Essay On Performing Lobotomies

Improved Essays
The first group of institutions were smaller and focused more on offering individualized care, while having good intentions. Since the first documented insane asylum, there have been specific treatments and medicines used for the mentally ill. The standard medicine given to mentally ill patients included performing lobotomies, electroconvulsive therapy, bloodletting, etc. Many of these cruel treatments were no longer being performed at institutions since they were dangerous and had mixed results. For example, lobotomies, or prefrontal leucotomy, were used as a therapeutic measure to assist disturbed patients with schizophrenia, manic depression, bipolar disorders, and other mental and physical conditions. The idea of performing lobotomies was taken from a similar experiment performed on two monkeys named Becky and Lucy. Dr. John Fulton and Dr. …show more content…
After discontinuing the performance of standardized surgeries, institutions adopted the use of drugs and other treatments. Asylums changed from only treating patients to then housing them. Research shows that certain interactions between a person with a mental illness and their family can either improve or worsen their mental illness. As the general population grew, so did the number of the mentally ill. This growth in population resulted in crowded institutions, which prompted the need for bigger facilities. The population in institutions created problems for the faculty and patients, such as terrible living conditions and patients were regularly abused and neglected. The mentally ill patients in these institutions were treated like animals most of the time. Patients were allowed little movement within these cells and nobody knows if the patients were sufficiently fed. In most institutions, rooms were never cleaned and patients were forced to sit amongst their own trash and waste. These conditions were common in asylums around the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In November of 1941, Rosemary Kennedy, was ordered by her father to receive a surgery that was said to be life changing. It was called the lobotomy. The Kennedy Family was immediately skeptical of such a surgery, and came to a conclusion that it was not what they wanted for Rosemary. But their opinion and rejection to the procedure was all in vain. Joe Kennedy ordered the lobotomy to be done immediately, without his family knowing.…

    • 2859 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lobotomy Research Paper

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Since this study was only on one particular person, it is hard to form an opinion on the procedure. There are so many things that could have factored in regarding his effects afterwards. That being said, lobotomy still is never an ideal situation is why it is not practiced in this way as treatment today. Like you have mentioned in class, it is much more targeted today, done by a specialist, and much less barbaric. Because this study was done several years ago, I wonder what the results would have been like if they did not perform lobotomy and just treated the patient with medicine and therapy instead.…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Overview of 19th/20th Century Asylums: After 1808, parliament approved public financed hospitals for the mentally ill public, and 20 were assembled. Following 1845 it got to be obligatory for areas to construct asylums, and a Lunacy Commission was set up to screen them . Before the centuries over there were upwards of 120 new lunacy hospitals in England and Wales, lodging more than 100,000 individuals . “Ground plan of Tone Vale Hospital, Bishops Lydeard” -Feb 1947 Sympathy toward the affliction from what was considered dysfunctional behaviour steadily expanded and was especially grasped in the social and political approach of the Victorian time. District asylums were the proposal of a House of Commons select advisory group, which had…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This has created new problems that have never happened before. In the late nineteenth century, Dorothea Dix and Reverend Louis Dwight had a campaign that got a lot of the mentally ill out of prison. Because of this campaign, there were mentally ill hospitals everywhere, and the numbers of confined people with mental illness sharply declined. However, there was a lot of abuse within mental institutions and a lot of involuntary imprisonment of people. When antipsychotic medications were established, it showed great promise; however, the drug was overused and this resulted in horrific treatment protocols.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout their sentence, prison inmates endured miserable life before and during the Prison Reform Movement of 1800’s, unlivable conditions, and physical abuse from the guards. “Men rarely become spiritually better by being made subject, through human discipline, to extreme bodily discomforts; these convicts are not made morally better by such treatment as they are subjected to here in the days of bodily weakness and pain” (Lightner 56). Prison Reform Movement from 1870-1930, greatly changed what type of treatment that was acceptable in prisons towards the inmates, much of these changes were due to the effort of Dorothy Dix and her efforts to investigate the prisons. When prisons first formed, people weren’t exactly sure how they should go…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Transorbital Lobotomy

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Which led them to recommend the use of lobotomy of mentally ill soldiers who couldn’t be cured with other forms of treatment. This led to around 2,000 vets being treated with lobotomies (Lobotomy Files, 1). Freeman also introduced the use of transorbital lobotomy, urging that this form of lobotomy could be done by psychiatrists who were untrained to perform any type of surgery. To this day Freeman is seen as one of the most controversial figures in American medical history. During this time lobotomies were not entirely accepted by everyone.…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay On Magdalene Asylums

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Historically, people deemed socially unacceptable have been institutionalized. Institutions dehumanize the very people they intend to serve by denying their basic human rights and stifling their opportunities to contribute meaningfully to society. People living in these establishments receive no compassion or love and, as a result, live traumatized lives. Previously, people were placed in institutions or asylums based on race, religion, sexual orientation and other societal categories. Women were placed in the Magdalene Asylums for being sexually active or having impure thoughts.…

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Throughout time mental illness has been looked upon in numerous ways from people. The time period in history can tell us a lot about the ways people were living and how they believed behavior affected certain mental illnesses. In my writing I will describe a man who is mentally ill during the early 1700’s. I will also describe an African American in a Georgia asylum and also a middle-class woman in a water treatment spa in upstate New York. I will detail what each of these individuals does on a daily basis such as their hygiene, what kind of clothing they wear and also how the person may interact with others.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Based on the videos, the surgical procedure of lobotomy served to be a cornerstone and a significant medical advancement within the field of psychiatry during the 1940s. The growth of mental illness was dominant during the time period due to which lobotomy was seen as a form of cure and hope for patients suffering from different mental disorders. Egas Moniz, a psychiatrist first introduced the concept of lobotomy (Kring and Johnson 17) but the surgical procedure became a medical breakthrough due to the contributions of Walter Freeman who began to lobotomize individuals and patients suffering from depression, psychosis, dementia etc. (PBS.org). Lobotomy became a form of medical innovation as no other treatments or medications were available to patients or individuals that were secluded from the overall community and was seen to be critical in setting people free from their…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Foucault rightfully regards the appearance of the first asylums a significant step forward for the whole world. It meant that the medical community accepted psychological diseases as a medical problem and basically announced that it was going to try to treat it. Madness did not seem like some kind of curse or other superstitious phenomenon nobody knew what to do with anymore. This point is delivered well by the author in the first part of the article. When Faucault describes how the asylums treated their patients, he turns to the models proposed and implemented by Samuel Tuke and Phillippe Pinel: Tuke’s idea was to define madness as the opposite of reason and try to battle it with reason; Pinel thought that madness should be isolated from religious…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Larry Gostin addresses the many unethical justifications doctors have so they can continue to perform lobotomies on mental patients. Gostin discredits psychosurgery (surgical treatment for the chronically ill) as an efficient procedure that helps patients. He addresses the risks patients go through as a result of the way of practice of lobotomy is run. With continuous modifications to the procedure, there is no definite way of performing a lobotomy, leaving lobotomy to be more prone to mistakes, and the mistake of adopting lobotomy surgeries and performing them when little was known about the brain in the 1940 's. Gostin 's article confronts the medical community for using lobotomy procedures, "where many holes lie in the foundation of the surgery and the practice of it "(149). This article will be helpful for my literary review because although it addresses all the negative points surrounding lobotomy Gostin never once mentions it being a bad procedure, rather he mentions that lobotomy procedures are capable of change as long as we have knowledge about the brain and the right tools to keep the patient away from risk.…

    • 1609 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These drugs would help the patients by making life for them a bit easier and calming the patients. These drugs continued to advance. The asylums started to change how they were run and how they treated patients because it would help with the improvement of the mental health of their patients. The Friends Asylum was run by a lay staff unlike usual mental institutions that were run by medical doctors and nurses (D’Antonio 2). This was different because now some institutions stopped using medical science to help patients and started using the talking cure, and psychology.…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dorothea Dix Philosophy

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages

    By 1820, it had already been recognized that mental illness was illness, not sin or depravity, therefore, many institutions across the world had begun to free the mentally ill from excessive restraints and had also begun to establish the concept of humane treatment in institutions devoted to their care. Dix, however, perfected the idea and the new model of care became known as the moral treatment. The moral treatment consisted of removing mentally ill persons from a stressful environment and family conflicts and placing them under a rather benign but autocratic system of organized living. There were regular hours of habits, and the patients were kept occupied with crafts such as gardening and more. Everything was under the close supervision of a superintendent, a physician, and his word was law.…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Due to the fear of those who were insane during the middle ages, mentally ill patients were housed and confined in asylums (“Mental illness”). Those who suffered any type of mental illness were misunderstood and discriminated against. Cases in history and the facts that are present now show that these patients struggle with not only self-stigma but also social stigma (Corrigan, Patrick W., and Deepa Rao). To treat certain mental illnesses like schizophrenia, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and severe depression antipsychotics drugs are used. The problem is that they have numerous negative side affects, and pharmaceutical companies have not been able to make many advances in treating schizophrenia; furthermore, increase in suicide…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    According to Erving Goffman, if a person has attributes that not only make the person differ from other people, but may also be seen as “a less desirable kind”, we will not see him or her as a “discounted” person instead of a “usual” one. In Hong Kong, there is a nuance of communities being stigmatized – LGBT, physically handicapped people, ethnic minorities and more. In this paper, the stigmatization of mentally ill patients will be reviewed. Mental illness is a state in which influences one’s feelings, mood and thoughts. Statistics have shown there is a progressive increase in the number of in-patient discharges and death in Hospital Authority hospitals for mental and behavioral disorders from 2008 to 2012. Of all age groups, there is…

    • 1338 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays