Essentialist Approach To Homosexuality

Improved Essays
Those who ascribe to the essentialist approach to sexuality conceptually believe in an ahistorical, acultural, and presocial understanding of sexuality; that sexuality has been a consistent, unchanging reality or essence shared among the members of human civilization (Seidman 26). Typically, sexuality essentialists’ base their belief in biomedical arguments -- citing studies that attest to how genes, hormones, and other biological developmental parts of the human body create a fixed desire for heterosexual sexual interactions which trumps any extraneous background variables. This implies that there is factual causation for homosexaulity primarily due to biological abnormalities within homosexuals. Essentialism isn’t limited to those who identify …show more content…
In general social constructionism is understood as the practice of knowledge that establishes realities as socially constructed by humans in our interactions with one another. Unlike sexuality essentialists, social constructionists do not believe anyone is born with any predisposition toward a particular sexual preferences. Instead, they believe that sociohistorical contexts -- or the environment, both material and socially constructed, one grows up in -- are instrumental in understanding how sexaulity is learned and then performed because society and politics are both responsible with shaping contemporary discourse around sexuality, regardless if this process happens over long stretches of time. Society is so much involved with shaping normative sexualities and enforcing stereotypes as social norms that it even has the power to pathologize other non-heteronormative sexaulties (Seidman 39). Social constructionists believe that predisposed love to only one sex is a false concept invented by modern Western society, and fails to accurately describe the development of human sexuality in non-Western cultures -- what, sociologist, Jeffrey Weeks explores in a chapter titled “The Invention of …show more content…
I could cite my curiosity of wanting a deeper understanding of the world around me, but I know that due to not having a stable sense of sexaulity or a preffered gender presentation when in primary school, arguments of biology, the bible, and other religious texts were not convincing. I recall a specific instance in middle school where I sat in the living room of my family’s apartment as President Obama delivered a speech in favor of marriage equality. Upon its ending, my mom, a devout Muslim and Afro-Palestinian immigrant, blurted, "Why do the gays need rights?" I remember telling her that she shouldn't be saying things like that, how it wasn't about personal opinions, and her responding, "Why does that matter? Are you one of the gays?” Her explicitly essentialist conflation of support of queer rights with identifying as queer only is the tip of the iceberg of instances that legitimize the spectrum and social influences of sexuality. For my parents, practices of Islam impacted their tolerance of homosexuality and narrow perception of sexuality. For my mother, specifically, living in a country where homosexuality was criminal, Western embracement of queer hood was equally perplexing as it was sinful to her. Therefore, upon entering university

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In Koppelman’s (2014) book Understanding Human Differences: Multicultural Education for a Diverse America, one chapter specifically deals with the controversial issue of sexuality and its role in this society. Koppelman explains how the idea of homosexuality was typically regarded as immoral and unacceptable. There was a build up of personal discrimination and homophobia based on homosexuality misunderstandings. In recent times however, there has been more acceptance, tolerance, and knowledge of it. Moreover, there has been information on the intricacies concerning sexual orientations—even enforcing policies to encourage equal rights.…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The constructionist views of gender and sexuality is the way an individual is born either male or female. With this in mind the constructionist view gender as a social structure and acknowledge that masculinity and femininity as one way of classifying individuals, but they realize that each society and each past society’s time period differs when it comes to defining masculinity and femininity (Ferris, p.246). The constructionist view has changed the way society identity’s an individual because they do not only look at their sex but other contributing factors like other theories. Some of the other theories are the functionalist theory, the conflict theory, and the symbolic interactionist theory.…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    At the height of the AIDS epidemic, a melding of revolutionary ambitions and homophobic misrepresentations give rise to the empowerment of Queer Authors to challenge and shift the heteronormative systems of society (“Queer Histories”). Leo Bersani and Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick are two queer Authors who have impacted the public and academic structures of knowledge during this crisis. Examining Bersani’s “Is the Rectum a Grave?” and Sedgwick’s “Epistemology of the Closet,” both are positioned towards different audiences and found to converge and diverge from each other in the historically contingent need for justification of homosexual identity during the AIDS crisis, to the queering of social constructions for acceptance. Beginning in 1981, the…

    • 1537 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Biological essentialism is an ineffective method to studying sexuality and gendered relationships because it does not consider the social, familial, and politically imposed regulations and roles on the individual that have influenced his/her sexuality. The culture of poverty theory fails to examine the aspects of racism and prejudice while condemning an individual of an ethnic marginalized community for perpetuating poverty. Psychotherapeutic literature attempts to explain the actions of an individual by diagnosing him/her with a physical malfunction rather than addressing the circumstances that the individual was raised and socialized into.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Starting with functional theory, sexual identity is “learned in the family and other social institutions, with deviant sexual identities contributing to social disorder”. Under conflict theory, individuals or specific institutions consider some forms of sexual behavior desirable therefore enforce heterosexism; while symbolic interaction theory views it as “socially constructed when people learn the sexual scripts produced in society” (Andersen,…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gayle Rubin's Analysis

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Gayle Rubin connects the usage of sex with political agents such as racism, war, caste systems, and immigration that encourages repression, oppression, and produces assumed dominance in modern Western society. Rubin analyses today’s cultural stance on sexuality by exposing the hypocrisy that holds anyone of different sexual orientations or leanings as inferior. Rubin feels that it is time to address sexuality in a time where it is embellished and there is much debate over sexual evaluation as it relates to acts and religion. Her work can be best divided into the specific claims she argues for or against as they relate to feminism and western culture’s take on sexuality in the modern era. It is obvious that the title of the article should…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Before entering the course I had a mediocre level of understanding about women and gender issues. I understood that women and men were viewed in different ways. This difference created issues for women such as the unequal pay gap in the United States. The material presented to me throughout the course has aided me in seeing the vast amount of issues women face in their daily lives and the complexity of these issues. It has changed my perspective to viewing the issues through a wider lens, which take into account every part of the complex issues facing women in today’s society.…

    • 2013 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social Construction

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages

    To understand how sexuality is socially constructed, one must understand how men are constructed as men, and women are constructed as women, by looking at the social construction of sex and gender, the exact qualifications of which despite having evolved over years, remain largely unchanged. Such qualifications, despite clarifying one’s role and creating a place for one in society, also ensures that one “could easily lose all that he had carefully built up if he did not take steps to safeguard it” (Garb, 60). In the nineteenth Century, the typical man was expected to behave in one of two ways. The bourgeois man was expected to be “dark, hairy, dry, hot and impetuous” and “demonstrate deep voices, a developed musculature, a ruddy complexion, a beard and possess the qualities of courage and generosity” (Garb, 60). The working-class possessed “taut muscularity, elongated arms and sinewy torsos” and used “their bodies to earn their livelihood” (Garb, 68).…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Axiomatic Sedgwick’s “Axiomatic” introduces the reader to the argument that one must understand analyses of the definition of sexuality and romantic attractions in order to understand facets of contemporary Western culture. The author opens her introduction by discussing how the identity of a homo- or hetero-sexuality has always existed and how it affects other supposed binaries across a variety of cultures. Sedgwick laid out seven ideas which she held to be self-evident truths about anti-homophobic analysis. I had not previously heard of some of these concepts, but nonetheless can make sense of them. I interpreted the first axiom as bringing up a critical idea of present equality movements: intersectionality.…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People question why homosexuality persists even if it does not offer reproductive values, which is a critical feature in natural selection. Evolutionary theorists explain this by the idea of “inclusive fitness”: the reproductive success of oneself and one’s close relatives (DeLamater&Hyde, 1998). Homosexual men and women contribute to their siblings’ and other close relatives’ successful reproduction by providing necessary support and resources as a way of passing some of their genes down, including same-sex sexual orientation. Consequently, the “gay gene” is maintained and passed down from kin selection. Evolutionary biology strongly suggests that some people have predisposed gay genes from past…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Homosexuality is a constant topic in the media and is always being shunned with religious motives in both past and present. In recent news, politicians in some states are aiming for the criminalization of homosexuality while others are passing legislation for the recognition of same-sex marriages. Michael Levin presents a purely scientific and secular argument against homosexuality and homosexual marriages in his work “Why Homosexuality is Abnormal.” Michael Levin addresses the debate question: “Is homosexuality abnormal?” His position on the debate is affirmative.…

    • 1640 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From a very young age we are taught the “sexual scripts” (pg. 313) that we are expected to follow and this largely dictates how we feel we should conduct our intimate relationships. Sexual scripts in many societies are largely “heteropatriarcical” meaning they are based on a system of heterosexual male dominance (pg. 354). Tight control over what is sexually acceptable can be harmful for the development of healthy intimate relationships especially for those who do not fall within the traditional heterosexual gender binary. A young American female receives mixed messages about her sexuality every day. In her article The Cult of Virginity author Jessica Valenti says that, “present-day American society- whether through pop culture, religion, or institutions –conflates sexuality and morality constantly” (pg. 336).…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A) Gayle Rubin’s “sex hierarchy: the charmed circle vs. the outer limits” is a chart that displays society’s view on what is correct and incorrect sexual practice. The inner part of the circle is what is seen as “normal” sex while the outer circle is deemed “abnormal” or bad sex. The inner and outer circle categories are polar opposites of one another treating sexuality in black and white terms that states that there is only one proper way to have sex. This approved form of sex takes form as a heterosexual, monogamous, married couple of the same age who only have sex with only their own bodies in a private place to make children by means of vanilla sex, this practice is without any porn, toys or money for service transactions. Any sexual practice that differs from this ideology is considered to wrong, sinful, and unnatural.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Essay On Heteronormativity

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The dominance of heteronormativity facilitates protection for those whom assimilate into its culture of binary masculinity and femininity; yet, it also necessitates a disruption of such a status quo, seen in the development of queer theory -- queer embodying identities incompatible with heterosexuality, such as lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender; and, theory critiquing connections…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Heterosexuality

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In many of today’s societies, heterosexuality is seen as natural and superior to its opposite of non-heterosexuality. Willis (2007) states that “oppositional and hierarchical concepts of sex and gender are crucial for making heterosexuality appear as the dominant and ‘natural’ configuration” (p. 185). Placing heterosexuality as the norm discriminates against anyone who doesn’t quite fit into that category. However, without the presence of non-heterosexual categories, the concept of heterosexuality would not exist. Hicks (2008) describes that “ simply pointing out that someone is heterosexual, however, draws upon and reminds us that other possibilities are present” (p. 67).…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays