The Negro Church In America Analysis

Improved Essays
Exam 1

In this essay I will be referring to the article, The Negro Church in America written by E. Franklin Frazier. I will be comparing the evolution and function of the Black Church in America with Emile Durkheim’s and Marx’s Theories of religion. I will do this by first providing the background of the African slaves that led to their loss of cultural identity. I will also describe both Emile Durkheim’s and Karl Marx’s theories of religion individually. After this I will describe the evolution and function of the Black Church in America with each of their theories and also how I believe they would react to this same article if they were alive today to read it. First, I will provide information on the African Background that leads into
…show more content…
First of all it is important for one to understand that Marx has a very complex attitude towards the Christian religion that has affected his attitude towards all religion in general. One of Marx’s most central believes towards Religion is how Religion is a product of the society that it is in. Marx also believes that through the process of changing ideas one can change the actions of humans. Essentially this means that people can use words as weapons which most people agree can happen. The term the Pen is mightier than the sword has been a very impactful saying in history. Marx also believes that it was whatever roll one is born into in society that determines their consciences. If one is born into a rich family they won’t have any knowledge or concern of someone who is born a slave because they will never be affected by that way of life. Marx is a strong believer that religion is one of the most powerful tools that has been used in the alienation of humans. He writes how religion is used essentially to keep people in their place in life to rule over …show more content…
Above I noted how Durkheim believes that religion is will develop in society no matter what. But what we see in the reading is that early on the Slaves are not developing a religion or even a culture for that matter. One might view this and think that it goes against what Durkheim taught but upon further investigation it does the opposite. Durkheim talks about how religion I formed from out of body experiences found largely from large gatherings or a culture or society. But the reason that the African Slaves are not able to develop a religion is because the slave owners are specifically not allowing the Slaves to have a culture. The Slaves consist of small groups of people that for the most part cannot even communicate with one another. Later on in time however we find that the Slaves are developing their own religion in part because of the increase in numbers of Slaves in America just as Durkheim wrote. The religion the slaves developed was Christianity but not the same Christianity as there white masters. The main Force the Slaves felt in their religion came from the music they sang. It was through this music and working through the hardship that the African Slaves developed a sense of belonging

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Nelsens’ model which is said to be closer to the Black Church may be called the “dialectic model” of the Black Church. Black Churches are institutions that are involved in a consent series of dialectic tensions. The dialectic holds opposites in tension, constantly shifting between the polarities in historical time. There is no Hegelian synthesis or ultimate resolution of the dialectic. The task of the social analyst is to examine the social conditions of any black church, including the situation of its leadership and membership, to determine what its major orientation is in relation to any pair of dialectical polarities.…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both the Baptists and Methodists resonated with the African Americans because they were not preaching one thing and doing another. Methodists experienced an increase in their growth “the Methodist had just achieved a virtual miracle of growth, rising from less than 3 percent of the nations church members in 1776 to more than 34 percent by 1850, making them far and away the largest religious body in the nation(Finke and Starke 156).” However, the Methodists experienced a decline and the rise of the Baptists “as the Methodists declined from 42 percent to 28 percent of all adherents, the Baptists grew from 30 to 43 percent (Finke and Starke 157).” The transformation from sect to church was one of the reasons that the Methodists lost their numbers, and what they lost the Baptists came to gain in…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although many valid points were made in The Communist Manifesto, a few fatal flaws exist in his ideology. The United States has tried communism, but it was not until this system’s failure that property rights and capitalism took hold. Although many valid points were made in Marx’s The Communist Manifesto, a few fatal flaws exist in his ideology. The United States has tried Communism, and it was not until communism failed that property rights and capitalism took hold.…

    • 1741 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    YeJoon Kang HST 103_06 Professor Borbonus 10 February 2015 Karl Marx & Samuel Smiles During the time of Industrialization, Europe and the United States were the leading exporters in the global markets. It was most difficult for the working class when there was an abundant amount of supplies, also known as surplus of products once in demand. One of many reasons they were suffering was because; “As more and more factories were built to produce the same commodity…competitors slashed prices by slashing wages” (Marks 136). Many similar problems were practiced in the time.…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In school, the Negro isn't taught the business side of things when it comes to a job or career. This factor prevents the Negro from employing one another and in turn they are left to wait and hope that a white businessman will hire them. The problem with this factor is that whites at this time only called for the Negro when all the workers of their own race had been taken care of. The author feels that the negro easily throws away good opportunities by not turning something that they are good at into a thriving business because they may feel that they have a college education and that they are to good for it. The author uses the example of a white professor who resigned his position to run a laundry mat for Negroes and became rich from the idea.…

    • 2163 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Martin Luther King Jr. and Frederick Douglass are two African American activists who lived in different centuries. The former fought for African American civil rights in 20th century while the later strived for abolition of slavery in 19th century, but they both carried one single agenda or goal in common –fighting for the equality and integration of African-Americans. In the Letter from Birmingham Jail and the Narrative of an African American Slave, Martin Luther King and Frederick Douglass have similarities and differences in their views of Christianity’s role in the larger context. For example, both Martin Luther King and Frederick Douglass expressed their indignation and criticism towards the white Christian churches for their justification and permission of slavery and segregation, although the tone or the severity of such condemnation differs. Moreover, King also holds more optimism towards the role of Christianity in overcoming the legacies of slavery and segregation and takes a more progressive stance on such matter.…

    • 1923 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Marx also disapproved of religion. Marx wrote the Communist Manifesto in 1848. In Marx's Manifesto he said that North America and Europe would collapse, economically and socially. He also told other workers to join his movement. Marx thought that capitalism would help start a revolution.…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He states we have no access to eternal truth and the value of the human world is through religion which emerges from human nature. Marx argues the need to understand relationships with other people and our productive capacity. Thoughts are shaped by economic circumstances and need to think about humans in the world. He argues that there is no such thing as human nature which is intrinsic to us because humans always in certain circumstances. Human nature is defined by the historical context of that…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Written in 1933, The Mis-Education of the Negro provided a platform of discussion in terms of the debilitating state of African-American education during the 20th century. The thesis’ author, Carter G. Woodson, relays information about the education system of his time and how that same system has propelled blacks to seek lower-level positions on the social-economic totem pole. Though, this thesis was written many decades ago, the black community is still suffering; I personally believe that many of the things affecting some black communities today can be remedied if more businesses were black owned and reinvested in their community. Now, those of you who have read The Mis-Education of the Negro know that the author discusses several factors…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Karl Marx made religion a position in society and people were committed to the benefits of religion. For instance, during American slavery, some religious folk said the Bible claimed that white were able to enslave black people, so with the Bible’s word most people felt complacent with slavery for a long time. Karl Marx believed that the injustice system were pushing their own agendas on people who believed in religion and it was unfair. Religion keeps people involved in social activism and the society keep people from gaining their rights from the government. The Soviet Union was not tailored toward the belief and rights of individual, but it is also true that the Soviet Union wanted equality and wanted to protect the rights of their citizens.…

    • 211 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Karl Marx and Emile Durkheim on the Social Function of Religion When one thinks of religion, one generally associates it with contentious debates and conflicting ideas. However, it is undebatable that religion has been a powerful force in human society since its beginnings. Due to its prevalence and importance, many thinkers have studied the religion and formulated their own ideas on its function and consequences in society. In this paper, I will specifically address two such thinkers, Karl Marx and Emile Durkheim. First I will explain Marx’s view of a religion as a tool of oppression and a distraction from reality.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marx On Religion

    • 111 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Marx referred to religion as comfort and a soothing agent for the people of society. , however, his views were seen as extreme. He described the abstract views of religion as being superstitious and a twisted way of thinking; he believed that religion created fantasies for the poor focusing on things such as the successful rewards they would reap in the afterlife. The bourgeoisie took advantage of this in order to keep the proletariat satisfied with the unequal existing state in society. He also thought of religion as being highly addictive to the members of society as they could relate their own quality and way of life, and justify it, in religion.…

    • 111 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Karl Marx Religion

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In Karl Marx’s native home of Germany, he observed many inequalities around him including widespread suffering and misery in the working class. He states that religion was widely used as an anesthetic to help people cope with their suffering. According to Marx, religion is a reflection of man, because religion is one of man’s constructions. So man uses religion as an illusion to shield himself from his own own sufferings. Marx claims that that the happiness gained from religion is an illusion, and through the criticism of religion it will reveal man’s true happiness.…

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marx And Religion

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages

    To begin with, it should be noted that Marx agrees with Bauer that religion should be abolished. Particularly, Marx despises religion because he believes that it not only belongs to the same ideological framework that supports capitalism, but also that it is often utilized as a tool to keep people enslaved. In Prussia, Christianity was used to condemn Judaism and Jewish people by banning them from occupations, and essentially relegating them to second-class citizens. Furthermore, Marx ([1843b] 1978) disapproves of the King of Prussia and how he alienates himself from his citizens because he believes he should be closer to God and the heavens, and is thus oblivious to their plight. Therefore, he is critical of German philosopher, Hegel’s deification…

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Marx: Emancipation from Illusions As I read Karl Marx’s writings within The Marx-Engels Reader, four key terms became apparent in order to understand his theories regarding religion, politics, and economics: emancipation, alienation, species-being, and proletariat. While I do not intend to summarize his ideas, this essay will resemble an almost ‘thinking out loud’ type of process, helping me to better comprehend Karl Marx, his vision for the world, and his impact on the discipline of religious studies. Unlike Durkheim’s approach to religion, which emphasizes the importance of religion’s role in the collective consciousness, the substance that animates society, Marx interprets religion as a phenomenon that occurs primarily within the individual.…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays