Too Close To The Bone By Roberta Seid

Improved Essays
In the article, “Too ‘Close to the Bone’: The Historical Context for Women’s Obsession with Slenderness,” author Roberta Seid proclaims that the health of society today is measured by appearance and attitude towards food and eating. Seid stresses that the obsession over being skinny and how the obsession is fueled by fashion and society. She warns that this obsession can lead to anorexia and she fears that many are okay with that. In the article, “Fat and Happy: In Defense of Fat Acceptance,” author Mary Ray Worley believes that society is corrupt in their ways of thinking and judging people who are too overweight. Worley emphasizes that fat people are people too, and they deserve fair treatment and equal opportunities. She feels that people …show more content…
Although Worley and Seid both agree, Worley seems to feel more strongly about the stigma that is being fat because she has felt and dealt with this first hand. Worley insists that society sees fat as being such a bad thing that many would go to severe extremes just to not be fat. She says that people will go so far as to “... die or cut off a limb…”(163) to not be fat. Seid would agree with that statement, as she says that women want so badly to meet the standards that are held for them, simply because every woman wants to be desired. Worley feels that all fat people are constantly being ridiculed for their weight and that no matter who they are or how successful they are, they will always hold the stigma of being a fat person. She claims that those who are fat are molded by society to feel shame and anguish when they see themselves, and should constantly stand in the shadows as to not let anyone see their body that they are so ashamed of. Seid and Worley agree that society has targeted fat people, and the way that society pressures fat people and makes them feel is just …show more content…
Worley explains that she has felt personally victimized by the fashion industry, and can only find clothes that fit her overweight body type when she is on a “different planet” (163). Seid implies that the recent fad of obsessing over skinniness has been fueled by the fashion industry. Worley has said that in her experience, she can rarely find clothes that are actually fit for an overweight person. Seid explains how the clothes you wear are not the center of fashion anymore but the naked body is. Fashion is currently about what’s under the clothes, and if its pretty enough to wear the clothes that are being sold. Seid explains that what really matters about a person anymore is not their morals, attitude, or overall personality, but how they look, clothed and not. She implies that all of the standards that come along with fashion and beauty are the leading causes of eating disorders. Seid states that once the fashion industry began to promote thinness, authoritative members of society began to make statements such as “...one could never be too thin”(175). Seid touches on the subject of fashion more than Worley. Seid approaches the subject of fashion with a negative attitude, explaining that it has degenerated and has caused physical and emotional pain to women

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Commenrcials like these are what make society think that we can only be beautiful if we are the perfect weight. Making other woman who are already the “perfect weight” turn against women who are just thick and beautiful because they believe they are either too fat or too skinny. However size does not matter and women shouldn 't be putting it on themselves but what 's crushing is that thanks to society woman are starting to forget the true meaning of beauty! Also according to Wilson, C., & Silverwood, J. (2014, Oct 05 comments like these : “put it away fatso!” And “Urgh!…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Fat is a feminist issue because women are valued on their appearance above any other aspect of their character and being a fat woman in society is viewed as one of the worst things you can be. Fat bodies are extremely stigmatized in our culture. Society is obsessed with the idea of controlling the appearance of women’s bodies- and this includes size. Fat is seen as lazy, unbearable and something we should never be okay with being. Society communicates to fat women that they should not exist in the body they do.…

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As both illuminate the ways in which fatness and disability are linked by bodily control. Gruys and Peters’ pieces about fashion center around the idea that within fashion, women’s fat bodies are something that they must always have control over. Linking this idea to disability studies reveals how in both fields, people’s bodies are not in control and that disabled and fat people are looked down upon for the exact reason that they appear to have lost control over their bodies. Here, Afful’s and Ricciardelli’s piece on fat bloggers comes into play when fat bloggers challenge the idea that this lack of control over one’s body should mean that they themselves are a morally inferior…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Perfect Body

    • 1512 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Gloria Steinem once said, “If you ask men about their body image, they will tell you they look better than they do. And if you ask a woman, she’ll tell you she looks worse (Body Image Quotes).” In today’s society, women are more worried about how their bodies look than they ever have been. Women have to have a “perfect” body because the media tells them that they have to look a certain way in order to get a guy’s attention or fit in. Some will do anything it takes to achieve that “perfect” body, including developing an eating disorder. The portrayal of women in the media today is one of the leading causes for eating disorders.…

    • 1512 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Orbach believes that women have this urge to overeat, and have this severe and excruciating feeling of being judged by being overweight. The dissimilarity to Orbach’s belief, Miller suggests that obesity may be the cause of purchasing junk food and fast food, instead of healthy nutritious food. Miller states in this conflict that lower-income families rather bargain unhealthy food; such as candy or soda because they are low-priced (Miller 5). Even though Miller considers that lower-income families have the most obese rates, she noticed it could be he or she are not financially stable to afford nutritious…

    • 1319 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Media And Beauty

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It has caused self-esteem issues not only in the United States, but all around the world. The media has everything wrong about what beauty really is, and it is not right for people to tell women how they need to look to be considered beautiful. The media has caused women to think badly about themselves and to even develop eating disorders. Lexie and Lindsay Kite, two sisters who wrote an article titled, "What the Media Gets Wrong about Beauty", stated in their article that "persuasive exposure to such a narrow image of women has shown contribute to painfully low self-esteem, a preoccupation with appearance, and full-fledged eating disorders"(Kite). This is clear evidence that the media has had a huge effect on many women.…

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Overall, will lead to men to only see women as objects and condition women to believe this “body image” is only acceptable in society. For this reason, this endanger the women community accessible to sexual violence and provokes low-esteem. According to HealthyPlace, “advertisements emphasize thinness as a standard for female beauty, and the bodies idealized in the media are frequently atypical of normal, healthy women.” (Writer) Because society sets a ideal body image more woman found themselves dieting, the younger girls specifically suffer as they continue to grow up. The NEDA reported that “ ..By age 6, girls especially start to express concerns about their own weight or shape. 40-60% of elementary school girls (ages 6-12) are concerned about their weight or about becoming too fat.”(Get facts on eating disorder) This statistic shows the type of message the media sends to the younger girls influencing them, young girls are already deciding that their body type isn’t gonna live up to society’s ideal body type of a woman.…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although, the most popular fashion industries are only showing thin models to present their "modern" clothes. Schwarz goes on to state that he believes anorexia is all cultural and psychological. These two things do play a big part in anorexia. He points out culture being a part of eating disorders and, culturally is just what I 'm arguing. Our culture today embraces; thin women with long hair, long legs, and clear skin and bashes anyone who looks a slight different.…

    • 1527 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Teens reading these magazines that encourage dieting are prone to develop eating disorders, and weight-control habits (“Body Image Timeline”). The message, is not meant to be taken and used negatively, but unfortunately it is. In this day in age beauty is the main concern for most, and therefore it seems extreme measures must be taken. Even after certain measures are taken to prevent the unhealthy dietary habits, magazines, modeling, and pageantry still promote the “thin is in” stigma. “…The perils of overly thin models projecting an unhealthy body image for women…(critics) Voiced concern that fashion houses are encouraging potentially hazardous behaviors by glamorizing models who are rail-thin” (Bilefsky).…

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This constant shifting in expectations for women have created many fitness challenges that are harming. For example, a trending challenge is the “A4 challenge”, which is basically someone holding up a letter size piece of paper (8.5”x 11”) vertically and if it hides your waistline, you are considered paper thin (Meyers). This is just one of the many examples of how social media has taken a toll on women. Medical professor, Zhang Darong, at Peking University said it best “"Society 's pursuit of a certain body type or facial feature style is harming the youth a lot." Seeing how heavily America’s fashion industry influences other parts of the world should only make us want stricter and healthier…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays