Rhetorical Analysis Of Mary Shelley's Speech

Improved Essays
energy to persuade Captain Robert Walton’s crew to complete their mission. Frankenstein’s speech contradicts his previous dangerously ambitious and irresponsible actions. His speech promotes heroics and sublimity, two major values of the Romantic poet. Reading Frankenstein as a criticism of the Romantic poets who surrounded Mary Shelley, Frankenstein is a failed Romantic who takes Shelley’s contemporaries’ ideals too far. Shelley highlights the hypocrisy of this failed Romantic through Frankenstein’s uncharacteristic and ironic rhetoric and through his contradictory ideals attached to a changing landscape.
While Frankenstein’s speech values the heroic ambitions of the Romantic poets, he uses the same manipulative rhetoric as the Creature to do so, exemplifying Shelley’s warning about the limits of the Romantic poet. Frankenstein’s progression from rhetorical questions about heroics to the imperative tense convince even Walton, who does not notice the contradictions between Frankenstein’s previous account of his irresponsibility
…show more content…
Much of Mary Shelley’s original Frankenstein, however, has been manipulated by an external influence. As Bette London highlights in her essay “Mary Shelley, Frankenstein, and the Spectacle of Masculinity,” Percy Shelley modifies Mary Shelley’s straightforward prose into the ornate phrases which seem embellished to the contemporary reader (401). The Creature’s effect on Frankenstein’s rhetoric could therefore be allegorical to Percy Shelley’s effect on Mary Shelley’s writing, although Victor Frankenstein is often interpreted as a proxy for Percy Shelley (London 392). Regardless, Mary Shelley did not approve of Frankenstein’s rhetoric, and the irony in Percy Shelley’s manipulation of Frankenstein further supports her criticism of the Romantic

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Bates writes in his article that “Satire is satire not only because it attacks absurdity and vice but also because it alerts us to the incongruities inherent in a poet’s gesture of setting himself apart as an authoritative moral observer” (245). This is true in Wyatt’s poems because he incorporates his personal experiences. Thus, a possible reason many find his satire unintentional. Dolven meets halfway, and firmly believes, “Wyatt did not know what he was doing and that the something we are getting at has everything to do with style” (86). As much as I want to disagree, I see Dolven’s point.…

    • 1740 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, an under lying subtext is “society’s valorization of beautiful” (Fredricks). The creature in this story is ostracized because of its appearance and the only place he is safe and can voice his struggle is in sublime settings. John Keats wrote odes and other poems that emphasized beauty and the experiences humans go through. As a man who suffered from total deafness, his love for mankind, gave him the power to continue writing. This passion can be seen in his poem When I Have Fears, “Never have relish in the faerie power.…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The diction of this poem is critical in conjunction to Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein. Diction not only embodies mutability, but it questions the action which change can bring within humans. While Victor Frankenstein is reluctant to create a new creature, the change which he brings does not correspond with his initial goal of glory. Thus, the embodiment and acceptation of mutability through mutability costs Frankenstein and his Monster a great deal of grief. The change which he brings frightens him.…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sonnet 130 for instance is quite obvious in its satirical approach to subverting the conventional Elizabethan love poetry. In the sonnet Shakespeare completely and obviously opposes the usual approach to such a sonnet, instead of focusing on anything that makes her beautiful Shakespeare emphasizes her flaws from the first line; “my mistress’ eyes are nothing like the sun”(Greenblatt,1184). This sonnet breaks the important convention of flattering the speaker’s beloved. This approach to the sonnet can be described as an aggressive satire, as Shakespeare mocks not only the expected format of a love sonnet but also those that write in such a form, making the declarations of love written by his fellow poets seem shallow and false. In his radical opposition of falsely flattering the desired subject Shakespeare resists the idea that beauty is the be all and end all in love, the speaker states instead that a true and lasting love should not be affected by beauty, that he still desires his beloved in spite of her flaws.…

    • 1942 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shaw himself was anti-romantic by nature. The principle objection raised by Shaw against romantic literature is that it deals with imaginary ideas and artificial emotions. So, Shaw decidedly and intentionally wrote the play Arms and the Man in his innovative design of anti-romantic comedy. In Arms and the Man, Shaw wittily, humorously and critically exposes the hollowness of romantic and emotional concept of war, love and…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Florence Milner also observes this and notes that “The Duchess’s song to the pig baby is an absurdity in itself, but a much greater one when contrasted with its serious parallel.” (14). There is no doubt that this parody serves to question Romanticism in the same way that his parody of Watts served to question Puritanism. In this instance, Carroll again introduces violence to what was once a peaceful work, thus mirroring the violence and chaos of the events unfolding around the Duchess and the baby. In addition, the subversion of the original themes of gentleness and caring aims to make a mockery of Romantic ideals. Carroll’s spoof of this poem offers an equal but opposite extreme to the Romantic idea of unconditional love and caring for a child, thus highlighting the extreme nature of the original work which may have gone unnoticed by readers beforehand.…

    • 1379 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the early stage of the story, Dorian reveals his wish to trade his soul for containing the beautiful and innocent visage of him for eternity; his paranoid addiction of surface beauty distorts his moral values and drives him to be a villain who care nothing but to maintain his appearance. As the major turning point of his life, Sibyl Vane’s suicide strongly affects Dorian life and displays his nature indecency of credulity and irresponsibility that foreshadows continuation of decadency of soul. Serving the role as a moral book, the novel The Picture of Dorian Gray teaches readers to live in a positive, good and moral life rather than allows defects such as excess pleasures, covets, and naivety to impact the bright future. Life is one’s own life and it is one’s decision of whether or not listen to someone else’s opinions; instead of blaming to people around, one should take the responsibility of their own. By studying literatures that represent and demonstrate certain morality, the readers can feel the profound literary accomplishment of the authors as well as be taught of certain moral lessons that will be beneficial for…

    • 1307 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    His passionate love goes against everything being taught as his emotions seek to disrupt the balance of marriage which is valued so highly. This Renaissance art can be said to depict the most negative themes in Petrarch’s poetry, those that love leads to shame and pain, instead of focusing on the beauty and passion that true love can…

    • 1786 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout the play, Hamlet strives to separate his noble qualities from surrounding corruption and misfortune; however, his overall persona is notably diseased by his melancholy and mania. He proclaims, “But I am pigeon-livered and lack gall” (II.ii.554). Hamlet’s compromised will eventually overpowers his disposition, and his reference to a dove implies that he has no capacity to feel resentment or to seek revenge. His lack of response could represent a deficiency in the “humour responsible for generating … bitter and rancorous feelings” (Levy 85). This diseased will presents a dichotomy between the corruption of powers and Hamlet’s quest for revenge.…

    • 1520 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The effects of morality are also depicted on his main character, Dorian Gray. In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, the reader is introduced to this conflict in a more conventional means, instead, describing good with an element of divinity. Shelley also uses her main character, Victor Frankenstein, to present a divine purpose of morality, as well as the effect that morality has on one’s character. In both The…

    • 1493 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays