelter for homeless veterans where he lives: ‘It’s like my body left the prison, but my mind is still in there.’” Jails are also unsafe even for the more hardened criminals; the multiple ways to be assaulted are too many to count and millions of dollars worth of drug getting funneled through the system. The need to find a clique in jail has lead to a huge spike in prison violence showing that, “Causes for prison violence can include gang-related activity. Gangs are present within prisons and include groups and alliances that have developed both inside and outside of prison walls” (Blanco). Many carve untraceable, small knives called shanks, “shanks are illegal contraband made from plastic silverware, scraps of sharp objects, and toothbrushes.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    None of the “prisoners” consented to being arrested at home. Methodological issues: Zimbardo’s involvement in the experiment as a prison superintendent meant that he was influencing the experiment while also observing it. Zimbardo confessed that this dual role was detrimental to the experiment and subjected him to the conformity effect that was occurring in the…

    • 1148 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zimbardo then asked another male student to join his experiment. The new male student saw what was happing in the monk prison and soon wanted to leave, but was told he could not leave. He then began to act out and decides to go on a hungry strike. When the study went to an end on the fifth day because of one psychologist thoughts of the prisoners, who felt that they were being abused by the guards and that it was terrible what Zimbardo were doing to the…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Philip Zimbardo (and his graduate students as well as other personnel) designed a very poor experiment that would have never been approved in present day. Nevertheless, this experiment most likely helped push guidelines to be more stringent to prevent such experiments from occurring in the future. The experiment was very successful because it basically broke the inmate students into believing that they truly were inmates that broke the law and deserved to be there. However, Zimbardo’s supervising crew never once stops the experiment for completely messing with the inmate students psyches. Furthermore, he is a most likely former Christian that talks about Satan and God forming hell.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays