Cathy Davidson Classroom Makeover Analysis

Superior Essays
Class systems and social classes have always played a substantial role in society. The classes vary - from those born into a higher class to those that start at the bottom and work their way up or just stay at the bottom. Society splits itself based on the social status of individuals that today is essentially based off income. It has always been advantage and opportunity that has pushed people ahead in the ranks. In today’s American society, success seems to stand at the pedestal of priority. Parents expect it, pop culture inspires it, and children in the process, are pressured to stand one day at the top of this pedestal. For centuries, it has been up to our educational systems to make success a possibility for the future and upcoming generations. …show more content…
What happens to children who do not become lucky enough to ace a test and therefore be transferred to a better school? Should teachers be encouraged to teach students beyond their perceived capabilities? How might race influence the type of education one can receive? And as interesting as it would be to have all those questions answered, there aren’t any actual true answers to them because of how the education and social systems are set up. In an essay by Cathy Davidson titled “The Classroom Makeover”, she asks that educators must “unlearn” in order to construct new teaching methods that better engage and evaluate their students. In her essay, Davidson addresses the “one size fits all” model which is the educational construct where everyone is taught in the same way, under the same conditions, about the same subjects. It is a construct where educational systems have narrowed down the tested skills; have narrowed down their “attentions” to math and reading, thus discrediting students for having any outside specialties (Davidson 61). Relevance is also a key factor in boosting students’ attention spans and keeping them in school. When a pupil is able to tie what they learn in lessons to the world around them, absorbed information is able to fill another purpose other than for scoring high on tests. When these further purposes are acknowledged, students are more fascinated and engaged with the lessons. When they see how information can potentially have an impact on themselves; how lessons can be applied to their everyday lives, or even enrich and add on to their existing curiosities and interests, students want to pay attention. Classes are still very apparent in this present day. It’s easy to see what kids will and will not get ahead just based on how wealthy their family is

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In Cathy Davidson’s, “Project Classroom Makeover”, Davidson analyzes and elucidates upon faults she observes in the American education system. In particular, Davidson introduces her own experiment, the iPod experiment, in which she distributes free iPods to all first-year Duke University students and all other Duke University students who have the iPod incorporated in at least one of their classes. Through the experiment, the iPod upgraded itself by having its learning experience enhanced. Similarly, in Jonathan Lethem’s, “The Ecstasy of Influence: A Plagiarism”, Lethem argues that individuals who have successful ideas should allow up-and-coming artists to use their ideas and build on it to make a unique, albeit heavily inspired, invention.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What holds society’s social structure together? Man-made and ever-evolving institutions such as race, laws, gender, practices, and religion are foundational in human social life. Cathy Davidson analyzes the educational institution structure and call for transformation in her essay Project Classroom Makeover; she discusses how the customs of educating students impacts their future skillsets and current attitudes and also critiques the outdated hierarchical classroom paradigm for obstructing students from reaching their brightest potentials. Furthermore, Karen Armstrong in her selection Homo Religiosus writes about ancient through modern eastern religious practices and reflects on their cultural purposes and significance in human social life.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Cathy Davidson’s “Project Classroom Makeover,” Cathy discusses about how unlearning can lead for the positive change of education. Three example she uses to show unlearning are Duke’s introduction of the Ipods, the girl who had special abilities and talents, and lastly Inez Davidson’s unique classroom teaching styles. All these stories showcase that unlearning plays a huge role in education. Unlearning completely changes the way of how education functions and allows student to be more engaged into learning and create challenges that they have to think through. Duke and the iPod completely changed how an iPod could serve as a purpose to learn.…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    At the turn of the digital era, it is crucial for the educational system to acclimate and prepare students for new progressive career opportunities. In Cathy Davidson’s essay, “Project Classroom Makeover,” the use of personal, professional, and cultural anecdotes are used to strengthen her argument for the use of more innovative, collaborative, and technological teaching methods in the classroom. Davidson’s relevant organization and incorporation of the Duke iPod experiment and United States job market and educational history illustrate the need for educational renovation and greatly advance her claims. However, the second half of her essay complicates her main argument for digitalization and instead focuses on the need to replace the dehumanizing standardization of education and combining play into the classroom by focusing on children whose talents fall outside of the system’s norms and her mother-in-law’s outdated teaching methods. Davidson and other esteemed…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A crowd-sourced, collaborative education is a smart alternative to top-down learning, but it can easily become counterproductive. “Project Classroom Makeover” by Cathy Davidson showed the success of collaborative education with Apples Digital Campus. “The Naked Citadel” by Susan Faludi showed the destructiveness and failure of crowd-sourced education at The Citadel. In the case where crowd-sourcing failed, it was because of a lack of supervision. When crowd-sourcing succeeded, a professor was involved from the beginning.…

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As individuals, we are taught that we are the same and can become anything we want in life. However, people are not taught that they are born with some advantages and disadvantages that are due to their class. Class is the system and structure of organizing a society, in which people are divided into groups based on their social or economic status. Classes have been in society since early 19th century and was established by western Europe. (Britannica).…

    • 1939 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cutting Edge Classrooms In Cathy Davidson’s piece “Project Classroom Makeover”, she voices her concerns about the lack of quality of todays education system. She thinks that America’s classrooms haven’t evolved enough to prepare students for our advanced society full of new challenges and networking. She argues that by adding more game play into curriculum, learning could become more engaging and interactive for the young students of the twenty-first century. Games are a way to add a whole new level of interaction in the classroom.…

    • 1531 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The education system in the United States, since 2001 when the “no child left behind” act was passed, has moved to much less wholistic version of education. This issue is presented in “The Essentials of a Good Education,” by Diane Ravitch. In this article Ravitch presents many thought provoking points about the importance of looking at students as people rather than numbers. The author argues that since 2001, schools have been focusing more on the scores their students receive on standardized tests and less on how much students are actually learning. The author establishes credibility very early, and maintains it by presenting facts and using a professional tone.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Paul Fussell wrote, Class a Guide through the American Status System in 1983. Fussell introduces interesting points that perceives how we, as Americans are viewed through social class. This book will have you contemplate about where you fall in line in terms of the social hierarchy system. As I read, the Class guide I analyzed how our social status reveals itself and not just in terms of money, but other significant contributions that defines us as humans. We have socially categorized as humans, our commonality extinction is to make assumptions about the people around us or label them.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Class in America - 2012,” by Gregory Mantsios, explores class in the Modern Day United States and its effects on individual accomplishments. Mr. Mantsios believes that the classes of America can be divided into three categories: The ultra wealthy, the working class, and the poor. However, this is simply not the case. On the upper end of the spectrum, there is a capitalist class of people in between the ultra wealthy and the working class. On the lower end of the spectrum, there is a class of people wedged between the ultra poor and the middle class.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 2005, according to The New York Times article “Shadowy Lines That Still Divide”, biographers, Janny Scott and David Leonhardt discuss the effects of class divisions. Biographer Scott says, “class is one way societies sort themselves out… classes are groups of people with similar economic and social political position; people who, for that reason, may share political attitudes, lifestyles, consumption patterns, cultural interests and opportunities to get ahead” (Scott). This draws confusion to the issue because America is losing class, yet social class is important to America. Americans care about where they stand economically and socially in society. It’s a problem we are facing.…

    • 1643 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Gregory Mantsios’s “Class in America” he discusses the myths and realities of class differentiation. One thing he jumps into in the beginning of his essay is that Americans don’t prefer to talk about social class. Some people have even stated that they dislike using the word ‘class’ or ‘upper-class’ due to the reason that they believe it mows down their fortune and responsibility. Even though some Americans are concentrated on class identification Mantsios writes that most people aren’t aware of their actions to avoid this subject, this may be because of the fact that “…Class identity has been stripped from popular culture” (Mantsios, 282). It is now deemed ‘un-American’ to even compare certain issues with classes.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social class in America is an uncomfortable subject for many Americans; most believe that America is an essentially middle-class nation, however, author Gregory Mantsios argues otherwise. In this article, I will break apart “Class in America-2012” and explain how it creates a persuasive effect on readers. Mantsios accomplishes this effect by debunking popular myths through statistical evidence and providing real-life examples. This analysis will only provide the author’s opinions, and not my own, as to remain objective and fair throughout. Is the social class divide in America as large as most Americans think?…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introductory Paragraph This essay will do the following; demonstrate how the agents of socialization limit our choices, how commercial media can influence our views on our community, and the power of cultivation. I will also analyze how the media’s portrayal of different ethnic groups can sway our opinions about them. In this essay I will give several examples of the mean world syndrome and how it can affect us in our daily lives. Limits on Our Choices We are always making decisions.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social class is defined as a division of society based on social and economical status. In other words the relevance of your family’s name(brand) and the amount of revenue you bring in yearly give you advantage over those below your status. Class consciousness has been an issue in which generations have turned there head to avoid over the decades but while it may not be the topic of discussion it is a major issue and concern in communities, churches, college campuses, and even within families. The longer we let the topic go on , without the board discussion it deserves the more oblivious it will be to the world. This is a topic of equality and opportunity but this will teach the life lesson of humbleness a trait in which we as the people need to impute into our future youth with such disasters going on in today’s society.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays