Comparing The Narrator In The Tell-Tale Heart And The Yellow Wallpaper

Improved Essays
Life is like a rosary, it’s full of mysteries. This motto relates to these stories who was written by Edgar Allan Poe, Charlotte Perkins Gilman and Stephen King. Firstly, “The Tell-Tale Heart”, the narrator hates the eye of the old man and decides to kill him to be free of it. Secondly in “The Yellow Wallpaper”, the narrator suffers from depression and has been isolated in a room with a yellow wallpaper with different patterns that made her think that there was a woman behind it who is trying to break free from the wall. Lastly in “The Strawberry Spring”, a “false” spring, much like an Indian summer, when several students are murdered by a guy named “Springheel Jack” who left no clues not even footprints and in the end the narrator was scared …show more content…
With this in mind he confesses and ruins his “perfect crime”. As a matter of fact, the narrator in the “Strawberry Spring” said, “I’ve been thinking about the trunk of my car--such an ugly word, trunk--and wondering why in the world I should be afraid to open it” (King 7). According to that he was scared that he might be the killer. But the truth is he does not remember anything that happened before. However, the narrator of “The Tell-Tale Heart” is more unreliable because he was proud that the crime was clean and there's no marks that can put him in jail. The narrator once said that, “I think it was his eye!” (Poe 1). This shows that the old man’s eye really bothers him and the way he thinks. Which makes him unreliable because the way he said that it was the eye, shows that he was unsure about it. That makes people think that there is another reason behind it. Later on, someone came to the old man’s house, “I took my visitors all over the house. I bade them search--search well” (Poe 3). He’s confident and thinks that it was a perfect crime that’s why he placed his chair above the dead body. The narrator’s untrustworthiness is shown by how calmly he narrates what happened on the day he murdered the old guy just to prove he is not insane. The crime that he thought was perfect was not because of his mental defenses crashed down …show more content…
As can be seen in the way he sneaks into his room late at night for eight nights in a row demonstrates his obsessiveness for the old man. This also emphasizes the fact that he loves the old man, but only for his “evil eye” that results to the killing that makes the narrator unreliable. Unlike the narrator in “The Yellow Wallpaper”, because she admits the she is unwell and she could not take care of her own child because she is scared that she might do something on the baby. Also the narrator in the “Strawberry Spring”, because he was afraid to open his own trunk thinking that he might be the killer though he does not remember anything. All in all, the narrator’s obsession for the eye affects his thinking and behavior--which establishes his unreliability in the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Misfit allows for his punishment because he assumes it is for a sin that he committed during his life even though he is aware that it is not for killing his father. Viewing life the way he does, The Misfit believes that punishment will come for any minor sin that is committed. The Misfit states that he calls himself The Misfit "because [he] can 't make what all [he] done wrong fit what all [he] gone through in punishment," but with much thought, one can conclude that there is more to the meaning of his name (O 'Connor 1295). Because of a crime that he never committed, he is placed in prison; therefore, he does not fit in with the rest of the prisoners who were punished for actually committing a crime. In "Capital Punishment," Alexie expresses that after witnessing multiple executions, "If any of us stood for days on top of a barren hill during an…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He was extremely paranoid when sneaking into the old man’s room, because he is nervous of waking him. After sneaking into his bedroom, he is unable to kill him because he was sleeping, which means he cant see his eye. The old man wakes up to realize that someone is in his room, so he becomes immediately frightened. The narrator noticed the scared, and awake old man. He can hear the old mans frightened heart beating, and at one point he felt that it was so loud that he had to jump on…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Innocent Killer Ender Wiggin, a genocidal killer we somehow feel sympathy for, but is our sympathy justified? In an essay by John Kessel, titled “Creating the Innocent Killer”, Kessel discussed this matter and concludes that we should not feel sympathy for him as he is a murderer. He killed two people as well as the entire population of a foreign species, yet still labeled innocent. I agree with Kessel’s conclusion, because although he didn’t know he was committing genocide at the time he planned on doing so in the future, he was always unnecessarily violent but wasn’t punished for it, and his intentions don’t change his actions. To summarize Kessel’s essay, “Creating the Innocent Killer”, Kessel felt no sympathy for Ender.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His oversensitivity goes on to make everyone believe that the narrator is hearing multiple sounds that are not possible to hear. The narrator knows the old man’s thoughts and can still hear his heart after he was murdered. The thoughts and heart sounds that he hears are not average noises that everybody hears, especially being able to hear the old man’s heart. The narrator gives information that cannot possibly be true, leading the readers to understand the narrator’s mind. As shown by a Comprehensive Research, “He cares not whether the reader knows how horribly he stalked his victim, since in the narrator’s eyes this is merely proof of his rationality, methodical planning, and precision” (Bloom 41).…

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He goes on to say, “…observe how healthily – how calmly I can tell you the whole story.” (Poe 1). Just because the narrator can tell the story calmly does not mean he is not mad, but he is trying to convince the audience otherwise. The narrator had no reason to kill the old man, but he found one in the eye. The narrator stated that the old man had never done him wrong; he never insulted him, in fact the narrator says that he loved the old man. He had no desire for the old man’s gold.…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The narrator in “The Tell Tale Heart” exclaims that he “welcomed the gentlemen into his own house and that he desired the policemen to rest and stay a while” (Poe, 717) The fact that the man desired them to stick around the same place that he committed a brutal murder screams insanity. He wanted to feed his ego by convincing himself that there would be no way for the policemen to ever find him out. In the other story the mad narrator does the exact same thing. The narrator became so confident in his abilities that he had the audacity and nerve to tap his cane on the same area of the wall where the body was hidden. Poe has a niche for putting these confidently insane killers in his stories.…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    He was not a kid who usually would get into trouble. However, after an accident occurred where a white woman tripped over him, the officer in the store believed he was stealing and the senseless beating began. Quinn observed the crime and pretended to have not seen it at first, but realizes that his testimony would be important for justice against police brutality and prejudice. Rashad also initially does not want to take a stand, but eventually sees it as a persistent issue of social justice and police brutality. Rashad’s character was to be the “All American Boy”.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “I then smile gaily, to find the deed so far done.” (Poe, 384) “I put a dark lantern, all closed, closed so that no light shone out.” (Poe, 382) “Why would they not be gone?” (Poe, 386) After he kills the old man, his excitement and cheerful feelings are rising. This shows how little empathy he has for the old man and how he is mentally unstable. The lantern symbolizes the lack of insight on the part of the narrator, and acts as a support for his beliefs. He doesn't realize that he is crazy, and he thinks that killing is normal. He keeps on justifying his reasons for murder with the evil eye.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As stated before, he spied long nights upon the old man to seek his perfect moment to annihilate his pet peeve. The heart of the old man being described as “a low, dull, quick sound, such as watch makes when enveloped in cotton” is an example of how repetition is used to emphasize that the old man is aware of that death is creeping upon him. After he kills the old man, that repetition of the old man's heartbeat shows up again; it represents his guilt for murdering an innocent person because just because of his ignorance toward the “hideous” eye. The power of the “eye” throughout the story overpowered his sense of morality to follow the path of evil. That is where his mental illness comes to play, his illness changed the meaning of evil.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dick Clutter Murders

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages

    4. Did Dick really not commit any of the Clutter murders? Did Dick receive the appropriate punishment for the crime he did commit? Even if Dick did not physically commit the murders, the entire plan was concocted by him and attributable to his mind. His control over Perry allowed for him to murder while keeping his hands clean, and that makes him just as guilty as if he had been the one to shoot the gun.…

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays