Manufacturing Consent Noam Chomsky

Improved Essays
“Manufacturing Consent: Noam Chomsky and the Media” is a documentary in which we can observe Noam Chomsky—in various interviews, debates and forums—make a relationship between big corporations and the media. In this documentary, Noam Chomsky makes us realize how we, the people, are conditioned to believe certain things in the media because of the business elites. This idea will be demonstrated through The New York Time’s coverage of the atrocities in East Timor and Cambodia and through Chomsky’s idea of “necessary illusions. At some point in the documentary, Chomsky discusses how big media corporations covered the atrocities that happened in Cambodia and in East Timor during 1975 and 1979 to elucidate the propaganda. The New York Times was the example given. We could see how The New York Times dedicated much less coverage to East Timor during the Indonesian invasion and the extermination that followed. They displayed bias in favor of the small group of people who have a certain amount of control over the society and did not covered both events equally. The New York Times payed a particular attention to what happened in Cambodia and almost ignored the genocide in East Timor. We were shown that East Timor received 70 column inches of entries while Cambodia received 1 175 column inches of entries. If The New York …show more content…
To him, there are 2 targets of propaganda; a political class of 20 percent of the population who are under the control of the business elites—they sometimes own it—and the masses (or the “people”) are alienated and controlled by the necessary illusions. The idea of necessary illusions represents the way the elite dominates how things happens with a part of the people (the 20 percent) involved and the other (the 80 percent) diverted and marginalized. The media is used and owned by the elite to create those illusions that are quite necessary to divert the masses from the political

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In his emotional appeal to the audience, he frequently repeats the idea of ‘left-wing fake news,’ to elicit a response, yet there is no explanation as to what he is referencing. This name-calling attempts to undermine the stories and media that supported the democratic party, but is meaningless, as it remains undefined. He also presents several bandwagon appeals, in which he suggests that if others have benefited from similar actions, why can’t the Republican Party? Specifically, Pollak’s fifth and eighth point argue that since the Obama administration has been accused of manipulating media for political gain, and for interfering in foreign politics, it is of no consequence that the Russian’s are doing the same now. This shift of blame offers no resolution, and leaves Pollak’s argument sounding…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetorical Ethics

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The question of whether journalists or private philanthropists have a greater responsibility to rhetorical ethics requires an examination…? David Oliver Relin and Greg Mortenson’s Three Cups of Tea demonstrates the power of a private philanthropist in using emotional appeals and embellishments of truth to convince the public into giving money to a charity—in this case, the Central Asia Institute (CAI). On the other hand, an analysis of John Krakauer’s rhetoric in Three Cups of Deceit proves that investigative journalists, unlike private philanthropists, have a responsibility to truthfully represent events within their writing. The principles of journalism mandate ethical journalists to write based on factual information because there exists…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Instead of doing what they would consider the right thing, they chose to do what they knew would keep the consumer involved and keep their power intact. In today’s age, “…not surprisingly, war and terrorism have consistently ranked at the top of the stack…” (Williams). Our society’s craving for bad news is quite clear, there are 17 “bad” news stories for every “good” story. There is also an argument made that the media is only responding to our society’s views, that they adapt to us and therefore should not be blamed.…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He addresses the emotion it requires to realize the government’s folly but then offers a pragmatic reason as to why the misinformation strengthens one’s worldview. “It is simply unpleasant to think about oneself being propagandized,” Greenwald asserts, “but the more substantive reason for this resistance is that the way in which we assess the set of information about the world is very self-reinforcing” (827). Greenwald encourages the public to deliberately search for a wider scope of political opinion, but insists that one must “believe there is actually a reason to do it” (828). To assess how Americans fail to seek out completed information, Greenwald mentions Christopher Capozzola, who discussed the public’s response to more extreme cases of government-controlled media and its relation to the situation today (829). In tyrannical governments, information is tightly controlled and altered to the governments liking.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The film Rich Media Poor Democracy asserts that journalism in the United States does not serve the interest of the public, instead they serve the interest of media corporate bosses. Moreover, the film points out the media corporate bosses are to blame for the absence of choice and diversity in the media which stems from a shortage of competition created through mergers. Rich Media Poor Democracy proposes that citizen involvement can and should rescue the media, otherwise corporate bosses will maintain their stronghold and riches providing and even poorer democracy. Opponents of company mergers is not a new concept. In fact, Medoff and Kaye note that since the beginning of the century, consolidation of station ownership began to raise issues…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In recent years, there have been accusations against the media regarding how it informs us of news. There have also been accusations against public officials accusing them of stretching the truth or fudging numbers up. These misrepresentations lead the public to develop a distrust of their government and the media. People are starting to wonder if they’re being told the whole story. This is particularly true in the book 1984, written by George Orwell.…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bernie Goldberg, author of Bias, conveys his knowledge on the media distorting what the truth is in order to have many others believe in the same values as others. Goldberg, in a discussion with John Stossel, Dealing With Media Bias, demonstrates how a group think works within a newscast and exhibiting how previous friends of his had abandoned him from a lack of an open mind, especially since those friends were all in similar mindsets, in similarity to Stossel, as well as other news reporters, being fired or leaving a job. Along with this, Goldberg believes that the “truth” for a network based on one-sided views is filtered through only liberal beliefs. Goldberg shows this by giving the example of the widespread attention his article got, Networks Need a Reality Check, and resulted in a group of friends not speaking to him anymore. The ideology of a group think among his previous friendship is the epitome of a goal the media bias has and those who represent the liberal views.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Modern days saw news media served in favor of powerful figures and their strings especially there was a sensitive issue which could not justify their drawbacks. Through the Cold War, so-called global powers used news media as a good means of propaganda. Both the United States and the Soviet Union pilloried the opposites’ ideology, distorting even historical facts and driving each individual to be hostile against other sides.…

    • 68 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, “When all news is ‘fake’, whom do we trust?” the author Ruth Marcus writes from an interesting point of view about the media. Her article provides no biasness and only gives facts about the media and the society at large. She leaves the begging question as to whether the media should or should not be trusted by the society to the reader of the article. She provides facts to support her article, the technique of the author’s delivery is established as formal.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Like the Nazi’s Joseph Goebbels, those within the U.S. government today understand propaganda intuitively, and it is used on a daily basis to sway public opinions on elections, support war engagement, and to further delude critical thinking skills from those who consume it. " Critics see the greatest failing of the modern corporate mass media as that it daily bombards its audience with facts, figures, and statistics, it rarely attempts to bring coherence or any meeting at all," stated journalist Jim Marrs, author of The Rise of the Fourth Reich (Marrs, 342). In a sense, the media would report the story, but only a fraction of the facts are released to the public. Regarding how consistent the media is, it is not designed to tell the public what to think, but rather subtly persuade them what occupies the back of the corridors of their minds. The public’s thoughts are filled with images of violence and how dangerous the World is.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Critical Overview # 1: Chomsky One common theme is Chomsky’s criticism of intellectuals and his interpretation of the basis for United States’ intervention. Chomsky argues that the basis that US intervention is largely based on strategic interests and that often intellectuals will perpetuate the idea the that pursing US interests is virtuous. Chomsky provides several valid critiques about the intellectual’s rule in supporting government propaganda and through their dismissal of those who criticize them. Although Chomsky rightfully accuses the United States for masking their pursuit of their interests in their mission to spread liberal ideals, he does not address the United States’ role in humanitarian intervention. In the face of massive human…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Media Bias Analysis

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Numerous media outlets ranted and raged over the immoral and political inappropriate acts for countless days. Due to the amount of coverage that these acts received, one has to wonder how the various news programs decided how to portray these stories and stories in general. The majority, if not all, of the news outlets use techniques called filtering, slant, framing and priming. By using these techniques the media and news stations can skew the story to their personal political allegiance. With the process of filtering, the media decides which stories to cover and which stories to neglect.…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chomsky analyzes the work of the media saying that there is a huge use of propaganda in the news and that broadcasts given to use is filtered by what the media thinks we need to know (Robinson, J). Chomsky looks at who is in charge and who has the authority to make the decisions and laws that decide how we as a society are able to function. The economic and political influences that are shown to society hold a great deal of guidance and power when it comes to who has the wealth and makes important decisions for our society. All decisions that society makes is something society as a whole believes the government would approve of. When it comes to understanding our society, the government and media hold the highest position when understanding what makes the world…

    • 1614 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In today’s society it seems as if the media is starting to take control of people’s ability to think for themselves. There have been multiple cases in which many news broadcasting stations have lied to their viewers in order to spread fear and confuse, when in reality nothing serious had happened. In today’s world there seems to be three reasons in which the media is causing harm in today’s growing society. One particular reason in which the media is causing harm is what many people like to call media bias, which is the practice of how many news journalist decide in which stories to cover and how they want to cover it. After knowing how media bias works, it leads to the second reason in which does the media report fairly and how the news lies…

    • 2167 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These institutions, backed by both the government and the banking industry, have an enormous scope, and can extend their message across the country efficiently and at a subsidized cost; in effect, they are the narrators of America. Narrators, real or fictional, control a rather significant ability: they can omit, add, equivocate or subtly alter any detail they wish, and these decisions impact the manner in which audiences perceive them. Should flak, politics, or controversial issues put their corporate interests at stake, the institutions use this power of selection to protect their own agendas, in addition to those of their allies, and to silence radical opponents. In his biographical documentary Manufacturing Consent: Noam Chomsky and the Media, Noam Chomsky, a major critic of corporate media, brings to fore the Indonesian occupation of East Timor and the resulting genocide, identifying it as a prime instance of the media’s agenda-specific selection system. This conflict received very little domestic attention across virtually all major outlets due to the United States government’s sponsorship of the Indonesian campaign; an inherently controversial and dangerous issue, corporate media chose to turn a blind eye in an effort to defend their ally - the government -,…

    • 1855 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays