Case Study Of Crawford's Ethical Dilemma

Improved Essays
In case one, Crawford submitted his archaeology project through a crowdfunding company and soon received the amount that he asked for. After completing his project, several of his investors wanted a share of the profits. Mr. John Manley, one of the investors, requested a letter to explain Crawford’s intentions. Crawford should explain to Mr. Manley that commercialization of his new found artifacts are ethically wrong and these artifacts are public property.
To sell the artifacts that Crawford found is ethically wrong since it gives the artifacts a monetary value. When artifacts get a monetary value, it promotes looting of archaeological sites. If looting rises, archaeological sites will be damages and destroyed. This will produce minimal cultural
…show more content…
Breaking this ethics code may result in looters destroying known and unknown archaeological sites from this tribe so that they may find other undiscovered figurines and artifacts.
Sir Collier could potentially put the tribe in danger from thieves, if he purchases the figurines and returns them to the tribe. Since the figurines has a large monetary value, thieves will go out of their way to steal something valuable so that they may profit from it by reselling it on the black market. These thieves may also harm the tribe if the tribe refuses to give up the figurines.
Although many people may have good intentions, the outcome may have negative consequences that we did not imagine. We should patiently think it through as well as consult others so that we may avoid these negative consequences. Sir Collier should not buy the artifacts and return them to the
…show more content…
Archaeological looters may target these sites and destroy them for their valuable artifacts. Removing these artifacts and destroying the sites would not allow archaeologist to get a good idea of the site such as how it was used and what items were used at the site. Some looting may be accidental. An example of this is a traveler who wants to remember the serenity of the site by taking a small piece of pottery. With every small piece taken by other fellow travelers who have visited the site, this can accumulate to a large portion of the site being looted.
Although the archaeological geocaching was meant for sightseeing and an outdoor activity, the unintended consequences of their actions can destroy the site. We must somehow be able to do both: allow the activities of archaeological geocaching and preserving the sites and artifacts of our ancestors. Robert would be helping archaeologist by attempting to shut down the archaeological

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    This sub group of the CIfA promotes the maintenance of professional standards to safeguard the practice of high quality forensic archaeology work. It’s ‘Standards and Guidance for Forensic Archaeologists’ outlines site management, documentation, prevention of contamination, recovery of remains, the final report and more. Also, the ‘Forensic Archaeology Competency Matrix’ highlights the different levels of role complexity between expert, associate and practitioner members; giving students an indication of the range of role competencies in working archaeologists. The site is beneficial for a clear understanding of the expectations and proficiencies required of a professional forensic archaeologist both on site and…

    • 100 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cahokia Book Critique

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In any archeology project, people's actions and thoughts can be a burden. The author makes this clear throughout all of his examples of archeological digs and really describes the secular problems that can come with a job like this…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    David Crisp was hoping to find something interesting when he set out on a walk with his metal detector in a field in the English countryside. But little did he know he'd of discover a true treasure buried beneath the dirt - a collection of coins dating back to the third century A.D. The 52503 bronze pot about a foot below the surface. k and silver coins contained in a two-foot pot about a foot below the surface. Knowing he'd found something special, Crisp called on a team of archaeologists to unearth the treasure, and they concluded the coins were buried about 1700 years ago.…

    • 135 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This sort of vandalism has decreased as awareness of the importance of these areas has grown but the mentality still exists. The sites that have been looted and are still in danger of being looted are not just pueblos and sentimental wall carvings but places where sacred burial grounds where the ancestors of Native Americans that have lived in the area reside (Matz). Within the proposed boundaries of the Bears Ears Monument, over 100,000 archeological and cultural sites are would be protected…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This supports why pennies should be preserved because their little value gives the penny’s owner the intention to give it to donations and without that intention donations will suffer. Penny’s little value can be important maybe not to some but to others it makes a big…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Kennewick Man Facts

    • 1782 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The Kennewick Man is human skeleton discovered in 1996 whose ethnic affiliation has sparked legal controversy and scientific debates. Scientists asserted that the Kennewick Man neither belonged to Native Americans nor related to the tribes in the Northwest areas of Pacific region. These two groups advocated for the repatriation bones because they believed they were related to the Kennewick Man. The main law that warranted the return of the bones to natives was the Native Americans Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA). However, the outcome of the scientific analysis rendered null the application of the NAGPRA rules.…

    • 1782 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Kennewick Man

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Anthropologists and Native Americans were the major participants in the controversial debate and court case over the ownership of the Kennewick Man, sometimes called the “Ancient One.” The US Army Corps of Engineers, who superintended the land where the Kennewick Man was found, also participated, siding with the natives to fight for the reburial of the Ancient One The Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, otherwise known as NAGPRA, is a federal law that protects items in relation to Native American culture. According to NAGPRA, cultural items such as sacred objects or human remains in affiliation to Native American tribes, eventually have to return to the ownership of the natives for cultural purposes like proper burials. The law was created so that culturally significant artifacts or human remains could be properly identified, processed, and analyzed by scientists, like anthropologists without disrespecting the cultural values of Indian and Native Hawaiian organizations.…

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout Allie Condie’s novel, Matched, the prominent theme is the perceived perfection that the Society offers through its rules and restrictions. The Society has implemented a rigorous governing design where individual freedom’s and decisions are non-existent. The goal of the autocratic design is not to provide citizens with the optimal health and happiness as promised, rather it is to control, manipulate, and condition citizens to conform to the Society’s way. This idea is demonstrated through the numerous references to artifacts that belong to some of the residents of Oria. Their symbolism not only aids in revealing the Society’s underlying motives but also demonstrates how the artifacts bring a sense of security and comfort to their…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Looting In Peru

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Article Analysis Two 1) In ‘The Destruction, Looting and Traffic of the Archaeological Heritage of Peru,’ author Walter Alva focuses on the mining and looting of ancient sites which leads to the destruction of many artifacts present. He also touches on the damage done to the archival record by removing the artifacts from their original context and sending them away to collectors or foreign museums. Alva works towards drawing attention to how collectors and museums play a large part in encouraging looters and explains just how damaging looting is. I do think that the issues Alva outlines have impacted the cultural heritage in Peru.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the commercial world similar causes have produced similar results, and the race is benefited whereby” (pp. 392-393). Greer explained how the poor enjoy things that even the rich could not afford until today, and how farmers have more luxuries today than ever. Above anything previously talked about, in the Introduction to “Ethics and Morality” it was said that “if humankind’s goal is happiness, then the path to that goal must go through the precincts of ethical and moral behavior” (p. 686). We as people have to be ethical about our money.…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Human agency seems to be a large concept, when applied to the specific understanding of archaeological data, and this has opened debate among archaeologists about if agency fits in the realm of archeological inquiry. (Dobres & Robb, 2005). However, Robb (2010) argues that agency brings a past with faces to archaeology, and puts people back in the past. Agency certainly has a large role to play in archeological analysis in the contemporary era. Key to archaeology is material culture, as it and gives insight into how humans transform, create and give meaning to their external environment (Dobres & Robb, 2005).…

    • 1367 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In my opinion, the purpose of the film "Curse of the Axe", appears to be an attempt to glorify the field of archaeological research. The filmmakers attempted to demonstrate that archaeologists can teach First Nations about their history. This film suggested that the Huron-Wendat had little, to no knowledge about their past. I feel that the filmmakers, even if they depicted an interesting portrayal of pre-colonial Aboriginal history, did so in a biased manner. In contrast to the last chapter of "Ontario Archaeology" which highlighted hostile relations between Aboriginals and archaeologists, the movie made it seem as if Aboriginal communities depend on archaeologists for knowledge of their ancestors.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ancient Artifacts Essay

    • 1104 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The most important reason is the moral issue. Malcolm Bell, an art professor at the University of Virginia. According to his essay, “Who’s Right? Repatriation of Cultural Property”, he thinks all the antiquities should be returned to their original countries. In his opinion, “The ownership claim of a country of origin offers two benefits: It blocks the undocumented digging that destroys archeological sites and strips artifacts of their functional and historical contexts.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Modern Archeologists have a range of different non-intrusive archeological survey techniques available to them when locating and interpreting a site for excavation. These techniques prove useful in locating sites before any excavation is needed and can also assist during the excavation process. They help bring many mediums of data together to make a clear report of the archeological site and any finds that lead from that. The techniques include but are not limited to, looking at historic maps, aerial photography, LiDAR, analytical survey, field walking and geophysics and Geographical Information System (GIS). All of these techniques are useful to an archeologist however, they all have varying degrees of expense, financially, in manpower and…

    • 2260 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rock Art Essay

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Rock art can be viewed as part of everyone’s cultural heritage or as part of a specific groups’ cultural heritage. It is this difference of thought that can cause much debate on who should have access to and how to manage rock art sites. One way to ensure that the heritage is preserved regardless of what happens to the rock art itself is to record the stories that go along with the art. “Collecting and archiving [stories], with due respect for the traditional owners and in accordance with their wishes about what can or cannot be published, is as much a duty as preserving the art and its natural and archeological contexts” (Clottes, 2008:6). There is just some knowledge that is not meant to be learned or recorded.…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays