Negatives Of Technological Determinism

Improved Essays
The Negatives of Technological Determinism
Describing the relationship between technology and society can be somewhat difficult, with many individual perspectives. Individuals can either have a utopian and positive outlook on technology, whereas some may have a distopian and opposite perspective, and see technology as a deterrent (Quan-Haase, 2010). Additionally, there are many more theories on the relationship of technology and society.That being said, some of those theories prove to be more appropriate than others. One theory that is commonly discussed is technological determinism, which is a very limiting theory when it comes to describing the relations between technologies and society. This theory is used to describe the relationship between
…show more content…
Deterministic individuals may believe that technology shaping society is one sided, where as many historical events have proved this to be incorrect. As mentioned in Volti’s reading, is no secret that technology has impacted our economy positively. Our economy has grown in several ways due to technology (Volti, 2001). However, more often than not, Culture shaped events more than technology has. This being said, technology has and currently does shape present society, but cultural events have also had importance as well. As also discussed in Nye’s article “Does Technology Control Us?”, humans have made use of supplies for thousands of years (Nye, 2005). Many of the readings discuss technology as a positive, working alongside technology. There have been instances in society that one may believe are due to technological determinism, a well-known one being the Luddites. One may say that the Luddites went after technology due to it destroying their problems, thus having technology controlling the social order of society. However, it is possible to say that these employees were angered with their lives and the current state of the economy, and wanted a target that could not fight back (Volti, 2001). In present day, we use technology more as a tool than as a guide for society. The internet has come up as quite controversial, as individuals can post their work freely. This …show more content…
Technology should be viewed as a fluid tool rather than a necessity for human life and development. Humans have created the need for technology, thus rendering the theory of technological determinism as inaccurate. As discussed in Carey’s piece, the telegraph was an invention that revolutionized technology. It helped to not only develop a whole electronic and technology industry, but to also be the turning point for how individuals could communicate with one another. The introduction of the telegraph brought a new realm of communications that had not ever been done before (Carey, 1991). This in turn was all due to the human need for a communication device, thus leading to the creation and invention of the telegraph. Technological determinists may argue that the telegraph shaped the way we communicate. In some senses this may be true, but it is better to look at this idea from a social deterministic view. The events leading up to the creation of the telegraph called for it’s creation, thus giving societal controls on this invention. The United States of America has been generating technologies for years, with a steady increase and growth rate. It is a given that new technologies will bring forth new changes to society (Starr,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    I shows that technology is a great aspect for society, but as well as bringing trouble to the society for progress to occur many people had to be affected. The market revolution caused technology to progress and spread it revolutionized the United States. How did expansion and technological development in the United States change the nature of government? How do we see progress, is it accomplishments that pile can reach the heavens, is it bringing safety of your people, or is it gaining strength for your nation by expanding. Isn’t that the expansion and technological boom in the United States was bound to happen at some point in which would have been beneficial to the government and the people as a whole and that is “progress”.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Innovations created in the both revolutions have and will impact the world for thousands of generations to come. With the Industrial Revolution starting the technology and machinery revolution, as it was invented to miniaturize human labor. As the changing technology came up on people the new innovations made the quality of human life better, as they had machines to reduce the amount of work. Manuel Castells who works for MIT Technology Review says that with the wireless communication in the early Twenty First Century us humankind is closer to now almost entirely connected. What Manuel is stated would not have been possible without the work from the early days of the Industrial Revolution with the creation of telegraph which was used to communicate long distance like we do today with wire laid between stations.…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without the creation of new technology, people wouldn’t be spend large amounts of money on a product. In addition, technology creates conveniences for us which increase the production of things. This is extremely comparable to Brave New World because their society and economy is much like this but a bit more extreme about the use of technology. To any society, technology is a bug relevance in today's…

    • 1461 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the Industrial Revolution and industrialization had political, economic, and social benefits for countries able to adapt quickly, they proved disruptive to nations that took longer to develop. The political stability of a nation helps predict how well it will industrialize and if industry will be beneficial. The first industrialized countries faced political ordeals while introducing mechanized jobs. Public dissatisfaction lead to…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Gilded Age and the Roaring Twenties did not have these simple and effective technologies. The Gilded Age, brought out new technologies that were at first only used by skilled engineers because the technologies were complex. While this technology was impressive for its time, The Roaring Twenties in the 1900s brought out enhancements to these inventions for the general public to use, while also using communication to win the first great world war. Communication in the late 1800s to the early 1900s has helped humans become closer to one another in the world. The late 1800s, brought new communication technology to drastically stay informed of the world.…

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The effects of industrialization upon the world have been studied and celebrated for centuries. Of course, there were some negative aspects; child labor and pollution were major problems during the Industrial Revolution. Despite this, many positive consequences arose after and during the movement. While some historians may argue that industrialization had primarily negative consequences on society, the movement had many more positive aspects, including new forms of technology, more jobs, and improved methods of transportation. The Industrial Revolution brought multiple waves of technological introductions to the world.…

    • 1571 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Technology is a part of the evolution of humans, without technology our society would be the same as it was a decade ago. Although some people believe that technology is taking over our society it is honestly just giving us a new way of being distracted. Our brain is like a toolbox, as we get a new form of technology it is like adding a new tool to our toolbox. When we get new technology that is dramatic it produces a new kind of human being. Just because we as a society is connected to technology does not mean that we cannot become disconnected just as easily.…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Even Neo-Luddites, a people who are weary on the expansion of the dependence of machinery, address that “technology is intrinsic to human creativity and culture,” (Glendinning 84). Innovations in technology are developed by humans, for humans, and are created with the divine purpose of extending the average human capacity to much greater lengths. This is because tools “for thousands and thousands of years, [have] been a physical modification of self… extend[ing] our physical selves” to excel in ways our bodies were not capable of; however, now humanity is “addressed with an extension of the mental self,” persisting us to communicate, think, and function differently (Case). Tools ranging from the first ignition of fire to recent expansions within computational devices have mirrored both the physical and mental evolution of mankind; devices cannot progress on their own, however it is the implementation of these tools that allows humanity to expand. In a way, modern technology is built in the form of man, with its numerical coding reflecting the genes of its creator; artificial intelligence and data bases have allowed technology to play a greater role in the transcendence of the human intellect and perform logic based routines similar to human cognition.…

    • 1799 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Technopoly would heavily impact society, as we know it, if it was to be completely realized. What we were once able to control would be controlled by technology. Humans will then begin to, for a lack of a better term, glorify technology. One’s wouldn’t have to think for themselves anymore, technology could take over that feat for us. Postman in particular offers education as an example to this notion.…

    • 1617 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the reading, Langdon Winner puts lots of arguments to show how artifacts are more than just inventions when we look their effects in the society and the way they are indirectly related with the political beliefs. Artifacts also can be known as technologies over time have redefined the way we look at them because they model our society and bring the change once they are introduced. In the beginning of the reading, Winner introduces argument in a way that persuades reader in his topic of discussion. The argument begins when he says, “At issue is the claim that the machines, structures, and systems of modern material culture can be accurately judged not only for their contributions of efficiency and productivity, not merely for their positive…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays