Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero Or Villain Essay

Superior Essays
Hero or Villain? Noteworthy. Andrew Carnegie managed to overtake the business world by storm. During the Gilded Age, were the economy grew and the rich flourished, he managed to develop wealth and prosper from steel. Despite his actions being genius, they were far from heroic. He should be considered an eminent business man. Andrew Carnegie, although not a heroic figure, is a legend to the business world due to his innovative pioneering, business techniques, and leadership expertise. Furthermore, Andrew Carnegie was gifted with unique ideas. In 1872, Carnegie seized the opportunity to partner with Henry Bessemer, the inventor of steel, to build a steel mill (Document 1). Carnegie realized that iron didn 't possess the capacity to succeed, …show more content…
Carnegie demonstrated his leadership skills with a survival of the fittest attitude. In “Wealth” he expressed this thoughts on how the best were meant to win and demonstrate their winnings (Document 8). He stated, “the duty for all men of wealth is to set an example of modest living…”(Document 8). Through this mantra Carnegie set out to be the best of his league. Although, he desired to be known for his revolution of the business industry, he needed more. This enabled Carnegie to donate back to foundations. Carnegie’s total donation to various charities was a total of 350,695,653 (Document 9). Andrew Carnegie established these foundations briefly after retiring from the business world. His actions indicate his need to be heard one last time. Carnegie demonstrated leadership throughout these actions because he knew what people wanted to hear/see. He mastered the perception of image and knew had to cultivate his own. As a result of this notion, Andrew Carnegie left his desired legacy for the centuries to …show more content…
According to Merriam-Webster, hero is defined as “a person who is admired for great or brave acts”. Carnegie failed to complete actual heroic actions during his lifetime. For instance, Carnegie ignored his worker’s demands and neglected to sympathize with them. Carnegie’s workers were paid $1.46 for a full 12 hours of brutal work (Document 6). Although that was the average pay in 1892, Andrew Carnegie was not the standard boss. Carnegie earned 92,000 dollars daily (Document 7). On that note Carnegie’s workers were greatly underpaid taking into consideration the success of the business they worked so diligently for. Moreover, one would infer that Carnegie would sympathize with his worker because he once was also poor (Document C). Yet, this inference is obviously wrong. For these reasons, Carnegie cannot be considered heroic. Although many will argue that before his death, foundations were set in place to build libraries and fund education, Carnegie executes this for the image purposes mentioned above. An accurate representation of Andrew Carnegie was depicted by The Saturday Globe (Document 10). Carnegie is shown to have two sides, the one he wanted to be portrayed as and the one he actually was (Document 10.) Yet, this does not diminish his accomplishments in the business world. His innovative thinking of vertical integration, popular demand, etc. could not be faked. Therefore, Carnegie

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Steve Jobs: A True Hero

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Jobs was a man that revolutionized technology in his professional career, did not take more money than he needed, and inspired many great innovators with his accomplishments and strengths. Truly, Jobs represents an American hero through all of his achievements personally and professionally. He chooses the part of life where success is fulfillment enough rather than the money, which proves he is the American model for new coming businessmen. Heroism is a symbol of greatness and fearlessness that is represented throughout America. Thus, in a modern world filled with obstacles and challenges, Jobs found a way to leap over as many as he could.…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This class is composed of men such as Andrew Carnegie, John D. Rockefeller, and JP Morgan. These men owned the industries that boomed the economy, from Carnegie owning steel to JP Morgan owning the banks, these men knew that the country was in a great time of prosperity. Their ideology was that of social Darwinism, the reason for them to reach the pentacle of success was because they were the fittest. This ideology was in direct contrast to that of the working class of the nation, who believed that too much money and power in the hands of a select few was dangerous. Andrew Carnegie lived under the belief that the extreme concentration of wealth that he accumulated was essential to America thriving, because with such a vast amount of wealth he could help the rest of the entire country overcome the obstacles that kept them bound to the lowest of classes in the nation.…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The people of this time period should have accepted the wealth in his hands because years later he gave his money back in huge bulks, to educational matters to share with the country, which states that they should have accepted the wealth in few hands because he ends up giving his wealth back in the long run (Hewitt, Lawson). Although there was only wealth in hands of few, he clearly used his power and money for better, to help extend and make this country succeed even more than it already has. One of the greatest quotes I read dealing with philanthropy and Andrew Carnegie would be, “The problem of…

    • 1765 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    While in many cases he was a hero, showing the reality of the American dream and being able able to make it from nothing. It also shows the ideas the business leaders had toward the working class and the ideas the working class the had about the leaders. To the working class Carnegie was just like everyone else, trying to make an extra buck. If that came from cutting wages or trying to stop Labor Unions he would do what he could to make the most amount of money possible. With this it really depends at how you look at Andrew Carnegie.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His strategies of buying businesses and also by buying stocks in certain business was very smart. He would make offers that no one could resist. Example buying Carnegie steel when everyone thought that he would never sell. I think his strategies were very smart moves and worked very well for him. My impression of him was he would look at things and be able to see the opportunity and that is what made him who he…

    • 1834 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Carnegie paid his workers only about $1.81 when they worked for about 10.67 hours, which was one of the highest paying job in manufacturing. Whereas, Carnegie statistically made $9,200 ($92,000 as of today) every hour (Doc I). Also, during the Homestead Strike, Carnegie knew something bad was going to happen but ran off and left his Vice President Henry Clay Frick who used methods that were horrible to get what he wanted (Film).The relationship with his workers is a good reason why Andrew Carnegie wasn’t a hero because even though the pay for the workers were alright, they were working in horrible conditions; it was all hot, loud and gas was given off. He earned a lot of money and didn’t raise their wages for all their hard work but decided to slowly lower it for his own profits. When the laborers went on a strike to get a union, they blocked the company, not allowing anyone to go back in to continue working.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Carnegie paid his workers $1.81 a day for 10 hours a day. Even though this is somewhat good for during the Gilded Age, Carnegie was making $92,000 a day. Carnegie didn’t even bother to give the workers a raise even though he was making that much money (Document I). Carnegie also had trouble with his workers striking during his career. Carnegie refused to listen to what the workers wanted to say and he brought in temporary workers until the other workers decided that they weren’t going to get what they wanted.…

    • 1284 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Andrew Carnegie’s American Dream For Andrew Carnegie, the name of the game was profit by any means necessary. Some may consider him an innovative businessman, yet others could call him a ruthless capitalist that would do anything to make a profit. No matter where Carnegie worked he was excellent at running a successful business. A prolific idea engrained in the minds of Americans since the turn of the century is the American Dream (Livesay 1). This vague concept is exemplified by Carnegie’s capitalistic views of a newly industrialized nation.…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Even if wealth was measured by knowledge, Bill Gates would still be the richest person in the world. As a man with extreme ingenuity, and expert business skills, Bill Gates has a net worth of over 78 billion dollars and is considered the most affluent being alive. Coming from a privileged family, Gates’ was taught the importance of good work ethic, and working hard to achieve his goals. As more of an introvert, Gates was pushed to be more social, so he was sent to a private school in hopes that he would find people who shared similar interests as him. Bill Gates’ passion for technology helped him found and shape Microsoft, developing the company into a worldwide phenomenon that overcame legal obstacles: and with the urge of others, Gates’…

    • 1525 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    History Of The Gilded Age

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Gilded Age was defined as the time in America as the time between the Civil War and World War I during which the U.S. population and economy grew quickly, there was a lot of political corruption and corporate financial misdealing’s and many wealthy people lived very fancy lives. This time had major roles in the development of the country. Entrepreneurs used this time to meet the demands that were needed and help grow the nation. However, during this time the economy was torn between the two realities of the lavish life of big business against the lie of poverty. The rich lived glamourous lives spending tons of money while the other people wore rags and were living in cities with crime and filth.…

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays