Wilson And Roosevelt's Three Progressives

Superior Essays
The term “progressive” in politics is used to describe someone who brought about political, social, and economic changes and reforms while in power. The period around the early 1900s has been named the “Progressive Era” because of the work of these three former Presidents of the United States: Roosevelt, Taft, and Wilson. At times, these presidents, especially Taft, would go against the progressive ideals that they are associated with today, but these three presidents were deemed progressive because of Roosevelt’s Square Deal policy, Taft’s dissolving of trusts, and Wilson’s reforms involving taxes and tariffs.
As a progressive president, Theodore Roosevelt fought to better the lives of Americans as individuals. He utilized a “Square Deal”
…show more content…
Teddy made the decision when he was elected that he would not run for another term, but he handpicked Taft to be the next Republican nominee. Taft won the presidency and was thought to be a mild progressive that was aware of the needs of the nation. He turned out to be too mild of a progressive, especially in relation to Roosevelt, according to many other Progressives of the day. Surprisingly, Taft broke up more trusts than Teddy Roosevelt, but that is where the progressivism begins to decline. In a move that was initially intended to lower excessive tariffs, Taft urged the House of Representatives to pass a bill to slightly lower some tariffs, but the Senate made major revisions to the statute, which in turn, caused tariffs to go up on many products. Progressives obviously were outraged by this decision, and Taft began to lose support from that group. This deviation from the progressivism of old caused a split in the Republican Party, which allowed Democrats to have the majority in the House of Representatives. Roosevelt came back to attempt to become the Republican candidate for the 1912 election. After failing at that attempt, he formed his own “Bull-Moose” Party and became a third-party candidate. It was this split in the Republican Party that allowed a Democrat to win the …show more content…
The regulation of trusts compelled owners to consider the public opinion in making their own decisions. Consumers became more protected in the economy and in health and safety aspects. Lowering of certain tariffs enabled greater revenues for America, which were used in other projects to improve the country. However, not all Progressives were the same. Some had more radical ideas than others as seen by the work of Theodore Roosevelt as opposed to William Howard Taft. Overall, the main goal toward progress was reached as America made its way into the 20th

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    How and why did the progressives and their reforms change America? What were the limits of progressivism? What was the legacy of the progressive reform? Progressives, or progressive thinkers, were the cornerstone of reform in America, inspiring and encouraging new programs that would benefit citizens. The progressive era in America was not without its complications as progressivism played a role on both sides of the political spectrum, leading to a clash of what was considered worthy of reform, and what was regarded as the government prying too much into business and citizens personal lives.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first thing he thought about was the tariffs; he thought of an act, Payne Aldrich Tariff of 1909, that he thought was reasonable for this country. This act was a sort of a restricted amount, but it was later changed to an excessive tariff. Taft way of thought caused an uproar to the party politically. Taft 's way splits the party, “the “Old Guard” Republicans who supported Taft and the Progressive Republicans who backed Roosevelt. This led to chaos to the politics; the parties were not able to back up the people that were necessary to so Teddy Roosevelt created a new party “Bull…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They were known as the Progressive Presidents. Theodore Roosevelt was a republican who brought the movement to the federal level, and he became president in 1901 after the assassination of William McKinley. After becoming president, he demanded a “Square Deal.” The goal of this “deal” was to prevent the waste of natural resources, control corporations, and provide consumer protection. He aimed to differentiate good corporations from bad corporations. Good corporations provided useful products and services for reasonable prices while bad corporations only had mercenary intentions.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Roosevelt’s confidence and popularity before and during his time in office influenced him into assuming a legacy of his policies to fight for the average Americans and against big business (Cooper 79). Roosevelt’s strong sense of confidence, American nationalism, and American exceptionalism which at times blinded him from passing long lasting legislation rather than being a hero and getting involved in single situations of intervention (Cooper 85 and Irwin). For the 1908 presidential election, Roosevelt supported the candidacy of William Howard Taft with the expectation that Taft would carry on Roosevelt’s policies when he won (Cooper 109 and…

    • 1877 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By 1914, the Progressive Era had instilled a healthy dose of positive liberty into American domestic policy, resulting in many important educational, labor, and economic reforms that continue to affect American legislature today. But following WWI, President Woodrow Wilson took the concept of positive liberty to an even more influential level by proposing a new approach to foreign policy that essentially advocated for internationalism. In doing so, he was challenging the American tradition of isolationism that had more or less stood unchanged since the presidency of George Washington himself. Because of its perceived radicalism, Wilson’s proposed policy was initially rejected by Congress. But in the years that followed, WWII and the publication…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In a time of majorly Republican feelings, Cleveland broke through with Democratic ideas, not once, but twice (Grover Cleveland). While many argue that he was a sub par president, the time period in which he was in office must also be taken into consideration. Not only was he in charge during the Panic of 1893 (Boyer), but he was an anti-imperialist in a time where many were pro-imperialism. Allen Nevins properly summarizes Cleveland’s success. He writes, “[I]n Grover Cleveland the greatness lies in…

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Howard Taft Personality

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages

    He chose not keep him due to his use of previous executive orders to promote conservation instead of following legislation. Taft also fired Chief Forester Gifford Pinchot who was one of Roosevelt’s closest friends and advisors, for his radical ways of promoting conservation. These two replacements angered Roosevelt even more as Pinchot and Garfield were some of Roosevelt’s closest advisors and friends, and was a major reason why Roosevelt decided to run against Taft in the 1912 presidential election. Taft had more luck making Supreme Court appointments where he carefully chose judges who he had known for years and had lots of experience. Taft, however, did have a controversial appointment when he appointed Edward D. White as Chief Justice in 1910.…

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Taft and his rival Woodrow Wilson, the 1912 presidential election was leaning in the favor of the Republicans. This changed when the Republican Party decided to abandon a progressive platform and stick with conservative ideals. The decision prompted Roosevelt drop support for Taft, betraying not only his party but also their close friendship. Instead he chose to leave the Republican Party and form his own Progressive Party, also known as the “Bull-Moose Party” (“The Election”). This divide in the Republican party led to a division of voters, causing both parties to lose the election.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas Jefferson began a massive shift of power from the Federalists to the Republicans that would lead to the eventual disintegration of the Federalists. The first way Jefferson’s election did this was through the striking down of many Federalist policies, such as repealing the Judiciary Act of 1801, which got rid of 40 Federalist judicial positions that John Adams had filled last-minute before Jefferson took over as president. Actions such as the aforementioned helped Jefferson to gain more leverage for his agenda as president. However, Jefferson did keep quite a few economic policies established by the Federalists, most notably the Bank of the United States, which he had once spoken out against as unconstitutional. Such tolerance to important Federalist ideals began to make the two parties more similar to one another, as Jefferson’s radical Republican policies became more moderate.…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Under a more public approach to improve regulations, these presidents became the key foundation of the Progressive Era. However, there 's always a concern regarding, where do these presidents rank among the progressive spectrum. After thoroughly analyzing each president 's approaches and actions during this period, I concluded that Woodrow Wilson is the most progressive, closely followed by Theodore Roosevelt, and lastly William Taft. Starting from the least progressive is William Taft, who embroiled both progressive and conservative ideals. Due to the oppositions of these factor, often times Taft ended up satisfying more toward the conservatives rather than progressives.…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays