New Deal DBQ

Good Essays
The Great Depression was America’s lowest and longest downtick throughout Western history which was an after effect of the Stock Market collapse in 1929. There were many short term causes that contributed to the Depression, but the two main long term causes were agriculture and industry. Farmers made a living by growing crops and providing food for the war raging in Europe. After the war was over, the farmers income dropped and they upturned their land. Since there was a severe drought, the soil collected and was picked up by strong winds creating a Dust Bowl which, in the end, put all farmers out of business. Along with this, technological advances made it harder for existing companies to stay afloat. Railroad companies lost to trucks, buses, …show more content…
Nowhere does it mention the New Deal benefitting the minorities. In fact, Document 7 states that the New Deal discriminated against blacks. They received unequal pay, lower employment rates, poor living conditions, and little to no support from the president. FRD was too afraid to lift bans against lynching and abolishing the poll tax, putting his person wants before the people’s. This shows that the New Deal was only targeted to help whites and didn’t take into consideration the already struggling minorities. If the New Deal was truly a successful program, they would put in extra effort to help those in need. The New Deal barely scratched the surface when dealing with unemployment. Document 5 is a table and graph showing the unemployment rates from 1933 to 1945. Although the New Deal did decrease unemployment rates, it never got it back to the average 4%. The only time unemployment rates did return to normal was at the start of World War 2, which is too late for the New Deal to be called a “success”. Document 4 is a political cartoon that exposes the realities of what really went on between FDR, Congress, and America. FDR is bossing Congress around and Congress does everything FDR asks. Each bottle is labeled with a New Deal program but none seem to be helping Uncle Sam. This represents New Deal programs not curing the conditions of the Great Depression and FDR …show more content…
Although the political cartoon in Document 4 is meant to expose the flaws with FDR and the New Deal, it also shows FDR’s willingness to try new ideas, even if some fail. This is an important trait when trying to fix a national dilemma such as the Depression. More jobs for women opened up and through them, they were able to benefit the community by educating youth (Doc. 1). Through the education, there were higher chances for them to get jobs and to help rebuild the economy. With people with more jobs, the economy could return back to normal faster. Lastly in Document 6, the Works Progress Administration was providing hot food to unprivileged youth and jobs for women. Again, more jobs opened up for women and would expand the economy for the better. Slowly but surely, New Deal programs did affect society in positive

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Dbq The Great Depression

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Great Depression began on October 29, 1929 and was the worst economic depression in the history of the US. One cause of the depression was concerning the industry. Unemployment rates began to increase when new advancements in technology led to everyday workers being laid off. For example, railroad workers began to lose their jobs because trains were beaten by automobiles. Another cause was due to the overproduction of crops caused farmers to drop prices.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The meager income and poor soil were further worsened when drought struck the plains of southern Alberta and Saskatchewan in 1934 and again in 1937; the scorching wind blew the topsoil into fine dust which forcing the farmers to abandon their unproductive desert. Grasshoppers and wheat rust further contributed to the crop failures as they destroyed the remaining crops that were struggling to survive. Almost nothing could grow under the onslaughts of nature. In terms of yield per acre, prairies wheat production had dropped to an historic low in 1937. This was less than one third of the yields achieved in 1928.…

    • 2455 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Great Depression, starting in 1929 on Black Tuesday, was the crash of the United States economy. During that time, 25% of Americans were unemployed, and millions lost their savings due to bank failure, leaving them poor and frustrated with the government. Causes of the Great Depression include the overproduction of crops and the deduction of consumer spending. After WWI, the demand for crops dropped 40%, lowering the prices of food, and forcing farmers to produce more to meet their budget. They tore up roots that had been holding the land in place to make room for crops, and combined with a drought and high winds, started the Dust Bowl.…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Before 1931 farmers in the midwest made a living from selling their crops, but after that it was completely different. The Dust Bowl was also known as the “Dirty Thirties” because of how dirty people would get and how dirty everything was after the huge dust storms. A decade of rains ended in 1931, which lead onto a long drought Farmers didn’t use dryland farming methods and it caused the dirt to lift up. With big winds, the top layer of dirt lifted up and caused the huge dust storms. The drought came in three waves, 1934, 1936, and 1939–40, but some regions of the high plains experienced drought conditions for as many as eight years.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Although people were getting paid more, it still couldn 't help the government from having a downfall. Lastly, in Document 7, it gives the idea that the New Deal promotes racism. It states that the NRA offered whites first dibs on jobs and segregated them from the blacks and offered the blacks lower pay. Soon after, the FHA refused to offer blacks mortgages when trying to buy a home in white neighborhoods and segregation camps were held in favor of the CCC. This resulted in a higher unemployment rate and the president failing to support bills to help blacks due to strong willed Democrats who didn’t want to bother with the subject of race.…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Drought threatened another disaster in the 1950's, prompting Congress to subsidize farmers in restoring millions of acres of wheat back to grassland. (“Dust Bowl”)People lost their homes, their farms, and some their life. People couldn’t live in a farm, and farm anymore with the amount of dust destroying everything in its path, and no fresh water, only dirty water filled with sand. Before the start of the Great Depression, there were 25,000 banks in the United States. By 1933, almost half of those banks (11,000) had failed.…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Both events resulted in troubled times for people and workers. People lost their homes, suffered from malnourishment and seemed to be struggling to make it through the day. This book focuses on the problems and results of the Dust Bowl, “the worst man-made ecological disaster in American history”. The Dust Bowl followed The Great Plow-up, which “turned 5.2 million acres of thick native grassland into wheat fields”. Eventually, the United States began to enter into the time of the depression and prices for crops began to sink.…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The prices were lower than the crop was worth. That resulted in them losing their farms and that made them angry so they made the government get involved. The government passed the Agricultural Adjustment Act which made a limit on the crop and herd size. The Dust Bowl was giant storms of dust cause by the farmers who over plowed their land and dust covered most of the midwest. It lasted 10 years and it caused many problems such as Asthma, brown plague, the influenza virus.…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In Grapes of Wrath, poverty is stressed through the times of the Great Depression. In the book, “many farmers in the 1920s faced mounting debts that were growing harder to pay. Just maintaining the payment schedule was worrisome and often difficult, and most hoped that better days were around the corner. Instead, the whole economy took a nosedive beginning with the stock market crash in October 1929. The already low prices farmers were paid for their crops sank even lower as the entire nation plunged into economic depression” (“Overview: The Grapes of Wrath” 1).…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Introduction The Dust Bowl of 1930 was the worst environmental disaster in the US history. Poor farming practices and extreme drought greatly damaged the ecosystem in the Great Plains. [1] The Dust Bowl was a man-make environmental destruction that completely transformed the landscape. Strong winds blew away an average of 480 tons of topsoil per acre, degrading soil productivity, harming health, and damaging air quality. [2] The wind removed the topsoil and the remaining dry soil was not suitable for vegetation growth.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays