What Was The Great Depression Analysis

Improved Essays
What was the Great Depression?
The Great Depression was the deepest and longest-lasting economic downfall in the history of the western industrialized world.
What were 2 long term causes of the great depression? 2 of the long term causes were Industry and Agriculture, railroads lose to trucks, buses, and cars. Coal loses 50% to hydroelectric, natural gas, and oil. Farms over-produced during WW1 to face europe. 40% declined after the war.
What year did Hoover get elected, and describe the 3 things he believed in. How did it prolong the depression?
Hoover got elected in the year 1928. He believed in Rugged individualism which means that people should succeed through their own efforts and take care of their own families. He believed in Voluntary
…show more content…
Details: The National Youth Administration (NYA) gave jobs to 2 millions high school and college students, but the wages were low and the jobs for people were not equal
Analysis: It was a failure because the government spent too much money and it didn’t end the great depression.
Evidence from docs: The image from document 4 showed that the new deal was a failure because the president has way too much power than the congress and they’re trying all the new deal programs and laws that doesn’t seem to be working.
Details: On the document the old man representing America is trying all the new deal remedies and it seems that nothing is working and America is not getting better.
Analysis: New deal was a failure because after all the laws and programs that we’re created, America didn’t get any better and it just made us lose money.
Evidence from docs: Document 3 says that more new deal laws and programs were created.
Details: More new deal laws and programs were created and the government spent too much money for these laws and
…show more content…
Analysis: The new deal was a success because it gave benefits to elderly, kids, and disabled every month to sustain their needs.

Conclusion
Was the New Deal a success?
The new deal was a failure, because after all these bunch of laws and programs that were created, still, america is worse and it didn’t end the great depression. In the form of relief, the new deal was kind of a success because it helped the people get jobs to sustain their family’s needs for a while but that didn’t last long, every programs closed down for it’s own reasons. That’s why the New Deal was a failure.
Do you think it is the role of the U.S government to intervene like FDR did, or do you believe that Hoover’s response was more aligned with the intent of the federal government.
I think that it is the U.S government’s job to do what FDR did. They should have tried the anything approach. Find ways to end the great depression, make america better. Instead of what Hoover did, just wait and see what is going to happen because there will be no progress if there’s no work done. The very first step is change, change all the things that’s bad and make it

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Roosevelt Administration and the New Deal were economically ineffective in overcoming the Great Depression and rebuilding the U. S. economy. As it stated in document two, Congress gave the Public Works Administration 3.3 billion dollars to create jobs and public work projects. The evidence supports that the government wasted 3.3 billion dollars to try and rebuild the United States economy. This example in economically ineffective because the government is now in debt. This corporation didn’t successfully help America, so it was a complete bust in trying to get out of the Great Depression.…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Chapter 7: (The Spoilsmen: An Age of Cynicism) The Spoilsmen were also known as Robber Barons or Captains of Industry. From 1865 through the Industrial Revolution, they controlled most of the wealth, and thought that since they or their parents worked hard to get it they deserved it. The Republican Party was corrupt at this time, and was more successful than the Democrats. All the Republican Presidents during this time period were corrupt in some way, and even the leaders of the Republican Party were corrupt, men like Roscoe Conkling and James G. Blaine.…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The aim of the New Deal was for the government to create Alphabet Agencies that would disburse money into providing jobs for the poor and unemployed. These led to action in helping industry and agriculture, resolving the banking crisis, more money spent on goods, an increased demand for these goods and increase in the production. In order for Roosevelt to be so successful he had to earn the trust of the US people. The population was used to being ignored and to suffer alone as Hoover left the economy to fix itself, which was ineffective.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    New Deal DBQ

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages

    If the New Deal was truly a successful program, they would put in extra effort to help those in need. The New Deal barely scratched the surface when dealing with unemployment. Document 5 is a table and graph showing the unemployment rates from 1933 to 1945. Although the New Deal did decrease unemployment rates, it never got it back to the average 4%. The only time unemployment rates did return to normal was at the start of World War 2, which is too late for the New Deal to be called a “success”.…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Document 4 also emphasizes the fact that the U.S was being thrown further into debt and that FDR’s programs were not quite doing the job. America was still in a record-breaking recession even with New Deal programs, so how much of a difference were they actually making? All of the job programs and changes to inefficient industries actually gave millions of Americans a place to start; those who found work were able to continue developing in a healthy way that would set up a stable foundation for their own life. Lastly, document 5 depicts the unemployment rates from 1933-1945 and that it took nearly a decade to bring the unemployment rate to under 5%. While it took that long to bring down the…

    • 1536 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Great Depression was a long term economic event that the American people experienced from 1929-1945. Many people were unemployed and unable to gain any incomes to support their families, leaving many homeless. Prior to the Depression, Herbert Hoover was elected in 1928 when the economy was still enjoying the Roaring Twenties. Hoover believed in three things which included rugged individualism, voluntary cooperation, and that the economy would experience had natural cycles. Hoover introduced rugged individualism which was individuals helping themselves.…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dbq Essay On The New Deal

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many New Deal programs turned the lives of the struggling around and made a bond of trust between them and their country’s leader. If it wasn’t for the positive effectiveness of FDR’s programs, the American people would most likely not have the hope they had to strive for a better future and work harder to overcome the Great…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    There were different opinions surrounding the effectiveness of this New Deal. According to history professor Roger Biles, the New Deal was an effective answer to the Great Depression. However, Gary Dean Best, who was a history professor thought that it wasn’t the correct solution for the Great Depression. I also agree with Gary Dean Best because the stock market, in later years crashed again, but at the same time FDR did a great job…

    • 1370 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to Document 2, the New Deal was a huge step towards both Socialism and Communism. The New Deal contained many programs which allowed the government to exert its control over corporations and is continually promoting labor troubles, highers wages, shorter hours, and less profit for business. If the government continues executing the New Deal, it will ultimately fail and would end in disaster for the entire country. Not only would the New Deal end in disaster, it also costed the U.S. government billions of dollars. As shown in Document 3, the government started with only 16.9 billion dollars in debt in 1929, but ended with 44 billion dollars in debt in 1941.…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Herbert Hoover’s philosophy about the function of the federal government was individualist in nature as well, meaning that he viewed a decentralized federal government with most of the day to day intervention being in the jurisdiction of the local and state governments. He was distinctly against the communist and socialist ideas that were spreading through Europe creating centralised authoritarian governments. Instead his individualist mentality resulted in a response through decentralized initiative, “…to avoid the opiates of government charity and the stifling of our national spirit of mutual self-help.” For Hoover that spirit of self-help is what separated the United States from succumbing to revolutions that plagued Europe.…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People believed he was the ideal president to battle the great depression, because of his background and strong understanding of the economy. When the economy got worse he urged the citizens to volunteer, to make the economy better. He wanted to get everyone involved to fix the economy. He supported federal public works to stimulate the economy, asked strong banks to help weaker banks, asked farmers to help each other, and also asked business leader to keep wages up. As the depression started to get worse and worse, Hoover’s plan seemed not to be working.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1929 the stock market crashes. Millions of dollars are lost, around 80% of families have no savings to fall back. (A) Many people’s money is tied up in stocks. One out of every four people is jobless (C), 28 states do not have any banks and 200,000 homeless children wander the country.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though, both unemployment and hours worked were cut by an alarming 25 percent in most sectors. FDR 's biggest feat was when he devised the New Deal programs, which sharply increased federal spending to offset the unemployment crisis and increase American spending power. Essentially, this was the start of government welfare and intervention to ensure the success of our nation 's economic capital. One of the largest government job opportunities created from the New Deal expenditures was the Works Progress Administration (WPA), it employed over 8 million Americans to better roads and parks throughout the nation.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    More money was spent on advertising than on education in a year. $6 billon goods were on credit. 80% of American families had no savings. In the last 60 days of 1933, 600 banks closed. By 1933, 28 states had no banks.…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Great Depression was an economic shortfall and a time of hardship that affected America and the rest of the world. The depression began when the stock market crashed on October of 1929 and ended in 1939 when America started to plan for World War 2. Many people 's lives were ravaged and some were taken during these dark times. This event was the longest and most atrocious fiscal hindrance that America has ever experienced. The Great Depression definitely changed the culture of America, positively and negatively.…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays