Be Fair ! By Stuntz: Article Analysis

Improved Essays
As the author goes on throughout this article, he begins with basically stating that prison for poor people, and more specifically, poor black men, is just their ordinary life. He then compares this to privileged white men in college. Then he continues on the mass incarceration on a scale almost unexampled in human history is a fundamental fact of our country today, where he then states or tries to relate it to the slavery fundamentals from 1850. The author states that there is now over six million people under “correctional supervision” in America. The estimated amount of people in these facilities is just as startling as the people already in there. For every hundred thousand Americans, about two hundred and twenty people were incarcerated. …show more content…
The Declaration of the Rights of Man says, Be just! The Bill of Rights says, Be fair!” Stuntz had mentioned this in his masterwork, “The Collapse of American Criminal Justice.” I agree with fairness, and that people should not be falsely accused of crimes, the whole enchilada. But some people get mixed up with being fair, and being just. Without being just, we’d have even more crime than we already do. We need to be just, we need to give people scary stories to keep them out of prison. We can’t make it look like somewhere they want to be, with the privileges of the innocent. As a country, we need to be just as fair as we are just, and vice versa. Which is also in this article, that above all we seek justice, and who can argue that.
Stuntz also states that you should always enter court with an understanding of what crime is and what justice is like. This is good advice, but it seems a little more like common sense. Then, the southern argument is that this story puts too bright of a face on the truth. But people need to know the truth. This is the reality of American prisons. If people can’t handle the truth on this, then they should just stay out of trouble and away from

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The memoir, Just Mercy, by Bryan Stevenson published in 2014 generally focuses on an unjust and merciless trial held from 1988 to 1993. It is informative and insightful because the author thoroughly discusses the flaws of racism and corruption in the judicial system. Stevenson struggles against inequality, abusive power, poverty, oppression and injustice which reveals his own brokenness. Stevenson’s message is to show us our brokenness so we can learn to embrace it, which “creates a need and desire for mercy” (290), helping us recognize the humanity in each of us. Stevenson grew up poor in Delaware, his great grandparents were slaves in Virginia and his grandfather was murdered. His background influences his view of how we we judge some people…

    • 1630 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the biggest issue Coates focuses on in his article, is how mass incarceration causes great damage to the Black community. According to Coates, the issues of poverty can be traced back to the matriarchal society in the African American community. Coates argues this is a problem because children are growing up without a father figure in their life, and their single mothers are too busy at work earning money to support their families causing them to spend less and less quality time with their children. Children are influenced by daily dynamics which they often seek from their parents. Children that are raised in a toxic environment where there is a lack of a father figure and/or absence of a strong familial unit, are often seen following their parents footsteps. Mass incarceration leads to the issue of poverty because it causes ex-convicts to work at a lower wage in order to provide for their families. In his article, Coates uses Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s example. Moynihan was raised by his mother because his father was in prison, his life consisted of single motherhood, poverty, and relocation. At a very early age, Moynihan was forced to split his time between studying, working, and spending time with family on rare occasions. Moynihan’s family example clearly goes to illustrate that ex-convicts have a harder time finding a job because of the stigma that they served jail time and thus…

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The last five chapters of the book “The American Prison: Imagining a Different Future” written by Francis Cullen, Mary Stohr and Cheryl Johnson discuss some of the various prison systems that can be found in America, and the issues that surround them. The main focus of discussion for each chapter is the history of the prison, its effectiveness in running, its social context in modern day America, and the authors of the chapter’s personal thoughts on the importance of that specific prison type. The four types of prisons covered in chapters 9-12 are the private prison, the green prison, the small prison, and the accountable prison; chapter thirteen of the book talks about the lessons that should be learned from the book regarding the harm and…

    • 2111 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The current American prison system is a leviathan unmatched in human history.” (Loury, 4). A leviathan; a beast as old as the book of Job, and even when made a myth, incessantly feared. A leviathan, an immovable force by which any hope of subduing is false, and the mere sight of is overpowering. Made to be an indestructible being, “king over all that are proud,” a leviathan doesn’t just describe the American prison system, but the institution racism has created in America as a whole. Prison, and imprisonment, are aspects of the systematic racism that built the United States. This system relies on internalization, prolonged manipulation, and fear. This system is a result of the white perception of the black body. And because of how effective…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness” written by Michelle Alexander, she talks about the issue of mass incarceration throughout the United States. She points out the legal discrimination felons are subject to, hence a second class citizen. Alexander sees the problem of the majority of the prison population are African American males. She states that the War On Drugs helped spike this mass incarceration, and had the intent to discriminate against African American males. Hence the name of “The New Jim Crow”, she found this to be the modern day Jim Crow laws which the criminal justice system is responsible for. Mass incarceration among the African American community is a problem, and this article provides the necessary information needed to convince the audience of the issues in our criminal justice system.…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Louisiana Prison Reform

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In 2007, 65% of white males were free while a 36% were imprisoned. In a disheartening comparison, only 12% of free black males made up the U.S population while more than 39% of black males were incarcerated (). Back in 1954, the number of imprisoned African Americans hovered somewhere new only 98,000 and by 2002 the number increased sharply to over 884,500. High crime rates among the black community have been linked to poverty, oppression and high pressure from local law authorities. Lawrence Bobo, author of Racialized Mass Incarceration, talks about the typical problems that stem from within black communities, “black involvement with criminal behavior is primarily traceable to differential black exposure to struc-tural conditions of extreme poverty, extreme racial segregation, changed law enforcement priorities, and the modern legacy of racial oppression”(Bobo). A combination of poverty, poor education and a justice system created to suppress certain inhabitants of society has created an economic machine that serves little purpose other than to withhold and…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Michelle Alexander’s The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness, Alexander calls mass incarceration the “New Jim Crow.” In this way, Alexander connects the past of the Jim Crow era to the present way in which criminals are treated today. The Jim Crow era refers to the racial caste system of laws and policies once set in place during the end of Reconstruction through the late 1950s by which white southerners reasserted their dominance over African Americans by denying them their basic civil rights in order to maintain racial segregation in the South. Mass incarceration, on the other hand, refers to a white power structure of racialized social control that, like Jim Crow, operates to humiliate, degrade, and control black people into an inferior position through law and order. After analyzing the racial aspects of mass incarceration, Alexander evaluates the world which ex-offenders enter once released from prison. She notes that there are…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cullen states, “For over a decade, virtually every contemporary commentary on corrections in the United States has reminded us that the system is in crisis” (57). By this he explains that the crisis of the corrections system that we face today is not relatively new. It has been issue for decades and we are still nowhere close to resolving this issue which is affecting us all. Prisons are overcrowded with the ever growing immigrant population and young adults. Cullen further reviews how today’s response to the corrections crisis has become worse. He explains how punishments have become more extreme, while also reducing amenities for offenders. According to Cullen the number of prisoners have been increased tremendously throughout the years, and the U.S. incarcerate its citizens…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This topic is discussed so often today everyone should have a good grasp of the concept of these terms. To elaborate on the concept of mass incarceration is the systematic round up of minorities in the prison system as a direct result of the War on Drugs. Throughout the reading, Alexander mentions other sources on television and other media outlets that beg the question, “where are all the good black men?”. As a joke, they say there aren’t any left or they’re dating out of their race or even president Obama calling to the problem of the absence of black men in their children’s life (Rothenberg 2016). In the Rothenberg text, Alexander explains the process that this nation put these black men through, and people of color, using the War on drugs as a means of getting these black men in the first phase of entrapment “the roundup” (Rothenberg 2016). As a result, police benefited from having higher arrests rates through federal grants while the blacks were condemned in the criminal justice system. In the second phase, “formal control”, their loaded up with extra charges and then stuck in prison. Once removed from the system they enter an invisible cage in this final phase of entrapment known as the invisible punishment. Here they can “never integrate into white society” only live as a second class citizen revoked of all rights given by the constitution. (Rothenberg 2016). The problem is also addressed in the documentary 13th, it is stated that 6.5% of African Americans make up the United States while 40.2% of them are in prison (DuVernay 2016). Ranking America with the highest rate of incarceration in the world also stated in the documentary (DuVernay…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Drug War Effects On Latinx

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages

    This source is vital to my research topic considering it discusses the race differences in the prisons of the United States. “Blacks in 1991 made up 12 percent of America’s population but 48 percent of both prison and jail inmates.” This quote represents that although Blacks made up 12 percent of America’s population, there were 48 percent of Blacks which means more than half the population was incarcerated. There is a clear disproportion of race in the United States prisons. Races are not treated the same in prisons and that is a state as well as a national problem. When more than half of the population is in prison, that is a problem. As well as when races do not receive the same amount of time for the same…

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States was created with the intentions of equality for all its citizens. Author Bruce Western & Becky Pettit of “Incarceration & Social Inequality” argue that equality seems to come to an end when it applies to prisoners. Incarcerations rates in the recent years have soared, the authors assert that these rising numbers have created a new social group of disadvantaged individuals. Most importantly this group is predominantly composed of African American men with no of little high school education. When someone is labelled a felon many limitations are placed on the individual to the extent that he or she has a difficult time converging back into society. Benefits that are critical to survival in this society are stripped away leaving these individuals homeless, jobless, and without food. Western & Pettit successful uses ethos, logos, and pathos to persuade their audience that social inequality produced by mass incarceration of African American men with limited education…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Because today it's well known that we lock more people up in America than any other country. And the reason the writer wrote about this topic is because today “mass incarceration on a scale almost unexampled in human history is a fundamental fact of our country today- perhaps the fundamental fact, as slavery was a fundamental fact in 1850.” (Gopnik) As Gopnik expressed in here too “In truth there are more black men in the grip of the criminal -justice system-- in prison, on probation, or on parole – than were in slavery then” He is claiming that this is who we were and this is where we are today. Which means that there were less men in prison in the past, then there are today. Because we as American trap more people in prison. He is saying mass incarceration defines us today, as slavery did in the history. And most people are not aware of this…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most inspiring books I read on the topic of prison overcrowding regarding racism was The New Jim Crow: Mass incarceration in the age of Colorblindness by Michelle Alexander. She believes that the issue of mass incarceration should be referred as the issue of racial justice. She mentions the speech “I have a Dream” by Martin Luther King and how we as a nation have disobeyed his dream. The book was written during the time of President Barack Obama. It states, that as United States was celebrating the election of Barack Obama, majority of black men were still locked behind bars. (Alexander, 25). Her main point is that by targeting African American men for minor crimes, we as a nation and the U.S. criminal justice functions to be a system of racial control. Not a system of crime control.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is well documented that, from almost any point of reference, one can discern that American society’s foundation is derived from placing white superiority and black inferiority as far apart on the spectrum as possible, especially through comparisons in wealth accumulation, incarceration rates, or even enrollment statistics here at the University of Michigan. Prisons are often deployed as nets to collect the ramifications of this structure, which implies that they can’t be viewed individually, as Jackson does. By allowing the prison to exist as its own agency, one severs it from being a representative of society. At the time of this writing, prison was, in fact, an almost direct representative of American society. It operated with a central command, which ensured obedience to a capitalistic society. The system, then, granted privilege to a small few (trustys), who were incentivized to subdue others by any means necessary in order to maintain power, even if it meant abdicating any commitment to a moral and ethical code. The necessity to ensure that prison is viewed as reflective of society stems from the necessity that each member of society takes responsibility for permitting a system such as the carceral’s to exist. The prison system does not exist in a vacuum, as Jackson’s comments suggest; rather, it portrays what the system doesn’t want its members to…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Throughout this chapter not only did I gain a better understating in parole, but I also learned that more than one-third of prisoners are under parole supervision all with the purpose to adjust into society. Moreover, with previous knowledge in the chapters I managed to understand that one of the reasons why corrections like parole exist is not only to improve individuals, but to also avoid prison overcrowding which is why about half of the population on parole release are under mandatory release. Mandatory release is part of a release mechanism that consists of inmates serving majority of their sentence time minus the “good time” while discretionary release is boundaries set by a sentence and law. Throughout the past decades parole has become…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays