Rhetorical Ethics

Improved Essays
The question of whether journalists or private philanthropists have a greater responsibility to rhetorical ethics requires an examination…? David Oliver Relin and Greg Mortenson’s Three Cups of Tea demonstrates the power of a private philanthropist in using emotional appeals and embellishments of truth to convince the public into giving money to a charity—in this case, the Central Asia Institute (CAI). On the other hand, an analysis of John Krakauer’s rhetoric in Three Cups of Deceit proves that investigative journalists, unlike private philanthropists, have a responsibility to truthfully represent events within their writing. The principles of journalism mandate ethical journalists to write based on factual information because there exists …show more content…
Credibility gives a journalist precedent with the public—people are more likely to believe a writer with an established reputation of factual reporting. Cuddy argues that prior to forming an opinion on the argument, the audience will decide whether the messenger is credible—“before people decide what they think of your message, they decide what they think of you” (Cuddy et al. 59). Powerful arguments are subverted by the character of the author—for instance, no matter the future content of his writing, nobody will take seriously the work of a journalist such as Stephen Glass, rising-star turned disgraced writer and failed lawyer (Grimminck). John Krakauer, author of exposés such as Three Cups of Deceit and Under the Banner of Heaven, contrasts with individuals such as Stephen Glass and demonstrates the importance of credibility. Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith, which examines the cult-like practices within the Christ of Latter-Day Saints and the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ Latter-Day Saints, was well received by critics, with the New York Times calling “almost every section of the book . . . fascinating in its own right” (Wright). An ethical journalist, therefore, has a responsibility to truthfully report on situations because existing credibility may be used to mislead the public. Krakauer’s precedent as a truthful writer partly contributed to the $17 million drop in donations to the Central Asia Institute in the two years following the publication of Three Cups of Deceit (Krakauer 104). A respected journalist holds a level of authority within his writing—because we believed him in the past, we tend to give the benefit of the doubt in the future. While Krakauer used his influence for a seemingly benevolent aim, unscrupulous journalists might not abide by an ethical

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Moliere 's Tartuffe, and Voltaire 's Candide are each praiseworthy abstract works of the eighteenth century in their own particular rights. Fraud is a sarcastic drama, and Candide a provocative travelog. While each sticks somberly to its type, different similitudes and also differentiating contrasts can be followed among the previously mentioned works. Composed amid the Age of Enlightenment, each of these works mirrors the belief system of the period and subsequently, has different likenesses. Firstly, each of these works commends reason over religion and the hypothesis that man is in charge of his own behavior.…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Media Bias

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This view point is intriguing as it shows a thought process behind those that are pro-source confidentiality. While this view point is illuminating, there is still the issue of credibility. The nation has passed the days in which people were able to take everything at face value, instead the population has become callous and distrusting of the information being published by media outlets. As a result, the media has the necessary obligation to be more transparent so as to enable the population to believe what is published by the agency. The media frequently calls of political transparency…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within this book Peter Schuck presents various predictions as to why government fails. Though he claims to be a moderate, bias appears in certain sections. In the introduction, Mr. Schuck speaks on the miraculous fact that our government has been “stable and durable” since the Civil War. He goes on to point out that even though the American government is sound compared to others, the American people do not believe in it. He then rattles off statistics showing how people are becoming more frustrated with the federal government and are trusting it less and less every year.…

    • 1619 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If systems like this are in place at a popular news outlet such as The Intercept , why are cases like Juan Thompson still occurring? The answer is simple, the editors are not verifying the work of the reporters. Like I stated , the cases before Thompson should have been a lesson learned and an example of the damage that can be done when employees are not attentive to what they are suppose to do. I would have done a lot of things differently if I was in power when the incident…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The difference in this article is that he goes onto explain the differences of Monarchies and how they would react to the notion of freedom of the press. Although Mr. Zenger completely supports Freedom of the Press, he feels that the press sometimes uses these instances to their advantage, just to sell paper. The people don’t always care about the truth, they just want to see what's going on. Mr. Zenger strongly feels that the press should thoroughly collect information before publishing content “and therefore very few good ministers can be hurt by falsehood.” While writing this Journal, I think his main focus was to tell his audience that what he was printing was not false and that all though he was tarnishing the reputation…

    • 1857 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is highlighted by how public relations practitioners lack the ability to create newsworthy stories, as mentioned by Charron (1989), “Journalists criticise PR practitioners in this sector for inundating them with uninteresting information” (Charron, 1989, p. 47). This is supported by Munro’s (2016) belief that a good journalist would only quickly glance and then throw away a media release, unless if it is interesting enough to research for an article. Public relations practitioners rely on the media to disseminate their message, and in order to ‘entice them’ it requires a media release to adhere to the media’s ‘rules’. The most important, is being knowledgeable about the rules of newsworthiness, which is achieved through knowing and applying the ‘news values’. These ‘big six’ news values are; proximity, significance, conflict, human interest, novelty and prominence (Masterton 1995, as cited in Lamble, 2013 p. 46), and they dictate what is and what is not news, this process could be seen as a ‘gate-keeper test’, whereby only if the media release passes this test, by meeting the criteria will it be disseminated to the…

    • 1027 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis The Economist is an excellent magazine that provides, report, and analyze news without prejudice. The Economist recently exposes the truth of post-truth politics that post-truth is not a fact and devolves on feeling and emotions and has bad effect on society today. Post-truth is mostly used in politics which is why The Economist wrote the “Yes, I’d lie to you: the post-truth world” to notify political news consumers to beware of post-truth politics. The author wants his or her readers to believe not to trust what they read on post-truth because post-truth is untrue. Some politicians use social media sites to engage with audiences; therefore, they say or write what they believe, feel, or think it is true even they do not have facts.…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Luntz’s focus groups the participants are asked to give their opinion on inheritance taxes, many of them didn’t have a good understanding of what it was. Even after having it explained to them, because it was presented as a “Death” tax they wanted it abolished. Despite the fact that they themselves would not likely be affected either way, the presentation of the tax lead them to lean in a direction that didn’t necessarily benefit them. To further expand on his theory that presentation is key to persuasion, Luntz rearranges the order of Ross Perot’s political ads. A man who was viewed as an inspirational rag-to-riches success story is now viewed in an unfavorable light.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Strategies: Argumentation: “The more often older adults were told that a given claim was false, the more likely they were to accept it as true after several days have passed.” Questions: Argumentation: The author of this article uses this technique to refer back to social experiments done in the past to prove his point about why many Trump supporters don’t see why some of Trump’s ideas are necessarily good nor beneficial to the country. This technique captures the author’s contemplative attitude towards the issue about Trump supporters not wanting to listen to some people’s reasoning when it comes to the discussion of politics because he introduces the topic with the description of an image about how a Trump supporter covered his ears in…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    To say that one does not see the consequences after reading the book would be an error. Goodall’s in-depth description of specific leaders does well to scare any leader into doing the right thing. However, the book seems a bit out of balance in telling the stories of faithful leaders who will and have finished well. The book is not void of such stories, but one could walk away from the book thinking they are doomed or that the task is too difficult. Therefore, I would recommend leaders learning from both unsuccessful men and successful men.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays