Testimony: The Brenton Butler Murder Case

Improved Essays
On May 7, 2000, Brenton Butler (15 year old African males) left his home seeking gainful employment at Blockbuster thought it would be just a not Sunday morning. However, on the other side of town at the Mary Ann and James Stephens were leaving the Ramada Inn after having breakfast. The couple came to Jacksonville Florida to vacation, but Mr. Stephen’s never thought this would be the last time day he would spend with his wife. An African American male between the ages of 20-25 approach the couple demanding Mrs. Stephens to give him her purse. Mrs. Stephens, 65, through her cup of coffee on the assailant, within second the gun goes off shoot Mrs. Stephens in the face, as the African American male runs off with her purse (Murder on Sunday Morning, …show more content…
He stated that Glover stated to him that there was an easy and a hard way to this situation. When Butler told him that he did not kill Mrs. Stephen, Glover stated “It’s niggers like you that make me mad” (Murder on Sunday Morning, 2001). Later the defectives took him to the wood where the weapon was supposed to have been thrown. Butler stated that Glover escorted him deep into the woods out of sight of the other detectives. Butler stated in his testimony that Glover punched him three times in his stomach knocking him to his knees as he cried stating “I didn’t kill her.” Additionally, Glover last hit was to Butler face causing him to stumble backwards (Murder on Sunday Morning, 2001). Butler also mentions that Detective Darnell wrote his statement forcing him to sign it.” During the trail the Mary Ann’s purse was found by a man collecting in a dumpster on Main Street. The purse was covered in blood with all credit cards inside, as well as two envelops with more than $1,000 in each. When on the stand, the gentleman who found the purse of Mrs. Stephens stated the police officers accused him of getting rid of the gun and was verbally abusive towards him as well. Additionally, the police department failed to examine the purse for finger prints or other DNA evidence (Murder on Sunday Morning, …show more content…
The purpose of a forensic psychologist is to accumulate information concerning the defendant by the means of assessment and results, interviews, as well as information from third parties. The material is presented to members of the court (e.g. judge, attorneys, and jury members) to assist with selecting the appropriate punishment (Heilburn et al, 2003). Forensic psychologist provided expert testimony specializing in mental health diagnosis as it relates to legal proceedings meeting the Daubert standard (e.g. has the assessment been peer reviewed, the reliability and validity of the assessment, just to name a few (Heilburn et al, 2003; Hugaboom,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Murder on a Sunday Morning is a documentary that shows the problem in our judicial system concerning the juvenile being accused of a crime. This documentary follows the trial of 15-year-old Brendon Butler from Defense attorney Patrick McGuinness’s and Ann Finnell point of view as he works to prove Butler innocence. This case became America most misleading Cassie's because of its lack of evidence on Mr Butler Butler. This accident took place on May 17, 2000, out of Jacksonville Florida many people say that this case was not handled properly by detective and officers could also represent that the young black teen time to be a stereotype base under skin colour.…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thorton had fatally shot eight people and wounded two more on that Tuesday morning. The questions in case are ones always asked, who could commit such an act of violence, and why. In this specific incident, law enforcement stated they were looking into possible work place harassment due to Mr. Thorton’s race. Events leading up to that volatile day included a statement made by Mr. Thorton’s girlfriend’s mother, Joanna Hannah.…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Facts of Case: On April 10,1985 two officers called Williams (respondent), stating that he needs to come down to the police station for questioning about a double murder that occurred on April 6, 1985. Williams was driven to the police station by the two officers, (he was not arrested). Once at the station, the officers began questioning Williams about the crime that committed. William began to go in-depth about what took place with the crime, and even made a statement that he provided the murder weapon, but he was not present, stating the killer called him telling where the weapon and other items was discarded.…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “Another African American man accused of rape and murder”, a quite often used headline in the 1980’s. Clarence Brandley was wrongfully accused of the rape and murder of 16 year old Cheryl Dee Ferguson in 1980. Brandley was a custodian at Conroe High School in Conroe, Texas. Him and another custodian, Henry Peace, found the limp body in a loft above the auditorium. At age 29, Brandley was wrongfully convicted and punished with the death penalty.…

    • 1578 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Police officers that were visited the accused home on February 15 2015 found a 9-mm semi-automatic firearm which had the defendants DNA and the evidence also revealed that it was the same gun that was used in the two robberies that have been described…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Forensic psychology is a very interesting, but emotionally and mentally draining field. I do not consider that I have the bravery to do it. In the US, forensic psychologist must also abide by the APA Code of Ethics. As a forensic psychologist your main will consist of providing assessments to individuals with a variety of severe mental ailments. On section 9, of the APA Code of Ethics detailed assessment processes are provided: from the selection of the instrument to implement, implementation of the evaluation, to the interpretation of the results thereof.…

    • 220 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity(NGRI) Intro The criminal justice system is utilized to punish those who violate the laws and to protect the rights of the people who abide by the laws. However, there are instances where the criminal act of an individual are not punished through imprisonment. In these instances they individual may have a mental illness, which is causing them to not understand the consequences of their actions.…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sociopathy Vs Psychopathy

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Statements of Interest The misconception of many is to assume that psychopathy and sociopathy are the same disorders. While they are very similar there are key characteristics which make them different. These mental disorders are classified differently in the DSM-5 “The diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders” in addition to that both are under the subgroup of antisocial personality disorder.…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Bobby Phoenix, an expert on batter woman syndrome, Sidney Miller, M.D, Physician at New Columbia Hospital Center, as well as the defendant, Dominique Stephens herself. On the side of the prosecution we have Detective Dana Hughes, from the Metropolitan Police Department, and Jordan Bright, Dominque Stephen’s sibling. The evidence presented at trial are the Metropolitan Police Department Statement, New Columbia Hospital Records, and a picture of the pistol used to kill Donovan Stephens. I decided to accept witness, Dr. Bobby Phoenix, as a professional on battered women syndrome. I’m basing his expertise on the fact that he is the Executive Director of the National Center for Women’s studies, he has a Ph.D. in Psychology from Georgetown University where he also teaches about domestic violence, and he is very knowledgeable on the subject.…

    • 2831 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    other than that , the police has also found no weapons using in that house and they doesn't found any weapons that suits to her husband’s wound , and so for that mary is innocent for evidence for now…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a homicide investigation, there are many factors which may impact the likelihood of a successful case. In order for a suspect to be convicted on trial, investigative processes must be followed that involve several imperative elements. However, sometimes these procedures aren’t followed and it is in these circumstances that major errors and flaws in the inquiry process are exhibited. It is then due to this that recommendations and frameworks must be created in order to avoid such weaknesses in future cases. Although, sometimes extrinsic factors, such as the influence of the media, may also impact the outcomes of such cases.…

    • 1989 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Brenton Butler Case

    • 1542 Words
    • 7 Pages

    After careful review of the assigned film titled “Murder on A Sunday” The viewer is introduced to the events that take place in Jacksonville, Florida on 7 May 2000 at approximately 0730. Mrs. Mary Ann Stevens was shot and killed in the breeze way of the Ramada. Stevens was accompanied by her husband Mr. Stevens, who was the only was the only eye witness in the case. Mr. Stevens identified 15 year old Brenton Butler as the shooter.…

    • 1542 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Insanity Defense

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Legal defense of “Not Criminally Responsible” as result of psychological disorders Psychology is used in the legal system in many ways, whether it is to assess the competency to stand trial, competency of eyewitness testimony, or asses the dangerousness of the psychopathy (Costano & Costanzo, 2013). In recent years a vast number of defences has used the argument that their clients are incompetent to stand trial or are not criminally responsible due to insanity or other psychological issues whether it be schizophrenia or PTSD, all in attempts for either lighter sentences or complete exoneration. A growing concern among the public has been the reliability and the validity of the psychological tests used in these cases – are the accused really…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brenton Butler Case Study

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Their sole piece of evidence was the identification given by the victim’s husband and a coerced confession that police wrote out themselves and beat Brenton into signing. With the research provided it is evident that eyewitness testimonies can be affected by many factors and it is not sufficient enough evidence to stand on its own. The police asked the victim to identify Brenton 2 hours after his wife had been shot which is hardly enough time for his shock of the situation to die down. Also, when they presented him Mr. Butler, they did not do so in the form of a lineup they presented him by himself in the area that the crime happened. The setting he was presented in, the time he was allowed to view Mr. Butler, the distance he viewed him and the traumatic state he was in, all led to his wrongful identification of Brenton Butler.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Night Walker Analysis

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Have you ever experience being discriminated because of your appearance? Your skin color? Your race? The short “Night Walker” by Brent Staples is about his experiences to his daily life, being accused of someone that he isn’t because of his skin color, his race and even his appearance. In “Nightwalker,” Author Brent Staples reveals a theme that: People shouldn’t judge others by their appearance.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays