I Am Fat Steinberg Analysis

Improved Essays
Okay, So I’m Naturally Thin I constantly hear girls give me the same compliment, “Oh I wish I was your size, you’re so thin.” The “compliment” they say always tends to irk me because I’m naturally thin, I always have been, but not by choice. I know that if I did not have the genes my parents gave me I would not be the same size I am today. To be honest I consider myself to be a fat person. No, I do not have a body image problem. I know I am thin, but at this point I should be extremely fat. I am constantly eating junk food, I am the one who goes to a party and instantly starts to look for the food and will shamelessly shove brownies, cupcakes, and bacon in my face. Trust me when I say eating healthy will never be a New Year’s resolution for me. So when people tell me they wish they were my size I instantly say back, “You are my size.” …show more content…
So I’m Fat,” it is made aware to his readers that he is overweight and that he knows it is bad for his health. Stein berg claims that there is a “final ignominy” that fat people have to deal with which are thin people. More specifically thin people who have to eat right, workout, and do whatever it is to become or stay skinny rather than thin people who are naturally thin. Thin people who work hard at being thin always seem to find a way to dig under fat people’s skin by constantly saying mean comments. I would say that I agree with Steinberg’s thoughts, and I strongly believe that people who are naturally thin are less critical about people’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Fat and Happy: In Defense of Fat Acceptance”, Mary Ray Worley explains that it is possible to be fat and yet happy with your body. She discovered this for herself at a conference in San Diego. In August 2000, Worley attended the annual convention of the National Association to Advance Fat Acceptance and she felt as if she was visiting another planet (Worley 163). Her eyes were opened to the possibility that fat people did not have to feel ashamed about their bodies. She explains the first time she had that “different planet” feeling was at the pool party on the first night of the convention (163).…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Saying that although the idealization certain kinds of bodies can cause anxieties and depression, could there be a positive side to it. These images of hyper thin models could carry “fantasized solutions to our anxieties and insecurities, and that's part of the reason why they are powerful. They speak to us not just about how to be beautiful or desirable, but about how to get control of our lives, get safe, be cool, and avoid hurt”(2). But like she says these solutions are just fantasies and thus making her point that there are not any positive sides to using extremely thin, bony models as pictures of…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I agree with Renee Engeln’s article when discussing the problem with how people negatively talk about themselves. The first topic Renee Engeln talks about is how often people express how large or in this case fat they feel. She writes about why should that matter? Why do we have the urge to tell people how we feel about ourselves and throw it out there in the open?…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In "Too "Close to the Bone": The Historical Context for Women 's Obsession with Slenderness" (167-179) and "The Man Who Couldn 't Stop Eating" (186-199), Seid and Gawande assert that we have unrealistic and destructive expectations for ourselves and others. Seid equates our current relationship with weight to a bad religion – one in which we are perpetually punished for our lack of virtue and one in which our worship and our self destruction take the same form. Our religion, according to Seid, is little more than a penance for our gluttonous goal to remain individuals in a society obsessed with slim homogeneity (178). Gawande provides a different idea, proposing that we are possibly just rolling with the punches, chasing goals as we see progress and constantly adapting to fit new ideals. The success of our…

    • 1034 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The weight debate rages on with Mary Ray Worley’s essay, "Fat and Happy: In Defense of Fat Acceptance." Worley, who is a member of the National Association to Advance Fat Acceptance (NAAFA), argues that “trying to manipulate our bodies into being something they’re not” (167), bearing the guilt about one's body, and trying to change how one looks in order to bring others happiness is not the way to live. Worley uses her experiences at the annual NAAFA convention and some examples of her lifestyle changes to demonstrate that it is possible to stay happy with your body even if it is overweight. Worley seeks to dispel and shatter many of the stereotypes often placed upon the overweight even though her article uses the same stereotyping that she condemns society for.…

    • 674 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People tend to judge and see abominably everything that is strange in humans, Obesity is one of these atypical problems that people commonly judge. “Discrimination at a large” is an article written by Jennifer A. Coleman that stress how she felt about herself and how judges to overweigh people are wrong and damaging as any racial or ethnic slur. On the other hand, the article “O.k., I am fat,” written by Neil Steinberg, says that despite some health problems, being fat is not a dilemma, but thin people usually remind them that is not normal. For me, both articles are much alike in terms of their perspective as being obese, their attitude, and how people ridicule them.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a NY Times article, “Is Fat Stigma Making Us Miserable?”, Emilie Lucchesi talks about the causes of psychological health problems arising not necessarily from the physical characteristic but from the overbearing stigmatization of being overweight in our society. Contrary to popular belief, there exists almost no direct relationship between how much a person weighs and their psychological health welfare; the problem lies, instead, within how people are being treated. She explains that it’s rather “the teasing, judgment and unsolicited advice directed at overweight people that can cause the greatest psychological harm.” The article goes on to introduce Courtney Bailey, a media scholar in popular culture, as she explains that the fat stigma…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Erik Orr Mr. Farias English Composition 1301 – 047 04 Aug 2014 Title “Americas War on the Overweight” by Kate Dailey and Abbey Ellin gives readers a look at the hardships and judgment’s that come with being obese in todays America. The majority of obese Americans did not choose to be obese; factors such as illness, genetics, and psychological problems play a determining role. The simple assumption that everyone who is obese is lazy, over eats, or is a slob, is far from the truth. There are numerous reasons as to why one ends up being extremely overweight, and many more reasons why they remain that way forever.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This stigma surrounding food and fatness is simply just another source of income for America 's capitalistic market, not an actual threat to one 's general well-being. Despite agreeing with the majority of her argument, there is one point that I cannot get behind one hundred percent, that point being her assertion that obesity is not a real dilemma with real consequences. No matter the size, our bodies are absolutely beautiful, fighting everyday to keep us alive and kicking. Albeit, just like motor vehicles, our bodies can only handle so much wear and tear before they begin to break down.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Insecurity Growing up on a farm with two older brothers, I was a bit of a tomboy. From birth until age seven, my favorite toys were Tonka trucks and wooden guns. I wrestled in the mud, ate like a teenage boy, and at the age of five took scissors to my hair, chopping it into a pixie cut, so I could “be like my older brothers”. Innocently, I wore my barn clothes to school and my kindergarten picture displays my hair in a rats nest, with a large crooked smile, and bright eyes. However, that yearbook picture changed as my innocence faded away.…

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being ashamed of one’s body can lead to medical conditions. People spend a lot of time comparing themselves to others. According to ‘Do I look Fat in This?’ by Sharon Kirkey, “Women who overhear others engage in fat talk are more likely to fat talk themselves and to experience heightened body dissatisfaction.” This shows individuals who are surrounded around people who have dissatisfied with their body are more likely to experience it themselves.…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She claims most people are reluctant to seek medical care because health specialists are some of the most prejudiced people there are (Worley 165). She believes physicians will treat a person’s weight before treating what is actually wrong with the patient and attribute many complaints or ailments to that person’s weight, and believes that these types of pressures can lead to the quick end of a fat person’s life (Worley 165). What Worley seems to be ignoring is the fact that being fat that can lead to many diseases, which have been previously stated, that will lead to the shortening of a fat person’s life, not being told they are fat by someone whose job is to keep people healthy. Even so, in recent surveys it was found that thirty-one percent of nurses and one in three doctors said that obesity was a condition to which they responded negatively (Ansfield). This survey of four hundred doctors supports Worley’s claims of prejudice fat people face from health professionals.…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Being Fat Is Not Ok Most of Americans are currently realizing that obesity is bad but being fat does not related on their health condition. Thus far, According to Paul Campos, the author of the essay “Being Fat Is Ok” for Americans, being fat is considered to be ok because he said that there is not enough evidence to show that this condition is a problem. The continuous condition of being overweight can lead to obesity for many people which will result in the obesity epidemic which affects people’s health. In facts, obesity has negative health effect such as diabetes, high blood pressure, and increase the likelihood of a stroke.…

    • 1634 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, it’s not only an individual’s personal problems that play a role in developing this distorted obsession of body image which leads to eating disorders but also public problems like social media. Tiggerman (2002) claimed that “the media puts severe pressure on women of all ages to be a certain size. Repeated exposure to such images may lead a woman to internalize the thin ideal such that it becomes accepted by them as the reference point against which to judge themselves” (92). Even though, it’s hard not to be influenced by media, it’s not only to be blamed for setting the standards of beauty because it constantly portrayed in every outlet possible. An article from Brown University explains that, “People with negative body image tend to feel that their size or shape is a sign of personal failure too and that it is a very important indicator of worth”.…

    • 1846 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Individuals suffering from obesity in most cases are always discriminated by the rest of the people that they associate with in their daily lives, this is because many people do not take time or do not completely understand the reason some people may suffer from obesity. While it is true in some cases that obesity is caused by just overeating and a lack of exercise there are also several metabolic disease and conditions that lead to obesity due to their bodies inability to regulate hormones in the body correctly. Since there is no way to distinguish between those obese individuals who have made personal life decisions and those who are effected by disease they all inevitably get lumped into the same category. In many instances, some people take advantage of these situations to mock them while referring to their huge sizes or deformed body figures (Wang, et al, 2014).…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays

Related Topics