The Cutting Of A Leg By Simiilih Cordor Analysis

Improved Essays
Tradition vs. Modernity and Medicine
In the African literature discussed so far in class, tradition versus modernity is a reoccurring theme. Characters challenge traditions like marriage rituals, female roles and male roles, and the line between family and society. What isn’t common in the novels and plays read so far is the compromise between modern medicine practiced by doctors and traditional medicine practiced by witch doctors. Similih Cordor addresses this fact by using his characters to show how a balance can be found between modern and traditional medicine. In “The Cutting of a Leg,” the character Fatu tries to negotiate with modern medicine to heal her broken leg, but ultimately submits to the traditional medicine that has been saving
…show more content…
What’s interesting about this story is that it is prefaced with a little biography about Cordor and what his intentions were with the story. Cordor is quoted as saying “The story is a dramatization of the humanity of a struggling African family in the big city…a portrayal of the plight of the semiskilled or unskilled, uneducated, and low-income masses of modern Africa who migrate to cities in search of better life for their families, but who only experience loneliness, poverty, diseases, alienation, and despair” (178). Kollie and his wife Marwu are poor, country people that have moved to the city and have five children with one more on the way. Money is tight, and Kollie is trying to avoid taking his wife to the maternity hospital for as long as he can because they cannot afford the …show more content…
In the case of Fatu, maybe it is a Western stereotype perpetuated by television medical dramas, but doctors usually try to go above and beyond for patients they feel they can heal. Dr. Cooper, while passionate about Fatu’s health, seems to take one look at her leg x-ray and skip right to amputation. Fatu becomes so traumatized by the practice of Western medicine in that hospital that she might never go back to a Western hospital again. She could from the end of the story onwards only rely on traditional remedies for her ailments. This is a huge contrast from the story of Kollie, who must rely on Western medicine when his wife falls ill. Though the modern medicine works for Kollie, he faces many challenges to receive the help he needs. He learns he needs to adapt fast to the social norms of not just the hospital but the city too if he is going to make a life for his

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Introduction: This essay will assess how cultural differences impacted Lia Lee's health in the book The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down by Anne Fadiman. It will point to several different times when cultural disagreements lead to distinct negative or positive effects on Lia’s health. It will also show how, despite overcoming almost all of the cultural disagreements amongst the Hmong and American doctors, Lia’s health still failed. A counter argument claiming that the doctors hold more responsibility than the Lee’s for Lia’s declining health is also provided and rebuked.…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Arthur Kleinman, there is no better doctor-patient relationship than one where both parties are able to answer a set of eight seemingly obvious and simple questions. The key to this dynamic is the ability to answer, not the similarity between answers. The importance of this distinction could have made all the difference in the conflict in Lia Lee’s case. The introduction of eight “golden” rules to consider in health care at the end of Lia Lee’s case allow all parties to self-reflect retrospectively and consider the cosmological differences between Lia Lee’s parents and her doctors. The take-away is to eradicate the cultural term of noncompliance, as this asserts moral supremacy.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. Describe the primary issues presented in the case study. The case study of the doctor in the sleep study clinic represents issues with health disparities, race, poverty/socioeconomic class, ethnicity and culture. The doctor clearly puts his own needs first as well as remains at the job due to its proximity to family and friends.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Contrary to Conquergood’s uplifting philosophy on the quintessential needs to acknowledge patients realities, Fadiman in the late chapters of the novel notes a epidemiologist own thoughts on the issue of clashing cultures “for better or for worse, Western medicine is one-sided. Until the culture of medicine changes, it may be difficult for doctors having gone through rigorous academic study to take their reality as only a view, not reality itself…” I found this quote to be very dramatic in the sense that it brings to light the flaws within American medical schools. The culture the colleague mentions, I believe, does have the capability to change given the assumptions that medical school students are not too busy worrying about residency and completing course prerequisites, instead rather taking the time to translate the cultural suffering of various societies into their own studies. Courses lacking integration of anthropology and ethnography are the reasons why the next generations of doctors may be lacking essential concepts of cultural language and the manners which to engage and communicate with patients without the assertive barrier of medical knowledge as a dominating means to control a…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the realm of medical anthropology, Julie Livingston’s Improvising Medicine stands as a poignant ethnography that examines the growing cancer crisis in Sub-Saharan Africa from the view of the oncology ward in Princess Marina Hospital (PMH) in Gaborone, Botswana. A professor at New York University, Julie Livingston is a medical historian who combines her training in anthropology and public health to evaluate medicine in Botswana with an emotional analysis, depicting a view of physical suffering in context of the social climate. Her previous work, Debility and the Moral Imagination in Botswana, analyzed the effect of economic and political development on traditional, medical care practices. This runs parallel with Improvising Medicine as the…

    • 1581 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Western medicine is primarily the medicine that all of North America and Western Europe are under the general care of. A large part of the population is oblivious to the way Western Medicine has everyone stuck in a trap of epic disaster. The collective actions of modern medicine will slowly build up antibiotic resistance, weaken immune systems and will eventually cause complete mutation of mindset when people are unaware how to function without having a quick fix pill for their health problem. Rather than the traditional doctors of Western Medicine being required to have training in nutrition, they instead spend hundreds of frivolous hours studying and memorizing symptoms and treatments to the body's system of interworking organs.…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There she stood in a market with other fated Africans, covered by nothing but a dirty piece of carpet (Odell, 12). Things didn’t look good for her. As a girl of about seven or eight years, she was little, scrawny, and inexperienced with hard field work. In addition, her health suffered from the foreign North American weather. What would happen to this girl if no one wanted her?…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, as the medical system changed over the time, the set of values is changed too, based on the technology’s evolution. Human know more treatments and medicines than any time before, doctors could not know “every treatment” anymore. The medical technology is updated, clinicians are all specialists now, even the primary care physicians. Everyone just has a piece of the care. In order for a treatment, a patient needs more clinicians to take care.…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s society when a person goes to the doctor with a specific problem, he or she expects that the doctor will give him or her a prescription. The patient takes the prescription to the local pharmacy and gets it filled, and in a couple of days of taking the prescribed medicine the patient will feel better and continue daily routine activities. The complaint could be more serious and strict than others but most individuals are confident that the doctor will be able to cure them and most of the time they are right, However, it was not always like this, about 200 years ago Medicine and doctors were very different from today’s doctors. Going to see a doctor did not mean that anybody could just go see a doctor and get the perfect cure for…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay “Shakespeare in the Bush,” Laura Bohannan attempts to demonstrate whether there is truly a “universal understanding” through her experience of sharing Shakespeare’s “Hamlet” with the Tiv tribe in West Africa. Throughout Laura’s story, the Tiv people object to many key details of the Shakespearean drama, however, overall they are able to accept and understand Hamlet. The drastically different cultural backgrounds made the Tiv and Bohannan’s interpretations fascinating to witness, as well as directing attention to the differences in their general ideas of life and death. Laura’s essay focuses on the contrasting relationship between the culture of the Tiv and that of Western society. In the very opening paragraph, Bohannan implies a very assumptive comparison between herself and the Tiv people.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    During the 1700s, in the Colonial period, the practice of medicine was primitive, as was the healthcare provided to the early settlers. During this time “heroic medicine” was practiced. Aggressive treatments such as bleeding, purging, and blistering occupied a central place in therapeutics. Different philosophies (Western medicine and Native American medicine) were making it difficult for doctors to command the authority they desired. It was very easy to become a doctor during this period, anyone could claim to be a doctor.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Summer Reading Reflection Medical ethics are as complicated as medical school itself, if not more so. In medical school, one is at least told what is right and what is wrong. These black and white pleasantries do not translate to the grey, intricate “correctness” of medical ethics. Anne Fadiman’s The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, follows the story of a young Hmong girl named Lia Lee, her family, her doctors, and almost a decade of ethical dilemmas.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mieko Assignment Questions

    • 1898 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Mieko ASSIGNMENT #1 QUESTIONS: (due 11:59pm, Thursday, February 11th) Provide essay-style answers (e.g., complete sentences) to the following questions. The best answers are accurate, highly descriptive, and well above the indicated "bare minimum" word ranges. Upload your completed assignment to your Laulima DROPBOX. Make sure to read each question carefully!…

    • 1898 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The good thing is that each of the baby’s parents used their resources wisely. They where so adapted to there own environment, if Hattie and her parents where placed in Namibia then they would have a hard time to survive because they are not accustomed to that type of atmosphere and…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hahn Nosology Analysis

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages

    What are nosologies? According to Hahn (1995:14-15), nosologies are the categories of sickness, how different sicknesses and illnesses are viewed in different cultures. Nosologies help us understand, classify, and differentiate different diseases and sicknesses. Hahn (1995:15-18) discusses three different societies of nosology: Subanun, Ndembu, and biomedicine in western society. These are three very different culturally diverse groups and each poses its own complications and distinctive means for dealing with and understanding sicknesses, illnesses, and disease processes.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays