“I see no alternative but to conclude that capital punishment cannot be justified on the basis of its deterrent effect” (Marshall,1972). Proving that is really is not a deterrence. Although one example of where capital punishment could be seen as an effective possible deterrent would be in The District of Columbia which has no death penalty has a very high rate of homicides. There are other deterrents to crime other than Capital Punishment, there is incarceration, fines, moral prohibitions and many others. One study, found that the elevated levels of assurance of arrest on crime lowered the burglary rate in Canada (Zedlewski, 1983).…
Specific Deterrence Specific deterrence is a method used in the criminal justice system to discourage convicted offenders, from reoffending, through the use of severe punishment. However, it can be argued that this is not an effective technique to deter criminals from repeating their offences. As demonstrated in D’Souza’s case, he was constantly involved in criminal activity throughout his adolescence, despite the severity of his punishment. Siegel & McCormick (2016) agree that the juvenile justice facilities have a minor effect on deterring youth from delinquent behaviour (p.146).…
However, this scheme fails to act as an effective deterrent, limiting its effectiveness in achieving this goal. This failure to deter future crime is further supported in the report, which states that “There is inconclusive evidence as to whether mandatory sentencing schemes achieve deterrence” This lack of deterrence to future crime is further illustrated in the with these regimes “not having a clear and directly attributable corresponding benefit in crime reduction” (ALRC Report). While mandatory minimum sentencing does not achieve adequate deterrence, it is a moderately…
There are numerous practices that are used in the criminal justice system. Professionals need to determine which theoretical approaches works best to help the system. Searching empirical studies and then utilizing that information can help determine the best theoretical practices. Correctional facilities should use different practices for restorative justice, crime prevention, and corrections to improve our criminal justice system. Defining different theoretical approaches can also improve rehabilitative services in correctional facilities.…
I want to talk about incarceration in America. In the wake of the Ferguson unrest, I feel that it might be useful to shed some light on the issues that are driving the anger and protests there. To be clear, I am not making any comments directly about Ferguson, Michael Brown, or the on-going investigation. I think it 'll be helpful to first state that we sadly need incarceration.…
Every year, millions of people in the United States go through the criminal justice system. This system at all levels of authority has numerous problems that it faces and provides equal punishments to those who break the law. When it comes to mandatory sentencing, many people take sides on what is considered fair and unfair. With the number of criminals rising each and every year, the justice system requires a well-balanced process for each individual case. With that being said, mandatory sentences are restrictions placed on judges when it comes to what kinds of punishment they can give to people accused of breaking the law.…
In fear of being subjected to the same punishment(s), people would deter themselves away from committing that crime. Specific deterrence focuses on a specific criminal, giving them a harsh punishment to reinforce the idea into the person’s mind that the crime is not allowed, and deter them from committing the crime, or similar ones,…
Notably in the United States, another way to oppress individuals, especially minorities is through the criminal justice system. The effects of the incarceration on this particular group is felt within the African American community; these individuals have adapted the mind set of not being able to trust anyone, especially the law since they are always targeted by police officers, who in actuality are given the power to protect and serve. African Americans’ not having the ability to fall back on the police force exemplifies why the police department needs to be redeveloped. Being that this is the career path that I wish to follow, my expectations that the police department should engage in- will be the policies.…
Incapacitation and deterrence are not successful reasons for prisons because they can make prisoners worse and be a factor in recidivism. Incapacitation is one of the two reasons why there are prisons. People are incarcerated to remove them from doing any further harm in society. However, by putting all of the people that have committed a crime together, it is only further nurturing criminal behaviors. When criminals get to prison, one of the first things they are asked is what they did to be put into prison.…
Abstract: Incapacitation or Deterrence? Is it really a matter of one or the other or is it the matter of properly using both stratagem for the efficient, and effective management of the criminal justice system in America? Furthermore, in a decade where the penal system seems to focus on strictly punishment I seek to discover if there is a better way. According to Todd Clear and Natasha Frost (2014) by the year 2002 the penal system of the United States had exceeded two million inmates.…
I personally feel tougher sentences do not necessarily mean deterrence, especially with drug offenders. I also feel habitual offenders that are serving life sentences for non-violent crimes never received the correct treatment for them to stop repeat offending. This has led to the overcrowding of our prisons and cutbacks to resources which makes it even harder for inmates to receive any kind of treatment they may need. We live in a county that leads the world in sentencing offenders to prison yet our crime rates haven't changed("Criminal Justice," 2017). A study conducted in 2009 by the top criminologists in the United States discovered 88% of their peers believed the death penalty which is the harshest sentence one can be given, did not…
Terrorism is a gigantic problem in our world today. The truth is, as big of a problem as it’s become; it is still one of the least understood topics in law enforcement. The research in this area is very controversial, and is widely disagreed upon by scholars, so I thought I’d take this time to apply some modern criminal deterrence theories to terrorism. One of the major problems with terrorism is that it’s not easily observed. The American Psychological Association states, “terrorists aren't likely to volunteer as experimental subjects, and examining their activities from afar can lead to erroneous conclusions.…
Deterrence is a concept that is central to lawmaking, it encourages lawmakers to create laws with punishments that discourage others from committing crimes. In this case, the court needs to send a message to society that citizens are unable to benefit from…
Before the classical era, punishment could consist of whipping, mutilation and public executions. Classical criminologist saw a problem with this and determined that the punishment should fit the crime and the punishments were to be proportional (Akers 2017). This means that the punishment could not be too lenient or too harsh and that individual difference did not matter, everyone shall have the same punishment. Proportionality was later taken out due to the consideration of child offenders and mentally incapacitated individuals (Akers et al, 2017). Akers et al, (2017) notes that the certainty of is more effective in deterring crime than the severity.…
In our society, it is important to control those who violate laws in order to keep the public safe. The criminal justice system is given this responsibility. Society relies on those in this system to effectively combat crime. This may sound simple, but many have debated how to efficiently fight crime for years. Two concepts that have been debated are the crime control model and the due process model.…