What Is The True Meaning Of Silence By Shashi Deshpande

Improved Essays
Extra-marital relationships are a part of Deshpande’s novels. In this novel, Jaya has a fruitful relationship with Mr. Kamat, a widower, Jaya’s neighbor in Dadar. The most striking quality of Kamat is that he sees Jaya as an equal. While Mohan discourages Jaya from writing, it is Kamat who introduces her with the ‘lost’ self. Jaya sheds her restraints in Kamat’s presence who gives comfort in a fatherly way. Her failed writing and her close association with Kamat are two example of Jaya’s inability to seek her own identity. Kamat makes her aware of her emotional as well as physical needs and asks her to break her silence and speak freely. In spite of his support and encouragement, Jaya leaves him dying because of social …show more content…
As she puts it, “You learn a lot of tricks to get by in a relationship, Silence is one of them. You never find a woman criticizing her husband, even playfully, in case it might damage the relationship” (Deshpande, 41). The novel is not an autobiography, except for certain parts dealing with the frustrations of an unsuccessful writer. Shashi Deshpande has presented an Indian woman as she is in India of the eighties and not as should be. Veena Sheshadri says in her review:
Why has the author chosen a “heroine” who only succeeds in evoking waves of irritation in the reader? Perhaps it is because a competent writer like her is never satisfied unless she is tackling new challenges. Also, she believes in presenting life as it is and not as it should be; and there must be thousands of self-centered women like Jaya, perennially griping about their fate, but unwilling to do anything that could result in their being tossed out of their comfortable ruts in to the big, bad world of reality, to fend for themselves. (Deshpande,
…show more content…
Jaya is “Suhasini” and also “Seeta”, the pseudonym she assumes to write columns about the plight of the middle-class housewife. Both “Suhasini” and also “Seeta” are as Jaya says, “the many selves waiting to be discovered[…] each self -attached like a Siamese twin to a self of another person, neither able to exist without the other”(69). Jaya has to live neither as ‘Suhasini’ or ‘Jaya’ nor as ‘Seeta’ or ‘anti-Kusum’. Jaya was in a dilemma about herself as she says that, “But what was that ‘myself’? ‘Trying to find oneself’- what cliche that has become.”( Deshpande,69). Jaya keeps on oscillating in opinions and choices, yet to decide, “Who she really she

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    His mother, a domineering, half-senile octogenarian, sits like a tyrant at the top of his house hold, frightening off his sister’s suitors, chastising him for not having become a doctor and brandishing her hypochondria and paranoia with sinister a Bandon. It was Sripathi’s children, however, who pose the biggest problems. Arun, his son, was becoming dangerously involved in political activism, and Maya, her daughter, broke off her arranged engagement to a local man in order to wed a white Canadian. Sripathi’s troubles come to a head when Maya and her husband are killed in an automobile accident, leaving their 7 year-old daughter Nandana without Canadian kin. Sripathi travels to Canada and brings his granddaughter home. While his family was shaken by a series of calamities that may, eventually, bring peace to their lives. Guilt-ridden for having refused to communicate with Maya because she humiliated him by marrying out of her caste and race, Sripathi brings his seven-year-old orphaned granddaughter, Nandana, back to India. Badami’s portrait of a bereft and bewildered child was both rest rained and heart rending, Nandana has remained mute since her parents died, believing that they will someday return. In his own way, Sripathi was also mute unable to express his grief and longing for his dead daughter. This poignant motif was perfectly balanced by Badami’s eye for the Ridiculous and her witty, pointed depiction of the contradictions of Indian society she also writes candidly about the woes of underdevelopment. In the course of the narrative, everyone in Sripathi’s family undergoes a life change and in the moving denouement reconciliation grows out of tragedy and Sripathi understands “the chanciness…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Deshpande implores women to discover themselves. Madhu writes the biography Savitribai Indorekar, Doyen of Hindustani music but Madhu doesn’t like writing the biography because she understands that it is not the original order of the story. She thinks that it is she who has the power to make changes in her story. She says, “I can take over Bai’s life ….and make Bai the rebel who rejected the conventions of her times. The feminist who lived her life on her terms. The great artist who struggled and sacrificed everything in the cause of her act. The woman who gave up everything in the cause of her art. The woman who gave up everything - a comfortable home a husband and a family – for love”. (SR 166) People see lives through their memory lane which are sometimes fractured and fragmented.…

    • 2054 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The regional settings in the novel are much relevant if judged from cultural perspective. This novel focuses not on an individual’s story but on how several people make sense of them, view the world around them and deal with the difficulties they face. The novel follows the journey of an embittered old judge Sai, his sixteen-year-old orphaned granddaughter, a cook, the cook’s son Biju. Kiran Desai introduces the characters as they live their life in the background of continuing fights. Throughout the novel there are two different story strands – one following the lives of people in Kalimpong, and one following the immigrant life of Biju in USA. The novel showcases the internal conflicts among different groups and it revolves around the past and present life of the characters. With all these plots the author binds the impact of colonialism, diverse cultural impacts and the identity conflict. Another concept is the political and geographical conflict caused by certain group of people. This is the backdrop of all…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jhumpa Lahiri’s short story collection Interpreter of Maladies has received much recognition since it debuted in 1999; the collection even won the 2000 Pulitzer Prize. Each of the nine stories is filled with details that are capable of captivating any reader and for this reason “Interpreter of Maladies” has sold over 15 million copies worldwide. The stories are about Indian and Indian Americans dealing with a variety of issues. The first story “A Temporary Matter” we see Shoba, a depressed young married woman with memories of her lost baby all around her. Shoba has been secretly looking for an apartment to leave her memories behind and start fresh without her husband who reminds her of their stillborn baby. Even though Shukumar has failed to understand her depression she still has feelings for Shukumar which is preventing her from leaving him abruptly. The next story “This Blessed House” involves a newlywed couple, Sanjeev and Tanima nicknamed Twinkle, two people with polar opposite personalities. Twinkle is a spontaneous woman who wants to be accepted by her husband the way she is. Twinkle’s obstacle is her traditional husband Sanjeev, who doesn’t understand her. Shoba and Twinkle are two different women one is organized, prepared while the other is disheveled, extemporaneous. Although they are different both women are having trouble with their husbands. Who will be able…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In A Time To Be Happy the marriage of Kusum and Sanad is full of tension because of the conflict between orthodoxy and freedom. So is the case of Maya and her deputy collector husband. The conflict, however, is resolved within the bounds of marriage though the values of the male dominated world are not much damaged Rashmi in This Time of Morning takes her conflict with her husband to a logical conclusion and seeks divorce, something not easily imaginable in a typical Indian society. Saroj in Storm in Cahndigarh offers a variation on the theme of conflict between woman’s longing for full life and male chauvinism. She suffers at the hands of her husband Inder, but finally she rebels against him and the house on the face of her husband and takes refuge in freedom.…

    • 1937 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The novel also transcends feminine constraints and raises issues, which the human beings in general encounter in their lives. The novelist’s objective is to show that one should take refuge in the self which means here that woman should assert and ascertain herself so that she can overcome or thrash the suppressing forces. She makes Saritha consciousness to be touched by her experience as a doctor. Saritha realizes that one has to be sufficient within oneself because there is no other refuge elsewhere, puts an end to her problems. She realizes that “we come into this world alone and go out of it alone. The period in between is short.Our society is full of paradoxes and contradictions. Here a female is considered a peripheral member of the family, both in her parent's house as well as husbands. Throughout Saru’s lifetime, she is unable to decide her roots and this leads to her insecurity. As the daughter is closest to the mother, this insecurity is rubbed on to her also. Saritha in confronts reality and, at the end, realizes that the dark no longer holds any terrors to her. She empowers herself to be survive in a male dominated world that offers no easy outs to women. She neither surrenders to nor does escape from the problems but with great strength accept the challenges to face them…

    • 1789 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    She explores extra-marital relationship-pre-marital, in-marital and post-marital relationships in most of her novels. This novel is not a story of an individual but of the institution of marriage, culture and tradition of society while it is threatened by the forces of change and faces dissolution. She considers marriage a very important institution but not a sacred institution. She thinks that fidelity, loyalty and sacredness of marriage are hard for human beings to adhere to and, therefore, majority of men and women find it to be a very difficult institution. Devayani meets Ashok in a party hosted by K. N and Rani at their residence. Ashok, is much older, married and father to a ten year old daughter feels attracted towards Devayani and proposes her unexpectedly. Devayani having a heart of a woman feels herself in a world of love and desires. In these moments of love, Devayani lets herself be ruled by emotions rather than reason. Deshpande is almost obsessively concerned with the inner world of her characters controls by their intense feelings for love which is also the reason of their psychological trauma. They are alienated from the world, the society and the family around them because they fail to meet the challenges of life. Their inability to face life forces them to regress to their…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The novel deals with chaos, despair, ethno-racial and historical relationships between people from different cultures and backgrounds. Love, longing and losses are dexterously handled in a humane manner articulating diasporic experiences of the novelist who is an Indian citizen but a permanent resident of America. Kiran Desai is deeply interested in India- the India of 1980s which honestly represents the mixed image .Desai observes everything through the ‘lens of being Indian,’ without that perspective she acknowledged that she can’t write. The Inheritance of Loss is a novel of implacable bitterness and despair. Full of pathos and tenderness the novel presents its characters as ultimately frail human beings struggling in search of their identity. It was the feeling of being caught between two continents that infuses The Inheritance of Loss — a story replete with sadness over globalization and with pleasure at the surviving intimacies of Indian life. “The Inheritance of Loss is not only a story, it is, a perspective, an inside look into post-independence India, with its roots dug in colonialism, its branches embracing Americanism, but its leaves brown and dusty with the age-old prejudices that govern people’s minds; an India where a class of people still speak only English and squirm at the mention of their mother tongues; where a mother is proud because her daughter has chosen to marry an Englishman: where a foreigner is treated suspiciously in spite of his honest efforts to lay foundations of indigenous industries; where thousands of Indians enter America as illegal immigrants-in the eyes of their families, they are the heroes, but in reality, they sleep with mice on the kitchen floors of restaurants or in squalid suburbs of…

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    There are many issues of gender and sexuality in A Passage to India: the novel includes an “alleged sexual assault on a British woman by an Indian man” (Childs 1999: 348), and the intimate, homoerotic, relationship between Fielding and Aziz, plays an important part. As Childs states, the novel analyses issues of control and resistance in terms of gender, race and sex (Childs 1999: 348.).…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Indo-English Fiction, the foundation was established by the great Indian Novelists Mulk Raj Anand, R.K. Narayan and Raja Rao and others who were followed by the younger generation of novelists like G. V. Desani, Anita Desai, Salman Rushdie, Khushwant Singh, Arun Joshi and so on. As it is evident that in twentieth century man belongs to “Lost Generation”, so consequently some Indo-English Novelists have persistently dealt with the question of the search of the individual for his identity. As the problem of knowing himself has become very acute so Arun Joshi, portrays this problem in his fiction and tries to provide a solution which of course cannot be final. He is perhaps the first Indian novelist who takes up this current…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Abstract : Shashi Deshpande a talented Indian novelist has written boldly on man woman relationship, particularly the relationship between husband and wife, father and daughter and mother and daughter. Person to person and person to society relationship are the main concerns to her. In this novel Shashi Deshpande has shown the conflicts between the mother and daughter. Mother is a traditional woman while daughter is a educated modern woman. Sarita the protagonist of the novel hates her mother. She thinks that her mother does not like her. Her mother forced her to stay within the four walls and follow the traditional route but Saru did…

    • 3092 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This is the condition of many Indian wives who silently swallow the pain, become tough by accepting life as it comes. This paper is an attempt to bring into light the dreadful agony of the protagonists in the novel “The Space Between Us” by Thrity Umrigar an Indian American novelists, who mirrors the suffering of a wife in the hands of a dread full husband, who’s marriage was once based on love, ended up with pain, when the true colours of him are exposed.…

    • 1914 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The plot is like a web made of various complex threads. One of them consists of the Kailash- Mira- and their daughter Rashmi narrative. Rashmi, a product of post independent India had relished every minute of life’s bliss and sorrow. After six years of marriage she returns back to her parent’s home as her marriage to Dalip an IFS officer becomes a deadening trauma out of which …. no feeling could ever again emerge. Alienated and utterly distraught she contemplates separation as she perceives as a similarity between a wrong marriage and prolonged starvation. She is a victim of wrong marriage but unlike Maya she does not confine herself to the cult of domesticity assigned to a virtuous woman, rather she seeks separation, from her husband to fully realize her identity as human being. The impact of the failure of marriage on her sensibility causes an emotional vacuum; life becomes a mechanical affair having no warmth of love. The sufferings which Rashmi experiences during this unhappy phase of marriage have taught her the value of endurance and preservation of life at any…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ray reveals that the nuance of human relationships and social structures often transcend “good” and “bad” and are compounded by multiplicity of influences and intentions (Ray, 1964). For instance, as Smith says, “Bhupati’s desire to encourage Charulata’s skills. This is both a cumulative and authoritative move. This shows compassion and love in his respect for her intelligence and passion for writing, but on the other hand, it also becomes another tool of control and further demonstrates the rift that exists between the couple. As Bhupati pushes Amal to be her “educator”, he is at once suggesting that he himself does not have the time to be occupied with such “trivialities” but his particular approach insinuates that Charulata must be deceived: ultimately she is treated as a precocious child rather than an adult” (Smith, 2014). This kind of irrational outlook on women still exists in today’s modern India: Educated men in India often consider their spouses as obtuse and consider it trivial to educate them. This gender inequality is pre-existing in India from 19th century. Ray and Tagore have been trying to solve this social inequality through their films and literature. Ray has amplified Tagore’s drive to create awareness about this gender inequality by transforming Tagore’s Nashnirh to powerful visuals that are appealing and effective in conveying…

    • 2072 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Socialization plays on important role in the construction of the gender and shows the link between social values and the touchstone of male domination. The gender socialization in the context of Deshpande’s novel A Matter of Time revolves around four generations of women Manorama, Kalyani, Sumi and Aru who are victims of cruelty exercised by patriarchal society where the measure of woman’s successful her married life, without which her all other accomplishments are considered worthless. Through him Deshpande has tried to present the special status and prerogative of men. The whole novel portrays the silent, brooding women, unhappy yet fulfilled adhering to tradition, though living in the present. Though men do not…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays