Government Surveillance Vs. Privacy

Improved Essays
The issues and disputes over surveillance and privacy remain prevalent in current events; citizens of nations throughout the world, especially of the United States ask themselves whether or not government surveillance leads to more or less trust and security. The novel, 1984, also deals with this issue while exploring the impact and consequences of surveillance in a totalitarian society. Through constant surveillance of all citizens, aware and unaware, the governments of Oceania and the United States gain control of each citizen’s thought process and everyday actions in order to gain power and national security; however, results in an invasion of privacy and a loss of overall government trust.
George Orwell’s novel, 1984, depicts the life
…show more content…
Winston, like every other citizen of Oceania is impacted by the nation’s strict surveillance. Telescreens, similar to regular televisions, act as security cameras to observe all citizens, who are aware of its purpose. These telescreens enable the government to spy on its citizens all day and all night. In fact, even when a person moves out of sight of the screen, the telescreen will still pick up sound, making it nearly impossible to escape surveillance (Orwell 3). Similar to Oceania, the United States employs constant surveillance to keep tract of its citizens; however, these citizens are not aware of this constant observation. Unlike Oceania, the United States is a capitalist nation, meaning the citizens remain in control of their own properties; receiving more freedom than those under totalitarian governments, such as Oceania. Until the summer of 2013, Americans remained unaware of government spy programs. On June 5, 2013, the British newspaper, the Guardian, published documents which proved the United States spies on its citizens through the National Security Agency, known as the NSA. These documents, released by former NSA …show more content…
Therefore, the impact of differed in each society. In Oceania, surveillance acts as a predominant part of the people’s lives, so much so that they do not remember a time not being monitored. The totalitarian government of Oceania works to achieve total Party cooperation and support, meaning enemies of the Party face harsh consequences by the government. Since the citizens are aware of this surveillance, their actions are influenced so that they are not caught with thoughtcrime, crime against the Party and its beliefs. Winston Smith struggles with constant surveillance throughout the novel. He only expresses original thoughts when he is out of sight from the telescreen, writes in a diary, or believes he is in a safe room without a telescreen. After falsely believing he was not watched, he renounced the government, was arrested and tortured. Other Party members, such as Julia and Mr. Parsons, exhibited anti-Party thoughts and actions. These characters, too, renounced the Party, were caught through surveillance programs, imprisoned, and not released until each person loved and obeyed the Party (Orwell 225). Moreover, the society of Oceania, ruled under a totalitarian government, revolved around government surveillance, emitting a false since of patriotism from its citizens, in order to control the actions, thoughts, and lifestyles

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Orwell’s 1984 he establishes a self-serving government to illustrate the impact on its citizenry, specifically Winston. One way that Orwell shows that the government is self-serving, is the use of mind control on the people of Oceania. “Big Brother” is a powerful deterrence of acting out against the government. Big Brother praises; War is peace, Freedom is slavery,…

    • 153 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This is accurate and has been proven in both novels, other works, and real history. In 1984, Orwell crafts a claustrophobic world where both the reader and the main character, Winston, are on edge and watched at all times. The line “Big Brother is watching you”, one of the most famous and repeated in the book, makes it clear that this is a reality where you are always watched. Winston has no privacy whatsoever, and as the book goes on we learn how detrimental that has been.…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1984 Betrayal Essay

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Living in Oceania is a life of no freedom nor privacy. Oceania is a dystopia, ruled by Big Brother. Big Brother shall not be overruled or tested. This is made clear in the novel because of the strict rules and laws. The people of Oceania are guarded by the thought police.…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    1984 Conformity Analysis

    • 3545 Words
    • 15 Pages

    Despite the fear of punishment, both of them choose to disregard the laws of the Party and pursue their relationship regardless of the possible consequences of their actions. The Party envisions a society where the citizens of Oceania are mentally transformed into mere instruments, paving the way for their dehumanization and living their lives without responsibility. Its control extends to the language used, the control of information, the manipulation of relationships, and laws. Many of these processes include the development of “Newspeak”, wherein the vocabulary used in language is reduced, thus making though processes limited, and the mental manipulation of children at an early age, where they are trained to spy on their parents and report any acts of rebellion. It is made clear throughout the novel that the freedom of thought and expression gives rise to the development of their individualities which made it prohibited; therefore, making Julia and Winston’s pursuit of personal happiness forbidden.…

    • 3545 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everything else was controlled by the Thought Police. Winston realized that there is no privacy in Oceania. Telescreens are placed all over Oceania to monitor the actions and conversations of the people, and to identify those who are against the party. Winston reveals during the two minutes hate that even the slightest change in your face in front of a Telescreen would give you away.…

    • 163 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There Is No Such Thing as Privacy “It was even conceivable that they watched us all the time.” These are the words Winston Smith and all of Oceania had to live by. George Orwell’s 1984 warns us about totalitarian regimes. The government, Big Brother, abolishes the citizen’s freedom and their own personal privacy, and even into their personal thoughts.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Theme Of Freedom In 1984

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages

    More Security, Less Freedom George Orwell’s dystopian book, 1984, is a step into the future, along with many side effects. This includes the people of Oceania, where the book takes place, and their security that comes with a price of their freedom. Winston is the main character in this novel and tries to ignore the fact, at first, that he doesn 't believe in Big Brother. While Winston is on his journey to freedom he comes across Julia, his beloved soul mate, and together they rebel against the Party. With many acts of rebellion the couple soon gets caught and their love and freedom of individuality is put on the line.…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Do you believe the government is spying on you through electronic devices? The government has invented many ways to spy on us as the years go by. We live in a generation where technology is used on a everyday basis, and not knowing there's someone behind every electronic devices watching or listening to you. The privacy violations Americans experience today are similar to the privacy violations in 1984 because the government spies on us through our phones, listen to our conversation through mics, and track us through our wifi and GPS.…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The police are only used to make sure the citizens are under control and are submissive to Big Brother. Many of these issues like privacy can relate to our own lives and how other governments of the world operate. In the totalitarian ruled Oceania, many ethical issues exist, one of which includes the invasion of privacy Big Brother creates. In this book,…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As these devices pick up even the slightest of movements and quietest of sounds, citizens of Oceania are restricted from having any moment in time solely to themselves. Consequently, the Party is always present within their lives and influences their behavior, which eliminates all forms of peaceful solitude within their lives. Bernstein asserts that the Party dehumanizes its people by removing its people’s right to seclusion: “This subjugation of human spirit is manifested by Orwell in his depiction of the frightening techniques of mind control: from the ubiquitous posters of Big Brother with eyes that follow you, to the electronic eye of the telescreen which invades even privacy of the bedroom” (26). Afraid of the Party’s scrutinous surveillance, the citizens of Oceania helplessly acclimate themselves to living according to the Party’s tacit rules to evade penalty. With the constant reminders of the omnipresence of the Inner Party through propaganda, these people discouraged from utilizing their free time for themselves.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    George Orwell’s dystopian novel, 1984, provides a chilling glimpse into a world where technology is used to control and to manipulate. The totalitarian government of Oceania, simply called, The Party, clamps down on the lives of its inhabitants, and forces them to obey Big Brother, the face of the Party. There is no room for revolution, as rebels are destroyed. Children are encouraged to spy on their parents, resulting in fractured relationships. The…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Emotionless Control From century to century, the government and its control over society seems to be becoming more and more prevalent. What people may or may not realize is that they could be under surveillance all the time. The government has the ultimate power over all of the citizens in a country, possibly forcing them to believe or act a certain way that they want them to. As seen in 1984 and Divergent, the two governments do everything in their power to control the people.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Party appears to be inescapable in the world of 1984 as the outreach of the Party makes the Party to be as “[acceptable] as something unalterable, like the sky”, as every citizen of Oceania can see the face of Big Brother, the beloved figure for the Party, and he can most certainly see them back through the technology of the telescreen which is a part of every Party member’s lives (Orwell 181). The words “Big Brother is Watching You” are emblazoned on “coins, on the covers of books, on banners, on posters, and on the wrapping of cigarette packages” and “always the eyes [of Big Brother are] watching [the people of Oceania] and the voice [of ‘Him’ is always] enveloping [them]...” (Orwell 27). Big Brother, in this sense, is ever present in their lives. He is the only certainty in their ever changing and war riddled world; they…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    1984: Diving into Deeper Meanings Imagine a society where you are always being watched. You can’t think on your own, speak your mind, or even feel any type of emotion. In George Orwell’s 1984, he writes of a Dystopian society in Oceania that is basically under totalitarian rule.…

    • 2185 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Psychological manipulation, technology and control of history are various methods which the government used to control society as a result it caused the citizens including Winston to lose their sense humanity, freedom and individual creativity. When individual freedom is denied, citizens become puppets of the state. In the end, Winston gave in as his final words were, “I Love Big Brother” (311). It is clear that Orwell is warning future generations. Our world is not far from becoming a totalitarian society because of regulating methods such as phone calls and bank transactions make our era similar to 1984 in which the government used telescreens to control its citizens.…

    • 1284 Words
    • 6 Pages
    • 2 Works Cited
    Superior Essays