Holocaust By Elizabeth Harvey

Improved Essays
The Holocaust was a significant event in history that has been analyzed in different ways. Much of what the Holocaust has taught is that all Germans right away supported the anti-Semitic thoughts of Nazis which, is not the case. Discrimination, persecution and eventually the murder of Jewish-Europeans between the years 1933 and 1945 as seen through accounts of historians, is argued that ordinary citizens participated in the territories where Jewish-Europeans resided. These ordinary Germans, participated in the persecution and murder of the Jewish Europeans as a result of the thoughts and ideals of the Germanic rule that was set forth onto German Jews and German Europeans. Much of the stigma that comes with studying the Holocaust is that …show more content…
The Germanic regime was expanding itself during the time of 1933 and 1945, making ordinary Germans have the ability to travel and be exposed to the world. Ordinary German men and women had the ability to help out the German government by gaining new jobs, which in turn helped out the government enact the anti-Semitic ruling. Without even knowing it, women exposed other countries to anti-Semitic and Nazi rule, through the jobs they received; even if these women themselves, did not believe in the thoughts of the Germanic regime. Elizabeth Harvey in We Forget All Jews and Poles: German Women and the ‘Ethnic Struggle’ in Nazi-Occupied Poland tells that women participated in two distinct ways to the persecution of Jews: either by physically being a persecutor or by teaching what the regime gave them. Harvey looks at the accounts of women who worked as “teachers, advisers and political organizers, asking how far such women were witnesses of and complicit in [the] acts of violence and injustice,” it is later shown that women were an “allotted ‘human border wall’” being loyal to their rulings and teachings. Such accounts, like Wendy Lower shows that ordinary German women who travelled and worked for Germany were “persecutors, gleeful onlookers, but also violent tormentors.” It can be speculated that these women …show more content…
The thought that people had their own intentions against the persecution of Jewish Europeans have been analyzed and looked as another reason for participation of ordinary Germans in the Holocaust. Two historians, Goldhagen and Browning both use the same sources to give two different opinions on the individual actions of ordinary German soldiers in the Police Battalion 101. Their analysis of pictures that were taken by soldiers of soldiers are the most interesting pieces of evidence they both use. Some pictures depict a sense of pride and glorification of soldiers violently hurting Jews. Browning on the cover of his book, Ordinary Men shows three German soldiers, one seemingly smiling and upon looking at the whole photo, two Jews are down on their knees in the middles of about a dozen of these German men. Actions in pictures give insight into just exactly what was going on in Jewish European areas; these pictures show that these soldiers must have liked the things they are doing. Much can be debated against both Goldhagen and Browning, one saying that soldiers wanted to participate in the persecution and murder , while Browning states that these men all had a choice to with some enacting these rulings and some not. The thought of choice is questioned; if citizens had the choice to enact such violence, and were not met with punishment

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Night Essay In a town called Sighet, Transylvania, many Jews were killed for what they believed in. This was called the Holocaust. During the Holocaust, people were being transported from their homes to much smaller areas called the ghettos. Without them knowing, Jews were taken to a concentration camp, where they were forced to work.…

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The book “Ordinary Men” describes the Police Batallion, a subset of the Order Police, who directly participated in the massacre of Jewish civilians in Poland of 1942. The author of “Ordinary Men”, Christopher Browning analyzes the testimonies made by the members of the Batallion in the 1960s, and tries to understand how any sane man was capable of performing the horrible deeds committed by these ordinary men. Browning takes a psychological standpoint in analyzing the motivation behind these killings, and generates multiple theories as to how a common man, previously a law-abiding citizen, can morph into a killer in such a short time. Browning assesses these theories, and tries to see if there’s any validity in them. When one is learning about the Holocaust, there is one question the general public always has: why did they do it?…

    • 1338 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Blair Louis Mrs. Gruehn English 14 November 2017 Night Essay Imagine going through a devastating time in history when people have to witness the death of beloved family members and having to suffer, endure, and survive in disgusting concentration camps. However, victims of the Holocaust had to face this terror in reality.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Goldhagen was a bestseller primarily because his argument made the general public feel safe about themselves because only Germans could possibly kill systematically. Meanwhile Browning’s argument makes his audience feel like anyone could kill innocent civilians because of the need to follow orders. Germans prefer Goldhagen’s argument because it coincides with the German exceptionalism, even though the Holocaust was a dark period in German history, it is still purely German. Browning’s book creates the image that the men operating in Reserve Police Battalion 101, were human and knew deep down what they were doing was immoral. In chapter, Browning makes a point of showing how the men were unable to execute the Jews properly because they knew they were killing innocent civilians.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being a woman with no rights, treated as an object, and tortured everyday was a huge struggle in concentration camps during the Holocaust. Life in concentration camps was extremely miserable for both men and women, but all of the little difficulties women faced, added up to create one big hardship. It was worse to be a woman in the concentration camps because they were more vulnerable to beatings and torture, had a higher chance of being killed right away, and had a hard time with excessive bleeding from menstruation. Elie Wiesel’s experience in the camps was different than a woman’s in many ways. Women were most likely to survive if they were in good and healthy condition.…

    • 638 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Daniel J. Goldhagen, an author and former Harvard professor, is an acclaimed academic who studies prejudice and antisemitism. While historians and professors are familiar with his published works, his response to Christopher Browning’s book, “Ordinary Men” has received the most attention. In his book, Christopher Browning argues that the men who committed the acts of mass murder of innocent people during the Holocaust were merely typical German citizens who killed due to social pressures. Goldhagen argues that the men who participated in these mass killings were not normal human beings and, in fact, killed for personal fulfillment. He successfully refutes Browning’s claim in his article “Presentation of Hitler’s Willing Executioners” by quoting credible historians and former Nazis, presenting accurate historical facts, and pointing out flaws in Browning's arguments.…

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ’”(22-24) In my perspective the degrading nature of the German and Hungarians shown in these excerpts instilled fear in the reader giving them an outlook on the severity of the concentration camps. This was a contributing factor when relinquishing the incentive…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He mentions that the Jews were efficiently treated much more terrible than other victims of the Nazis. He traits this distinction less to Hitler's priorities and the Nazi’s government rules, but instead indeed to the lethal antisemitism of the "ordinary " Germans. In the meantime, he mentions that the policemen were savagely expelling or killing on the spot of the entire Jewish community in the district. On the other hand, Browning explains the motivations of the Police Battalion 101 based on psychological perspectives. According to his research, Browning argues that these men have an inclination to follow their seniors command, even when those orders cause misery or death on others.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Neighbors The book I chose for this review is a shocking and disturbing account of unfathomable stories about anti-semitism in Poland in 1941. Neighbors, by Jan T. Gross, tells the story of a small Polish town of Jedwabne, where half of the population, was attacked and murdered by the other. The reason behind this inconceivable act against humanity was believed to be the work of the German SS, or death squads of the Nazi party; but through accounts of survivors it is now known that the killing was actually done by the townspeople. To determine the origin of hatred, Gross digs deep into the history of Poland and the Jews that migrated there many years ago.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout this class, and other history classes I have taken, there has always been little to no mention of women and the specific roles they have played in the Holocaust compared to the plethora of information about men. For this paper, I am going to compare three different stories about the experiences of women during the Third Reich and the Holocaust. Each woman comes from a different background faced varying degrees of misfortune and terror throughout their lives in Nazi Germany. The first woman, Ilse Landau, was a Jew who went into hiding during the war. Second is Marta Hessler, who was neither a Jew or a Nazi, just an ordinary German citizen who knew little about the mass murder.…

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first text read for this study is a journal article that was inspired by the lack of scholarship in the field of women during the Third Reich that was released in two parts: part one in Spring 1976 and part two in Fall 1976; it is Tim Mason's "Women in Germany: 1925-1940: Family, Welfare, and Work. Mason argues that besides Clifford Kirpatrick's 1938 text Nazi Germany: its Women and Family Life and Jill Stephenson's thesis 'Women in German Society 1930-1940' that the scholarship on women and Nazi Germany was scarce and there was a need to add to the scholarship. Not only is Mason inspired by the lack of scholarship on the topic, but also the women's movements in Britain and the United States occurring during that time. Because this is…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Spencer O’Brien English 10 Juskidus October 17th, 2017 Inhumanity in Humanity In Night, Elie Wiesel shows how millions of Jewish people were taken by the Nazis, placed into concentration camps and systematically killed. As prisoners, they were beaten regularly, starved, forced to live in horrendous conditions and were even stripped of their names. Overtime, the jews began to completely forget who they once were. As for the Nazis, they would tease, torture, and kill prisoners so often that it no longer seemed inhumane to them. Elie Wiesel demonstrates how the Holocaust brought out the most inhumane and savage side of both the prisoners and the Nazis SS guards.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the harsh times of the Holocaust, many German soldiers were put in charge to harm Jews and rid of their existence. Some might consider this an act of evilness, but many do not recognize that many soldiers were forced into these positions and their environment had propagandized false accusations against the group of people, which filled them with…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The theory that the people of Germany exhibited indifference during the Holocaust is widely believed to be true by many people. Both James M. Glass’ “Against the Indifference Hypothesis: The Holocaust and the Enthusiasts for Murder” and Omer Bartov’s “Defining Enemies, Making Victims: Germans, Jews, and the Holocaust” provide alternative reasoning for why German citizens not only watched the slaughter, but also actively participated in it. While Glass effectively argues that the German populace was indoctrinated to believe that the Jews were vermin, Bartov’s argument that they were simply scapegoated since they had historically fulfilled that role carries more scholarly merit due to his methodology. Glass’ essay focuses on disproving a previously…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Such was the case for the Germans following World War I. In “Defining Enemies, Making Victims,” Omer Bartov argues that in Nazi Germany and the subsequent Holocaust, the world has found the ultimate enemy in Nazis and the ultimate victim in Jews. Germany was broken after World War I on almost every level—financially, physically and psychologically. And, while German Jews had built a strong sense of solidarity while fighting…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays