Women Suffrage And Black Suffrage Summary

Good Essays
Dudden, Faye E. Fighting Chance: The Struggle over Women Suffrage and Black Suffrage in Reconstruction America. New York: Oxford University Press, 2014.

1. Thesis: Dudden argues the feminists of the Reconstruction Era saw an opening for women 's suffrage when coming abolition of slavery and black suffrage. Dudden 's book is the tale of black and women suffrage movements finding ways to coexist and ultimately fighting against one and other.

2. Themes: 1. The first theme of the book is teamwork; the main team being Anthony and Stanton. Dudden places a lot of emphasis on how the few key players she uses team up, for and against each other, under the guises of political movement groups. Dudden shows how alliances could break or make a movement.
…show more content…
The book begins with an introduction, introducing us to many of the key players in the book followed by an explanation of how the book is written and why. (Few key characters in a short period of history). The book is then followed by seven chapters and a conclusion. Each chapter begins a new era in the struggle for both suffrage movements beginning in the 1850 's and ending in 1869. The first chapter, The age is ripe for the women question, begins the quest of defining what role women reformers wanted to play, and what their goals should be focused on. Anthony ultimately decides that the vote should be primary goal, but Dudden does touch on some other subjects that get placed on the back burner, such as sexual autonomy, legal and property rights. Chapter two, Black Rights, Women 's Rights, and Civil, focuses on our two key players, Anthony and Stanton, taking a step and fighting for the end of slavery, because as Dudden reveals, Anthony believed that their efforts in the war would benefit both women and black (male) suffrage in the end (60). In Chapter three, The Negro 's Hour, new lines are drawn as Wendell Phillips introduces his "Negro Hour" theory. This theory will ultimately divide Phillips and Anthony for the remainder of the text and will also place Anthony in a subordinate role to Phillips because he holds the purse strings to the Hovey Fund. In chapter four, The Struggle for Equal …show more content…
Throughout the book, there were typographical errors such as misspellings (139) and omitted words (14). This did not do much to damage the entire story, but I felt it did weaken my opinion. Another weakness is Dudden 's bibliographical choices. While her varied and long bibliography allowed for a vivid tale to be told, I found a lot of her sources to be primarily focused on women 's suffrage, rather than having an equal amount on both movements. I feel this lends her story to be more of how the black suffrage movement "beat" the women 's suffrage movement. She also used the term "black (male)" suffrage a lot. I feel that she could have clarified once that "black suffrage" meant black male

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    This is why black feminism is so important for the black women of today, because it gives them a chance to be who they are without conforming to the ideals of others. It gives them their own set of ideals to live by, a unique voice that speaks from their viewpoint, regardless of sexual identity, ableness, or even class. In order to resolve such an issue where black feminism has lost it’s popularity over the years, bigger movements should start to take action by doing more in the name of black feminism and promoting its ideals so that it can reach out to people beyond what it has not been able to reach…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Feminism In The 1800s

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages

    With the help of Anthony, Stanton was able to push revisions in legislation in 1860 to protect the rights and interests of women (Gordon). Stanton also helped organize one of the most influential events for 19th-century feminism- the Seneca Falls Convention (Gordon). Once the Civil War began and the country needed to focus more on survival and less on social issues, Stanton helped organize reconstruction in the North and allowed women to be more involved in the war through the Women 's…

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The connections they made, their experience gained, and the sense of empowerment they gained by taking political action allowed them to fight for abolition for African Americans, as well as for the equal treatment of women in society. The act of women fighting for suffrage would lead to the feminist movements that took place. Some of the themes of these movements were self-realization that they were being treated unfairly, the realization that they wanted to participate in the market revolution, which was he expansion of the market place in the early 19th century, and the use of the slavery of sex analogy, which compared slavery to a woman that is married and not treated as an equal. The document, Margaret Fuller's "Woman in the Nineteenth Century" (1845), outlines some of these as Margaret Fuller explained that American women were not enjoying the blessings of American freedom. They were being denied the vote, legally subordinate to their husbands, and lacking basic legal…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the article “The Cult of True Womanhood” by Barbara Welter, she analyzes true woman hood and how society portrayed a so called ideal woman in the nineteen century. In the second article, “Women and the Civil War by Teaching with primary sources” by MTSU, they spoke about the different roles women took on during the Civil War. In “Women and the American Civil War” by Elizabeth A. Novara, she exposes the many themes of women in different perspectives during the war. In the last article by Lesniak, Rhonda Goodman called “Expanding the Role of Women as Nurses During the American Civil War”, the author used documents such as letters and diary entries by women during the Civil War period to expose the many roles filled by women. The four books that I will include more information about are called “Battle scars : gender and sexuality in the American Civil War” by Catherine Clinton and Nina Silber in which the authors talked about women and men during the Civil War.…

    • 2164 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Green and King (2001) finds that the key to black women holding leadership positions, is back empowerment. Empowerment will help direct black women in the right career path, taking on challenges and knowing that their voice and opinions are more needed than ever. With black women having the state of mind to hold a place in leadership than to take a back seat, will help them overcome the disadvantage brought amongst people of color. Empowerment will also stop the trend of black women flowing below the labor market, and put them in the position as the breadwinner. Although all of these scholars have different point of views on the black women’s impact, they all involve advancement, and how to get there.…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    She contends a transcendent community is more of an idea than a reality. Chapter 3. Protofeminists and Liberation Limbos: Limbos bring attention to the racial-struggles of black women often ignored by mainstream discourse for current political struggles. James writes, “In their progressive, forward movement, contemporary black feminisms often bend backward toward historical protofeminist ancestors like abolitionist Maria W. Stewart [black self-defense], Ida B. Wells [anti-lynching campaigns], and Ella Baker [sexual and racial exploitation experienced by black female domestic workers].…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Feminism sprung out in America every time the race issue begun to be the political heated topic. Before Elizabeth met in Seneca Falls, the most prominent feminist was Sojourner Truth. She argued that she is not a woman because she did the backbreaking workmen did when she was a slave (Hooks). The political uproar of the slavery abolitionist movement gave birth to the women 's movement because it was at an antislavery convention that Elizabeth decided to fight for women. The second feminist movement was inspired by the black race fight for equality in the civil right movement (Untold Women Who Changed the World | The Great Feminist Movement).…

    • 878 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    First-Wave feminism was a period in time that focused on legal issues pertaining to women. This was a moment in the late 19th century and early 20th century that worked hard to gain the right for women to vote also known as women’s suffrage (Professor Anderson). Although, this movement was for women it excluded women of color and labor workers. “Intersectional feminism makes an active efforts to include all women. It is anti-racism, anti-classism, anti-ableism, body-positive, inclusive of LGBTQ+ folks, and a celebration of all forms of gender expression” (Sathish…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Overview Of Feminism

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The next chapter of the feminism movements, centered on creating campaigns for women’s rights to gain political power. And currently, feminism movements are continuing to create paths for the freedom of women. In the article “A New Way to Empower Black Women”, author Joycelyn A. Wilson breaks down in six arguments, how traditional feminism has been unsuccessful for African-American women through the Critical Black Feminine Theory (CBFT). In the first…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    African American Sexuality

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages

    According to Beauvoir, “[T]here are deep similarities between the situation of woman and that of the Negro. Both are being emancipated today from a like paternalism, and the former master class wishes to ‘keep them in their place’” (Beauvoir 1949, 259). That is to say, both African Americans and women have been emancipated from similar consequences. The fact that Beauvoir is comparing feminism with racism is not only “minimizes the impact that [slavery] has had on all black [people] in America” but also “minimize sexist oppression of black women” (hooks 1981, 52). hooks reminds us that, no two significant historical events should be compared to or forced to compete with each other, regarding the terrorizing activities that took place.…

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays