Frederick Douglass Criticism

Improved Essays
The United States’ constitution allegedly adheres to the promotion of civil liberties of the American people, but in reality, persecutes the African Americans held in bondage. Frederick Douglass shines light on the persecution of his race in his narrative. Douglass was born a slave, yet died a free man. He fought hard to educate himself, and to establish himself as an intellectual human being, rather than an object for ownership. After he escaped slavery, he made it his goal to educate the public about his experiences as a slave. His eloquent public speeches, and his famous autobiography increased awareness about the wrongs of slavery, and encouraged people of all races to take a stand against it. His belief in human rights is prevalent in …show more content…
Specifically, he argues that the United States government is hypocritical. In his narrative, Douglass states, “I’m coming to a fixed determination to run away, we did more than Patrick Henry, when he resolved upon liberty or death. With us it was a doubtful liberty at most” (86). Douglass alludes to Patrick Henry to argue that Henry demanded liberty or death for his nation, so the slaves should be able to fight for the same liberty. Douglass purpose in alluding to Henry was to expose the hypocrisy in slavery, and to argue that the slaves should have the right to the same liberties that the United states was founded off of. In A Brief Notice of American Slavery and the Abolition Movement, Estlin argues that a nation that declares that all men have natural rights, then going against this claim by Constitution is hypocritical (45). The fundamental nature of the United States is based off of the idea of freedom and rights. Estlin argues that this claim is hypocritical because the Constitution blatantly deprives the slaves of the freedoms that the United States allegedly possesses. Also, in Constitutional Aspects of Slavery, Torodash discusses the idea that Jefferson condemned King George III for depriving his people of proper rights, yet the United States government deprives slaves of their rights (234). Torodash reflects on the United

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    He wants to disclose how slavery became an intrinsically American. The argument is solid because he analyzes the society that enforces slavery to reveal the circumstances. Because Douglas was born into slavery and realized that it was not “true to the life” (Douglas, 1000) he was able to appeal to slaves that thought their state was natural. Americans govern on the false beliefs that religious and economic arguments verified a reason for African Americans to be inherently lower to Americans; they belonged as the enslaved. Douglass makes a clear case that slavery is not sustained through the natural superiority of Americans, but through education and strategies that will hold power over Americans.…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    After he had passed, Douglass became one of the foremost figures of the abolitionist movement. Douglass' narrative exploits the advantages made in order to abolish slavery, by not only to evince the public on the malevolent, degrading adversity slave drivers loaded on their slaves, but to civilize the slaves that had been negatively affected regarding to the Southern institution of slavery. To embellish every horrific detail, to aid in his fight to abolish slavery, was what helped his objective. This influential narrative parallels Douglass maturing in life through all the struggles to uncover the power and dedication to demand the freedom for himself and all. This document was more than mere propaganda to solely contend in opposition to slavery, it was a testimony of a political purpose to provide abstract queries, with freedom as the subject, to personally define which side of the debate was just.…

    • 1200 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Frederick Douglass used his own life experiences to highlight the effects of slavery on society and how he discovered the pathway to freedom. He discussed how slavery was the deprivation of knowledge from slaves in order to manipulate them into thinking that slavery was the only option for them. Throughout his lifetime in slavery, he was exposed to various events that helped him form an idea of freedom. Douglass believed freedom was achieved by granting knowledge and education of the tyrannical practice of slavery to slaves so that they might be able to break through its bonds. Douglas’s definitions and meanings behind them were critical for the advancement of abolition during this time, such that abolition might not have happened in the manner it did without…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Growing Westward Expansion

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages

    He disagreed with Confederate states secession from America. Abraham Lincoln’s ideas were similar to Frederick Douglas’s ideas. Douglas argues that America has blinded themselves from the true American freedom. He tries to draw attention to the equality slaves deserve by affirming the equal manhood of the Negro race (Unit 4, Douglas). Lastly, stating that America has become a hypocrite, drawing attention to federal laws that are in favor of slavery.…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Western Expansion

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Contradicting this law is the Fugitive Slave Law and the right to punish anyone who resists the re-enslaving a man on the coast of America. This indicated that the same Constitution Americans used to protect human rights is the same Constitution Americans used to justify their unconstitutional actions. William Lloyd Garrison provides another moral point of view in “The United States Constitution” (Doc E). Many use the fact that the word slavery is nowhere mentioned in the Constitution to justify slavery. Garrison in this document, however, clearly states his belief that the government is the enemy of slaves.…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This quote is an example of how Banneker appeals to Jefferson’s feelings and emotions, since he states his beliefs of natural rights but commits a criminal act against slaves and does not practice his belief towards them.The colonists were under the control of Great Britain for a long period of time. During this time, the colonist believed that their natural rights were being abused by the British. That exact feeling that the colonist felt, is the same feeling the slaves have under the rule of the colonist. This was how Banneker…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He is correct to say that the South is not alone in its sin against Blacks. The North was indeed responsible as well. However, as Tindall and Shi point out slavery was the main reason for war. They state, “To argue that the Civil War was primarily a defense of liberty and the right of self-government…ignores the actual reasons that southern leaders used in 1860–1861 to justify secession and war” (Tindall and Shi 497). The leaders of the south wanted to keep slavery and they went to war over it.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Delano proclaims, “’You are saved: what has cast such a shadow upon you?’” (257) and Cereno answers, “’The negro’” (257). The ambiguity of this dialogue between Delano and Cereno puts the institution of slavery in question to Cereno and to humanity. Cereno has always believed that African Americans were inferior and loyal to their subordination, but he has been proven wrong. He has underestimated the intelligence and ability of enslaved African Americans and what they would do to earn their freedom. The knot, that has been woven and wound so tightly, is now put into question by European whites who experienced the enslaved advance through their revolt without suspicion and discovery until the end.…

    • 1557 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They viewed abolitionist’s states as hypocrites, betrayals of the long standing surviving and economically workable law of the land which is slavery. People like John C. Calhoun one of the important figures of pro slavery politicians towards the fugitive slave law of 1850, stood before the US senate insisting “That South Carolina will lead the way in defending its rights to hold slaves. He went on as far as arguing that “the federal government has no right to touch the institution he argues and defend, warning that the fact that abolitionists controlled the press, education and pulpit may bring about a civil war if not contained.” He threatened. slave masters argues that we take care of our slaves, we feed them and as long as they continue to provide food for their slaves, they don’t see any other fundamental rights slaves needs since they are considered less than humans in anyways. So it’s like having a Dog who is non-human, but all you can do, provide him with food and he follows your orders probably slave’s animals receive far more better…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas Jefferson and James Madison wrote against having slavery in America. Madison, in The Federalist article 51, says that a civil society ends when a “stronger faction can readily unite and oppress the weaker.” When the weaker are “not secured against the violence of the stronger,” then “anarchy may as truly be said to reign.” If the people want to continue to have their liberty, then the government must protect the weak. The slaves are a perfect example of the weak. They have no rights and are being oppressed by white people. Anarchy was reigning during the creation of the Constitution because the Southern states were threatening secession if the government restricts slavery.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays