Sotnikov Andrei Sokolov's Allegory In Destiny Of A Man

Improved Essays
Christian imagery and allegory are remarkably prevalent in many soviet films. This is reflective of the Russian Orthodox Church’s ineradicable position in Russian culture as well as the applicability – the universal nature - of the biblical story. Paradoxically, this phenomenon directly contradicts the idealized atheism of the soviet state. In this paper I will explore the different ways four of the thirteen films we have watched this semester incorporate Christianity. The most obvious elusion to Christianity is the allegory of Christ. This is a powerful cinematic choice in which characters, through personal attributes or general events, take on the significance of Christ, giving the film greater meaning. In the films we have watched, Sotnikov …show more content…
His status as an allegorical character is more complex than Sotnikov or Ivan’s because his story does not mirror the life of Christ in such an obvious way. Sokolov takes on the role of Jesus, the son, and God, the father, at different moments in the film. While he is a prisoner, Sokolov is Jesus, questioning his destiny and then destiny of men. Two scenes clearly illustrate this. The first scene is Sokolov escape. He runs to a wheat field and lies down in in a crucified position, looking up at the sky and at whatever god might be looking down upon him. The viewer knows that God is looking down on Sokolov because the perspective changes to a bird’s eye view, God’s view, of Sokolov lost in the sea of wheat. The second scene is a more obvious illusion to Christ. While in a Nazi work camp Sokolov is sentenced to execution by shooting. He is called into the camp leader’s office where the German officers are celebrating the false news of Stalingrad’s fall. Their meal, which is doomed, is reminiscent of the last supper. Sokolov awes the German commander with his ability to drink vodka on an empty stomach. Here, the vodka cup represents the holy chalice, the cup used at the last supper to serve wine. The commander spares Sokolov’s life and gives him a loaf of bread and some cheese. Sokolov returns to the barracks where, before collapsing, he commands that everyone gets an equal. The prisoners careful ‘breaking of the bread’ they are allotted represents communion. After the war Sokolov becomes God, the father. After all his suffering he adopts a young boy, just as God’s relationship with humanity becomes more intimate through Jesus’s suffering. Sokolov tells the young boy that he is the father, which gives the young boy’s world meaning

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Living with the Enemy Every human being since the fall of man lives with an enemy that wants to control us, his enemy can make the nicest person misbehave and do things they should do. In the Movie Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde by Robert Stevenson uses biblical elements such as the sinful nature that is in every human heart because of sin to reveal what it look like to want to do right but evil is seems to always be present and more fun. This picture of sinful man and what sin will make you do is very powerful. Stevenson allows the reader to see who enticing sin and…

    • 1567 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    His ethical, the religious life, coincides with Soviet Communism, as both are the universal and the embodiment of their Worlds. For Kierkegaard the religious life as the ethical allows his to devote his life to God, and for the Soviet Union, Soviet Communism as the ethical allows the people to devote their lives to the Soviet way of life. Boris, Alyosha, and Stalin never let their selfish desires control them in their respective films, and as such they all followed the ethical to the best of their abilities. Boris volunteered to go to the front in order to fulfill his duty to the ethical, Alyosha never diverted from his goal of getting back to the front after seeing his mother once again in order to fulfill his identity as a Russian soldier fighting for the ethical, and Stalin existed in the film as the personification of the ethical himself, supporting his people and Communism while encouraging them to continue the fight for the…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Christ Figure is a character in literature whose actions and intentions resemble those of Jesus Christ. In the three works of literature that we have discussed, each character exemplifies key aspects that relate closely with those of Jesus Christ. Though the three separate works each shows evidence of characters being a Christ Figure, they do so in their own unique way. A Separate Peace is a story that tells of Gene’s recollection of his closest friend Phineas life, death and the many events that occur at boarding school. Finny is a strong character with a boisterous personality and is the image of a perfect person to his best friend, Gene.…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book The Brother Karamazov, two of the major themes that are discussed in the chapter of Rebellion are the contrasting relationships between naturalism and Christianity in relation to suffering. To better understand the relationship between both of these differing beliefs, it is best understood from the main character’s perspective, who is Ivan. He does not endorse either naturalism or Christianity because he believes that neither of them are the solution to stop the suffering in the society. Also, he believes that they are both equally and morally unjust and lack accountability among its offenders and followers.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Alant Hunt: Moral Panics

    • 338 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Alant Hunt, makes a point that moral panics are part of wider dynamics of “moral panics” in which some agents act to “problematize the conduct, values or culture of others and seek to act upon them though moralizing discourses, moralizing, practises, and religion. ”(cited in Krinsky, C. 2013, p.134)The contemporary example of moral panic issue surrounding ‘gay-propaganda’ law in Russia was justified by the Russian politician Vitaly Milonov, as the need to protect children from being corrupted and uphold Orthodox Christian moral values as gay people stand as threat to those values. (Available at: http://sputniknews.com/analysis/20120830/175525037/Vitaly-Milonov-Laying-Down-Gods-Law-in-Russia.html) The agent of the moral panic is an Orthodox Church,…

    • 338 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Drunks Raskolnikov

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Interactive Oral provides plenty of facts from which knowledge can be acquired in order to draw parallels to literature. The Interactive Oral for Books 1 through 3 of Crime and Punishment provided knowledge of the cultural and societal influence of said novel. What was drawn from this experience is that the culture and society of Russia in that time period played a big role in terms of the setting, character development, tone, mood and overall plot of this piece . St. Petersburg, at the time the novel was written, was a filthy, destitute and impoverished place. The serfs of Russia had just been freed five years earlier, and therefore the city was more densely populated, with many struggling to find a steady source of income.…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Raskolnikov's Confession

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In part 1, chapter 2, Marmeladov talks about his miserable life to Raskolnikov. Raskolnikov soon finds out Marmeladov and his family are having a hard time because Marmeladov spends all their money buying alcohols. Marmeladov sees himself as a great sinner knowing that he is not a good husband nor a good father. He thinks he should be “crucified on a cross” (23) because he believes God will forgive his sins if he suffers like Jesus. Russian Orthodoxy appears in this situation by mentioning the crucifixion of Jesus Christ.…

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this poem, Dostoyevsky uses the thought provoking conversation between two very religious brothers to discuss God, the meaning of life and the role of God in life. He calls into question whether God is truly benevolent or a god of “Mockery” who enjoys watching mankind suffer and struggle. In this passage, Ivan is telling the story of the encounter between “the grand inquisitor” and Jesus Christ. Ivan had previously discussed how the inquisitor had questioned Jesus and his true intentions as God and in the passage above Ivan questions his brother about the possible truth behind the Inquisitor’s questions. He essentially described that through much thought, meditation, and ridding himself of worldly objects, the inquisitor came to the conclusion…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Persecution of Religion in Stalinist Russia Throughout history, religion has played an important role in shaping culture, government and the economy, but it is important to also consider times when the absence of religion has done the same. Under the control of Joseph Stalin and the Communist party in the early 1920s, Russia became the first nation to institutionalize atheism. Propelled by the ideals of communism and the example of his predecessor, Stalin sought to secularize the nation and to bring an end to religion in Russia. This paper will explore the tensions between religion and politics in Stalinist Russia, focusing particularly on how Stalin’s political agenda affected his religious policies.…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the title would imply the painting depicts an Orthodox priest offering a condemned prisoner his last confession before execution which he refuses because of the corrupt position of the Orthodox church as an extension of the autocratic state that he is about to lose his life in protest against. Partially inspired by the revolutionary Nikolai Minsky’s poem, ‘The Last Confession’ published in 1879 by the illegal Populist newspaper Narodnaia Voila (The People’s Will); Refusal was produced during the transition of the Populist movement from activism to terrorism marked by the assassination of Aleksandr II in 1881 by members of the ‘People’s Will’. This transition was also reflected in the changing composition of the figures, beginning sketches had a vigorous prisoner castigating the priest but the final version depicts a somber and steadfast man with the toll of imprisonment evident on the convict’s face. This painting is the most heroic depiction of a revolutionary of any of the Wanderers works on the theme and draws a natural and somewhat ironic comparison to nearly any example of martyrdom for one’s beliefs in the Christian tradition. The posture of the prisoner and the shrouded hands of both figures show the, ‘improbability of any rapprochement and the two figures remain frozen…each in his own faith.’…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The film analyzes the beginning of Christianity, giving an overview of the lives of key figures, particularly Jesus and Paul, focusing on the historical context rather than the legitimacy of the miracles supposedly performed through these people. Proving or disproving whether Jesus existed or whether he performed or endured the actions for which he has become famous is not the focus of the film but, instead, his social status is the main subject of question, for example, whether or not he was a poor carpenter who lived in a community isolated from urban culture, and whether or not his crucifixion was a spectacle witnessed by a large multitude. The film also analyzes the demographic composition and the social context of the early Christian movement.…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Battleship Potemkin, a Bolshevik propaganda film from 1925, impresses upon its audience the validity of the new Communist regime in Russia by presenting an idealized microcosm of the Bolshevik revolution on the battleship Prince Tavrichesky. Battleship Potemkin curates its audience’s reaction through the rise and fall of tension, which it does most prominently through the synergy of camera shot placement, camera shot order and music. Battleship Potemkin cycles through periods of calm, tension, and action. In this essay, calm is defined as a period in which on-screen subjects are not opposed to one another. Tension occurs when on-screen subjects are opposed to one another, but do not act on their opposition.…

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    His pain was constant, “quiet, serious, and insistent,” (Tolstoy, 88). Ivan’s appearance deteriorates throughout the novella and his eyes begin to present “not a spark of life within them,” (Tolstoy, 86). Throughout his life, Ivan constantly avoided his suffering. When his marriage became an inconvenience, he escaped by growing “more attached to his job, and more ambitious than ever,” (Tolstoy, 57). However, his illness provides an anguish that is not so easily escapable.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anna Akhmatova Allusion

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Moreover, religious elements are seen in “Thank You, God…” which demonstrates gratitude to God for helping her endure the loss of someone important to her life. Akhmatova expresses appreciation to God for helping her “dream of him more seldom” (“Thank You, God…” 1) and making “[her] soul healthy” (“Thank You, God…” 15). Religion is what could have helped many Russians persevere, but it was banned and those pursuing it were persecuted. The shift from the personal pronoun “I” to the plural possessive pronoun “our" in “Our Lord” demonstrates the universal functionality of religion in helping Russians persevere in Stalinist Russia (“Thank You, God…” 15). Hence, Akhmatova used religious references to explain the despair that Russians were experiencing during Stalinist Russia and…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Influence of Byzantine Culture on the Russian Religious Faith and Literature Byzantine heritage was the source of cultural life for Kievan Rus. Later, the territories known as Russian Empire, adopted the main principles of faith borrowed from Rus which developed into the whole system of philosophical views. Despite the fact that Byzantium fell in sixteen century, its cultural legacy continues existing today and it takes its rightful place in world culture. The main contribution of the Byzantine Empire to the spiritual life was made primarily through the establishment and development of Orthodox Christianity (Hussey). Thus, under the influences of Eastern tradition of Christianity the Russian religious faith and literature was exposed for…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays