The Argument Of Hidden Intellectualism

Improved Essays
Hidden Intellectualism has been become a controversial topic for educators of late and needs to be assessed so that educators can address this particular issue and modify classroom teachiwhether or not a person with a highly evolved “street smarts” and who does poorly in an academic environment should be considered any less intellectual than one who is well acclimated to academia and categorized as an excellent student

On the one hand gerald graff argues that “real intellectuals turn any subject how ever lightweight it may seem, into gist for their mill through the thoughtful questions they bring to it. Whereas a dullard will find a way to drain even the richest subject”. The essence of Gerald Graff 's argument is that students should be
…show more content…
Mike rose speaks about his mother “Rosie” as a waitress at a local restaurant, Mike began to study the working habits of “blue collar workers” his mother in particular. He realized that his mother 's type of work required “demands on both the body and the brain”. Although this wasn 't your typical career it was none the less a career that required extensive knowledge and on the job training. Mike points out that Rosie learned to work effectively and made sure that every move counted. She learned to handle problems with ease and dealt with them within the flow of her work. She constantly took her co-workers “emotional state” into account. For example was her manager in a good mood? or did the cook wake up on the wrong side of the bed?. Another example from “blue collar brilliance” is mike 's brother joe, who only received up to eighth grade education but started working at a G.M paint and autobody shop working his way up to the supervisor over the years. According to both “blue collar brilliance” and “hidden intellectualism” no person should be considered any less intellectual based on their amount of formal education anybody can achieve intelligent by learning more about their passions and doing what they love. For example if someone loves to work on cars growing up there is a good chance they would become a mechanic or in the automotive field making them intelligent in their career . Both Joe Meraglio and Rosie are extremely knowledgeable in their careers. even though work- related action becomes routine, they were learning at one point through observations, trial and error and most often verbal and physical assistance from experienced workers on the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Rose expresses his support for the working class by writing about his mother and his uncle and the jobs they performed and how they improved in life through working. He first writes about his mother, Rosie, who is a waitress. In waitressing, the amount that they get paid all depends on how well they perform. As Rose puts it, “Her tip depended on how wells she responded to these needs, and so she became adept at reading social cues and managing feelings, both the customers’ and her own” (246). Social interactive skills are vital in any occupation, it is very important in…

    • 1392 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This shows how blue-collar workers had to be crafty to get ahead in the working world. Also, by the fact that Gloria agreed to the deal shows how much she believed in Anneth’s skills. Working-class people often learn tricks of the trade by watching and learning from others. For example, Anneth learned from Gloria that when the restaurant isn’t busy to roll silverware, since there can never be too much on hand. Furthermore, when she became the boss, she had to learn the administrative side of the café, which was paying the employees and coming up with schedules (House 260).…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Each server has several tables at a time and it is their job to prioritize and strategize to give the most efficient service. A great tool to use is making strong relationships with coworkers and working as a team. Working in a restaurant teaches an individual how to be a team player. It takes several hands to properly run a restaurant. One of the greatest attributes I have gained from my experience as a waitress is a strong work ethic.…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the years, I have learned that growing up in a family business atmosphere has carved me to who I am today. Growing up, every semester break or public holiday, I would always attend to work at my father's pizzeria to help out and learn about the business. I have learned that managing is all about coping with diversity and complexity. As I grew older, I was given a managerial role of being a supervisor at work. Being the eldest daughter in the family, my father placed a big responsibility on me to learn inside and outside of the business.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pacheco’s 8th year at his job is approaching and he couldn’t be more proud of those he has met, soon to meet and he’ll continuing working on to teaching himself more communication skills. You can even learn life skills outside of the classroom like, Shea Trauba on his own learned how apply for loans, calculate college cost, pay college costs, buy a house, and buy a car. Trauba on his own learned to take steps in to the right directions of living on his own and taking care of all matter needs to live. Trauba continues on to this day working while still managing himself. But we learn all this stuff one day in our lives, especially with technology and whatnot, but some stuff it’s absolutely hard to learn on your own.…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What if people were defined by their intellectual ability and not by their educational creditionals or if people where taught how to be intellectual along with obtaining a formal education? Well in the articles, “Hidden Intellectualism” by Gerald Graff and “Blue Collar Brilliance” by Mike Rose both illustrates the term being intellectual is beyond the norm of school textbook knowledge. They believes that there are many forms of intelligence in which it can be capitalize and utilize as a life learned tool if its nurture properly. Our society is conditioned to rely solely on board-approved standard of education while suppressing those unique individuals who may be illiterate or not as book smart as the next person. Yet, these individuals have…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main stereotypes that we discussed were about how women belong in the kitchen doing their duties whereas the men are out and about working and hanging out with friends instead of being home helping out his wife with her duties wich include, but are not limited to cooking all of the meals three times a day seven days a week. Constantly cleaning the house, so that way the man of the house never has to see what a dirty house looks like. The women also almost solely raise the children from birth until about fifteen or sixteen years old for boys, when they are old enough to help their old man get money. Or do yard work. But if you are a female, then you get to learn everything that a good wife does for his husband.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Apple Cult: Steve Jobs

    • 1302 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Steve Jobs learned how to take apart and reconstruct electronics, a hobby that instilled confidence, tenacity and mechanical prowess. Although Steve Jobs was always an intelligent thinker, his youth was filled with frustrations over traditional schooling. His fourth grade teacher had to bribe him to study. Siri watched over him all of his life and introduced him to his future partner, Steve Wozniak, in high school. She made sure he met the right people in order to fulfill her goal.…

    • 1302 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After he finished college at Vo Tech, he did two years of apprenticeship to help him with his understanding of cars in the real world. He landed his first job within a month of graduating college at White Bear Dodge. He worked there for six years and after four of those years he finally decided that he wanted to become a higher ranked mechanic so he did everything he could to move up in the ranks, so he could be paid more. There were four steps he had to complete before obtaining his Elite-Master rank. He had to have a degree in auto mechanics, had to complete…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not only was I living it up, but I was also using my watchfulness for good use. I remember that around that time, I was starting to truly understand what my parents were up to. Despite what I was shown on my first day at work (which I remember only through videos and stories), I was actually learning about the business model that they had created. My parents had created an Empire. My mom played the observant, responsible, hardworking and perfectionist role in the story of our family’s rise to the top, whereas my dad opted for the role as the reliable jokester, who charmed the customers into coming back.…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays