The Death And Life Of Great American Cities Summary

Good Essays
On the topic of Jacob’s ideas to discourage criminal behavior, she is an open critic of the common theory of improving cities’ vibrancies by making room for more green space before considering whether the new parks would be properly integrated . If a park is located in “a low-traffic area such as the residential edge of a neighborhood, ” misallocated green space can become “havens for transient populations or criminal activity ,” and become the type of place where teenagers go to abuse drugs or criminal activity happens. Jacobs was a supporter of encouraging further testing and observation of greenspace models to “broaden understanding of the relationship between green space and health ,” but she recognizes that if the greenspace is not misallocated …show more content…
Her first book called The Death and Life of Great American Cities was written as a critique to the failing 1950s urban planning policies that led to the further decline of many already struggling neighborhoods, it was her most popular book and it ignited a spark of controversy among urban planning professionals in the field . Jacobs’ called this popular piece “the relation of the function to design in large cities.” One thing that Jacob criticized in her book was how the government supported the many urban planners who wanted to inject failing cities with big monopolizing industries along with areas of town specified for only one type of industry with the assumption that large industries would stabilize the economy because of “better internalization of the rewards to innovation” and good business experience would attract more capital than local competition . Unlike most urban planners at the time, Jacob’s theories supported that “variety and diversity of geographically proximate industry promote innovation and growth” where a batch of many types of local business led to the strengthening of the city’s economy . Models of both types of local business economies were tested by Glaeser and colleagues resulting in “negative evidence on MAR’s design…and consistent with Jacobs’,” with MAR being an influential urban designer in support of monopolizing industry at the time . To further enhance the importance of The Death and Life of Great American Cities, Jacob’s argues that her theories about urban economies do not only strengthen one community at a time, with many growing cities comes a growing region, resulting in a well-developed nation because of efforts started at grassroots levels . Because of universal application of Jacob’s theories become especially important as populations

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    According to a research that was done in s Hartford, Connecticut, using community policing helped lower crimes. The police were not charged to just stop crimes as they happened but to be more present in the neighborhoods that would help prevent crimes. They also carried out programs to improve the appearance, safety, and use of public spaces. Along side community policing, one of the programs created was the security in the public parks. Parks can be refurbished, lighting installed, and opening and closing times scheduled to improve security.…

    • 1260 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Her effort and passion in urban study significantly impacts the traditional ideas of urban planning. She accuses that traditional urban planning theories in that era (1950s) are catastrophic and can bring many negative impacts to a city. In the previous three paragraphs, the ideas that planners should leave sidewalks to children and should preserve old buildings are novelty and favorable ideas to me, because that focuses on a city’s soft power. A city’s humanistic spirit is critical. However, the slumming and unslumming theory is doubtful to me.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Mengdi Ec330 6.4.2016 How Cities Make People Richer Glaesar introduces his book by explaining that cities are made of flesh, rather than concrete. The city has triumphed in economic and technological ways through the provision of opportunities that lead to a further increase in opportunities. It is a foundation that Glaesar bases his arguments, especially in the aspect of how cities have made people richer by the minute. Being an elaborate and renowned economist, Glaesar centers his arguments on the fact that human contact, especially in the city, enables the populace to grow in terms of trust and cooperation. (p 35).…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    During the 1920’s America was hit with a time of poverty and despair, later to be known as the Great Depression. It’s hard to pinpoint what exactly caused this worldwide depression but there were many contributing factors, such as the lack of diversification, the poor credit structure of the economy, and the unstable international debt structure. Economists argue that if the government implemented more structure these causes could have been avoided, but no amount of government support could have stopped the economic decline. Before the Great Depression only certain industries controlled the wealth in America, essentially the construction and automobile industries. Relying so heavily on just certain industries increased the chances of sending…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If anything is forced to remain stagnant it dies” (Betancur 10). Just like what this quote states it is true that gentrification increases the value of a place and improves the entire physical conditions of urban areas; however, the urban renewal activities drive the poor away from the mainstream culture and move into the margins (Lipman 146). According to Zukin, escalating real estate prices and expensive stores have helped marginalize the people who initially contribute a neighborhood its authenticity characteristic such as immigrants, the working class, and artists (___). As a result, the poor are forced to live in communities suffering from economic shortage. Those minorities often feel powerless engaging in resistance; therefore, they accept how much they get paid for their properties.…

    • 2140 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The limited transportation obstructed the possibility of interconnectedness between cities and towns in the U.S. , which also obstructed the possibility for a thriving industrial economy. Throughout the Market Revolution and years after, with the construction of canals such as the Erie Canal in New York, and the growing sizes of roads, better transportation for people and goods was made possible. Cities could transport goods to one another at a much faster rate because the new transportation was quicker and could carry more at a time. The government sponsored internal improvements such as canals and, in later years, railroads, provided exactly what was needed to increase product and demand throughout the nation. Thus, the economy and cities experienced their own substantial improvement.…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Jane Jacobs: Badass

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages

    She valued small mom and pop stores and being able to look out her window and see her community. Jacobs took on the role of advocating for these values when they were being threatened, specifically by Robert Moses. Moses, known as New York’s “Master Builder” was determined to build an expressway through Upper, Mid and Lower Manhattan, displacing half a million people. He believed “A city without traffic is a ghost town.” His proposed Lower Manhattan Expressway would span from Chinatown to Greenwich Village, Jane Jacob’s beloved neighborhood. She fiercely opposed this expressway, and Moses’s ideal of city planning.…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    To Protect and Serve: The Progressive Expansion of the Police During the depression at the end of the 19th century, the Bradley-Martins, New York socialites who were determined to organize their most extravagant party to date, spent large sums of money to host a costume ball. This ball was highly criticized throughout the country due to the public’s antagonism towards the wealthy and prevailing public opinion that the elites were living wasteful lives. While the Bradley-Martins argued that they were throwing the party to stimulate the economy, it did not stop the Bradley-Martins from receiving police protection. Theodore Roosevelt was ordered to watch for people “likely to prove dangerous from an anarchistic viewpoint” (McGerr 5). This standoff was the quintessential example of society’s conflicts as the previous Victorian values of our society were replaced with modern values.…

    • 2181 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    During this era, companies turned into powerful industries, and our society changed into a more urban one. The Industrial Revolution had many positive effects because it caused citizens to unite, it led to urbanization, and created a huge increase in economic growth. Although, with the Revolution came long and tiring work hours, child labor, and pollution. Today, in the United States we still uses these benefits, but we also have to face the consequences that come along with it. We would not be the same country we are today without the Industrial…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    On the Left side some Americans claimed that it had gone too far and some claimed it didn’t go far enough. In their minds Roosevelt didn’t try hard enough to change capitalism and thought that the First New Deal gave too much power to businesses. On the Right Side Americans targeted Roosevelt, saying that he tried to intervene too much and the Court struck down most of his Legislation. In order to counter this, he started the Second New Deal, and also moved to the left politically. Although the Second New Deal greatly helped the Depression by creating a powerful social-welfare state for the well-being of American Citizens, there were still critics.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays