Stewart Brand Case Study

Improved Essays
The matter of cloning reached a peak when the CEO of BioArts International, Lou Hawthorne, announced to his company that they were no longer offering dog-cloning services since artificial creation was occurring just for a tiny and uninterested market. Though Stewart Brand was right in a way in talking about how artificial regeneration would lead to “conservation” of lost-species, the purpose of conservation should also be thought in terms of money. When Ehrlich stated that de-extinction, or rather “uninterested” genetics, is “a fascinating but dumb idea”, the CEO and Ehrlich were correct since genetic evolution, is an unnecessary medium of science which involves the expenditure of large amounts of resources and requirements and garners risk …show more content…
Though he stated the reason for bringing back the pigeons and elephants so as to “protect them to undo harm that humans have caused” (in other words, the human population’s second chance), he didn’t give any clear indication in his article on whether they would be able to thrive in the current environment. So not only huge amounts of money that would be invested “to bring new knowledge” would go down the trash, but all the other resources would also be put to waste. That is why, Ehrlich states that by bringing a meagre of a population into existence would not “compensate” for the past population, even if the resources of their original habitat aren’t “restored”.
One of the resource that would definitely not be restores is land. But if de-extinction experiments were to be legalized, land would have to be free from all the existing occupants of it and the conditions need to be favorable for de-extinct animals to settle on. Then technically, the native inhabitants would be under the radar of endangerment when actually, all the genetic scientists want is to “prevent extinctions” through
…show more content…
She writes “Scientists have developed techniques in which the mother-tube’s diseased mitochondria are swapped with healthy ones from an egg donated by another woman”. Although, the method when explained in writing makes a ground-breaking claim on removing genetic diseases, no trials or research did she refer to in this article proved the credibility of this experiment. Therefore, genetically disease free babies to be invented is easier said than done if proper experimentation has yet not been

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Animal Endangerment in Brazil Brazil is home to some of the world’s most diverse wildlife, with over 2,900 animal species occupying in the Amazon rain forest. (Animals) These animals serve an important role in the world’s ecosystem, but are quickly becoming endangered. Although the extinction of animals is a natural occurrence, human activities has quicken their rate of becoming extinct. From early European colonists and settlers, to deforestation, and to animal smuggling, the number of species in the Brazilian rain forests are rapidly decreasing, but with the endangerment of animals, comes the formation of organizations that are making an effort to help conserve the rainforests where these animals live and limit the factors which are putting…

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dollie the sheep was the first mammal to be cloned by an adult cell by using the process of nuclear transfer. This process started by a cell is placed in a de-nucleated egg, the two cells fuse and then develop into an embryo. Dollie was cloned at the Roslin Institute in 1997. The idea was developed from part of a research in producing the milk from farm animals.…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is it a good thing to have de-extinction? Because we are doing that. If you were glad that the mammoth were gone then you are going to like this. Scientist are working on bringing back the wooly mammoth and making de-extinction so far they are looking good and this will tell you about, what they have done to make one, what their idea is, and how far along are they from making what could be the start of de-extinction. There are probably some questions of what they have done to make a wooly mammoth…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the United States people are having problems with reintroducing animals back in the wild, a big one is wolves. Wolves have been around for centuries. Wolves help the animals that are scavenger like eagles and other small animals. Wolves help control the population of other animals. When reintroducing wolves it would be perfect for ecotourism.…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a society wherein new advancements are discovered on a regular basis with regards to the scientific and biological fields, the analysis of certain developments is required to ensure the safety and morality of the procedure. In particular, however, the issue of the reproductive cloning of animals has been the cause of many debates. The case of Snuppy, a cloned dog, has sparked controversy and this paper will focus on that whilst proving that reproductive cloning of animals should not be deemed unethical. Snuppy – the first dog to ever be cloned! …

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    [15] will lose its stings and sponsors will stop funding such projects. Brand acknowledges that the influential arguments against de-extinction are “the most technical ones, focused on extreme complexity of resurrecting extinct genomes”. [16] The author doubts the possibility of bringing back extinct animals to life as it has never been done before. However, he later revises that scientists have tried breeding Javan Batang cow with a domestic cow, and a chimeric duck with a chicken and one day the concept of de-extinction will turn it into reality.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Keep Zoo’s! Between 200 and 2,000 animal extinctions occur every year. I believe that animals should stay in zoos. Animals should stay in zoos because they wouldn't have to worry about getting killed and they will always get food.…

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On De-Extinction

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Over the past few decades, many animals have become extinct either due to natural causes or humans. Recently scientists and researchers believe that animals can be brought back to existence through a process called de-extinction. Some believe that bringing them back to life will make up for the wrong of extinction as stated in Text 1 : 3Q The Ethics of Species ‘De -Extinction’ by Angela Herring. However others claim that because of de-extinction, extinct species are being brought back but millions of other species in the ecosystem are at risk of extinction, stated in Text 3 : Case against Species Revival. Extinct species should not be brought back into existence because it will put many species at risk and will create controversy in…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Captivity or Death Species reintroduction may sound great on paper as animals are brought back home to the wild and are once again happy. Humans are able to save endangered species and nurture the populations back from the brink. Injured animals have a safe haven in which to rehabilitate and thrive, then return to their family at home in the wild. Animals in animal testing are released from their suffering of being poked and prodded. In theory, this all sounds great, but in reality, one forgets the crucial part: the animals in question.…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Michelle tries to enlighten the reader about these issues happening but also tries to persuade the readers to become active in fixing this world-wide issue occurring. It is said from Tim Male, vice president of at Defenders of Wildlife: “Politically controversial species attract more funding, as do species in heavily studied places: ‘We live in a world of unconscious triage.” Most animals we see today will end up disappearing just because of the accomplishment of not being able to pay for certain developments. Since each method favors certain priorities, when the computer method became about, it made more sense due to all of these methods not working for all species. These methods were working and capable of doing its job, but did not work for every specie roaming the earth.…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article Bringing Them Back to Life by Carl Zimmer, scientists are debating on whether they should bring back extinct animals or not. Some say that it would be cool to actually “de-extinct” an animal, but is it really worth the time and money to do so? Cloning can involve several different processes such as injecting nuclei into other animal cells, restructuring genomes and reprogramming cells. Bringing back or cloning animals from the past would be great scientific achievement but then again the past is the past and should maybe left that way. There is great debate of de-extinction; the pros of scientific advancement and preservation or the cons of playing God and wasting money.…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The new generation of the Human Race will never see the breathtaking sight of the Passenger Pigeon. This new arrival of humans can blame their ancestors for the eradication of the majestic, deep amber bellied, Passenger Pigeon. Over the years, human activity has harmed the natural world, driving some species to near extinction, to the point of helplessness. But even the people that brought destruction and tragedy upon these animals can save them from the neverending darkness of the grave. The human race needs to help rescue endangered species of animals because the laws that have been passed to help endangered species of animals do not work, there are still endangered species.…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    The Pros And Cons Of Babies

    • 2056 Words
    • 9 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited

    The increase of knowledge regarding the topic altering genes has become rapid and have open and paved the hope of designing your own perfect baby. Even today, the use of reforming and adjusting the genes of an unborn child is being put in effect. “Techniques of genetic screening are already being used, whereby embryos can be selected by sex and checked for certain disease-bearing genes. This can lead to either the termination of a pregnancy, or if analyzed at a pre-implantation stage when using In Vitro Fertilization (IVF), can enable the pregnancy to be created using only non-disease bearing genes” (Steere, 2011, para. 6). Altering the babies genes can not only harm the baby, however, can also terminate the baby.…

    • 2056 Words
    • 9 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited
    Brilliant Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Reproductive Cloning With constant new developments in science, society is forced to react and adapt. Along with these new developments, citizens are left questioning the ethics behind the experiment. Almost one hundred thirty years ago, society was introduced to the idea of cloning. It was not until the year nineteen ninety-six when the idea became reality and the first cloned mammal was born, Dolly the sheep. She set the grounds for the next cloned mammals to come.…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Summary: The persuasive piece that I have chosen to use for my rhetorical analysis is a transcript from a TED talk by Paul Root Wolpe titled, “It’s time to Question Bio-engineering”. Wolpe is an ethicist who studies the implications of the new sciences, is the head at the Center for Genetics at Emory University, and is the chief bioethicist for NASA. He begins his talk by presenting the audience with examples of selective breeding in animals and mentions many hybrid animals such as “beefalo”, “cama” and “geep”. When Wolpe brings up the discussion about these hybridized animals, he conveys to the audience what could possibly happen if bio-engineering continues to evolve and especially if it is used in humans.…

    • 1348 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics