Stereotypes Of A Happy Slave

Superior Essays
One of the main stereotypes promoted by these documents is the idea of a happy slave. They were portrayed as overgrown children who had to to be guided by their masters. George Fitzhugh believed that without enslavement Blacks would, “freeze or starve”. Furthermore, he and Hammond believed that “the negro race is inferior to the white race”. Unsurprisingly, these stereotypes even included some sort of biological basis to explain the condition of slaves. Dr. Cartwright believed that drapetomania was a disease unique to the slaves that caused them to run away. According to Cartwright unless the slaves were “frightened or panic-struck”, they would become “sulky and dissatisfied” before they ran away. The cure was to whip “the devil out of them.” …show more content…
Thus, ‘free negroes’ were particularly prone to the skin lesions not as commonly seen in slaves. The slaves who were prone to mischief did not do so intentionally, rather they were victims of this disease. Ruffian believed that the mental inferiority of slaves "prevented high grades of intellect” even in the North where they had access to schools and colleges. Fitzhugh justified the institution of slavery with his idea that the slaves were overgrown children in need of constant supervision and care from the plantation owners. He believed that their inability to take care of themselves required the White plantation owners to help the Blacks through the institution of slavery. Their inferiority also ensured that they would not be able to survive in the competitive free world. Therefore, in order to prevent them from dying of starvation and severe weather, they needed to be slaves. According to Cartwright, this position of White superiority was god given. The slave had to be taught his position of "the submissive knee-bender" both by kindness as well as by punishment when required. Hammond believed that the sole purpose of the Black people was to be slaves. He justified …show more content…
In reality, they had grown so accustomed to the life of comfort and idleness that they projected that onto the slaves who lived miserable lives. The abolitionists terrified them, as they were fully aware that the slaves would choose their freedom over being subdued on plantations. It is very ironic that while the proponents of slavery perceived these slaves to lack intellect and be childlike, they trusted them to raise their children. Thus, white children and their black enslaved nannies faced a unique situation. The children inherited these nannies as part of their estate and the enslaved nannies had to raise their future masters. Furthermore, the fact that many black women slaves were speaking out about their experiences of being sexually assaulted and raped probably caused them to worry incessantly. Thus, they convinced themselves that these were people who deserved to be enslaved. They used everything from religion to natural law to justify their doings. When all is said and done these were the words of men who were scared of the future devoid of slavery and the resulting profit. Thus, they even reasoned that slaves were more happy and free because of being

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    There is a common accepted historical narrative that portrays the antebellum era as one fraught with prominent, white figures who owned slaves who were subservient and complacent. This commonly accepted notion of what slavery was like depicts slaves as individuals who simply accepted their fate and did not opt to exercise any form of agency. This notion that slaves did not try to actively resist the confines of slavery is untrue and is illustrated by the work Kindred by Octavia Butler, Black Thunder by Arna Bontemps, and Django Unchained directed by Quentin Tarantino. These creative works of historical fiction do accurately represent how slaves were treated but also, perhaps more important how slaves resisted such unjust treatment. The three aforementioned pieces were all created at different period of time.…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George Fitzhugh was a pro-slavery advocate that called on his audience to understand that slavery was necessary to maintain order and harmony in American society. Fitzhugh strengths his argument through his use of mythological and historical allusion. His use of mythological allusion is seen when he compares slaves to“young Herculeses born with teeth” and abolitionists as “ Serpents who attempt to strangle them in the cradle” (Fitzhugh 366). Through his reference to the myth of Hercules, Fitzhugh tries to transmit the idea that slaves were safe in their environment until abolitionists decided to intervene.…

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marlene Choi September 25, 2016 SOC 222: The Family Instructor: Naomi Gerstel TA: Yolanda Wiggins 9:05am-9:55am In the reading “Reproduction in Bondage,” from Killing the Black Body, by Dorothy Roberts, the author discusses the conditions black females had to endure during 1800s. During the 19th century, white men dominated the majority of Africans in slavery. Most importantly, black procreation helped sustain slavery and gave slave masters an economic motivation to govern black women’s reproductive lives.…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unfavorable conditions, such as starvation and beating, symbolize the idea of romance between slaveholder and slave as the poor treatment portrays the downfall in their relationship. One image Douglass describes in particular is the memory of, “the cruel lashings to which these slaves were subjected” (21). As Douglass encountered many distinct slaveholders throughout his life as a slave, slaveholders would commonly torture their slaves without any provocation. One slaveholder specifically, by the name of Captain Auld, would tie up one of his younger female slaves, and whip her between four to five hours at a time, in Douglass’ memory, for no apparent reason. This tortured slave had no use of her hands, and had also never proven to be problematic.…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In general, slavery played a major part in American colonization and became the standard for all colonies and the African American slaves were heavily populated in the Northern and Southern colonies because of the Southern colonies had tobacco plantations and they needed laborers to work their land so, they can make a profit. In short, the Atlantic Slave Trade was established by the Spanish colonists in the Sixteenth century to help solve a need and because they were the most experience sea mariners during that time (Robin, Kelley, Lewis, 2005, p. 7). Therefore, slaves became the cheapest laborers in the colonies and this forced labor continue for centuries and some people of the colonies began to believe that this was the way of life. The…

    • 1778 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unsurprisingly, Douglass conveys that the life of the average southerner was the complete opposite, and slaves were hardly treated humanely. Southerners saw their slaves as animals who were greatly inferior to them. Douglass recalls when he is young that when his aunt was whipped by their master, “no words, no tears, no prayers, from his gory victim, seemed to move his iron heart from its bloody purpose. The louder she screamed, the harder he whipped; and where the blood ran fastest, there he whipped longest” (5). His shocking account of this event was effective in asserting his criticism of a southerner’s idealistic portrayal of slavery.…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Leigh Seeley February 22, 2018 In the 19th century, black men, women and children, commonly known as slaves, were subjected to terrible treatment by those who imprisoned them. From the paternalistic attitudes, to the poor living conditions and then finally, the resistance to the barbaric practice, slavery was a common (but horrifying) way to live life. Paternalism was based around an agrarian hierarchy where the master is at the top and is responsible for supporting all lower ranks (wives and children of the male slaves). This system helped the slaveowners to justify slavery because it hid the brutal reality of slavery and allowed slave owners to think of themselves as responsible and kind people.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sarah Ruan Professor Garvin History 11 4 June 2015 Takaki Paper #1: The Hidden Origins of Slavery (Chapter 3) When one thinks of the origin of slavery, they commonly think of the profit that the South was able to make off of it. Although this is a major origin and would explain why the institution carried on so long, the text in this chapter gave me a different understanding of the history of slavery. The author, Ronald Takaki, gives us a feel of the early colonial foundations of Virginia and the progression of slavery.…

    • 1574 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The South was as secure in their conviction that slavery was a proper institution as the Minutemen who turned the British back at the Old North Bridge were in theirs. The insulation of the South allowed these convictions to thrive without serious opposition in local communities. With everyone thinking and therefore voting the same way it was easy to keep slavery alive for decades. Insomuch as they believed the proslavery position was unfounded in reality putting forward idealized and sometimes fantastical ideas of Southern society and slave holding. The slave’s perspective was very much real where even in the best position slaves still felt the fear of sale and control by whites.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Slavery is a significant part of how the United States came to be. It caused several divisions and controversies, creating several different laws. Slavery began to increase in the year of 1793 when Eli Whitney invented the cotton gin. The cotton gin allowed more cotton to be produced, providing more money to farmers. Therefore, rapidly causing an increase in the need for slaves.…

    • 1832 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Slavery in the United States tore the nation in two. Slaves started to rebel against their slave owners through acts of both nonviolent and violent rebellion, which played an enormous role in the abolitionist movement. The social, political, and economic impact of the rebellions reached far beyond the Civil War, giving black Americans a newfound identity. A day in the life of a slave was tiring.…

    • 2057 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To start from a Pro-Slavery point of view, George Fitzhugh was a Virginia lawyer and the author of two books and various articles that advocated slavery. Fitzhugh's famous words "…the negro race is inferior to the white race, and living in their midst, they would be far outstripped or outwitted in the chaos of free competition. " This was one of his arguments presented in "The Universal Law of Slavery." In this document, Fitzhugh also argued that slave owners were perhaps doing their enslaved people a favor, allowing the women to do little hard work, and on average, in good weather, never work more than nine hours a day. The slaves were given a roof over their head, rent free, and were provided clothing, food and water.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This final paragraph is dedicated to the misconceptions and discrimination regarding slaves. As discussed in previous chapter, slaves were seen as property, a property to do with as a master saw fit. This paper also discussed how having the mindset of being superior over another person can warp the mind and nature of a person. This paragraph will expand on the misconceptions of slaves, which did not fit into the previous two chapters. One aspect that is critically important is the understandings that people had regarding the nature of slaves.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Olaudah Equiano Thesis

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages

    For a human being to be treated as nothing but product displays an evil that will not soon be suppressed at this time in history, but instead will grow and worsen. This article paints a resplendent image of just how poorly the Africans were treated. This wretched mistreatment also creates a spark for what, in the future, will be a total division of a developing country. This shows that the slaves were rightful in their want for freedom. Who would want to live a life where they are ripped away from the ones they love and the homes they’ve hailed from, and forced to succumb to a life of toil, sickness, and sadness?…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Literacy is the defining term that differentiated slaves from their masters. Slaves were kept from any connection or exposure to literacy, more or less reading and writing. In addition, by keeping them in constant mental neglect, the masters ensued their predominate power and wealth across the south in a time of prejudice and racial ideologies. As a result of becoming self-aware and knowledgeable of slavery’s demeanor and its injustices, Douglass contradicts the status quo in the South. This knowledge consists of the evident cruelties in slavery and how the masters hid themselves behind the justifications of their actions through religion and law.…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays