Essay It Real: School Success Beyond Black And White By Prudence Carter

Improved Essays
The wealthy and privileged receiving preferential treatment in the education system was supposed to end long ago in the 1950’s. Prudence Carter, in her book Keepin’ It Real: School Success Beyond Black and White shows that the great inequality still exists. She observes the relationships between gender, ethnicity, and culture as it applies to a group of low income students in Yonkers, New York. Carter’s research reveals that the work of reaching equality in education is far from finished.
One issue Carter tackles is the term “acting white.” “Acting white” is a phrase that is understood to reject standard educational values, but in reality it refers to a cultural barrier that exists in schools. The term “acting white” has been used for years, its roots stretching back to the times of segregation and intense racism in
…show more content…
As the general sentiment moves away from that notion a new connotation has taken shape. “Feminization of achievement” is the recent idea that the standard definition of achievement is contradictory to the view on masculinity in nondominant cultures. Gender roles placed on individuals from childhood cause them to be steered in different directions when it comes to what they have learnt. Girls are steered in a direction that may lead them to perform better in school while boys are not given the sames essential skills. Carter argues that they are taught skills that will help them survive. Skills like when to fight and when to flee, and how to talk on the streets. She shows that these lead them to “dangerous activities” that cause conflicts with the traditional school setting. Since the skills they learn do not apply to education as much as the skills girls learn do, a gap has formed for minority students with girls outperforming boys. Even the career expectations for boys are much lower than those of girls and lower percentages of males wish to pursue a professional

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The fact that they cannot be educated along their white peers inherently suggests that they are less valuable as learners and future members of society. Considering the horrific injustices, they had to deal with in the past, this inherent feeling and tone established by segregation makes complete sense. Further, a feeling of inferiority affects not only the sense of worth of the student, but also the students will or ability to take in educational opportunities. It takes away their motivation (183, 32). Even if students are given the resources they need to learn, such as teachers and textbooks, it does not necessarily mean that they will do equally well.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some argue that it is society’s fault and not the school’s, and that students of color should assimilate with the white students. This is problematic because it forces oppressed groups to accept racism in schools and to ignore the benefits of diversifying culture. Additionally, anti-racist education has been implemented by some schools. The Oregon School Study Council passed antiracist curriculum that had students write their reactions to racial incidents, to create a racism-free zone. The Ames Middle School Multicultural Club is a school program that allows student to empower themselves by sharing about issues of oppression and learning about numerous ethnic traditions and experiences (McLean).…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She points out that this might also be a deliberate strategy as quieter students are not disciplined as easily when they are acting out as the louder ones. In this way, teachers tend to expect certain kind of behavior from boys and girls and the gender-bias works as a self-fulfilling prophecy. These are just a few examples of the type of segregation based on gender that tends to happen in a classroom environment on a daily basis. Teachers are often oblivious to the gender stereotypes that they include in their teaching, and therefore are not aware of the possible consequences their actions…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Segregating Adolescents

    • 1725 Words
    • 7 Pages

    It was junior high happening all over again!” (Kid’s Quill). This shows how even though the girls had learned to be competitive and assertive, they weren’t used to being around males, making them become less assured and confident. Wouldn’t it be better for adolescents to be in an environment where they learn to interact and become confident with the other gender, so they can carry these skills into their future? Men and women need to be able to cooperate with each other, because most likely in the future these men and women will be colleagues. There is no way that the world can advance and become a place that people are happy to live without both genders being able to work together.…

    • 1725 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, a young girl who thinks she is not smart will more than likely fall behind in school whereas a student who believes they are good academically will more than likely work to succeed. All three play a role in the process of an adolescent becoming at-risk. All of them alone do not cause a youth to become at-risk, however, they play a role in the deterioration of how the youth see’s themselves, feels about themselves, and, believes what they can accomplish (McWhirter,…

    • 1020 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An argument for why dress codes are there is to help prepare teenagers for jobs, and the rules also apply to boys there is just not as many. School dress codes can appear to be sexist towards girls for a lot of reasons. One of the bigger reasons why dress codes appear to be sexist towards girls is because most of the dress codes rules revolve around girls. One of the more important reasons for having a dress code for a girl is so they won’t be seen as “a distraction”. In an article written by Laura Bates she mentions how schools want “a distraction free learning environment.” When they are saying this schools are…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The behavior of a four year old seldom warrants such extreme punishment, and black students certainly do not behave in ways that call for disciplinary action more frequently than white students, they are just disciplined more frequently for those behaviors. Due to this, a black or brown student is much more likely to have a disciplinary record, which will be passed from school to school according to FERPA. A disciplinary record influences the way administration views and handles a student. The prejudgment that can stem from a record causes placement in lower-level classes or alternative schools and an increased likeliness that further disciplinary action will be taken against the student. The racial bias that led to a suspension at a previous school for a minority student can result in a lower quality education at a different school, due to the legislation that appeared to be written to protect the privacy of all students, but just mainly defends the educational rights of white…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This situation lessens the improvement of learning for the girls, which can then lessen the improvement the education for the country. In addition, the girls will not feel comfortable in the class. For example, the boys always want to show off for the girls that the boys are smarter than them. Furthermore, girls will participate less when there are with boys in class in order…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is seen that lack of social skills cause “low academic success” (Nedium). The reason behind why lack of social skills cause low academic success is because they are both domains of school life and are interconnected. In other words, if a child struggles with not having any social skills they are more than likely going to also struggle with not having much academic success. School is not only a place where children learn reading, writing, and math. It is also a place where they learn to get along with other people and develop social skills.…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    School delinquency and ability grouping are linked in one study, finding higher rates of delinquency in students placed in low tier classes (Jenkins 1995). Since teachers in low tier classes may have lower expectations of their students, as well as less encouragement for future success, these students can suffer lasting damage to their self-images. Often, this feeling of incompetence can lead students towards delinquent acts, as well as less commitment towards school due to a lack of motivation. In extreme cases, students may even result to dropping out of school. Many minority and low socioeconomic status students face this inadequacy, believing they are naturally unable to succeed in school.…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays