Pros And Cons Of Advance Directives

Improved Essays
Advance directives have been widely promoted to benefit patients who are dealing with end-of-life care issues. Stated either as a Living Will or a Durable Power of Attorney or both, advance directives ensure that a patient’s wishes regarding life-sustaining interventions are followed, should they lose the ability to make health care decisions. Since the court cases of Quinlan in 1976 and Cruzan in 1990, in which both patients suffered as a result of “right to die” controversies, Congress passed the Patient Self-Determination Act of 1991 to increase societal awareness of advance directives (Crisp, 2007, p. 181). Furthermore, the Uniform Health Care Decisions Act approved in 1993 aimed to consolidate various state laws regarding adult health care decisions and durable powers of attorney (Appel, 2010, p. 417). …show more content…
The lack in utilization of advance directives calls for its mandated completion in the event that a patient is placed in an inpatient setting, however, maintains his or her decision-making capacity. This requirement is not only beneficial to the patient, but also to the patient’s family, the health care team, and the general society. This paper will, therefore, examine the advantages of the completion of advance directives, address concerns surrounding the proposal, and integrate ethical theories and principles and biblical relevance to support a much-needed stipulation in today’s healthcare

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the early 1970s, patients’ rights have been accepted, which had allowed the patient and their family decide on their own without the help of the physician, to continue life support. However, most American citizens suggest that it is best for the patient and the patient’s family to privately converse with the physician instead of getting involved with the the states since the Supreme Court had not ruled that there was a 'constitutional right to die' By 1973, “The American Hospital Association adopted a "Patient's Bill of Rights" which recognizes the right of patients to refuse treatment” (Zucker 1999). Within a few years, it was seen that the public had been interested in the right-to-die movement, and public surveys have shown that half of the American public supported the ‘physician-assisted…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Advance Directive

    • 167 Words
    • 1 Pages

    The desire to prolong life in human being has been an issues for most hospitals, nursing homes and health agencies. According to Susan E. Hickman et al., from “Hope for the Future: Achieving the Original Intent of Advance Directive, “Hasting Center Report (Nov-Dec 2005), since 1970s, the case of Karen Ann Quilan and Nancy Cruzan, authorities have had the necessity to urge the importance of planning the advance directive to keep the control over artificial means methods, medical treatment to ending life, and care planning for adults in good health conditions. Advance directive has been developing to be successful with all people possible who need it. The processes to legislate laws to appoint Statutory Livings…

    • 167 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nursing Case Study Anthony

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Anthony Vella is a 46-year-old man diagnosed with stage 4 pancreatic cancer. Which now has been said that further chemotherapy will be ineffective. Anthony’s health status had been carefully managed by the palliative care team and have been working with Anthony to explore his care needs and end-of-life decisions. His symptoms (severe nausea and abdominal pain) have improved until he was admitted to the Emergency department after collapsing at the shopping centre. At this stage, it is suggested by healthcare professionals that an Advanced Care Planning (ACP) should be undertaken even though Anthony addressed to the nurse he will “need more time to consider it”.…

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics in decision making Course: Clinical Practice Roles In this class, we discussed several ethical issues such as end-of-life decision making, advance directives, insurance reimbursement and interdisciplinary conflict. It is always hard to make decision when health care providers encounter ethical issues. There are several principles can guide us in our decision making. For example: Principle-Based Model is one of principle, which include autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, justice, veracity, fidelity, and privacy.…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This paper will argue that end of life directives should not be honored in Catholic hospitals against Directive 58 as imposed on Catholic Hospitals, as well as that End of life directives themselves are unethical as viewed through the ethical principle of Autonomy. Patients with directives that lead to a termination of their lives under chronic illnesses and states, conflict with Catholic teachings to sustain life. Therefore in catholic hospitals such directives may be ignored for the benefit of the patient until such time that it seems no longer beneficial to the patient. Many people create End of life directives to prevent themselves from living in a “compromised” state or from fear of experiencing pain or indignity. In the Catholic ideology the sanctity of life is paramount to all other…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Classroom Lecture The lecture today was delivered by Dubbie Masters, her topic of discussion is on ethical and legal issues at the end-of-life (EOL). Masters (September 13, 2016) opened the discussion by asking the RN-BSN students, what would they do if the patient has an advance directive. This writer replied that if there is advance directive and it is within the patients’ possession, then the goal is to comply with patient wishes. Advance directives is a way an individual can express their preferences for care that they may need at EOL (Black, 2014).…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Competent Analysis

    • 1777 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Choice Between the Competent and the Incompetent There have been many instances in which a patient, who discovers they have a disease involving dementia, would write an advance directive: a written statement wishing that no treatment is given to them once the dementia causes them to be unable to remember their past, and their family and friends. Arguments arise when debating on whether or not to obey the advance directives given by the patient, two of which will be examined in this paper. Through the comparison Dresser and Robertson’s paper, “Quality of Life and Non-Treatment Decisions for Incompetent Patients”, and Dworkin’s book, “Life’s Dominion”, the case of Margaret can be analyzed: Margaret is an Alzheimer’s patient. She no longer recognizes her family, but all of her caregivers describe her as very content.…

    • 1777 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In fact, it prompted me to self-reflect on my values and beliefs about death and led me in the development of a personal advance directive. As I worked on the advance directive, it was evident that I had values and views of how I want to die in the event of the end of life issue. Autonomy is a strong personal value of mine as outlined in my advance directive. Difficulty but essential value for me is to determine a course of action in matters related to end-of-life decisions rather than my family making it for me as outlined in my advance…

    • 1660 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Medicine has always been about prolonging the lives of human beings, through new technological advances doctors are now capable of maintaining artificial life. But one would argue that just because technology allows for the preservation of a life, it does not make it a life of quality. In a case in which the patients are in a permanently vegetative state or coma, although feeding tubes and ventilation keep them “alive” they are no longer living a quality life. The right to refuse treatment then falls into question. The very first U.S. court case to deal with the issue of end-of-life care was the case of Karen Ann Quinlan in 1975.…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    DNR In Health Care

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For the major focal point of this discourse, as explained before, advance directives are used to convey the patient and families’ preference in treatment, including to do or not resuscitate when the patient may suffer from cardiac or respiratory arrest after. The aim of CPR is to save the patient, but the evidence shows that the implementation of CPR does not ensure a high rate of survival to hospital discharge (Enohumah et al., 2006; Landry, Parker, & Phillips, 1992; McNally et al., 2011). Due to this, the policy began to develop to limit the use of CPR and in carrying out the DNR order. In reference to this issue, Quinlan case has increased the concern (Coburn, 1977). The conflict evolved between the physician and patient’s father in determining…

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In accordance to federal law, the two hospitals in Joplin, Missouri, Mercy and Freeman Health System, have conducted individual advance directive education procedures for many years. These procedures have not been thoroughly analyzed with a comprehensive list that indicates advised properties and methods of communication and education an advance directive education procedure should practice. This has not occurred because a comprehensive list has not been developed. However, research focusing on challenges of advance directives does provide possible solutions and recommendations, but has not been gathered or used to analyze a hospital’s advance directive education procedure. The creation of a comprehensive list could be used as a guideline for…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    End Of Life Care Ethics

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many ethical dilemmas involving patient care are issues pertaining to end-of-life care and advanced directives. An advanced directive is a legal document that states an individual’s end-of-life preferences when situations arise where they are unable to make medical decisions on their own due to a lack of capacity, terminal illness, or permanent disability (Karnik & Kanekar, 2016). Patients with advanced directives can appoint a family member or healthcare provider to act as a surrogate allowing them to make medical decisions that need to be made throughout a prognosis (Karnik & Kanekar, 2016). Ethical dilemmas that occur with advanced directives are when patients and surrogates disagree on treatment options regarding end-of-life care. Evidence…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Out of a study of 134 patients, 19 patients ultimately persisted in requesting CPR, even after the recommendation of the treatment team that it would be more harmful than helpful to the patient. The study describes the demographics of these nineteen patients and some data analyzed suggested that the surrogates made decisions for the patients that were actually against the wishes laid out in their advance directives. The second article used a qualitative approach in which the author observed surrogates moral authority in making decisions about palliative sedation. I conclusion, I believe that both of these articles highlight some interesting topics in regards to end of life care. However, the first article provides insight on how surrogates’ decisions during end of life care can greatly affect patients.…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Refusing Medical Care Refusing medical care is something all patients have the right to do. Doctors should honor the patient’s request, but they don’t always follow through. More often than not, a physician will assume the patient is non-compliant, and make forceful attempts to administer their desired care. At a critical stage of the patient’s life, the patient may have a deep feeling of helplessness; so making life-changing decisions is all they can (and want to) control. There are many reasons patients would want to refuse treatment.…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Because of this, voluntary euthanasia is most preferred by patients because they are being euthanized on their own terms and with their permission. On January 1, 1984, California put into effect a law that “enables competent adults to designate, in writing, another person as their ‘attorney in fact,’ with authority to make virtually all medical care decisions in the event that they are terminally ill and have lost the capacity to make such decisions for themselves. Four other states provide designation of a proxy…

    • 1573 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays