One Size Does Not Fit All: An Argumentative Analysis

Superior Essays
One of the most controversial topics of the current age in education is that of accountability. So much so, in fact, teachers have been accused of teaching to a high-stakes test, often to the detriment of learners, while failing to teach students valuable problem-solving and analytical skills. Nationwide, a debate has been brewing for years over what students should know, the effective teaching practices that ensure that learning, and how that learning is measured. Teachers are expected to differentiate their instruction, but standardize their tests. It is a widely held belief that accountability to a single standardized test is not the most effective way to demonstrate competency (Deubel, 2008). Rather, educational leaders continue to investigate …show more content…
Differentiated instruction provides high quality learning experiences that demonstrate understanding and application of classroom standards by all students. When teachers use the results of formative assessments to determine the needs of each learner, and then develop learning experiences to meet those needs, all students are engaged, they meet and exceed the expectations of teachers, classroom time is used more effectively, and frustration is alleviated (McCarthy, 2014). Empowering students to use their intelligence, interests and abilities allows them to confidently and successfully reach their maximum potential in the classroom. While some argue that differentiated instruction takes too much time, expert practitioners have proven that it saves time in the long run, because it ensures that no child is left behind. William Kilpatrick, often called the father of progressive education, argued that deeper learning should enhance and enrich life; it becomes innate and is strengthened by personal experiences that question or challenge values. When learning is accompanied by action, feelings, emotion, and interest, it is deeper and longer lasting, …show more content…
That simple statement has stirred controversy for years in the world of education, but because of the research of Dr. Howard Gardner and his colleagues at Harvard University’s College of Graduate Education, the theory of multiple intelligences has revolutionized education in the present generation (Harvard-Smithsonian, 1999). Despite harsh criticism from many, the theory has provided an educational foundation that is based in experience, practice, and activity with an ultimate goal of understanding and application. Genes and experience determine a child’s intelligence profile, and when educators take the time to get to know children and teach in a way they understand, real learning takes place. The proof is when the learner can appropriately apply prior knowledge in new situations. Gardner suggests that by studying fewer things with more depth with varied instruction, children understand more, which agrees with Common Core State Standards. Not only does practical application encourage creativity, invention, and discovery, it also decreases discipline problems by engaging students in meaningful activities that capture and hold their attention. The teacher must first capture attention using multiple entry points for lessons including stories, art, role play, or models. Then tie in prior knowledge with the use of examples, metaphors or analogies. Finally, allow students to express and demonstrate mastery of the topic in what Gardner calls

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Standardized Test

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Every individual learns differently, processing information uniquely and possessing different strengths and interests. Though this is the case, the modern education systems attempt to regulate and conform youth from such a young age, resulting in the suppression of the creative minds because there are no regulations for “thinking outside the box”. Standardized tests are shoved down students’ throats, and a simple number as a result from their answers on a multiple choice screen deems how intelligent they are. The school systems need to take action to nourish and develop their pupils’ individual interests and strengths instead of deem them inadequate or “below average” because they can not meet or exceed all the standards forced upon them. For…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Neoliberalism In Australia

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The testing and publication of results will ensure teachers and students strive to make improves is the argument at large (Thompson & Harbaugh, 2013, p.303). Research into the claim has shown that accountability may have a diverse effect. Thompson and Harbaugh (2013, p.301) explains standardised tests, like NAPLAN for instance, can result in teachers spending the majority of their time teaching the curriculum areas that appear in the tests and discarding the rest. Thompson and Harbaugh (2013, p.301) add that the direction teachers’ take toward the curriculum can have a negative impact on student engagement. Accountability has the intended purpose of driving the motivation of teachers and students.…

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lee and Rottenberg classify these test as a standardized test. These test-based accountability systems were influencing many adverse effects on teachers and students to which these tests were imposed. Teachers and principal were pressured to do also anything to gain high student performance on the standardized test. The consequences were found to be both educationally restricting and negative feelings derived from being blame for weak performances on the test. The two school studied -Hamilton and Jackson Elementary had a student population of poor socioeconomic status and mixed ethnic backgrounds.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When schools are failing and students aren’t learning, who is held for responsible? The answer to this question is more likely point toward one answer: teachers. Teachers have long since become the scapegoat or pawn for their students’ performance. Many debaters like Anne Perrin, author of the essay “Stop Blaming Teachers (2008),” argues that the society blame teachers for our nation’s educational shortcoming instead of the “real culprits” (87). I found her essay to be very strong as she uses ethos, pathos, and logos to support her claims as well as use humor to connect with her audience.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction High-stakes testing is believed to have improved the quality of American education through its systems of rewards and sanctions that are triggered by a student’s standardized test score (Nichols, Glass, & Berliner, 2006).The theory behind this new outlook is that educators and their students will work harder and more effectively to enhance student learning when faced with large incentives and threatening punishments. Many critics fear that the effects of high stakes testing not only will threaten the validity of test scores, but it may also lead to perverse and corrupt educational practices. Others worry that the pressure of doing well on a test will negotiate how instructional practices are implemented in the classroom as well as permit teachers from caring for their students’ needs that are separate from how they will score on these standardized tests. Therefore, it is hypothesized that the pressure of high-stakes testing has a negative impact on student test scores. History of High Stakes Testing Since the signing of No Child Left Behind student test scores have become a vital sign of how well a school is achieving.…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the past, the goal of education was to develop character traits of a citizen and enable them to make politically sound decisions (Maranto). Education has gone through reforms since then and the most recent includes a substantial amount of standardized testing that has criticism from many stakeholders. Does standardized testing accurately evaluate students and the quality of education they receive? The educational lens doesn’t include the economics of test making corporations, psychological aspects, or the historical course of standardized testing but includes teachers, parents, and students perspectives on whether standardized tests are beneficial for use of evaluating students’ academic standing.…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized testing has been a common trend all across the world. There are many pros and cons pertaining to standardized testing. According to the National Education Association (NEA), “The tests as we know them today were not used until the late 1920s and College Board created the very first SAT and still is responsible for these tests today. ”(Alcocer & Fletcher, 2009) Students begin taking standardized tests in pre-kindergarten and continue the practice beyond the end of their high school career. “On average, by the time a student graduates high school, the individual has taken close to 112 standardized tests.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Summary: Achievement Gaps

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages

    There has been an academia shift from learning to accountability in learning and data analysis. This is seen in the assessment of the following articles: Achievement Gaps in Education, The Standardized Testing Movement: Equitable or Excessive? and The Common Core “State” Standards: The Arts and Education Reform. We say we are charting/tracking “basic skills and accountability” according to Nezadal, “The creation and use of standardized tests find varying levels of support in different jurisdictions. They are increasingly being promoted in the name of the “basic skills and accountability” rhetoric of global competitiveness” (Nezavdal, 2003, p. 68).…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “The Secret to Raising Smart Kids” (Dweck. 2015) inspires me to reassess my teaching style as a teacher and a parent. Positive reinforcement can be very helpful to boost a student’s morale, but parsing, if not done properly, can be detrimental to student’s mental development (Dweck.2015) Every child is different with his or her unique talents and capabilities. As explained by Howard Gardner’s “Theory of Multiple Intelligences” , “We all exhibit different profile of intelligence and these are shaped by our genetic inheritance or heritage or our experiences ( Ryder, n.d)” Some students may not do well in class and not achieve high grade but they may outperform their classmates in other fields of life.…

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized tests are assessments mandated by the government that all students are required to take. These examinations are compulsory to graduate and attain your diploma. The scores students get on these tests are used to assess the level they are at in the particular areas in school, and mainly define a student as either a failure or a success. Standardized tests are extensively harmful to a student’s academic development. They contribute to the evident increase of students’ anxiety levels and mental stability problems, and the results are not eligible to exactly determine a student’s learning level, since the scoring is completed electronically and cost a lot to produce and implement.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized testing is not a fair measure of ability and have no true result of a student’s knowledge. As explained in the article titled “Americans Want Less Standardized Testing and More School Funding”, the author Tim Walker describes how parents and teachers both agree that schools need more time learning and less testing. Teachers feel trapped having to teach drill-like classes and parents feel angry about their child learning useless information for their after high school…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    High-Stakes Testing Thesis

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Taking time away from instruction to drill-teach students on how to score higher on standardized tests is a disservice to them and denies them the quality of education that students deserve. I want my future students to have the freedom that allows for creativity and expression and I will not deny them that opportunity by promoting test-taking skills over meaningful learning. As an educator, it is essential to place the growth and development of the student as a priority over simply learning how to take standardized tests. Despite my dislike of high-stakes testing, it is likely to stick around as the main assessment to gauge educational success. However, as Kozol points out, teachers should explain to their students that this test is not definitive of their intellectual abilities or determine their success in the future…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since I was in school, regulations have changed tremendously. Today teachers are forced to test the students constantly to ensure that students, teachers, and schools are to par. Testing has become the norm in most schools. Between the schools self imposed testing ciriculum as well as that of the local and federal governmnets, a large percentage of a students schooling revolves around tests and final scores. The constant testing students must endure today is much too much.…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    If a teacher implements this theory in the classroom the students will not only get a more personal education, but it can also provide more positivity and optimism in the idea that each student is unique and gifted in their own way. With my experience, the multiple intelligences used in the classroom have helped shape my students into stronger and more intelligent individuals. In the future, I hope to use Howard Gardner’s theory to provide a welcoming and stimulating educational…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every classroom is diverse. The students, teachers, and dynamics between each person set the the tone of how the class will function for the year. However, those relationships do not paint the whole picture when it comes to how a student will learn and thrive. The way in which individual children learn is unique. Within each classroom there is a wide array of learning needs.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays