Nationalization Of Illegal Immigration

Great Essays
My fight for immigration reform began in the sixth grade with the arrival of my best friend Judith and her family from Mexico. They have exposed me to a new, hardworking culture that does not get its due credit from media and politicians. The injustice these remarkable people face not only sparked a fire in myself but my entire family. My Father Dan Aldridge, a lawyer licensed to practice in both Alabama and Tennessee, would soon become well acquainted with a good friend of Judith’s family. Juan, who is a husband, a father to two children, and is an illegal immigrant. One night, he was arrested for a DUI while in his neighborhood and Aldridge took on his case. In the case of a DUI, the intoxicated person has to be witnessed actually driving …show more content…
As previously mentioned, there are 11.3 million illegal aliens living in the U.S. The undocumented immigrants are more valuable as citizens than they are being deported. Philip Wolgin argues that if the United States were to give these illegal residents a path to citizenship, the tax influx “would add a cumulative $1.2 trillion to the GDP over a decade.” Not only will the tax influx put a dent into the national debt but it will happen in a fairly quick amount of time. Theoretically, the gains that are shown will only increase overtime. With the mark of citizenship, the once illegal aliens will have opportunities to get higher paying jobs. The increased income will mean higher income taxes and higher revenue. If these people were to be deported in their entirety, the government would miss the opportunity to have major financial gain. There is also no data proving that if the U.S. legalizes these immigrants there will be a mandatory boost on funding for health services or defense services (Ferguson). The government will not have to compensate for the influx in population. Making illegal immigrants citizens will raise their wages and they will put more back into the economy and now without fear, thus helping fund jobs and the economy. The undocumented immigrant population is a crucial asset to working toward a surplus in the national …show more content…
One argument against nationalization explores the effect of mass immigration on America’s natural resources. Wooldridge points out “the long-term ramifications facing their progeny as water, energy, and resources exhaust themselves from sheer over-use and over-extension.” Nonrenewable resources are a pressing concern facing our future generations and the race for green alternatives shows an impressive drive for constructive developments. The solution to these problems could be hidden in the mind of an illegal immigrant that does not have access to the education. When they go through the proposed fast-track to legalization, their new validation will lead to personal motivation. Becoming knowledgeable about current issues the United States is facing should be a part of becoming a U.S citizen. The new citizens will utilize this knowledge and powerful motivation to make changes. There is also the argument of what would be a chain reaction following amnesty or an advanced legalization process. Kirsanow, an attorney, claims that the immigration bill proposed by president Obama “is structured to attract low-skilled immigrants and spur illegal immigration.” Both amnesty and the expedited legalization process would spark more immigrants to illegally enter the states to take advantage of this opportunity. If this were to happen, they would not stay illegal immigrants for long. The

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Illegal immigration has been a prevalent issue in the United States for a century, but unauthorized residents have made many contributions to the nation’s economy by providing unskilled labor for low wages and no benefits. Residing in the United States without proper documentation may be illegal; however, a large number of illegal immigrants work under undesirable conditions and receive pay which American citizens would refuse to accept. Aside from the economic factors of illegal immigration, illegitimate non-citizens also have social ties to their respective communities within the United States. Many illegal immigrants have children who were born in the United States, making them legal citizens. The question of what to do with the millions…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although it is understandable that deporting eleven million people is not practical, and the plan provides undocumented immigrants a legal way to earn citizenship and be accountable for taxes and laws, there are still issues regarding population influx, economic deficits, and safety. Allowing the opportunity for naturalization for eleven million people does not solve the fact that within those eleven million people, drug cartels, criminals, uneducated people, and terrorists reside (Why Illegal Immigration is Bad for America). It does not solve the billions of dollars worth of debt due to illegal immigrants. Yes, these new citizens will begin to pay taxes, which will take away a large tax burden from current American citizens, but these eleven million people will now be in direct competition with the twenty million already unemployed Americans who search for jobs. President Obama’s plan for amnesty is…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Immigration In Texas Essay

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the last decade or so, many important issues that were debated did not have much of an impact on local communities. However, one issue that is being debated today that will directly affect local communities is the policy on illegal immigration and how to control it. As we all know, immigrants looking for a new beginning founded this country and it has since been known as the country of second chances. The thought of the American Dream is what convinced so many people in centuries past to immigrate to America. This same reason is why today in America there are a large number of legal and illegal immigrants hoping to achieve this same dream. Over the years, the number of illegal immigrants has drastically increased. States with high concentrations…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Most people think that undocumentedillegal immigrants waste taxpayer money via benefits such as food stamps and healthcare. However, studies show that they actually contribute to the tax coffers. According to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, undocumented immigrants paid around $10.6 billion in state and local taxes(cited in Satana). Also, most undocumented immigrants are ineligible for most benefits such as food stamps. According to Tin Wise, the Author of Great White Hoax: Responding to the Politics of White Nationalism, “undocumented workers and their families are not eligible for cash welfare or food stamps.. They are only eligible for emergency medical assistance, prenatal care and educational benefits,”(Wise 28). These two factors causes undocumented immigrant to actually increase the amount of money the government has. These taxes go into things such as Social Security. They also increase the amount of money other people earn. According to the New York times, undocumented immigrants increased workers pay in skilled labor by 10 percent from 1990 to 2007(Davidson). This helped improve the economy because the more money people have the more money they spend, which in turn stimulates the economy. undocumented immigrants contribute to the economy and if they are legalized, they would be able to contribute…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not only would immigrants benefit from reformed immigration laws, but so would the U.S.! Studies have shown that increased immigration would even stimulate the economy. According to American Immigration Council, a deportation-only policy would result in a $2.6 trillion lost in GDP over the course of decade. In contrast, if an immigration reform included a legalization process for the undocumented, an additional…

    • 430 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unocumented Immigration

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages

    We could remove them, which would reduce the number of workers, but it would also reduce the jobs created by the economic activity they generate. So the right choice is to bring the unauthorized immigrants who are already here out of the shadows so they can help the country realize its economic potential. The main argument in support of undocumented immigration is that these workers do jobs that Americans do not want to do. Generally, they will work for lower wages because they’re in need of a job. It is estimated that undocumented immigrants' lower wages by approximately 3 to 8 percent for low-skill jobs. Furthermore, Americans who compete with immigrants for these jobs stand to make an additional $25 a week if undocumented immigration were to be severely cut down. One of the other most common arguments that comes with undocumented immigration is the use of government services. Most undocumented workers are not subject to federal tax deductions because they are normally paid in cash, so many people argue that these immigrants are costing our government a large amount of money by receiving benefits such as education, health care, food…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Illegal aliens have created a life in the United States for which their families depend on. The cost for mass deportation is nothing to be taken lightly. The deportation itself would ruin the country’s representation as a land of opportunity. As the Statue of Liberty itself states "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me, I lift my lamp beside the go3lden door!" Everyone in the United States is an immigrant, whether they came here before or after the laws of the land were…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The amount of legal documents being given to legal immigrants alone is already significantly high, “The U.S. government issues about 1 million residency cards, or "green cards," that allow people to move to the United States legally each year” (Immigration 2015). Immigrants perform jobs that natives do not want to take part in. Brannon writes, “It is commonly asserted that illegal immigrants “steal” American jobs, while the other side of the debate insists that illegal immigrants do the jobs that Americans don’t want to do” (Brannon 2016). Immigrants can better certain low income communities throughout the Unites States. Brannon writes, “Between 1990 and 2010, 40 percent of Texas’ workforce growth came from foreign workers migrating from other countries (Brannon 2016). Granting immigrants basic American rights can influence elections exponentially if they are able to vote. Allowing immigrants to vote can work in favor of any candidate, “According to calculations, the states where most Hispanics live which are, California, Texas, Florida, New Jersey and New York are worth roughly 171 electoral votes equaling 63 percent of the 270 needed to win the presidency” (Immigration 2016). Removing all illegal immigrants can also be costly to taxpayers, including native taxpayers. “The pro-amnesty American Action Forum (AAF) calculated it would cost the United States government $400 to $600 billion to remove all illegal aliens who are currently living in the United States within a period of two years, this also includes keeping illegal aliens out” (Immigration…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many immigrants are already helping our economy by paying taxes and helping our society by taking up jobs that many other people will not want to do because of the low wages and high hours. This is why simply allowing these immigrants to become american citizens would be the best and most effective solution to our rising immigration problem. The United States is a country that was founded upon immigration and it is our tradition to receive immigrants and house them in our country and give them a home. If this solution is able to take effective in upcoming years it will have a long lasting effect on our country, our economy, and the people that reside in these United States. Overall this is the only logical solution to immigration and the only one to actually have a positive effect on the United…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ultimately, we need to understand that without illegal immigrants the economic growth of the United States will crash. Although massive deportations may seem of concern to only a small group of citizens, it should be in fact concern for anyone who cares about the increase in taxes. Undocumented immigrants are a critical piece of the economy in the United Sates because they pay $11.64 million overall in state and local taxes. Per to the estimation of the Institute on Taxation & Economic Policy (ITEP) if legalization were to happen undocumented immigrants would pay $13.8 million in state and local taxes. Therefore, legalizing unauthorized immigrants would reduce the number of millions of dollars the government is wasting on massive deportations.…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Admittedly, as Jeffrey Bowman and C. Ames Cushman claims, “undocumented immigrants do not pay the taxes that American citizens pay, but still take advantage of many public services, such as public hospitals and public schools” (Bowman & Cushman). However, if immigrants were granted social services it would save taxpayers money (Pawlick & Finley). Therefore, undocumented Americans would tremendously be helpful to the economy and America.…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As any politically active American would know, the topic of Illegal Immigration has transformed into a very heated debate throughout the recent years. Many are tired of hearing about it, and can you blame them? However, when babies of illegal immigrants make up 40 percent of the total births in California’s hospitals (Smith) and that the total number of illegal Mexican immigrants in 2004 was estimated at 5.9 million (Buehn, Andreas, Eichler 30), it’s not hard to see that there’s an issue. These alarming statistics put the sheer number of Illegals entering this country into perspective. The simple fact of them entering the country…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is not enough money to go around helping those who aren’t citizens of America. On the contrary, they contribute to the cash flow. They make money that they then go back and spend, just like documented citizens. They are spending their money on bills, education, food, shelter, etc, again, just like documented citizens. Like I stated earlier, they have been here for years and all they’re doing is living like every other documented American, the difference is one is not allowed to be here. In fact, many spend so much money trying to get documented. Going through the fees for applications and waivers, it could cost between $1490 to $2490, plus the trips they might have to make or if something goes wrong, they might still have to pay more. All that money is given to the United States. By giving more opportunities to help undocumented immigrants, there will be more money that’s given to America. For example, my family has spent a couple thousand dollars in applications, waivers, trips, and fees to get documented. Money that somehow we had to have to continue our process every time. My family had to somehow find jobs where they wouldn’t ask too much about their status, which goes into my next point. Also, according to Fiscal Times, “Immigration benefits America in at least two ways. First, increased immigration expands the American workforce and encourages more business start-ups. Second, immigrants increase…

    • 1121 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That being the case, it would cost the federal government approximately $100-114 billion dollars to deport all illegal immigrants, and it would take nearly 20 years. Under those circumstances, it would cost less to deport illegal immigrants than to account responsibility for them because $100-114 billion dollars within twenty years is much less expensive than $326.7 billion dollars each year. More importantly, U.S Immigration and Customs Enforcement stated in 2013 it would cost around $8,600 dollars to deport one undocumented immigrant, using that as a foundation it would cost virtually $100 billion dollars to deport every single illegal immigrant within 20 years. Given that, it is important and crucial money wise for illegal immigrants to be deported. If not, there could be financial issues to come if America does not take appropriate action and grant a deportation…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    She claims many are waiting years just to obtain a “green card, or visas for permanent residency” because “no country may have more than 7 percent” of their applicants immigrate each year (Ngai). Another problem immigrants face is longer and tedious green card and visa application process. According to Darrell West’s article on “Inside the Immigration”, “American immigration is a 19th-century process in a 21st-century world” which means everything is done on paper and the waiting game is the most prominent aspect of this process. This conflict backs up the reason to reform immigration leading Ngai to support Hart’s reform about giving visas or green cards based on the individual or families’ need. Not just handing out visas or green cards on a first come, first serve basis, but to applicants who are in any type of danger or financial crisis. Therefore, Ngai proves her point to the readers about reforming immigration because the process takes too long with millions waiting to receive a visa or green card. Some students and their parents who have waited a decade to immigrate to the U.S. will benefit from this article while students who have never experienced this might not respond to reforming the law. Shorthorn readers…

    • 1621 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays