Compare And Contrast A Doll's House By Henrik Ibsen

Superior Essays
One never gets a second chance to make a first impression; whatever character is displayed is the one that will stick. Character itself is a strong factor towards judgement, swaying opinions and views based upon one’s self. Two individuals could be placed into the exact same situation: same time, same place, same action. Even if every detail in the event is identical, there will still be difference in judgement based upon the character of the individuals. This premise can be seen in Henrik Ibsen’s play, A Doll’s House. In Ibsen’s work, it is revealed that the protagonist Nora Helmer, and the antagonist Nils Krogstad, are facing the same challenges; however, the two undergo very different experiences from other characters throughout the play. …show more content…
Ibsen purposely writes one character as the protagonist of the play, and the other as the antagonist. Through input in dialogue from other characters in the play, Ibsen characterizes both Nora and Krogstad into their respective roles as the antagonist and protagonist. Focusing on Krogstad, it is clear that he is the antagonist of the story; nearly every character perceives him as an evil and immoral man. In example, in a conversation with Nora Helmer, Doctor Rank describes Krogstad as a man who “...suffers from a diseased moral character...”(1.15). Doctor Rank is not the only one who describes Krogstad like this; Torvald Helmer also goes into a rant about the immoral nature of Krogstad’s character, speaking on how he is destroying his family, and plays “the hypocrite with everyone...”(1.26). From the beginning of the play, Ibsen sets up Nils as an antagonist. He is created as the villain of the story, causing the reader to view him as such. Furthermore, his characterization can be seen in Nora’s actions and manner towards him, such as when she steps towards him and says “You?”; Ibsen pairs this short piece of dialogue with stage direction that directs Nora to speak in a strained, low voice(1.14). Through the tone created by Ibsen’s stage direction in this section of dialogue, it can be seen that Nora is …show more content…
However, it is through these similarities that a strong contrast can be seen within the societal view of the two individuals. In Ibsen’s play, Nora and Krogstad are both victims of the same crime: forgery of signatures. Additionally, one can see similarities within the motives of their actions. Both characters forged signatures with the desire to save their loved ones, as seen when Nora states, “...you[Helmer] must be saved—and that was how I came to devise a way out of the difficulty”(Ibsen 1.12). Furthermore, Krogstad’s motivation can be inferred from an interaction between Nora and Krogstad in which Krogstad states “But I can assure you that my one false step, which lost me all of my reputation, was nothing more or nothing worse than what you have done”(1.24) to which Nora responds, “You? Do you ask me to believe that you were brave enough to run a risk to save your wife’s life?”(1.24). This similarity within the two characters is not accidental; it is intentionally placed inside the play in order to explore characterization and development. Through nearly identical situations, Ibsen begins to explore and bring light to the effects of one’s character upon outside judgement. Nora and Krogstad both committed the same crime, and are forced to deal with the consequences of their actions; however, the two undergo very different

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The play is plotted in what is known as the pyramidal pattern. Each act shows a different structure of events that direct the play. All of the acts take place in the same scene, so the setting has very little change. This structure makes following the various parts of the play an effortless task. This allows readers to grasp the plot and recognize character dispositions and dialogue transitions. Isben created a new acting style that required emotion be conveyed through small, controlled gestures, shifts in action, and pauses. The plot begins in Act I when Krogstad, the subordinate banker, has his initial discussions with Nora, in which he proceeds in his extortion. The story, in contrast, begins when Torvald becomes sick and Nora must borrow…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Krogstad’s decision to not expose Nora’s secret is not convincing, because as a character, he is very manipulative. Krogstad’s shift from villainy to generosity is not adequately motivated, because he achieves his goals through threats and black mailing.…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Henrik Ibsen’s play “A Doll’s House”, Ibsen portrays the roles of society and gender inequalities between men and women of the time. While reading the play, the reader has an eye opening view on the inequalities of men and women, and the idea of feminism. The play reveals the relationships, and ideals between both women, and men. The main character Nora Helmer struggles to keep up with the societal gender roles, and be the best wife she can be, to her conservative husband. The play revolutionized the way women were portrayed, as mentioned by Michael Levenson; “A Doll 's House created a sensation, as its performances spread through Europe in the 1880s. It confirmed and heightened the feminist struggle and attracted as many enemies as friends”(Levenson).…

    • 1786 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This extract of A Doll’s House by Henrik Ibsen is possibly the most important extract of Act 1. Through this section the audience is not only introduced to Mrs Christine Linde and Nora’s first discourse with a lady of her class, but the idea of Nora’s growing desire to rebel. During this conversation Ibsen displays the differing histories and the resulting personalities and ideals of two childhood friends. Plus, this section introduces the main conflict within the play and Ibsen’s reflections of the time.…

    • 1538 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Doll Discerned

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “I have to stand completely on my own, if I’m going to understand myself and everything around me. That’s why I can’t stay here with you any longer.” This quote from “A Doll’s House” gives readers a glimpse into Henrik Ibsen’s brilliant blend of complexity and irony in his two main characters. Though Nora and Torvald seem to be a typical, well-off, and devoted couple at first glance, deep into the play Nora discovers that she does not know who she is or what her life’s purpose is anymore.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since Krogstad writes a letter detailing that Nora had borrowed exponential amount money by forging her dead fathers signature (which was heavily frowned upon), he purposely leaves out that she had been paying it off and they were completely debt free. In the end both Nora and Krogstad had lied to Torvald whether it was to protect him or call him a hypocrite for firing Krogstad when his wife had done the same thing. It would take an outside source to help solve the issue. Since the first letter had already been sent Torvald reads the the letter that Krogstad writes to him he is enraged, and can not believe what she has done. However, Krogstad's lady friend and friend of Nora convinces him to write another letter explaining the whole story since she believe him knowing the truth was the only way to ensure a true relationship. Only moments later he receives another letter with the correct story which causes him to apologize to her repeatedly. All of this leads to Nora seeing the whole picture of how horrible her husband is to her and how he treats…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Henrik Ibsen’s play A Doll’s House, students can understand that the main character, Nora, does not make the right decisions. In act 1 the audience is told that Nora forged a signature to help her husband from an illness. “ ‘No…It was I who wrote Papa’s name’.” (Ibsen 23). Nora is telling Mr. Krogstad, who works for Nora’s husband, about the forgery she committed. Mr. Krogstad promises not to tell Nora’s husband if she asks him if Mr. Krogstad can keep his job. “ ‘If i lose my position… you shall lose yours with me’.” (Ibsen 24). Mr. Krogstad is threatening Nora that he will tell Torvald the problem. Nora thinks about what she needs to do and decides to make Torvald keep Mr. Krogstad. Towards the end of the play, Nora contemplates on whether…

    • 203 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “A Doll’s House” is a play by Henrik Ibsen written in 1879. It’s a drama about a mother’s struggle with a bad lawyer who she struck a secret deal with to receive money for the sake of her husband’s health. However, she forged her father’s name on the bond a few days after her father had already passed away, and the story takes place years into her paying off this debt. The heart of the play is all a build to the climax of husband and wife where secrets come out and honesty is shared. It’s about how relationships can be destroyed through a lack of trust, communication, and misunderstanding. The play covers a span of three or four days and covers the secret conversations held with Nora, the mother, Torvald, who is her husband, Doctor Rank, who is a close friend of both Nora and Torvald, as well as her close friend Mrs. Linde, and Krogstad, the man who loaned the money to Nora.…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Helmer tells Nora that Krogstad is a bad man and he “wriggled out of it with lies and trickery” – (Ibsen pg. 1573). He then goes on to say that Krogstad is the worst type of person, the type who wears a mask in front of the people closest to them. Saying this, however, Helmer says he’s not quick to condemn a man but seems harsh in saying “Krogstad wears a mask in front of his own wife and children” similar to the way Nora is now, being she owes Krogstad the money back and her family does not know. Krogstad eventually leaves a letter in their mailbox after losing his job to Mrs. Kristine Linde. This letter tells Torvald everything that has happened with the forging of the signature. The secret is unfolded and Helmer Immediately says that his wife Nora is forbidden from raising her own kids. Nora is shocked and decides to leave considering in the end she only borrowed the money to try to help her husband even know she felt like she was a “doll,” little and delicate and easy to break not only once by her father but by her own…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When one lies, it shows that one is becoming rebellious, since one does not want to take in commands from someone. Ibsen makes the macaroons represent sin as a bittersweet taste to her, since she enjoys the sweetness of them, yet she is forbidden to eat them giving her an immoral conscience. This foreshadows how she is willing to stand up for herself and live without her husband. Now that she disobeys him, she feels that she can handle things on her own. Ibsen proves to the readers that a woman is not a maid to do what a man tells her what to do. Nora went from being an angelic obedient person to a someone who manipulates and becomes an independent person.…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Krogstad acts to maintain and improve his own image, but his main motivation is his sons, as revealed when he says: “My sons are growing up; for their sake I must try and win back as much respect as I can in the town.” (Page 189) He responds to this demand by blackmailing Nora into convincing Torvald not to fire him . In this, he is not only responding to the demand of raising his two sons, but also the demand of society to maintain good-standing in order to live a decent quality of life. His response is seen again in the second act, when again he confronts Nora, reiterating that “I want to rehabilitate myself, Mrs. Helmer; I want to get on; and in that your husband must help me.” (Page 209) After reconciling with Mrs. Linde, Krogstad offers to take back the letter, and as a better life for him and his children is ensured, he acts in a complete opposite way to his previous behaviour, demonstrating that his former actions were based in self-preservation. In using Krogstad, Ibsen shows again that individuals will act in ways they do not normally in order to ensure self-preservation in the face of the demands of society, individuals, and…

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Henrik Ibsen “A Doll’s House”, Nora Helmer, the beautiful wife of Torvald, is a representation of women’s freedom. She loves to spend money, dress elegantly, and cares for her children. However, Nora’s most important concern is charming her husband and being a perfect wife. She is a private individual and she covers her feelings from her husband even when there is no advantage in doing so. Even though Nora is deceptive and thoughtful, she is not aware of her true value until the last enactment of the play. Throughout the play she exhibited different sides of herself by being childlike at times while still displaying her intelligence. As the play develops, Nora’s role changes from the self-proclaimed trophy wife to that of a very prepared…

    • 1094 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henrick Ibsen’s, A Doll’s House, is a drama play set in a Norwegian town in 1978. The play follows a woman who leaves her overcontrolling husband behind. We start off with our main character, Nora. She is the wife of Torvald who has just has been promoted at the bank. Krogstad also works at the bank and agrees to let Nora forge her father’s signature to take money. Mrs. Linde has been Nora’s friend since they were young. Dr. Rank is Torvald’s best friend. Through the course of this play, Dr. Rank is slowly dying but does not tell Torvald, because of Torvald’s dislike in death. From Torvald’s actions throughout the play, he begins to realize how he abused his power and drove Nora to the unthinkable in society at the time.…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This may not have been Ibsen’s intent when he first wrote A Doll’s House but it is nonetheless how it’s interpreted today. The catalyst for the change to her character was the blackmail letter that was placed in her letterbox in the previous act. Nora, having failed in her attempt to convince her husband to keep Krogstad in his position at the bank is confronted by Krogstad in her home while Torvald is gone. During the exchange Krogstad goes over the changed he envisions for his future at the bank. He believes that within a year with Torvalds help he will be manager of the bank. Nora of course exclaims that he will never see that happen. Krogstad, assuming that she plans to do something drastic asks her if she means suicide. She affirms his question and proclaims “I have courage enough for it now” (Act II; 704). Krogstad who had contemplated suicide before when his reputation was dragged through the mud due to his crime of forging, is not impressed. He responds morbidly, “Under the ice perhaps? Down into the cold, coal black water? And then in the Spring, to float up to the surface, all horrible and unrecognizable, with your hair falling out” (Act II; 704)? It is after this passage that Nora goes through the first of her changes. She replies “You can’t frighten me” (Act II; 704). This passage is important to the evolution of Nora’s character because it marks the first turning point of her defiance in the face of being the perfect “doll…

    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henrik Ibsen’s play “A Doll’s House” features complex characters who are different than they appear. Nora and Torvald each undergo a transformation of their character from the start of the play until the finish. Torvald begins the play appearing very strong and confident, but by the end he is broken down to a scared and unhappy man who is holding onto an image of himself to receive respect from all he encounters. Additionally, Nora experiences a similar transformation of moving from a wife who does as her husband asks to an independent and strong woman who is willing to sacrifice everything to bring about her own happiness. Therefore, I assert that Ibsen’s goal in writing “A Doll’s House” is to accentuate that people are not always what they…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays