Andrew Jackson Book Critique

Superior Essays
7th president of the United States of America, the face of the $20 bill, a war hero, a charismatic man, and a man who wanted to eliminate the Indian race. These are some things that the “admirable” and controversial Andrew Jackson was known for. Andrew Jackson was a president that has and still is heavily analyzed by historians because his impact on America for better or worse. To some, many may think Andrew Jackson is one of the greatest presidents ever. Nevertheless , there are mixed views on whether Andrew Jackson was an “influential” president in today’s view. Jackson had different views that didn’t strictly lean to the left or the right. Furthermore, which results in heavy dispute if Jackson was the ideal conservative or liberal in today’s …show more content…
Even when discussing the events of the Trail of Tears, he didn’t seem like he was inserting his own opinion. But rather just stating the history of the initial actions. Overall, Wilentz presents the book just a unbiased informational piece on Andrew Jackson’s life. If you look at more information about the author, he’s a liberal and a supporter of the Clinton campaigns. Despite his liberal views, he talks about Jackson’s involvement in abusing human rights on a neutral standpoint. Even though Wilentz is neutral when it comes to his stance on Jackson, he shows a glimmer of admiration for the 7th president. Highlighting Jackson’s personality and accomplishments shows that the author doesn’t show a dislike nor favoritism for Jackson. Respect is shown for Jackson by Wilentz. But he did downplay the events of the Trail of Tears and the Indian removal act as something that just happened rather than unpleasant part of American history.
Walter Russell Mead’s book review of Andrew Jackson praises Wilentz’s work for being “concise and clear” . In his review, he compares Wilentz work with someone else 's. He was very short and sincere about his review about Andrew Jackson. In another review, Ray Olson is concise about his thoughts about the book as well. Olson said that the “text is harder to read” more than others but “it’s essential for serious history students”

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Andrew Jackson was a very controversial President. There are multiple positives and negatives to Andrew Jackson. Andrew is America’s great worst President. I am going to discuss and tell you if you he was a good or bad President is his term from March 4, 1829- March 4, 1837. Before Andrew Jackson was President, he had nine slaves. By the time he was a President he had nearly 150 slaves. He was given the title of an Elite Planter.…

    • 2021 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrew Jackson Biography

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I really enjoyed reading this book, it taught me a lot of new things such as facts about Andrew Jackson and his background information. This book is very informative with a lot of things…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is due to his credibility with his study, the way he portrays how President Andrew Johnson made the process longer than it needed it to be, how African Americans dealt with these new circumstances with their new lives, and how the south tried to keep control of their power. The book is well researched that it reads like a History textbook that makes it both instructive and memorable to those who read. And, the book is the best resource that a person can have if they want to do a project of Reconstruction. It will bring them a new take of the Reconstruction era and it would hopefully help people in an uncertain world. and, it shows that we still have come a long way since Reconstruction. But, we still have a lot of work to do to achieve freedom, liberty, and the pursuit of…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jackson’s strongest conviction was that Native Americans would not become civilized, and although many other people of that time agreed, these opinions should not have given him popularity. “He shared the white Tennessean’s common opinion of Indians. As he saw it they were the festering sore that afflicted the settlers and limited the colonization of this great land, the progress of this newest and best nation on Earth, man’s hope for freedom from kings and dukes and tyrants and priests…” Jackson wrongly encouraged views of Native Americans like those above, showing that he was a strong racist. Moreover, “Cherokee: a blob of forests, burnt-off fields, and raging streams with savages robbing travelers and, often enough, torturing them to death. That was Cherokee to him.” However, Cherokee had settled down, learned to farm, and did, in fact, live what whites would call “civilized lives”. Again, this shows Jackson was a liar, racist, and corruptly gained popularity by spreading such statements, all which are qualities of a bad…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He goes thoroughly through all the wars and events that have occurred between the Americans and Natives and sympathizes for the lost history of the natives. He confirms with his explanation of the short short stories and historical facts that the whites have been too harsh on the natives for their personal interests. He tries rectifying the reason behind the history of the natives and the americans and concludes that ‘racism’ isn’t the reason behind the war. He wishes that details of the history were appropriately recorded. Instead of showing how the Natives were an hindrance to the European migration to their lands he wished that the Natives and Europeans were portrayed in an amicable manner where the records would have applauded the efforts made by the Natives to give assistance to the Europeans by showing them the river routes, trade routes, showing them around the neighborhood and introducing them to their people. He wished that history focused more on the aid that the Indians gave to the Europeans than the trouble they had caused. It determines he did not want these massacres to happen and wanted the history to promote peace rather than…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This was a quick and easy read, yet was packed with valuable information and valid arguments. Johnson delves into American history,…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrew Jackson, a strong-willed, stubborn, selfish man who only listened to himself and ignored the opinions of others, won his way into presidency during the election of 1828. Throughout his presidency Andrew Jackson made some horrible choices, that affected the country in negative ways. People were killed, orders were ignored, laws were broken, amendments were violated, all because of the choices he made. Even before his presidency he was a cruel man, that deserved punishment. Thomas Jefferson states that Andrew Jackson “could never speak on account of the rashness of his feelings. I have seen him attempt it repeatedly, and as often choke with rage…. He is a dangerous man.” (Meltzer 1993)…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The past and its people are often romanticized. One such character of early American history that was romanticized was Andrew Jackson. Yet author James C. Curtis does not romanticize Jackson’s actual achievements, and also tells of his faults and flaws in his book Andrew Jackson and the Search for Vindication. Curtis reveals Jackson’s participation in national events, his inconsistent morals and ethics, and the women most important in his life.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    President Andrew Jackson was the seventh president of the United States. Jackson was head of the executive branch for two terms, from 1829 to 1837. Jackson was also known as the president of the common man. His new title was not the only thing that came out of his presidency, many changes occurred during his presidency that impacted The United States in many ways. During Jackson’s presidency, he attempted to shape the economy in a way he saw fit, Jackson also played a role in the reformation of previously established orthodoxy. Jackson’s presidency also paved the way for a revitalized political party system, and played a major role in the development of other political affairs.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Trail Of Tears Summary

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Additionally, the book gets deeply into the Removal Act from 1830, which was signed by President Andrew Jackson approving the president to give away grounds west of the Mississippi in return for Indian lands inside existing state borders. The author focus in this book and what I believe is his thesis is to show the readers how the white immigrants try to use unfair…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    One of his greatest accomplishments as president was when he became involved in a battle with the Second Bank of the United States. Jackson took a stand towards this monopoly and vetoed its re-charter bill, charging the bank with unfair economic privilege. Even though Jackson was popular with the common man, his presidency did have some controversies. One policy that is up for debate is how Jackson dealt with the Native Americans. In 1830, many southerners wanted Native Americans to move out of their land and in response; Jackson urged congress to pass the Indian Removal Act (Lapanskey-Werner, et al page 254). This sought to negotiate the exchange of Indian lands in the south for new lands in American territory (Lapanskey-Werner, et al page 254). The Jackson Administration urged many Native Americans to sell their land and move out of the southern territory which a ajority did; however, the Cherokee Indians refused to move and went to the Supreme Court (Lapanskey-Werner, et al page 253). The Supreme Court eventually ruled that the Cherokee Indians be allowed to remain on their land, but Jackson decided to force them out of the southern territory, along a Trail of Tears, that ended in Oklahoma (Lapanskey-Werner, et al page 254). Many people criticized Jackson for these actions, calling them inhumane and cruel, but Andrew Jackson’s focus was for the interest and welfare of the people of United States. Even…

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jon Meacham, a three-time New York best seller, a native of Nashville, and a recipient of the Pulitzer Prize for American Lion, Meacham is an accomplished writer. He received a degree in English literature and had been editor for numerous organizations. While his notorieties should be praised, his background must be noted that he did not earn a degree in History. His writing was vivid and engaging; it was easy to get engrossed by his book. While the literature was impeccable, it should still be noted the historiography is slightly lacking. American Lion is a phenomenal book to understand Jackson within the White House, yet not a full encompassing Andrew Jackson biography. Due to a couple of simple facts. First, Meacham focused on Andrew Jackson’s…

    • 1789 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Robert V Remini Summary

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Historian and a specialist on the life of Andrew Jackson, Robert V. Remini, tells the story of Jackson’s life from childhood to his years of presidency, and how his whole life revolved around the Indian conflicts of the time.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indian Removal Impact

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Why could we not have left the natives of the southeastern states how they were, and ventured further west without disturbing the natives of those areas as well? Thousands of Native Americans died during the forced migration that they called “The Trail of Tears”, and I feel that in some way all of it could have been prevented. Even though Andrew Jackson played a large part in the Indian Removal Act, which in my opinion, was one of the lower points in his presidency, he did have a “deep and lasting impact on the structure of the federal government” (MindTap U.S. History, 9.2). The impact that he left on the way the government still functions today was made very evident to me throughout this week’s readings. Also, reading about American life in the period between the American Revolution and the Civil War, made me realize how hard life could be for the common man, and that political leaders were not always on…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When we as Americans look back at our past, we are often overwhelmed with all of the significant events and people that shaped this great nation. When we take a closer look we can pick out a few that shaped this nation more than others. This country was founded over 200 years ago which gives us plenty to analyze, however, Andrew Jackson is one person in particular who undeniably played a huge role in shaping our country in the 1800s. A man of humble beginning that rose to prominence on the national stage and enacted his policies in a nation.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays