Comparison Of Silent Spring And Garbage Wars

Superior Essays
As the environment becomes increasingly more in danger, problems start to arise within human communities as well as within the communities of all living organisms. The impact of these complications prompts the need for establishing a solution. However, the results of these human created solutions can lead to further social and environmental crises. For instance, the two excerpts from the books, “Garbage Wars” written by David Pellow and “Silent Spring” written by Rachel Carson, display how solutions to maintain environmental problems can actually create a foundation for additional environmental injustices. Although Carson and Pellow may seem to present similar arguments concerning the importance of addressing environmental crises, each portrays …show more content…
Throughout “Silent Spring,” Carson wishes to inform the American society about the dangers of a specific pesticide known as DDT. Carson describes many environmental impacts that coincide with the widespread spraying of DDT in the United States, questioning the logic of the large use of this chemical without completely understanding the environmental and human complications that could potentially arise. Throughout, “Silent Spring” it is illustrated how DDT entered the food chain and then began accumulating into the tissues of animals along with humans. Carson concludes that pesticides obtain the power to irrevocably harm animals and pollute the world 's food supply. Consequentially, the chapter, "A Fable for Tomorrow," is included within “Silent Spring” in order to depict human’s potential future. The chapter describes an American town where all forms of life, including humans, have been "silenced" by the gradual harmful effects of …show more content…
Individuals needs to recognize, increase awareness, and take responsibility for environmentally unjust actions. Carson questions “How could intelligent beings… bring the threat of disease and death to their own kind?” The use of pesticides such as DDT cause instrumental impacts and a ripple of further implications that will become apparent within future generations. Species are endangered and health concerns arise. However, American society is blind to any future consequences. Furthermore, Carson implies that officials overlook health and environmental concerns in order to acquire greater amounts of money. Yet, supporting the use of pesticides results in the depletion of insects creating a disturbance within the ecosystem. Through out Carson’s writing, it becomes apparent that the use of DDT in order to control the amount of “pests” on crops, leads to further environmental problems that should not be ignored. Throughout the two excerpts written by Carson and Pellow, the need to establish a concerned consciousness in order to solve environmental crises is heightened. Pellow stresses that solutions to maintain environmental injustices lead to environmental racism within a community and Carson wishes to reiterate that solutions to maintain problems within the environment can lead detrimental

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Outline About Parathion

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I. Introduction a. Background information parathion and use of pesticides in the 1950-1960s b. Information about the environmental movement that happened after the book was published THESIS: In the excerpt from Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, she states that the use of spraying pesticides is not worth the damage done because of the poison's widespread damage to nature and farmers' ignorance to the dangerous effects parathion has on humans and their worker's lives. II. Body Paragraph 1 a. Carson describes parathion's widespread danger by presenting much of wildlife that was killed as a result of spraying the poison's damage as innocent and describing other deaths as an attempt to change the audience's view to have sympathy for these unintended deaths that do…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Even though people cannot do much, we can all take part in taking responsibility in improving the environment. Ehrlich’s writing urges people to do things that can slow down global warming effects and prevent more harm to ecosystem by showing readers glacier that melt in fast rate due to increased industrialism by humans. Gawande’s article helps me to understand that pollution not only can damage the earth, but pollutions can have direct effects on humans as well. He’s article of “The Cancer Cluster Myth”, implied impact of contamination (Both in water and on ground), and toxic waste on cancer cluster effect in some communities. Saukko’s essay shows us many ways the planet can get poisoned; her essay helps readers to think about what we can…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    A quick glance at the local or national paper will show you that there are many environmental issues today. Some of the issues you will hear about are related to population issues and how to control the population of humans on Earth. Some stories will be about the loss of ecosystems in some part of the world. Maybe you'll see something that has to do with the current administration treats environmental issues. You are going to probably be reading a lot of articles that talk about climate change.…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since the environment is a hot topic in today’s news, many people have strong opinions one way or another about how people should handle environmental problems. The satirical book The Future of Life, juxtaposes two extreme ideas about environmentalism. Edward O. Wilson elaborates on the unproductive nature of headstrong, uncompromising environmental discussions by utilizing exaggerated diction, hyperbolic rhetorical question, and parallelism. By using exaggerated diction, Wilson highlights the satirical nature of unproductive environmentalist arguments.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Underground, dark, warm, and damp is the work environment of a coal miner. Coal mining has been around since the 1300’s. Since then, technology has changed and is still booming in today’s society. It was approximately around the late 1800’s that coal became a significant resource in generating electricity. The differences in coal mining today and back then were tremendously different.…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Air Pollution Controversy

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Air Pollution Policy and Controversy Rachel Carson boldly warned the American people in 1962 that if the United States continued its agricultural and industrial practices, songbirds would cease to exist. Losing an important part of the ecological food chain would have repercussions, possibly worse than we could imagine. While literature like Silent Spring helped bring attention to environmental concerns in the mid to late 1900s, several fatal disasters struck a stronger chord. Smog in Pennsylvania and the fire-lit Cuyahoga, for example, illustrated just how dearly the environment needed policy reform.…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pesticides can do many things that make human’s lives easier. They can kill unwanted bugs, which are called insecticides, they can kill unwanted plants, which are called herbicides, and they can kill fungi, which are called fungicides. There are many more pesticides out there as well, each with a different job. These pesticides are meant to help make human lives better, but do these pesticides really make our lives better? In Silent Spring, written by Rachel Carson, pesticides are examined and shown how pesticides cause environmental issues far worse, than the pests humans are trying to kill.…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Residents of West Anniston refused to accept continual denials from Monsanto as to the potential health effects of PCBs which incidentally are still stated on their website today: “the health effects of PCBs have been extensively studied. Published studies have shown no consistent excesses in cancer.” (Monsanto) This claim flies directly in the face of EPA findings which state that PCBs are probable human carcinogens and these conclusions are supported by 15 peer reviews by experts on PCBs. (USEPA)…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “I think the environment should be put in the category of our national security. Defense of our resources is just as important as defense abroad. Otherwise what is there to defend,” (Robert Redford). In the article, “Why Bother”, the author, Michael Pollan, discusses the importance of saving the environment and how it will not be easy to achieve. He believes that as a society we need to, “find ways to provide for ourselves without diminishing the world,” (Michael Pollan).…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s world, global warming is common knowledge to most people. Every day global warming gets worse. Some people in today’s society are eager to stop global warming because they are aware of the problems that global warming is causing to people and the Earth. Across the world, people know that industrial smokestacks are a big cause of global warming in today’s society. Some people believe that by ignoring global warming that it will not affect them, and that they can’t make a difference.…

    • 2039 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There are endless problems with the environment and the big scheme of things is very overwhelming to those who want to solve the issues, in turn, nothing is done to solve the problems. “The Environmental crisis: The Devil is in the Generalities” by Ross McKitrick explains how the result of the generalization of the word environment causes people to believe the world is always in an environmental crisis. McKitrick’s essay is effective in displaying the overall effects of generalizing the word environment. His two main concerns and insightful views on who to blame for such environmental crisis’ make his argument valid and compelling. The overall idea of being “pro-environmentalist” is great and McKitrick touches on how people do want…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The essay, “It Always Costs” written by activist and scientist David Suzuki, argued for the importance of the negative outcomes of technology within our society. He further emphasized this idea by exploring the fact that although we rely and benefit from these technologies, everything comes at a price no matter how little or small it may seem. For example, malaria carrying mosquitoes, were being eliminated by a designed toxin (DDT) however, the genetics of the mosquitoes had mutated. As a result, the disease was difficult to erase and more toxins were used to improve the outbreak. The DDT affected the food chain and integrated into the egg shells of birds causing a high bird mortality rate.…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The term “environment” is a vague word used to frame the discussion of a broad issue without refining the topic. The conversation surrounding the environment can often get caught up in generalities which can quickly drive people towards crisis mode. McKitrick attempts to persuade his reader to cease talking about the environment as a single entity, and instead focus on the specific aspects that compose it. In Ross McKitrick ’s essay “The Environmental Crisis”, he uses references to authority and specific examples to show how using a general term can muddle the perception of a comprehensive issue.…

    • 942 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These lyrics define the growing problem of human expansion into the environment as a form of protest music, especially against the industrialization of American farming: “Hey farmer farmer, Put away the DDT” (Mitchell lines 22-23). In this manner, Mitchell became a popular music spokesperson for the fight against industrialization of farming, which often involved using harsh chemicals, such as DDT, to control insect infestation in crops. Wills (2013) explains how Mitchell wrote about “DDTs” in her lyrics as a form of “environmental ballad” in the protest of the use of chemicals/pesticides in industrial farming: “Mitchell penned “Big Yellow Taxi” (1970), an environmental ballad. Mitchell dedicated one stanza to DDT, reflecting the pivotal position of pesticides to modern environmental consciousness” (Wills 112). This is one example of the powerful lyricism of Mitchell’s song, which directly attacked the chemical industry that promoted DDT in an effort to control insect infestation.…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Global warming, climate change and the idea the humans race lack of care toward nature is leading to the Earth’s doom is a theory that has seemed closer and closer to becoming a reality. This issue and its effects on our lives can be told by Rachel Carson, a MA zoologist from 1932, who switched her focus to the effect of pesticides on humans and our environment (Articulation 358). Carson goes on to express facts in order to shine light on the harms of chemicals on our environment. With the whole world unclear of the future at stake, Carson reaches out to the audience to realize the possible truth. In The Obligation to Endure, Carson expresses the harm of chemicals on our world by appealing to the reader’s emotions and relating to an issue that…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics