Gilded Era Vs Progressive Era

Improved Essays
Two prominent eras from American History were the Gilded Age at the end of the nineteenth century and the succeeding period, the Progressive Era. The Gilded Age, also know as the Second Industrial Revolution, was a peak of high economic development with the rise of monopolies and technological advancements. Besides its economic growth, the Gilded Age handled the shift in social divisions. Before this measurement of time, slavery struck the partition between groups. After the abolishment of slavery, the class system had three major groups with robber barons at the top, then the middle class, and finally the working class that encompassed enormous quantities of immigrants. The following time period, the Progressive Era from around 1890-1920, …show more content…
Through negative liberty one believes that freedom comes when there is no interference. Likewise, free market economies believe that regulation should come from self-interest, not from government. Adam Smith said that “QUOTE” However, during late eighteen-hundreds markets were defective by reason of monopolies. Monopolies impair competition. As one company was in charge of a specific product, they consumed power over not just that creation, but over prices and workers. CITATION in the City Upon a Hill it says, “they saw the corporations as an economic tyranny—setting wages, determining working conditions, setting prices, and manipulating the political process for their own gain.” (A City Upon a Hill 211) These oppressive conditions the Robber Barons put on the people below them created incentive for a modification of liberty within …show more content…
The executives of large companies became exceedingly rich as they produced products such as: steel, railroads, oil, and other important goods. These men became millionaires as their workers worked hours upon hours to earn a few dollars. Even though during the Gilded Age wages were higher than normal for worker, there was a dramatic difference between the working class and upper ten incomes. CITATION Michael McGerr showed the contrast of the upper ten and working class in his article, from a Fierce Discontent by stating, “Upper ten, with so many millions of dollars, had no need to work, save and deny themselves pleasure at the end of the nineteenth century…working-class life—low wages, lay-offs, accidents, limited opportunity, early death” (Fierce Discontent 150). The contrast of these social classes urged many to strike against the Robber Barons to motivate better working conditions. The government intervened and monitored big companies by placing reforms on them like the Interstate Commerce Act to regulate railroads to limit their power to make it more balanced with the middle and working classes. The government used positive liberty to balance the power the upper ten had over the working class, so less strikes and to eliminate damaging boycotts and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    For example, during this time big businesses, like the steel company, grew massively and became very successful. Andrew Carnegie, the robber baron of the steel industry, grew very wealthy with the achievements of his company (Doc D). Andrew Carnegie’s book on the Gospel of Wealth displayed that the wealthy people of society’s purpose is to help the poor. The belief of the wealthy having to help the poor grew with the widening gap of wealth in society. This shows how industrialization affected the social aspects of society because with the success in large businesses the rich became richer while the poorer class is left behind.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Roosevelt responded to “New Freedom” with a program called “New Nationalism.” This program pointed out the unavoidably of big business and hoped to use the government to stop its corruptions. Roosevelt’s Progressive Party Platform called for many things like: women’s suffrage; federal supervision of corporate enterprise; direct election of senators; national labor and health legislation for women and children; shorter work days and living wage; social insurance for health, unemployment, and old age. The platforms includes that equality and liberty could be achieved if the government would step in and supervise these problems. Even though many Americans supported his platform, Roosevelt still lost. People supporting the Republican Party split the vote between Taft and Roosevelt which left Democrat Woodrow Wilson with almost half of the popular…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gilded Age Dbq

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages

    What took England and Germany roughly a century to complete, America managed in half the time. This time period, coined the Gilded Age by Mark Twain, was a time of both astounding wealth, and astonishing greed. Consequently, it’s not hard to believe that this revolution brought both positive and negative results. On one hand, innovators were churning out idea after idea. This led to a larger work force needed to fill the increasing demand for product.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the first section of this paper I will briefly examine some of the characteristics of what is described as the Gilded Age in America, the period immediately following the Civil War, the phrase being derived from Twain and Dudley’s novel The Gilded Age. One of the landmark achievements of this period, around which much of the novel also revolves, is the completion of the first transcontinental railway network in the year 1869. Predicated upon this, to a large extent, is the process of industrialisation in the US, which gathered great momentum following the development of the transcontinental railway network. As a result, investments in heavy industries like coal, iron ore etc., also become more commonplace. In an essay titled, “Understanding…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Gilded Age, an evolutionary time in the late 19th century, which altered the common farmer’s life, from living in the rural into an industrial worker living in the city. The Gilded Age created the transcontinental railroad, racial tension, end of freely roaming Native Americans, tedious labor, unemployment, substantial immigration, an extreme government and fraudulent politics. With all these crucial events occurring from the early 1870s to the early 1900s, I believe the most crucial years in the Gilded Age consist of 1873, a time in which many events concluded, 1893, the commencer of the Great Depression, and 1896, the year of a fundamental election. The year 1873 marked the end of many movements and eras, but set the scene for other prospecting years. One big era that ended in 1873 was the Native Americans free roam over Western U.S..…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It has created power structures and the workers at the bottom have ideas imposed on them, which they are forced to accept. Human labor will soon become superfluous by the perfecting of future machinery (Engels, p. 707). This will create even more division between the people because of the existing competition. This “now puts these individuals in a position to raise themselves into the ruling class” (Marx, p. 174). The capitalistic society that we live in has enslaved workers.…

    • 1307 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Just 10 percent of the population controls 75 percent of the nation’s wealth. The rich are exceedingly rich while many industrial workers earn less than $500 per year. The threat of working class poverty and misery is an important justification for government intervention into economic affairs. Some legislation is needed to control the opposing views of business power. First, Businesses should be required to pay workers a reasonable wage and provide safe working conditions.…

    • 1617 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Gilded Age DBQ

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Soon in 1900, statistics showed that the one hundred prime American companies controlled nearly one third of the countries production capacity. The inequality of the wealth distribution was more intense than ever. Henry Demarest Lloyd points out in the North American Review that man will put capital in front of society and wealth in front of citizenship (Doc 2). Lloyd says it bluntly, people were selfish and made their own monetary needs a priority before they even began to look at other people’s problems. Not only were people upset with the economy, smaller political parties even attempted to take a stand, but inevitably miserably failed.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Later on in the Gilded Age came the Populist Party, or People’s Party. They were a group of reforming, working-class people who advocated for such causes as the end of national banks, the deprivatization of railroads, silver coinage, and a graduated income tax, as bolstered by the “National People’s Party Platform” (Doc 4). The opinions of working-class people, their platform was crafted to discourage many abuses of America’s economy and political system by big business at a time when political machines run by the wealthy elite were rampant in the U.S. Corrupt political machines had…

    • 1748 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Karl Marx Vs Adam Smith

    • 1879 Words
    • 8 Pages

    One major differences between the two are that they both have extremely opposite views on how an economy should be run. Adam Smith believes in capitalism and free markets where the government has little to no control which in other words is known as, Laissez-Faire. Whereas Karl Marx believes in socialism and trusts that the economy is best run when the government has control on all aspects of an economy and were wealth is shared out equally amongst the public. Another difference between the two theorists are their opinions on how the production should be processed. Adam Smith advocates that division of labour and specialisation is the finest way to produce goods as firms can become extremely efficient and produce numerous more goods in a day as the production is divided into various parts.…

    • 1879 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays