Am I Black Or White Belonging Analysis

Improved Essays
Belonging is often closely linked to identifying with a particular group of people.
A retrospective view of human history shows that for centuries, the intervention of cultures has grown steadily, and as a result people have now mixed cultures and created sub-cultures of belonging - but there are still many conflicts regarding personal and communal identity. Belonging comes from an understanding, or the knowledge that an external sense of being comes from an internal sense of connection and safety. The concepts of belonging are excellently demonstrated in two highly differing texts - ‘The One Day of the Year’ by Alan Seymour and ‘Stolen’ by Jane Harrison.

‘Stolen’ tells the stories of five Aboriginal children - Anne, Ruby, Shirley, Jimmy and
…show more content…
Anne understands and appreciates the comfort, security and wealth her white family have provided her - and can continue to provide her. However these comforts cannot dissuade her longing to feel at home - a sense of belonging that her indigenous family can provide. Her indigenous family advises her to “stick together” against the whites, who have raped their women, grabbed their land and stolen their children. The question, “Who are you?”(28-29) points at the identity, social, racial, cultural and spiritual problems. There is the realisation as the play ends, that the place that the children belong - is as part of the stolen generation. The forcible removal of Indigenous children from their families was part of the ideology of assimilation - which was founded on the assumption of black inferiority and white superiority, proposing that Indigenous people should be ‘bred out’ through a process of natural elimination, or, where possible, should be assimilated into the white community. Children taken from their parents were taught to reject their Indigenous heritage, and made to adopt white culture - their names were changed, and they were forbidden to speak their traditional language. This way of thinking posed the thought process within the children that not only did they feel that they did not belong within white culture - they were taught from a young …show more content…
Anzac Day, which is central to the nation’s understanding of itself and its identity, comes under attack but the play is bigger than just Anzac Day and deals with Australian identity in general. The son Hughie is the new Australia who, with access to education, can change himself. The characters of ‘The One Day of the Year’ are also caught between two realities - the parents have a sense of belonging in the pre-war era - a time of female domesticity and traditional values; the other reality being a time of education and wealth for the younger generations. This education promoting radical and free thinking - challenging the way of life their parents have set for them. The parents sense of belonging is slowly being pulled from them as the younger generations begin to challenge their long-upheld

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Fly Away Peter Analysis

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Australian and New Zealand Army Corp. (ANZAC) soldier was born in this war and exemplified the masculine Australian described in the discourse. Malouf uses the war as a context because it is unique among global discourses due to the view that it holds that WW1 was a foundational event in the Australia’s national history. Otto (2009, P.36) states that WW1 is viewed as a moment which exemplifies the masculinity of Australians as described in the national discourse. However, Malouf uses the war to contrast the reality of the war with the imprecise descriptions the discourse provides. Firstly, he uses the event of the protagonist Jim Saddler going to the Western Front to represent the innocence of Australia as it went into the war.…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Burquini Hits The Beach

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The famous Australian play “The One Day of the Year” by Alan Seymour explores various conflicts over ANZAC Day in the 1950’s in a working class family from Sydney’s Western suburbs. Since then, opinions on gender roles and cultural diversity in Australia have changed and so have ideas about Australia in general. This is also closely examined in Ellen Connolly’s article ‘Burquini Hits the Beach’, written for the Sunday Telegraph on February 4th 2007. The text reveals a plan by Surf Lifesaving Australia to introduce new uniforms that conform to the guidelines of Muslim culture regarding women’s modesty. This was created by a program named “Call the Same Wave”, which was established after the 2007 Cronulla riots.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Her rhetorical questions challenge and persuade the readers to question their values and to hear the experiences of a whole race’s experiences as in the example “how must it be, to be children who have been snatched from their mothers and systematically stripped of culture, language, rights and dignity? How must it be, to be… Stolen children? Her way of convincing us to empathise with the dilemma faced by the Aborigines is through the sense of moral outrage of their treatment. Making us recognise the huge importance of giving them a chance to speak about all horrifying experiences that they went…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Struggle of a Native How can a country move forward if they still cannot respect the givers of their history? Quite frequently, our modern society ghettoizes and segregates our Native people without rational reasoning. Day to day, people are viewing our Natives in negative ways and often face them with several unnecessary challenges. Still, there is no change being made to these unfortunate circumstances, and our First Nations are currently struggling to be accepted by our society. These reoccurring concerns reflect on their struggles and adversities that greatly affected our first nations in the past.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Relationships and experiences shape an individual’s sense of belonging. To what extent is this view represented in your prescribed text and ONE text of your own choosing? Introduction…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tomorrow When the War Began: Ellie and Homer The novel, Tomorrow When the War Began, by John Marsden, uses characters that reflect the independence and strength of Australian youth. They have strengths, intelligence and abilities that allow them to take control of their situation and survive. Ellie and Homer show this best. John Marsden has created a typically Australian novel because he has set the book in a stereotypically Australian environment, a small country town surrounded by the bush.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Australia day commemorates the anniversary of the arrival of the first fleet on the 26th of January 1788. To some, it means the beginning of the dispossession of aborigines and the lost of their culture, but to others that was the birth of a great nation. This time of the year sparks many debates on whether Australia day should be celebrated or not. Chris Berg contends that the emergence of Australia as a great and powerful nation cannot be pinpointed to a certain date, nor is the 26th of January necessarily a date to rightfully celebrate on in his article ‘there is much to celebrate on Australia day’, in which he adopts an evaluative tone. Alternatively, in her article ‘changing the date won’t fix Australia day’, Celeste Liddle argues rationally…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anzac Spirit Analysis

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Villers-Bretonneux, a town in France, is home to the main Australian World War One memorial, Musée Franco-Australien, Victoria School and Restaurant le Kangourou. The meaning behind its Australian atmosphere and influences are quite remarkable and displays the pure qualities of ‘Anzac Spirit’. These qualities include endurance, courage, ingenuity, good humour and mateship. It is believed that, “The only thing necessary for evil to triumph, is for good men to do nothing” (Edmund Burke, Goodreads.com, 2017).…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racism In The Sapphires

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Thought I told you Abos to get off my premises” (Noelene). The gravity of racism exhibited in the film is a strong reminder of the inequity and discrimination that Indigenous Australians faced both then and now. Body Paragraph 2 – Cultural differences…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Lands were claimed to be their own, for purposes of resources and creating new markets for their own citizens. The process of colonisation has the nature of civilizing, removal of the indigenous culture and replacement of the western cultures, values and beliefs (Cunneen, 2008). For example, thousands of indigenous children were removed from homes and were placed in European families. This assimilation policy prevent them from practicing their own culture and speak their own language, which in turn gradually removes their own cultural identities (Marchetti & Downie, 2013). Moreover, the majority of them were confined within the white families and were deprived of liberty and ultimately lacking the opportunity to prosper (Cunneen, 2008).…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    An individual’s interaction with others and the world around can influence, alter, one’s behaviour, actions and beliefs. However, various external factors influence an individual such as, positive and accepting environments an individual’s sense of belonging can enrich and expand, while negative behaviours such as exclusion and rejection might limit and restrict it; this in turn moulds one’s sense of acceptance and value of being. This idea is explored in the picture book, The Island by Armin Greder which analyses segregation and discrimination, and further alludes to the strong xenophobic culture and how such ideals can influence the experience of belonging.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I could not help but think about my own life after reading “Jimmy, Was Huck black” and the readings out of the textbook. Essentially Shelley is proposing the argument that Huck could have been black because of his dialect. They are simply saying that Huck was a black boy hidden in a white boy’s body because of the broken English and terrible grammar that he used throughout the entire novel. It really makes me ponder the question “What makes me black”?…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Belonging is an essential division of life for individuals and a group as it creates a sense of security and trust, and can in turn influence beliefs, experiences and perspectives people have on the world around them. Belonging to a group involves effective communication with other individuals and a sense of security on both sides. The exceptional memoir The Happiest Refugee by Anh Do reveals how belonging to a group can influence one’s life course, morals and values, both positively and negatively. Having a positive sense of belonging can lead to having an easy and comfortable relationship, which in turn can lead to having a better outlook on the world. Anh and his family belonged to Vietnam, but left because of the war going on at the time.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Drew Hayden Taylor’s Sir John A: Acts of a Gentrified Ojibway Rebellion, tells the history of Canada’s Indigenous People. The play shows how Canadian Confederation created a lot of resentment and mistreatment for Indigenous people which is still felt today. The play is divided between two different eras; 19th century Canada with Sir John A MacDonald and present day where the characters debate MacDonald’s legacy and the impact of his policies. MacDonald’s character describes important historical events his monologues highlight that his focus and duty as prime minister was to ensure national unity and promote patriotism but this cost Indigenous people their land and sovereignty.…

    • 1875 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the “The Phenomenology of Gift Giving”, Helmuth Berking (1999), the author, explores the causes and mechanisms of gift – giving as a social practice. He maintains that the gift – giving is an essential part of reciprocal communication between individuals. Berking also suggests that both the gift and reciprocation to it corresponds to the established structure and character of human relations in a community. Berking (1999) starts by pointing out that gift – giving as a practice transferred from a political and economic sphere into the area of personal relations.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays