Compare And Contrast The Cask Of Amontillado And The Tell Tale Heart

Good Essays
Edgar Allen Poe Essay

“If still you think me mad, you will think so no longer when I describe the wise precautions I took for the concealment of the body.” (Poe, TTH 49). Edgar Allen Poe’s short stories The Cask of Amontillado and The Tell Tale Heart show us a terrifying world of madness and murder. The sensory details to the narrator 's thoughts provide the audience with a display of mental instability and madness. From envy to obsession, these stories show equal amounts of a specific mental delusion, urging the narrator to commit an unthinkable crime. Although it is evident that Montresor of The Cask of Amontillado is insane, the narrator of The Tell Tale Heart displays a madness of much greater magnitude.

For instance, in the opening
…show more content…
His deed is finished- the corpse is hidden under the floorboards and no drop of blood has been spilled, when suddenly three police officers show up at the door in suspicion of foul play. The narrator courteously and enthusiastically brought the officers all around the house and asked them to sit down, an eerie scene of dramatic irony. He is incredibly confident in his clever and perfect triumph but not long after, he felt himself growing pale and heard an increasing ringing that was not within his ears. The narrator is now crazed, pacing the floor, speaking rapidly, and flinging his chair, yet he says that the officers are still chatting pleasantly, which they obviously would not be. He then confesses. “Villains! . . . dissemble no more! I admit the deed!-tear up the planks!-here, here!-it is the beating of his hideous heart!” (Poe TTH 52). Even after he dismembers the body, the narrator imagines the beating of his own heart as that of the old man’s. Therefore, he is indeed not able to reason or control his raging imagination- making him a …show more content…
His inability to distinguish between what is real and what he imagines shows that he is not mentally stable. And although he takes on the role of a storyteller quite well, calmly telling the tale, it is still blatantly apparent that his murderous crime is something only a madman would do. Ultimately, he is the agent of his own downfall. But perhaps the narrator is indeed not mad. Perhaps his senses were heightened, he was in a superior state and could reasonably decide to kill the old man. Would anyone in their right mind commit such a crime as

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The narrator tells the story but it is unreliable since the use of dissimulation is very prominent. Dissimulation was one of the narrator’s strongest tools to get away with murder, but his insanity ended up being the reason for murder and the reason for the narrator’s downfall. It led to his oversensitivity and created an area for him to tell the police the dead that he did. The insanity and the old man’s eye motivated his actions and allowed the whole story to play out as it did. Without the eye his insanity may have never been pushed over the edge, and without his insanity the eye would have never bothered the narrator.…

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “The Cask of Amontillado” is a poetic tale of an exemplary murder told by Edgar Allan Poe. As a vicious, murderous man, Montresor may be considered to be an unsympathetic character. However, after a close examination of Montresor’s characteristics and personality, it may be concluded that there are many traits that may be reflected on readers, traits which reside along with more uncommon characteristics. The man who Montresor murders, Fortunato, experiences the wrath of these characteristics first hand, and would be the first to call Montresor either evil or insane. But careful scrutiny of Montresor will result in the discovery that Montresor is not simply black or white, evil or insane, but a spectrum of grey and diverse characteristics that aided him in his quest to commit the perfect murder.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This instability creates a sense of distrust towards the narrator. Poe adds this psychological element to horror to reveal how the story is possible. Though dark, the narrator’s thoughts can be deemed realistic, and comparable to a sociopath’s thoughts. Poe also uses second person narrative, which draws the reader in and creates a sense of intrigue and mystery. This narrative adds to the instability to the character’s unstable state like when they ask, “but why will you say that I am mad?” this makes the narrator seem obsessed to prove their sanity.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The narrator’s words and actions present him as an unreasonable, and untrustworthy narrator. The narrator of Tell Tale Heart attempts to justify his actions and prove to the audience why he is not insane. The reason he tells the story is to try and defend his sanity, yet he confesses to killing the old man that he is a caretaker for. Ironically, he gives proof that he does have a paranoid personality disorder, when trying to convince the audience that what he did was not insane. The old man, who lives with the narrator, becomes the victim of murder.…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Tell-Tale Heart Poe proposes the narrator is insane by the storyteller's cases of madness, the storyteller's activities draw out the irony of the story, and the storyteller is crazy as indicated by the meaning of unreliability as it applies to "The Tell-Tale Heart." He is trying from the earliest starting point of the story to put forth a defense of his madness. However, the short story he tells impairs and is inconsistent with his declaration of madness. All through his account, he reviews the occasions that drove him to kill the old man and after that his admittance to the crime. He tries to outline his “perceptive sensibility” with illustrations.…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Misapprehension Vs Authenticity in Edgar Allan Poe’s the form of untrustworthiness; the trait of lacking a sense of liability and not feeling accountable for your actions What is the telltale to say if a man is mad or not? A man may talk like a wise man, and yet act insane. In Poe’s "The Tell-Tale Heart", the narrator portrayed a story that he killed the old man because of his “evil eye" that made his blood run cold. Although the narrator tried to persuade the reader that he was normal, several pieces of evidence for confusing delusion and reality sufficiently indicate his madness and meaninglessness. By examining his behavior and mind, I will expound his insanity thoroughly.…

    • 1102 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When exacting revenge, a person’s character can come into question. In “The Cask of Amontillado” by Edgar Allen Poe this is the very question that seems to be answered with not just a glimpse inside the thoughts of Montresor, who is the guilty party in question, but giving readers the ability to see it all play out from his eyes. The whole story of his revenge is based upon the assumption that Fortunato, his oblivious arch-nemesis, at one point, scorned him so badly that he had to take great lengths to exact his plans with full harshness. With all the thoughts of a truly psychotic character floating over these pages, it is hard to pinpoint exactly why Montresor did what he did. Never the less, the character himself is a complicated but well…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Edgar Allan Poe Themes

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Edgar Allan Poe made many of his characters mad. (Gargano 179) Poe’s insane characters only make themselves more insane as they try and prove themselves sane. (Gargano 179) Gargano states that his characters grow more insane because of their obsessive natures. (179) Poe constantly wrote stories in which the characters would make themselves go mad. (Gargano 179) After a character commits a heinous crime, the character is usually overcome with an immense feeling if guilt.…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The story represents the insight world of an insanity of the narrator. Although, the narrator claims to be completely sound while slaying a person, the reasons of him doing so, and the way he chose to do it clearly state his mental instability. The old man’s evil eye is a greater extent of a symbol of the narrator’s insanity, and it is represented through his irrational lust and delusion to get rid of a person that he loves. The narrator needs to eradicate the eye, not the person; otherwise this eye will destroy him. The eye is a symbolic representation of the narrator’s sadistic, insanity, and guilty.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The insane persona who killed a man, is not the major discovery for the reader. Instead, it is the uncovering of his madness that is most confronting, inviting us to experience the cognitive action of a psychopath. The use of a confessional tone and symbolism, “It is impossible to say how first the idea entered my brain,” inviting us into his mind as we are confronted with his obsessionality, here we discover an insane man's illusion that he has control over his actions. While acknowledging that he, like the house is “haunted” by his obsessions, his illusion of control emerges through his conversational tone. Just as Prospero was oblivious to how much his magic is controlling him, the persona is oblivious of the control his mental illness has, over his behaviour.…

    • 1315 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays