Advantages And Disadvantages Of The Tuskegee Experiment

Improved Essays
After reading about the two cases, Subject to Aboriginal Experiments and The Tuskegee Experiment, I can’t help but wonder do researchers who began with good intentions, become selfish people that lets their experiments lose its moral in order to obtain their goals. Its immoral that researchers tries to take advantages of those at a disadvantages, such as those hungry children and poor black men.
In general, experiments should first be approved by the Institutional Review Boards, and even if its approved, no freedom should allowed when researchers are conducting their research. Especially experiments that contain potential harm to the subjects, should be closely supervised and regulated. From past examples, we learn that sometimes researchers can become so obsessed with their research that they would strip their subjects’ human rights and dignity. For example, in the Tuskegee Experiment, “even after penicillin became a standard cure for the disease in 1947, the medicine was withheld from the men. The Tuskegee scientists wanted to continue to study how the disease spreads and kills.” The poor black men weren’t even given a slight chance to choose to their fate. Therefore, to not
…show more content…
Or else, like in case four, the Yanomami, who weren’t truly informed about the truth behind the research, created an uproar about their disapproval of the researchers violating their cultural values. This is why a way to be fair and respectful to the subjects is necessary. Also, under any circumstances, subjects should be given the right to excuse themselves from any experiments if they wish

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Benefits

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The question is simple. Is the person’s personal rights over their tissue more important than contributing to science and research to benefit the common good? I believe that a person’s rights to his or her own body is more important. Scientists seem to exploit people for samples of cells only to make a profit.…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In Harold Varmus and David Satcher’s article, Ethical Complexities of Conducting Research in Developing Countries, the main argument presented is studies done in the Third World not only follow bioethical principles, but also benefit the research participants. Varmus and Satcher justify the ethical decision of conducting research in the Third World by noting that they are actually serving those populations because previously, there was no one to help them. Furthermore, Varmus and Satcher explain the context of their research and what ethical difference it makes. They do this by mainly explaining the use of the placebo group. For one, “a placebo-controlled study usually provides a faster answer with fewer subjects” (Varmus and Satcher 1997).…

    • 217 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unit 731 Research Paper

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In most developed countries, human experiments are very rarely done and are usually substituted by animals such as laboratory mice. When a human experiment is absolutely needed, most of the time it needs to be approved by the government and the people partake in the experiment do it completely voluntarily. The Declaration of Helsinki provides the general outline for how a human experiment should be done if it is ethical. Overall most of the declaration claim that the person involved in the research must do it completely voluntarily. They must also have all the information and procedures about the experiment beforehand and the benefits of the experiment must outweigh the costs.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lastly, there must be an ethical selection of subjects. The Belmont Report states, “they should not offer potentially beneficial research only to some patients who are in their favor or select only "undesirable" persons for risky research” (The Belmont Report). Researchers must be far when selection their research…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pros And Cons Of Muskegee

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There is also the issue of whether resolving the conflict between the two opposing sides will solve the problem the policy seeks to resolve. The risk is merely shifted to another population with the potential it will increase the safety of the overall population. Thus the policy as it was initially drafted, no matter how it plays out, the risk for some will continue for thousands of years. Yet a policy that bring about a solution that reforms the energy production would have been better suitable since it eliminates ‘new’ risk. This again contradicts the principles of US and Muskagee society.…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The treatment of human subjects in research has evolved dramatically over the past century. Society has witnessed maltreatment and abuse, and in response, has pushed for oversight and ethical standards for scientific study. In this posting I will discuss some points of the “Tuskegee Syphilis Project” including why the men chose to participate in the study, if the study violated respect, beneficence, and justice, and if this study would be approved today with current regulation and safeguards in place. In the beginning, the idea of the Tuskegee study had merit.…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics and morality have been of great philosophical interest to me from the time I was a child. It is mind boggling the spectrum of which we recognize good and evil and the relativity of opinion that ensues. I am always humbled by the findings and arguments made by such studies as the Stanford Prison Experiment conducted by Philip Zimbardo. Where participants of the study seamlessly assumed their roles as prison guard or prisoner in which progressed an environment of abuse and lack of empathy for the powerless. I assume many of the psychological mechanisms, which cultivated such a grotesque but profound experiment where in place when conducting the Tuskegee Syphilis study.…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kennewick Man Essay

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As modern technology advances, genetic testing has become more advanced and accurate than ever before. In the case of the Kennewick Man, also called The Ancient One, it has been a tool that has helped with a controversial issue. If the bones of the Kennewick Man are given to Washington state, the continuance of the research would lead to a greater outcome for the rest of humanity. However, one can argue that the culture of native tribes of Washington must be respected. Furthermore, it is important to recall the usefulness of scientific discovery.…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In class I learned about the Tuskegee study and the different types of drugs used and abused by Nazis and German physicians. The Tuskegee study is very important because it has a huge impact on how we conduct research today. The Nazi and the people who did the Tuskegee experiments are very similar because they either used drugs or innocent people for their own selfish reasons. German doctors gave methamphetamine drug Pervitin to Nazi soldiers to enhance their energy to fight better in World War 2. The Germans supplied them with this drug because the idea was that they can turn a regular guy into a super soldier.…

    • 236 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ethics This essay will discuss the ethical safeguards for clinical research that may not apply to evidence-based projects. Additionally, this essay will discuss ethical controversies related to two ethical exemplars. In conclusion, patients’ ethical responsibility in improving healthcare will be explored. Ethical Safeguards Clinical research involves the study of investigational analysis of data or experiments that involve humans.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tight living spaces, dirty environments, and chemicals being injected into your body every few hours. Is this how you would like to live your life? As an experiment for everyone to gain knowledge on. No! In an essay written by Jane Goodall, which addressed the cruelty chimpanzees go through when treated in research laboratories; Goodall saw stark actions being placed and harsh surgeries performed and knew she had to help make people aware of these situations.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From 1946 to 1948 the United States and Guatemalan officials infected soldiers, prostitutes, and mental patients with syphilis and other sexually transmitted diseases without informed consent. The researchers claimed that “The goal of the study seems to have been to determine the effect of penicillin in the prevention and treatment of venereal diseases.” Although, penicillin therapy was given to 76% of the subjects only about 26% of the therapy completions were fully documented. Francis Collins, the current Director of National Institutes of Health, said that these experiments are “a dark chapter in history of medicine.” Furthermore, this example is a reason why regulations such as informed consent and others should be enforced to limit some of the freedoms of the researchers, to…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The HEW Final Report had concluded, “fundamental ethical rule is that a person should not be subjected to avoidable risk of death or physical harm unless he freely and intelligently consents. There is no evidence that such consent was obtained from the participants in this study.” (Brandt, 1978, pg. 26) as the main point of unethicality in this experiment. It was most definitely a big part of it, but the blind eye towards the obvious racial intent of the study could be argued to be just as unethical of the HEW. Dr. Clark and Vonderlehr both went into the experiment talking badly of the men in Tuskegee, speaking as if they were another species entirely.…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The research I conducted gave me a new view and influenced my thinking to produce the claim: In some cases, morality plays a role in human experimentation. The research provided ample information to how many cases of human experimentation has justification as well as morality in most cases. For example, an article I read was about how human experimentation has many rules were made to ensure safety among the subjects. Committees of distinct individuals (RECs) help rule out unethical and dangerous experiments to protect the wellbeing of humans. They provide a professional and lay POV, and an experiment can be ruled to be unethical if not known about in these committees.…

    • 638 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, the individuals who were recruited by the USPHS were not privy to all of the information and were taken advantage of due to their lack of education and poor economic status. Furthermore, even after penicillin was found to be an effective cure, patients were withheld from treatment. According to the Belmont Report, a document that came about in 1978 notably as a result of the Tuskegee study, If a physician proceeds in his interaction with a patient to bring what he considers to be the best available techniques and technology to bear on the problems of that patient with the intent of doing the most possible good for that patient, this may be considered the pure practice of medicine. In addition, the report published by the National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research affirms that experimental and treatment programs represent two distinct fields of biomedical research and they should only be conducted if the benefits outweigh the risks.…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays