Henrik Ibsen Compare And Contrast Essay

Improved Essays
One fateful winter’s evening would be the catalyst of change in a quiet housewife’s life. In Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House, Torvald and Nora Helmer appeared to be the perfect parents to a perfect family. This illusion came to an end when it had been revealed Mrs. Helmer had been keeping a large, dangerous secret from her husband. The secret had been exposed, however, there was no longer a threat of danger to the public reputation of the couple. Although the Helmer’s had their picture-perfect life back to safety, their life could not go back to normal because Norma no longer loved her husband. She promised to leave her family behind in hopes of a brighter future for everyone, including herself. Despite the story ending in a consistent way, Ibsen …show more content…
Helmer would have stayed with her family in the end of A Doll’s House, the story would be drastically different, as well as inconsistent with the message it sent. In the original storyline, the main character, Nora, came to the painful realization she did not love her husband. The realization came to her after their initial conflict over fraud was resolved. Although her husband, Torvald, had forgiven her of secretly making a deal with Krogstad, Nora was not willing to accept his forgiveness. When Torvald was initially in trouble, he verbally attacked his wife and then pretended nothing happened when the conflict dissolved. Nora found Torvald’s behavior to be disgusting and vile, which in turn made her realize she did not truly love him. In addition to not loving her husband, she concluded Torvald does not listen to or value her. On page 1646, Mrs. Helmer explains, “You’ve always been kind to me, but our home’s been nothing but a playroom. I’ve been your doll-wife, the same way that I was Papa’s doll-child.” (Ibsen) The quote stands out in the text because this was the moment Nora realized her husband treated her as something he could control and ‘play’ with, not as a wife. Because she was enlightened about her situation, she did not want to stay with him. In turn, if Nora would have stayed with her family anyway as part of an alternate ending, it would make little sense because it was made clear, Mrs. Helmer did not wish to remain married. Because she did not want …show more content…
Throughout Nora’s journey in the play, it often hints to her nurse-maid taking care of the children. For example, in the opening scenes, the children were not home because they were with the nurse-maid. When Nora attempted to decorate the tree, she had the children stay upstairs with the nurse-maid once again. It is extremely apparent the children are with their maid every day, versus spending time with their mother. Because of this, Nora began to question her parenting. At one point, she asks the nurse-maid about raising other people’s children, but most importantly, if the children would miss their parents if they disappeared. This simple question shed a light on Nora’s true feelings about being a mother. Identically, Nora recalled how she did not get to know her own mother because she was raised by a nurse-maid as well. This part of the play foreshadowed Nora’s feelings at the end of the play. While arguing, Torvald commands Nora to not raise the children anymore because he is convinced she is corrupt. After he had scolded her, Nora realized she is an unfit mother for her children. To solve the issue, Nora planned to leave her family and never look back. In the alternate ending, Nora watched her children asleep and decided to stay for their sake. The course of action taken does not make sense because Nora acknowledged she does not know what she is doing when it came to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Of course she was hurt by her father, but even more so by Dana, the person she became great friends with. Chaurisse was hurt to find out that such a good friend would lie and keep such a big secret from her. Chaurisse then questioned their entire friendship and wondered if it was all a trick to separate James Witherspoon from his main family. Instead of apologizing, Dana decided to stay away and let go of the friendship that she built with her sister. Dana did not abide by her father at the beginning by keeping away from his main family, but she sure did abide by him at the end, once she realized he would not choose her family over Chaurisse’s.…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Remy had never noticed there was a distance between her and her mother until her fight with Don. It established the fact that even though her marriages have never been successful, Remy’s mother chooses her husbands over her own daughter. Her mother’s five, unsuccessful marriages taught Remy that love does not exist and she has commitment issues because she was never shown a lasting relationship. This belief that love does not exist or last causes Remy to have a negative and cynical belief in relationships. This is why her boyfriends have “expiration dates”; Remy goes into a relationship knowing she will give “The Speech” to slow down the relationship, then sleeps with them, and then reasons with herself that it’s time to end it (135).…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The feeling of being oppressed, deprive, isolated, and the emptiness finally got the best out of John’s wife, that she literally breaks free from all of it and start her new beginning by leaving her husband. Similarly, in the play of “A Doll’s House” Nora struggles to be honest to Torvald about the decision that she made eight years ago. The decision she made is to borrow the money illegally to help Torvald regain his health by moving him to a more suitable climate to improve his health. Knowing that her husband will never understand her reasons for this decision. This is also a good illustration of feeling alone since she is hiding her actions from her husband.…

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Darcy are very happy with each other. When Mr. Collins, whom Elizabeth does not like, proposed, she explained that “You could not make me happy, and I am convinced that I am the last woman in the world who could make you so” (Chapter 19). Elizabeth, instead of giving in to the pressure from her mother to marry, understands that she and Mr. Collins could never make eachother happy, and so she wisely did not marry him. When Mr. Darcy proposes for the first time, Elizabeth again chooses to follow her opinions, rather than marry someone she doesn’t like. She tells Mr. Darcy, “I had not known you a month before I felt that you were the last man in the world whom I could ever be prevailed on to marry” (Chapter 34).…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On one hand she “loves her,” but on the other hand, she “hates when she leaves her home alone.” Monica describes their relationship as “rocky.” She states “everything is fine when she is home,” but “I get mad when she leaves.” I curse her out, shout, and I will cut myself just to show her I am not playing.” “She admits her grandmother is afraid to leave her home alone and she is threatening to put her out of the house if she does not change. Monica states she also has a strained relationship with her father. She has male associates but states they are “only good for one thing.” They never stick around for the “long haul.” Her extended family “cut her off several years ago” and they have limited…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first reason Mama Elena's actions were not coming from good intentions is because she showed her no affection that a loving and caring mother would do. When Tita was seen crying by Mama Elena, she does not comfort her. Tita was upset that she had to prepare the wedding for her sister and the man she loved. Her mom thought of her as ruining Rosaura wedding and did not stand for it. The narrator says “Mama Elena read the look on her face and flew into a rage, giving Tita a tremendous slap that left her rolling in the dirt.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She wasn 't able to walk around by herself and every little action was controlled by her parents. However, she was able to figure out a way to see her partner. This form of stubbornness developed as a anti-statement to her parent 's control. Next, she was pregnant and while she was hiding her pregnancy from people, the news were spread in town. In this part of the story, I was disgusted by the boyfriends action of not respecting his girlfriend and violating her privacy.…

    • 2020 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This makes reference to the fact that Ophelia has cracked under the pressure from her family to no longer be in a relationship with Hamlet though she does truly love him. This is proved when Ophelia takes her own life as she has nothing in her world anymore because Hamlet is no longer a part of her life. Overall, Hamlet exposes Ophelia by uncovering that she is loyal to her father and doesn’t make her own choices which disguises her true…

    • 1971 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, this wish is stamped out by the thought that “[Jacinda’s worries are] going to kill [Renata]” and her mother will “hate [her], thinking [she’s] lying about the guy [her mother] loves” (Holeman 121). But contrary to what Jacinda expected, when her mother discovered the discomfort Jacinda was experiencing, she immediately ended her relationship with Jerry. Hence, the feeling of nobody listening can be partially true, but teens should realize that there is someone who will care and listen to what they have to say. It is up to the teenagers to open up to those people, and let their voices freely…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    All Curley talked about was how he’d beat up people and he was constantly angry. Curley’s wife wanted to talk about something other than that, She really didn’t want to marry Curley. The only reason she married him was to infuriate her mother. Curley’s wife was certain that her mom took the letters she was sent by the man who promised to make her a movie star. Her mother told her she didn’t take the letters but curley’s wife was too naive to believe her.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays