Why Is Louisiana Purchase Unconstitutional

Superior Essays
Through history people believed that some choices made by presidents were unconstitutional or they abused their power as president. The purchase of Louisiana made by Thomas Jefferson is one of the events that happened in history were people believed that the choice he made to purchase Louisiana was unconstitutional. The purchase of Louisiana made by Thomas Jefferson was constitutional and he didn’t abuse his power as president. There was nothing in the constitution that said the president couldn’t buy land from foreign countries. He bought Louisiana to avoid future war, collect new resources, and lastly it the purchase would expand land.
On April 30, 1803 the land of Louisiana that was owned by Spain then given to France, was bought by Thomas Jefferson, president of the United States that current time. Thomas Jefferson who was a strict constitutional follower was shamed and argued upon saying that he shouldn’t of have bought the land from a foreign country. Thomas Jefferson bought it from French minister Charles Maurice de Talleyrand. Jefferson knew that he had messed up on buying it but had many reasons to do so. To expand America and avoid the future war that was to come if Thomas Jefferson didn’t buy Louisiana.
…show more content…
People were angry that the president did a action that would surpass the president’s power. Also many believed that the president shouldn’t allow other nations to join the U.S and incorporate their government.” It destroys the perfect union contemplated between the original parties, by interposing an alien and a stranger to share the powers of government with them…” (Speech by Representative Roger Griswold) Roger was saying that if Thomas Jefferson was to buy Louisiana, France would probably try to strike dealing and propose that they should have their ruling of government be combined with the U.S government to change a few

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Even though Jefferson had claimed to be for small government he was willing to go above this if it meant protecting the country. This use of power was barley touched by the Federalist and Jefferson was willing to go beyond his predecessors. Under Jefferson the greatest expanse of U.S territory occurred when Louisiana was bought from France in the Louisiana Purchase. The French had been willing to sell after they loss their colonies in Haiti and Napoleon realized he was not going to be able to achieve his American empire. This allowed for America to now have a vast land to expand and move west into.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He saw it as a means of allowing Americans to expand to new lands and possibilities that were otherwise impossible without the attaining of new land. Jefferson would find himself defying his belief that the Constitution be strictly interpreted and therefore exploiting himself to the Federalists, who were against the purchase because it would deem their eastern seaboard less important. Jefferson indeed faced multiple dilemmas in the decision to go through with purchasing Louisiana territory from France; defying his beliefs, putting the government in question, and risking Federalist upheaval across the nation. But it seems that, in the broader aspect of things, Jefferson made the correct decision in expanding American land because it allowed increase in production within American farming and therefore made the nation twice as strong as it was before 1803, not just in wealth but in power as well. All great nations start their conquest with expansion, and this was the beginning of the United States’…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Jefferson’s Dilemma The United States history thus so far, is full of many bargains but one of the most controversial and beneficial bargains is the Louisiana Purchase. This bargain occurred back in the 1800s of which the President Thomas Jefferson was able to undertake the deal of the century. This bargain initiated when Jefferson wanted to purchase New Orleans because France was enforcing stricter regulations therefore, making it difficult for American settlers to trade in that particular location. Then Talleyrand proposed “what will you give for the whole Louisiana,” a counter offer that the nearly deaf American Robert Livingston, was in no position to undertake. This offer then brought about a series of the most radical things that President…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Embargo Act was a disaster. Jefferson had thought that Britain and France would be angered when they didn 't get their regular shipments of food, weapons, and other American goods. Instead, the two nations managed to get along without American. The Embargo Act backfired, and American ships sat in American ports. James Madison, was elected president, but before he left office, Jefferson signed a bill repealing the Embargo Act.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Once Jefferson becomes president congressmen alerts Jefferson to prepare for a war against France. In addition, “Spanish officials who still governed New Orleans announced the closing of that port to American commerce (October 1802).” (PG. 184) Leaving Jefferson in a tough position he preferred to negotiate rather than going to war. This negotiation resulted in the Louisiana Purchase. The American people were enthusiastic about the new state but Jefferson “worried that the purchase might be unconstitutional.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They thought that the nation owed a debt to France because they helped the United States for their help in the Revolution. The Democratic Republicans also had a very strict interpretation of the Constitution and they argued that the President did not have the right to declare neutrality, only Congress can declare war between countries. Also by supporting France, Britain may not be the lead trading partner to America, which in turn, can make the nation more self-sufficient. On the contrary the Federalists, supported by their leader Alexander Hamilton, were for neutrality. Their reasoning was that they thought that France only helped the U.S for their own selfish reasons, since they only helped to hurt Britain, there is no debt to repay.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although the Act was later repealed, at the time when the act was still in place, Johnson disobeyed it. Johnson tried to veto the Tenure of Office Act, but it was passed over to the Radical Republicans in Congress. The act was placed to prevent and restrict presidents from gaining power by removing past members of the office without consent from the Senate and replacing them with people who agreed with them. However, going against this act, Johnson fired Edwin M. Stanton. This is a clear violation of the law, whether it happened once or more, a president should not be able to make excuses when it comes to breaking the law.…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This can be corroborated by “Jefferson’s Great Gamble” by Charles A. Cerami which emphasizes: In fact, as Marbois later wrote, he felt the decision was already made (to cede Louisiana to America). That was probably because he (Marbois) had always known that Louisiana could not prosper as a French colony unless France also controlled a prosperous Saint Domingue. And that island was proving to be Napoleon’s worse disaster to date…

    • 1853 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Purchasing the Louisiana territory, that almost doubled the size of the county was not allowed because it doesn 't say in the constitution otherwise. However signing and negotiating foreign treaties were allowed. Jefferson had to act fast, he signed the treaty and purchased the territory. He believed in an agrarian society, so he also promised to provoke agriculture and handmaid commerce, but on December 22, 1807 the Embargo Act was passed. The Embargo Act closed all of the United States imports with the intent to pressure Europe.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The selling of the land caused France to come into a great deal of money. France declared land theirs past the Mississippi river in the early 1800’s, then after the French and Indian war, Spain owned the land west of Mississippi. Napoleon realizing that he needed to sell the land in order to make money to fight against the British, he made a treaty with Spain, in which Spain got a New Orleans, an important city port, while France got the remaining Louisiana Purchase. Napoleon knew that it was necessary to sell the land after the war with Russia and the major defeat, his army was very weak. Although Napoleon needed the money, he still was hesitant to sell it.…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays