Chickering's Theory Of Identity Development Analysis

Great Essays
The Problem I Want to Solve

For the most part, the problem I want to solve has remained the same throughout the weeks. I am eager to manage and ultimately own a business in the interior decorating field. I aim for my business to inspire others with our decor and style. I want my employees to be able to create a beautiful space with whatever they are given, and I want my clients to be so happy with the results and make their house a place they are happy to call home. This is my plan, but I realize that plans change with circumstances. This week, our class focused on the idea of identity development. Chickering’s theory of identity development “remains arguably the most well known, widely used, and comprehensive model available for understanding
…show more content…
First, Rodriguez develops competence by figuring out what his obstacle is going to be. In his story, the obstacle was “institutional racism.” Then, he moves through the vector of managing his emotions by learning to respond appropriately to the emotions that face him. He states, “ I wish I as I write these things that I could be angry at those who mislabeled me” (p. 152). This shows that he is able to control his emotions. Rodriguez is then forced to move from autonomy toward interdependence. He moves away from reassurance, affection, and approval from parents, peers, and other social groups by accepting the things that he cannot change. He then develops mature interpersonal relationships with teachers and faculty, which in turn help him to establish his identity. None of his professors simply passed him, and none treated him with condescension. Rodriguez stated that, “The odd thing was that in the classroom teachers reminded me of both my public identity and power as a student of literature. But outside of class few were willing to recognize that I was, at best, paradoxically named a minority student” (p. 156). After establishing identity, Rodriguez develops purpose. He says, “In late summer, I decided to finish my dissertation and to accept a one-year teaching assignment at Berkeley” (p. 160). Later on, however, he develops integrity by balancing his …show more content…
In Hunger of Memory, Rodriguez states that “The very fact that I am in a position to apply for this job should make that clear” (p. 168). This quote is powerful because Rodriguez realizes that despite his differences, he is still worthy of great things. In the process of solving my problem, it is inevitable that I will face difficulties; however, it is important that I know that I am enough and that I am worthy of great things.
2. In the article, “Chickering admits that everyone develops at different rates. Although his theory focuses on the development of college students, some people may take longer to move through the vectors than others.” Moving through the vectors is the first step in solving my problem, so it is likely that I will be eager to get through them. However, I cannot get discouraged if I see other people moving through the vectors than me.
3. The “Establishing Identity” vector is dependent on the experience in the vectors that come before it—the competencies, emotions, confidence in one’s independence, and relationships all factor into identity development. Recently, I established my identity by ending a relationship. I was not confident in my independent, and I relied too heavily on someone else to make me happy. When I checked in with myself and found myself to actually be unhappy, I became very discouraged. I have heard many people say that college is the place to “find yourself,” and that 's what I strive to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    4- Where and how the change comes to Jose’s life? When Jose goes to college and takes many humanity classes, practices critical thinking and get introduced to race relations, he realizes that looking like a Latino or being a Latino doesn’t bother him anymore. He is neither proud nor ashamed of who he is. His racism toward himself has soothed.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Compared to the teachers who Rodriguez idolized, his parents seem shameful to him. Rodriguez’s father had a negative attitude toward education, despising “the trivialization of higher education, the inflated grades and cheapened diplomas, the half education that so often passed as mass education in my generation” while his mother wanted a close “Mexican styled family” (Rodriguez 522). However, unlike Leo, Himmler, and Griffin’s grandfather, Rodriguez did not follow his parents’ ways of thinking. Instead, his father’s negative attitude toward education and his mother’s desires of a close knitted family affected him in how he portrays his parents as uneducated people. In other words, Rodriguez did not become like his father and mother; he became the opposite, an admirer of education and an admirer of educated people.…

    • 1369 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Boots Villanueva Summary

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In Villanueva's “Bootstraps: From an Academic of Color” he talks about the challenges he faced when becoming a writer and how he overcome those challenges. In our everyday lives, we face many difficulties and obstacles that we have to overcome and surpass, Villanueva’s obstacle was when he decided to go to college, and he had to overcome and figure out why he was receiving bad grades on essays he wrote. We all have experienced similar issues to Villanueva's where we need to overcome an obstacle; a major part of life is overcoming and conquering those obstacles that we face. Growing up English was one of the hardest subjects I had; I met many teachers throughout the years of schooling I went through who didn’t accept creative minds or creativity…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Glenn Loury’s “Is He One of Us? Reflections on Identity and Authenticity,” Loury is addressing the Brown University Class of 2012 in its 2008 Opening Convocation. His objective for the speech is to encourages the students not to focus so much of their attention on their identity and others identity. He encourages them by sharing examples of the pitfalls he experienced and backs it up with excerpts from other notable essays. Even though Loury does not use much evidence in proving his point, the quality of the evidence makes this an effective convocation speech.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Life is a constant battle, a battle in which one characteristic can be the cause of a victorious ending or an ongoing defeat. Sometimes in life, a person's trait can be their greatest help and hindrance. In “Born Worker” by Gary Soto, main character Jose is a victim of this situation. Jose is a low-class boy of Hispanic descent which causes people to stereotype him. Jose has a cousin Arnie who is a middle-class boy.…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through this program, students are able to “develop a sense of who they are by exploring their identity within the context of various local, national, and…

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    Dr. Janice Hillard, PhD, LMHC “Whatever you do, work at it wholeheartedly as though you were doing it for the Lord and not merely for people” Collosians 3:23 Dr. Hillard is a female, African American, Christian, and Counselor Educator that has persisted through the rigor of doctoral studies, and is teaching Human Services – Mental Health Counseling program serving “nontraditional” learners. There are common themes surrounding success strategies, trends in the field, obstacles to avoid in academic and professional development, and general feedback that would regarding my current plans, that are supported by various peer reviewed journal articles. This discussion post is a summary of a very comprehensive dialogue regarding identity.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Brilliant Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The term identity is the fact of being who or what a person or thing is. Famous author, Nathaniel Hawthorne once said,“No man, for any considerable period, can wear one face to himself, and another to the multitude, without finally getting bewildered as to which may be the true” (367). This quote, from a well-known novel, The Scarlet Letter, brought to my attention the many identities people often create for the convenience of the people around them. This way, we as people can feel accepted or maybe even respected in a sense. We often feel the need to alter our characteristic qualities, but who we are as a person isn’t necessarily affected.…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I have always had a strong self as a teenager and do not recall going through an extended period of identity confusion. Identity confusion, however, became evident throughout my undergraduate years. I went through a period where I experienced identity diffusion, developed a sense of identity, lost it, then developed a new…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Vivienne Cass had created a theory of identity development which was developed in 1979. It consists of six stages that people will go through trying to identify themselves. The stages are identity confusion, identity comparison, identity tolerance, identity acceptance, identity pride and identity synthesis. Some people might go through a previous stage at different points in their lives. I believe I have gone through almost all of these stages.…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When discussing identity, there are many ways, shapes, and forms that your identity can be affected. One article found conducted a study on how identity development is affected through social interaction, action, and recognition. It also talks about many studies done on identity development. Education researchers have turned an eye towards the basis of attitudes and behaviors, but they are extremely complex and challenging to understand. An alternate view to figuring out and understanding behavior can be found through the examination of identity.…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Scholarship Boy Analysis

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Introductory Writing Assignment In the beginning of scholarship boy, Richard Rodriguez starts off lecturing young students whose minds easily become distracted except for one who remains alert and focused and in her of them he sees himself as a child and then begins to reminisce about his own childhood, and how he was a scholarship boy a student anxious and eager to learn but also imitative and unoriginal. Whenever anyone would say “Your parents must be very proud” or ask him how managed it his “success” he would give a quick answer then nod and smile. Although his siblings helped motivate him to become a better student by bringing home trophies that made him envious, as well as his parents would encourage him to do better however they account…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Greek system, active members of the chapter are noted as the foreground who help to influence and mold conceptions of self-identity in new and impressionable members and establish the groundwork for a life of prestige and elitism in their campus community. The search for identity is one of the most challenging issues that a college student will face. Often, the difficulty to precisely define individual identity is due to the fluidity and many multi-layered facets of identity. Personal contextual factors such as class, race, gender, religious affiliations, and sexuality are often used to help define and establish a sense of identity.…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The purpose of the present study was to review identity status-based theory and research with adolescents and emerging adults, with some coverage of related approaches such as narrative identity and identity style. This theoretical framework asks a fundamental question that is not when active consideration of identity issues begins, but rather when this first iteration of self-examination is resolved. A number of models have been introduced to describe and help explain the process of identity development from late adolescence through emerging adulthood. The results suggest the possibility that a coherent and well-organized sense of identity may facilitate illness-related coping and may protect against distress associated with chronic diseases. As a result the identity status model has withstood a number of criticisms and has given rise to contemporary conceptualizations that have cast identity as a dynamic, iterative process.…

    • 210 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is an individual’s identity development? Is it a person’s appearance, the home they live in, family, value, or beliefs? When is personality developed? All individuals have an identity and there is not one like the other. There are several different identities across the world.…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays