Pros And Cons Of Juvenile Offenders

Superior Essays
High Risk of Reoffending One of the liveliest debates over the United States’ imprisonment system today (as well as the systems of other countries) concerns juvenile offenders. On the one hand, the debate consists of acknowledging that they are children. It is believed that juvenile offenders have not had the chance to fully mold their lives, and are very often merely products of the environments in which they have grown up. On the other hand, it is proven that many juveniles are capable of committing crimes every bit as heinous as fully grown adults. The case of juvenile offenders presents a unique problem for systems of criminal punishments and deterrence. An additional layer of complexity is added when we consider repeat juvenile offenders. …show more content…
al. 2001). This raises the most revealing and poignant question involved in the issue of imprisoning juvenile offenders. What is the point? If the point is to keep a dangerous criminal off of the streets, then young offenders are surely better off in juvenile penitentiaries. They will there be just as safely kept away from society as if they served their time in adult facilities. If the point is to punish them, then an entire host of questions arise. What is the purpose of punishing a child? How many parents would punish their children using a technique that is virtually guaranteed to make their children lifelong criminals and inmates? More importantly, why would you want to punish a child, in your capacity as a member of the legal profession? A high percentage of juvenile offenders are either in the foster care system, and effectively have no parents, or they have parents who are drug dealers or other criminals. Does it really make sense to punish a child for being born into such circumstances? Should not the approach rather be to help and rehabilitate …show more content…
Scholars have long since identified methods of treatment and interventions that actually reduce the rate of recidivism, rather than increasing it. Furthermore, like most incarceration programs in the United States, imprisoning young people costs much more than it benefits society (Duncan 2000). It is a striking fact indeed that American politicians, policy makers, law enforcement personnel—and in fact the voting public—would much rather pay to imprison a young black man, for life if necessary, than provide his mother with the opportunity to feed him the food that he desperately needs, and to house and clothe

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Parents should be punished as same as their kids should. If the kid is judged to stay in a separate juvenile system, their parents should stay with them and try to teach them to be a better person in the future. Moreover, parents should stay in prisons when their kids are judged to imprison for severe crimes. Parents should also be responsible for their kids because parents should take care of their children from they were born until they are adults. If their kids do violent crimes, it means that parents lack of taking care of their kids and giving them good suggestions to become a good person.…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A hateful crime committed by juveniles should always be punished with a sentence to life in prison. Being a juvenile should not exempt you from receiving a punishment. Even though teens might commit a crime due to an abusive family environment, they must be punished in order to learn that wrong actions will have consequences. It is safe to say that teenagers are capable of committing crimes that any adult would commit. Many argue that a teen’s brain is not fully developed but how come they are able to plan the crime that they want to commit.…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also after being imprisoned in an adult facility, the juvenile is more susceptible to execute a crime not only quicker but also to a higher degree. Juveniles should not be tried as adults because it might not be their fault they turned out to be offenders. Huge determining factors in the development of a child are the people who raised the child and also the environment in which they were raised upon. Too much discipline or the lack thereof from a parental figure may negatively influence an individual to become an offender. Permissive parents raise their children to become reckless and not understand the ‘limits to acceptable behavior’ in society (Begley & Kalb, 2000).…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Juvenile Court System

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Should Juveniles be tried as Adults? Draft #1 Juvenile court systems are the first line of defence against youth crimes. This system is quickly failing to produce the appropriate punishments for major youth crimes passing the responsibility to the guardians and off of the child. Supporting the trial of juveniles as adults is imperative in creating a safe and secure society. The Juvenile system is often criticised for being highly flawed, the system based off of rehabilitation minimalizes the seriousness of the crime committed.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Effects Of Juvenile Jails

    • 1051 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Research has shown that their side effects from being in prison in an adult facility like most teens get physical and sexual abuse while in jail, which have led to the high suicide rate among teens”(Bechtold). This shows how instead of having kids get rehabilitated in a jail, it is actually harming them. In adult prisons, “they are also kids that are in for minor crimes. They should not be in adult prison but instead in juvenile facilities where they can be rehabilitated” (Bechtold). This might be linked to the color of the skin of a kid because judges think they are dangerous.…

    • 1051 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    States recognize that children who commit crimes are different from adults: as a whole, they are less blameworthy, and they have a greater capacity for change. Which means they can be blamed but they have a conscience and they regret things? One could understand if the murder was planned and thought out for a child to receive a maximum of 25 years once they turn 18. By giving children life in prison is ruining their lives and they miss out their education. To respond to these differences, states have established a separate court system for juveniles, and they have created a separate youth-based service delivery system, that is different than that provided to…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This serves to show that juveniles are the main target in an adult facility, they are not as protected as they make is seem. One does not think that juveniles should have to turn to suicide, that ideas proves juveniles are not safe in a prison environment. Being ashamed serves to show that society makes them feel like aliens, they make them believe that they are disgusting because they committed a crime. Although a life was lost and we could not do anything to prevent it, everything is in our control to provide juvenile delinquents with the correct resources in order to prosper and be awarded with a second…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Sentencing Hypocritical

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Sentencing a juvenile life in prison without parole is depriving them of their rights and is clearly hypocritical. The minority who are pro sentencing them to life without parole don't take into consideration the possibility there is in enlightening these kids in becoming better citizens and learning from their mistakes. The reason why I consider the sentencing hypocritical is due to the way society treats juveniles and classifies them as “kids” until they commit a crime. I am in full agreement with the majority of Supreme Court ruling of abolishing mandatory life in prison for juveniles who commit murder. Many who oppose my vision on the topic, use claims such as, “they’re old enough to know better” or “a crime is a crime no matter age,” but…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Another reason is that if kids are tried as adults, they they should get the same rights as adults. For example, in “Kids are Kids -- Until They Commit Crimes,” a representative of Texas mentioned how the voting age should be lowered to the age of fourteen if kids were tried as adults. This shows that if people want kids to receive the same punishments, they should receive the same rights. Lastly, sending a child to rehab is a much better place than sending a child to prison. If a child goes to prison, they will not get the help they need, however, if they get the care from a rehabilitation center, it betters their chances of becoming a better person.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Youth should be tried and sent to a detention center just like adults due to their reckless actions that caused a scar on another person’s life. There are several reasons that support the claim of why children should tried as adults. On the website OccupyTheory., they state one reason saying, “Those who believe in the benefits of trying juveniles as adults are firm believers in the fact that a crime is a crime, no matter how old the person is who committed it” (Theory). People do not care whoever committed the crime, it is an act that can no longer be taken back. Juveniles should be treated and tried as adults no matter what they…

    • 1972 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics