Positive Money Research Paper

Good Essays
Positive Money’s sovereign money proposal: Could it work?

Under the sovereign money proposal proposed by the forward thinking group positive money, the power to create money would be taken away from the banks and given to the central banks. Banks would therefore serve two purposes; a transaction function with which people stored money until they needed to spend and this money would be secure, the other a lending and savings function with the banks acting as a middleman between savers and borrowers. But could this system effectively work if brought into to somewhere like the UK and what would be the advantages and disadvantages of bringing in such a system.

In the current system in the UK the vast majority of money (97% of it (1) ) in circulation
…show more content…
Within the current system as stated earlier on 97% (1) of money is in bank deposits which are effectively liabilities of the bank of the bank and are very dependent on how well the banks are doing and how their affairs lie. We have seen the most recent crisis that banks have failed often due to poor investment decisions which led to deposits within banks frozen, the banks then had to be saved so that their customers could avoid losing their money. It shows how the banks were more inclined to take risks in the knowledge that government intervention would be on hand in order to save them, this meant that economy was dependent upon banks who were willing to take risks in the knowledge they would be save, this is not a sustainable environment. This problem would be overcome under the sovereign payments system, investments and lending of banks would become entirely separate to deposits in banks in transaction accounts meaning that their money would exist in the central rather than a liability for the commercial banks. So if banks were to fail due to risky or poor investments then the transaction accounts balances could be easily transferred to another healthier bank as it was stored at the central bank and not lost in poor investments. This would be a huge advantage of switching to the sovereign money system as it would overcome a huge problem that …show more content…
Currently in the Uk when there has been a financial crisis like the one of 2010, banks have been unwilling to lend money and there has been a lack of credit due to the perceived risk of default by consumers, which leads to further economic difficulty due to the lack of credit and therefore consumption. Sovereign money could provide an answer to this problem as the central bank would be in charge of creating money it could create money in these times in order to try and counter act the crisis. Money creation could be altered easily during the cycle in order to soften the extremes of the cycle; reducing money creation in the booms and increasing money in the busts and recessions. This would help lead to a more balanced economic

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Debt Problem Essay

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages

    If the bank helps, it reduces the risk of lending bank 's reputation and ability of the banking business. Whichever bank is more risky than the other will operating inefficiently. This impact on the reputation of the bank makes the customer 's trust in the bank is reduced. It will directly affect the amount of customers who send their money to the bank and use of banking services, so the scale of banking operations were affected, thus, financial will be losses. In addition, if the bank does face many risks in lending, the possibility of bankruptcy of the bank is very…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    • Funds borrowed from other financial institutions Finance and accounts department is the main department who runs the whole RICBL. The weakness of the department is that they face a shortage of funds and they borrow a fund from other financial institutions. Opportunities • Adoption of better software for BRS The Finance and Accounts department has an opportunity to adopt a better software for BRS (Bank Reconciliation System), to minimize a workload of the department. • Adoption of IFRS The department is planning to adopt a new system that is IFRS which will help the investors/shareholders to better understand investment opportunities. Threats • Hacking of system • Staff turnover • Embezzlement or misrepresentation of public…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    During this period banks funding sources dried up quickly and they found themselves short on cash to cover their obligations (Olagunju, Adeyanju, and Olabode, 2011). There is a general sense that banks had not fully appreciated the importance of liquidity risk management and the implications of such risk. As result, policymakers have suggested that banks should hold more liquid assets than in the past, to help self‐insure against potential liquidity or funding difficulties (BCBS 2010). Holding of liquid assets such as cash and government securities generally have a relatively low return which imposes an opportunity cost on a bank. In the absence of regulation, it is reasonable to expect that banks will hold liquid assets to the extent they help to maximize the firm’s profitability.…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Many businesses and consumers had lost confidence in banks. After the banking crisis, many companies significantly reduced the investment and led to long-term economic negative growth and rising unemployment. More seriously, the banking crisis caused a global economic recession. In order to address the negative impact of the banking crisis, the Financial Reporting Council released the Stewardship Code. And Independent Commission on Banking Reform published a Vickers Report.…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    (Brett Child, 2011) 2. Disadvantages Firstly is credit score and interest rate. Although the business has chance to persuade lenders to lend money to them, the interest rate will still be based on credit score. If the company has terrible credit, P2P may refuse the loan requirement, or give higher interest rate. At the same time, ignore the payment would also influence you credit rating badly just same as banks.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Gfc Case Study

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Financial innovation Another reason attributable to the GFC, which was regarded by David T Llewellyn as the ultimate cause of this catastrophic recession, is the emergence of new financial innovations such as CDOs, CLOs and MBSs. These financial instruments adopted to lower the risk and create a more easily accessible market for borrowers, were of extreme use, hence brought about the inverse effect. Moreover, since these innovations require the separation of different tranches of lending activities, there has been a mismatch of interest between lending and borrowing entities. Thence, perverse incentive was formed leading to the unnecessarily risk-taking behaviour and the adverse-selection problem. Banking sectors, which frequently deemed to…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    India 1991 Case Study

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This led to an economic crisis in India in 1991 as foreign exchange reserves dipped. Banks were unwilling to give loans to new people and cash outflow from India started occurring at a rapid rate. The Old Economic policy was focused on protecting the domestic producers. They were restrictions on import, high import duties in order…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One of the ways to avoid discretion, as outlined in the concept of organization literature, is to make the foreign banks only depend on “hard information”. This however decreases the significance of foreign banks for the economy as a whole, since one of the main tasks of banks is to utilize “soft information” which unknown marketplaces on their own would not be able to13. Private local banks do not have the advantage of foreign banks in terms of access to external liquidity. This raises the concern, particularly in emerging markets with fragile regulation and legislation, that private domestic banks would be prone to “looting” leading to banking crises and catastrophes (see e.g. Akerlof and Romer (1993)).…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ap Euro Case Study

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Similar to conditions in the United States, at this time, many banks in Europe to realize that they may have overleveraged themselves. This caused the leadership to start looking for a solution to this problem. At the same time, these banks did not want to decrease their lending abilities with higher interest rates. Because of this, many European banks started suffering extreme losses on loans defaulting, particularly in the housing industry, causing some of even the biggest banks to fail. This led many of these banks to begin requesting bailouts and reimbursements for losses they took from their respective governments which in turn looked to the International Monetary Fund to bailout the governments.…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Doubts In China

    • 1790 Words
    • 8 Pages

    So significant capital leaving will trigger off the chain reaction that people who see the stock market goes down significantly will also sell their shocks before the subsequently devaluation. for maintaining their money. So the price of the stock market will go down in response of this. Also, some investors who already invest the real property and interests of saving money in bank will also seek to other stable ways to make money. With a huge proportion of Chinese investing stock market, these draining in China financial market will effect the domestic economy negatively.…

    • 1790 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays