Masterpiece Cake Shop Case Summary

Superior Essays
A Case about Freedom -- Masterpiece Cake Shop vs. Colorado Civil Rights Commissions

Our world is entering a new phrase, when the society welcomes and embraces all kinds of identities. In this great era, people can bravely express their personal opinions, religious beliefs, and sexual orientation without the fear of being punished or discriminated. In every sense, we are living in a more unprejudiced world. However, with the increasing diversity of the society, problems and conflicts ensue. Complications between races, cultures and religions seem to exacerbate. Moreover, followed by the legalization of the same sex marriage in the U.S, the relationships between the LGBT and religious groups become even thornier. The upcoming Supreme Court
…show more content…
As Mill states in the On Liberty, “ Protection, therefore, against the tyranny of the magistrate is not enough; there needs protection also against the tyranny of the prevailing opinion and feelings; against the tendency of society to impose by other means than civil penalties” (4). With the legalization of the same sex marriage, on one hand, people are celebrating this social progress. However, on the other hand, the liberal groups seem to have a higher expectation towards the public. They expect all people to accept and, if possible, to give well wishes to the same sex couple. This public expectation is really obvious in regions like New York, California, Massachusetts, Colorado and other “democratic” states. People in these regions seem to be especially sensitive towards opinions like “it’s not okay to be a gay”, and there seems to a tendency of correcting this so called “discriminative” views and re-educating those unsatisfying people, who is holding this

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In 2012, Charlie Craig and David Mullins went to Masterpiece Cakeshop in Lakewood,CO, and requested that its owner, Jack C.Phillips, design and create a cake for their wedding. Phillips refused to design the cake because of religious beliefs, he doesn’t create wedding cakes for the same sex wedding. The issue is that since Phillips declined to create the cake, Craig and David Mullins filed charges of discrimination with the Colorado Civil Rights Division; they formed a formal complaint with the office of Administrative Courts. On August 13, 2015, the Colorado court of appeals unanimously affirmed the commission’s order, finding that the bakery discriminated and violated the state law. The Colorado Supreme Court denied review while the United States Supreme Court granted certiorari on June 26, 2017.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Charlie Craig and David Mullins are a homosexual couple from Lakewood, Colorado that were in search of a cake for their weeding day much to their surprise when they entered Masterpiece Cakeshop the owner refused to sell them a wedding cake as it violated his personal religious beliefs. A Supreme Court Case was open in ruling that the owner Jack Phillips was discriminating the couple for their sexual preferences. In the first audio the court case of Jack Philips claims that he did not believe he was acting against the law because there has been various occasions in the past were the owners of cakeshops have denied their services to same-sex couples with the claim that they have the right to express their beliefs under the jurisdiction of the…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The court’s decision compelling Phillips to create a cake for a same-sex couple infringes on his right to practice his religion how he sees fit. To Phillips, the cake is symbolic because it represents a sacred covenant made between man and women, as it traditionally has for years prior to establishment of same-sex marriage. However, there is a fine line between practicing your chosen religion and acting against opposing and popular beliefs. Phillips is not saying he is opposed to the rights given to the LGBT community but is simply making a point that many comparable companies have made: This case is not disagreeing with the rights given to the LGBT community, but rather suggesting that we offer the same protections to those with opposing, religious beliefs. In an interview with CNN, Phillips said: "I feel I'm being compelled to create artwork for an event -- an…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The right to marry might seem trivial to some, but for those who have never been able too, it is an amazing feeling. Although not everyone feels so positively about it, those individuals are not in great company at least that is what the research suggests. That is not to say that these individuals and entities are not causing problems for those trying to enjoy the right. The most notable are the clerks in Kentucky refusing to issue licenses and the courts in Arkansas upholding poor legislation to attack homosexual couples. Overall, this case decision has set the stage for equal protection and treatment for the LGBT…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the year 2000, a case came to the floor of the Supreme Court dealing with interpretation of the First Amendment. In a country of the free, we are plagued by discrimination daily. The targets have shifted over the years. Religion and race seem to be the ever-present discriminatory subjects. Though religious groups also cause hate of those who are different in sexual orientation.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Pros And Cons Of Kim Davis

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the United States of America, our people have come a long way since our nation’s founding. Nevertheless, we have slowly but surely fought to get to where we are today. After years of civil rights’ movements and desegregation laws, our government has now legalized same-sex marriage. While a majority of the nation rejoices that all people can now have equal rights when it comes to this life decision, many are opposed to the new legislation. One citizen who has refused to acknowledge this change in law is Kim Davis, a Kentucky clerk who has refused to issue marriage licenses to any same-sex couples.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For many years, gay marriage has been seen as something that is taboo or immoral, but as United States society has come to be more accepting, gay marriage has become a regular occurrence. On June 26, 2015, American society changed forever when the ruling in favor of the plaintiff in the Obergefell v. Hodges case legalized homosexual marriage in the United States. Many people have opposed the marriage of two men or two women for religious purposes. However, many people also support said marriage, reasoning that love is love no matter the gender of the individuals getting married. The ruling made nine months ago has effected people of all sexualities and religious affiliations.…

    • 1485 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Karen Partanen Gay Rights

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Over the past few decades, the movement for gay rights has been flourishing across the United States. From the first state legalization of same-sex marriage in Massachusetts in 2004, to the law protecting LGBTA rights in the workplace in 2007 (AGRM Timeline, Infoplease), the LGBTA community has finally began to get the basic rights and liberties they deserve. However, there are still many areas where their rights are lacking and inadequate. In many states across the country, the parental rights of LGBTA individuals are very limited.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Religious Liberties Religious liberties is a highly debatable subject with very passionate supporters and opponents which has caused a major division in the country. This disagreement is present between the two major political parties with the Republican Party as supporters while the Democratic Party currently leads the opposition. The current debate is focused on whether the government should allow owners to refuse service to people based on their sexual preference citing a religious objection (Smith). Opponents want the federal government to extend anti discrimination laws to not allow owners the right to refuse to people solely based on their sexual preference (Badash).…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    As Mike Pence prepares to take office as Vice President, the LGBTQ+ community awaits the many difficulties he may pose for their fight for equality, especially considering his stance on conversion therapy for homosexuals. Despite United States Surgeon General David Satcher issuing a report in 2001 stating that there is no valid scientific evidence that sexual orientation can be modified or changed with medical or psychological intervention, Mike Pence has involved himself in supporting efforts that seem to be linked to conversion, or “reparative,” therapy. Fighting conversion therapy is nothing new to the LGBTQ+ community. Since the early Freudian period, many have attempted to change sexual orientations to fit hegemonic standards of the corresponding…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the court ruled that Phillips had to bake a cake for Charlie and David, he did have his First Amendment rights violated. In the future, the court should consider a different ruling, such as a fine and allow people to run their business in a way that doesn’t violate the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act, rather than forcing him to provide the service. My decision would support the reasoning that people can have their own beliefs under the First Amendment, as long as they do not violate the rights of another. My decision would not force Jack Phillips to make wedding cakes for same-sex couples unless he is making them for heterosexual couples; he has the decision to make wedding cakes for everyone, or for no one. This ruling supports that the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act are…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The unequal treatment in health care, the political system, and religious institutions of LGBT, which stands for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgendered people, is still prevalent in the United States and needs to be remediated. This is a social problem for several reasons, including the condition not only exists but is widely known, it produces harm, it has social causes and can be remediated. First, the unequal treatment of the LGBT community is widely known. The Gay Rights Movement officially started in 1969 with the Stonewall Riots, when LGBT people fought back against the police when the police tried to arrest LGBT bar goers just for being gay (Arriola, 1).…

    • 1670 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Transgender Movement

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The transgender movement first emerged in 1952, but was formality made into a movement in 1969 with the Stonewall riots, which also was the birth of the LGBT movement. Since then transgender rights and transgendered people, in general, have been a prevalent topic in todays media since the passing of several LGBT laws. The passing of laws in favour of the LGBT, such as, marriage equality law, the transgender community is now focusing on obtaining laws that favour the movement in gaining equal and civil rights. Now ever since the movement emerged there has been a debate over whether there needs to be laws to protect them from discrimination. There are roughly 1.4 million people who identify as transgender in the U.S. and with the increase in…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Same-sex marriage, conflict of laws, and the unconstitutional public policy exception. Yale Law Journal. May 1997, v.106, n7, 1965-2008 Strasser, Mark. Legally Wed. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. 1997.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is a problem that is all over the world, “religious communities around the world take a range of positions on homosexuality, from acceptance to prohibition” (Karaim). It could be in favor of the LGBT community or it could be in favor of the religious community. There have been several laws passed on both sides, the LGBT community and the…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays